7 ms·
Kellogg’s is going to war over Mexico’s nutrition label rules
- skummetmaelk 3y agoThere must be some way to add a legal mechanism for preventing obvious and egregious loophole exploitation. Why can it not be done?
- ben_w 3y agoMmm, sounds like the arguments between "common law" and "roman law".
- mrweasel 3y agoI've seen one suggestion, regarding closing loopholes in general but it has it's own issues. The idea is that you define the intention of a law and violate the intention of the law then you're punished as well. So in this case the intention is to make people eat healthy and Kellogg is violating that intention by replacing sugar with an ingredient that they know isn't covered, because they specifically lobbied for it not to be. Similarly Coca-Cola by designing their labels to only have the warning on one side and asking the supermarket to place the items so that the warning isn't visible. There's no real way that these companies come out of this looking good. Either they label correctly and people can see that their product is a lot more unhealthy than they might have realized or they go to court to protect their "right" to knowingly damage the healthy of their customers for profit. I fail to understand how you can have so little moral integrity. Why not just embrace the new labels and design better products.
- ben_w 3y ago> Why not just embrace the new labels and design better products. Not to disagree, but this is probably the same kind of thinking that means websites have popovers saying "we respect your privacy click here so we can share your behaviour with an unfeeling AI designed to manipulate you into obsessively returning to this site at best, and at worst also with advertisers who will use their own unfeeling AI to manipulate you into buying stuff you don't need and can't afford for the highest price they can squeeze out of your overburdened wallet"… instead of just not having analytics and advertising tracking.
- yieldcrv 3y agoor just copy tobacco companies and not care they have medical patients on their boxes down there, the trade is a big as ever
- justinclift 3y agoThe tobacco companies seemed to care quite a bit in Australia, judging by the legal bullshit they tried here when the government made their packaging unappealing. The tobacco companies lost, thankfully. :)
- Broken_Hippo 3y agoIt wasn't just Australia: They've basically fought warning and package legislation wherever it has been introduced.
- simiones 3y agoYup, Australia is just one of the few places where it succeeded, since it's big and rich enough not to be easily bullied with "international law". The Philippines lost in trade tribunals - apparently the commercial interests of these companies are easily found to trump public health.
- pyrale 3y ago> the trade is a big as ever In terms of % of population smoking, the trade has been shrinking significantly: https://tobaccocontrol.bmj.com/content/31/2/129 https://tobaccocontrol.bmj.com/content/31/2/129
- 0dayz 3y agoI remember this being mentioned in this documentary and other absurdly by our other favorite food corporation, Nestlé: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=myv7yydtCKc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=myv7yydtCKc
- jnsaff2 3y agoWar over labels is the "showing initiative" for middle managers at Kellogs. Wait till GLP-1 is going to have widespread effects. Apparently it is already been cited as risk in earnings calls for public companies[0]. [0] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-08-18/glp-1-drugs-are-coming-and-they-could-change-everything https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-08-18/glp-1-dru...
- jacknews 3y ago"Companies like Coca-Cola and Kraft Heinz have begun designing their products so that their packages don’t have a true front or back, but rather two nearly identical labels — except for the fact that only one side has the required warning. As a result, supermarket clerks often place the products with the warning facing inward, effectively hiding it." lol. This isn't the kind of innovation we want market capitalism to deliver, but it's exactly the kind it is best at sometimes.
- RetroTechie 3y agoA supermarket who'd care for their customers, would defeat such shenanigans by instructing their personnel to always put the warning-side visible on the shelves. Such that their customers can't overlook it if present. Of course, most supermarkets are more interested in profit margins, and whatever helps to increase them.
- tmnvix 3y agoNestlé have the support of the Swiss government to fight the same rules. (Against warning labels on junk food in Mexico: How Switzerland danced to the Nestlé tune) https://stories.publiceye.ch/en/nestle-mexico/ https://stories.publiceye.ch/en/nestle-mexico/
- kwhitefoot 3y agoI try to avoid buying anything from all such companies but the concentration of power in the international food and drink business makes it quite difficult.
- orwin 3y agoNice to have an update on Nestlé corporate culture. Looks like I'll keep boycotting them (which is quite hard when also boycotting Lactalis, but well, what can you do).
- gausswho 3y agoSo bummed they even snagged Poland Spring.
- gillytech 3y agoJunk food manufacturers depend on the addictive nature of the sugar and fat they cram into their products. I don't see how this is any different than cigarette warning labels.
- rqtwteye 3y agoSometimes I buy sugar free corn flakes and although they should be cheaper theoretically, in reality they cost a multiple of the super sugary flakes. It would be great if we could get more products that aren’t sweetened when you buy them. Like corn flakes, cereal, bread, chocolate milk and lot of others.
- sneak 3y agoThis is a grocery store and grocery distribution consolidation/duopoly/monopoly problem, which is a separate issue than the food that is sold. This is actually one reason I love FBA - I can buy all sorts of small brand specialty health foods from Amazon, bypassing what the local stores choose to stock (or, more often, not stock). Amazon's anticompetitive practices mean this will become harder in the future however, as they will use this sales and pricing and customer data directly against any mom and pop product that becomes sufficiently successful. We really need better protections for small businesses that sell via giant online platforms. There is no shortage of healthy, tasty food, people who want to sell it, or people who want to buy it.
- globular-toast 3y agoCorn flakes and chocolate milk (I'm so confused by the mention of this) are junk food products made with sugar. It makes no sense to have them sugar free. As for cereal and bread, it should be trivially easy to find these without added sugar. I don't know where you live but I'm confident you can find these.
- RetroTechie 3y agoHehe, a while ago I embarked on a quest to find the lowest-added-sugar corn flakes. 6 or 7 supermarket chains further, sometimes a dozen products in same category, end result: not one (0) without added sugars. Anywhere. And all in a similar range, iirc. So basically the same product everywhere. Just minor tweaks (or with/without chocolate, eg.) + packaging, brands & pricing differences. Just goes to show how powerful food conglomerates destroy consumer choice.
- OfSanguineFire 3y agoMexico’s big black hexagons warning across excess fat/sugar/calories are kind of ridiculous. I don’t think they are serving to dissuade consumers, and even foreigners stop noticing the labels after just a couple of weeks in the country. The problem seems to be a wider one: Mexico is importing the convenience-store junk-food culture of its northern neighbor. People are often eating crap because there isn’t much else available from an Oxxo.
- prmoustache 3y agoGoing even further from that, to many mexicans having those labels is now considered similarly to a badge of honors. The more labels you have, the more the average mexican expect the product to taste well. This song from Fito Olivares is quite old and is still a hit in most parties. You'll also encounter it in many tiktoks and instagram reels: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3-RV8ZbMcdQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3-RV8ZbMcdQ
- licebmi__at__ 3y agoMexican people also jokingly say stupid shit like you have to act gay 5 mins to avoid it the gayness to accumulate. I put the joke about black labels being a taste rank on the same “stupid things people say” bucket.
- RexFactorem 3y ago[dead]
- veave 3y agoIf someone eats froot loops and can't see by themselves that they are too sugary do they even have the intelligence to make decisions based on those black hexagons?
- squishy47 3y agoThe point of food labels is help consumers make more informed decisions on what food they consume, especially when the food industry works to make food as addictive as possible. Lets not forget that the messaging behind many (most?) products, especially the unhealthy ones, is one of health and nutrition. When the only message about a food is it's health benefits it's not too farfetched that people may consider Froot Loops part of a healthy breakfast. Froot Loops is an extreme example, in most cases it's more subtle, like granola.
- starbugs 3y agoWhy not just legislate the supermarkets to put a label on the respective shelves?
- Broken_Hippo 3y agoBecause that doesn't help when you are outside the supermarket. It isn't uncommon for folks to eat things other folks buy (for example).
- starbugs 3y agoWhile that makes sense, I still think it would be more effective than having big multinational companies manipulate their way out of a well intended law.
- kwhitefoot 3y agoPerhaps supermarkets should be required to divide the floor area into two with all the stuff that is bad for you further from the entrance than the good stuff.
- starbugs 3y agoThat makes it very easy to come up with new manipulation about the meaning of "good for you", I guess.
- sn41 3y agoNutrition Labels in India are strange. Many drinks (like refrigerated shakes etc.) have nutritional information per 100 millilitres, whereas the actual bottle is say 330 millilitres, and the "serving size" will be defined as 250 millilters. The point being, the added sugars will probably come to 20-25 percent of the daily allowance if you drink a single bottle of beverage. At the same time, it will not be seen as "high in sugar" because, hey, the serving size is only 250/330 of a bottle, so the sugar level is below 20 percent. [Sophisticated level of duplicity] Most people are not that careful anyway - they might glance at the nutritional label, and see that the sugars are only 7.5% and think: that's pretty good, I'll have one, not seeing the 100 ml gotcha. [Basic level duplicity] The only thing that will alert you is the cloying sweetness of the drink which will cause you to pull out a calculator and see what that small bottle is going to really cause. Processed foods (snacks and beverages) in India seem to be very high in sugars, sodium and fat, more so than the same brands available elsewhere.
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago>Nutrition Labels in India are strange. Many drinks (like refrigerated shakes etc.) have nutritional information per 100 millilitres, whereas the actual bottle is say 330 millilitres, and the "serving size" will be defined as 250 millilters. Why is it strange? The metric system? It's exactly the same in Europe. Nutritional information is per 100ml/g, so that you can easily understand compare nutritional values. >Most people are not that careful anyway - they might glance at the nutritional label, and see that the sugars are only 7.5% and think: that's pretty good, I'll have one, not seeing the 100 ml gotcha. No mate, people in India and in EU are used to looking at the nutritional information per 100g/l as that lets you easily compare nutritional value between foodstuffs packaged in different weights, and figure out what's healthy/unhealthy, for example I saw Coca-Cola and most soft drinks are about 10g/100ml sugar, meaning that 10% of the product is sugar, so that's my yardstick of unhealthiness, or that most chips/crisps have around 30g/100g fats, aka 30% fats, so I seek out variants that have much less. Having only the nutritional value listed per random serving size or the entire product like in the US is confusing because I can't easily compare sugar/fat percentage content of different products of different weights.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- beefield 3y agoI would propose a regulation that if a food package somehow mentions there is not something (sugar, fat, artificial sweeteners etc) in the food, but the food contains some other element of the same list, the thing that is contained should be mentioned with at least as visible labeling than the one that is missing.
- badcppdev 3y agoNutritional labelling is such a cesspit of lies. My pet hate is the 'portion' or 'serving' sizes which are blatantly wrong just so the companies can lie about how much sugar they are selling to you. So you get 500 ml bottle with nutritional info shown for every 100 ml and 250ml because that's the 'serving size'. No-one has ever drunk 250ml (8 ounces) and then left the rest for later.
- theshrike79 3y agoIsn't this why Tictacs are "zero calories" because the serving size is one Tictac and it's so small that the nutritional values round down to zero :D While actually it's basically 100% sugar.
- alkonaut 3y agoIt does make sense to have the same "serving size" for a beverage across 0.33, 0.5 and 1.5L bottles though, regardless of whether no one actually shares the smaller ones. If anything, the "what's the sugar content of this whole package" should perhaps be declared separately.
- Ekaros 3y agoFor Finnish on quick check 0,33 can has 0,33 as serving size, same for a bottle. However 1,5 l bottle has serving size of 250 ml.
- BoorishBears 3y agoNo it does not make sense. We know that larger container sizes alone can increase intake (https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22306436/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/22306436/) and the purpose of nutrition facts is not to tell you what an arbitrary amount of something contains in a vacuum, it's to inform you on the contents of what you're about to ingest. "Servings" are just a convenient way to capture the fact that there are some cases where you're not expected to ingest the entire container: that's why a packet of mayonnaise and a jar of mayonnaise have near identical serving sizes, and same for packets of sugar vs boxes of sugar.
- 3y ago
- sam_goody 3y agoMany years ago, the FDA tried to pass a rule that that nutrition labels should have either a red, yellow or green border. The idea being, you could eg. tell your kid that they can have any cereal as long as the border is yellow, and have to mix it with one whose label is green. The black "BAD" labels are not as effective, they desensitize to BAD, and if all sweets are BAD you just ignore the label (though they do help some, according to data from Israel which implemented such labels a few years ago). The color codes (not as direct, but even more universally recognized) and the chance for a middle level is a better system. And they could put Allulose in that level, for a compromise that has a better chance of passing. That plan was lobbied to death; no surprise.
- Dylan16807 3y ago> They included a provision in the policy that required companies to also warn when products contained artificial sweeteners. Well there goes half the incentive to remove the excess sugar.
- XorNot 3y agoI'm unconvinced. Artificial sweeteners still have the problem that you prime yourself to expect sugar-flavors in everything.
- Dylan16807 3y agoYou're not convinced it decreases the incentive? And having one major problem is better than two.
- XorNot 3y agoWell I'd rather pressure them from both angles: reduce sugar and reduce artificial sweetener usage. Optimally everything could stand to be less sweet as the default. I've been on a campaign of cutting sugar down as much as I can: even in nominally "sweet" things it's incredible how much sugar standard recipes will call for then you can 1/3rd to 1/4 as much and get a superior result.
- em-bee 3y agoi read somewhere that artificial sweeteners cause the body to make you eat more because sweet taste signals sugar incoming and then there is no sugar so the body craves more to make up for that. not sure if thats true. my main concern is that many artificial sweeteners are suspected to cause cancer
- ThunderSizzle 3y agoI lost more weight drinking water than drinking coke zero, snd obviously it wasnt because of coke zero calorie. I do think there is an underlying truth to this.
- shmde 3y agoThis is a drink[1] which millions of Indian kids drink while growing up. Just see the amount of added sugar. And parents wonder why is the kid addicted to sugar growing up. Out of 100grams, added sugar = 32.2 grams. 32% of the drink is just pure sugar. People wonder why kids have rotten teeth growing up. [1] https://www.amazon.in/Cadbury-Bournvita-Chocolate-Health-Drink/dp/B06XSB6RB2?th=1 https://www.amazon.in/Cadbury-Bournvita-Chocolate-Health-Dri...
- XorNot 3y agoThis is the Australian equivalent we had when I was growing up[1]. Someone worked it out and basically realized it manages to give you more sugar per volume then actual sugar. [1] https://www.milo.com.au/powder https://www.milo.com.au/powder
- helsinkiandrew 3y agoSame product is available in the UK, but can't be called a 'health' drink!: https://www.amazon.co.uk/Cadbury-Bourn-Vita-Chocolate-Powder/dp/B010ICCJU8/ref=sr_1_1?crid=2W5V1DKP81ASR&keywords=Cadbury+Bournvita+Chocolate+Drink&qid=1692869401&sprefix=cadbury+bournvita+chocolate+drink%2Caps%2C187&sr=8-1 https://www.amazon.co.uk/Cadbury-Bourn-Vita-Chocolate-Powder...
- shoo 3y agoGo Mexico! Unregulated markets often don't produce great outcomes for society. Regulate them for the public good. I live in Australia, this reminds me of our tobacco plain packaging legislation [1]. A post implementation review was conducted a few years afterward [2]. Some interesting bits from the PIR conclusion: > Applying the government’s RBM framework, the regulatory burden was estimated as $73.87 million across the entire industry (including manufacturers, importers, wholesalers and retailers). > While it was not possible to complete a full Cost Benefit Analysis for this PIR (due to the limitations on the data available at this time and provided by industry), potential monetised benefits were also analysed including an illustrative example of health benefits. That example estimated that a 0.07 percentage point drop in smoking prevalence would be equivalent to $273 million in monetised health benefits > Dr Chipty’s modelling also estimated a 0.55 percentage point drop in smoking prevalence in Australia, over 34 months following implementation, attributable to the 2012 packaging changes. This strong result, that is “likely understated”, is expected to grow into the future as the full effects of the 2012 packaging changes are realised over the longer term So, within 3 years after the introduction of packaging changes, smoking prevalence throughout the population had dropped by at least half a percent (approx 100k people). It cost the tobacco industry less than $100m in one-off transitional costs, and it's estimated to have more than $2b in monetised health benefits over that three year period alone. It also cost tobacco industry lost revenues & profits, but hey, that's their problem, maybe they can find a different business to invest in. [1] https://www.health.gov.au/topics/smoking-and-tobacco/tobacco-control/plain-packaging https://www.health.gov.au/topics/smoking-and-tobacco/tobacco... [2] https://oia.pmc.gov.au/sites/default/files/posts/2016/02/Tobacco-Plain-Packaging-PIR.pdf https://oia.pmc.gov.au/sites/default/files/posts/2016/02/Tob...
- refurb 3y agoIsn’t tobacco use trending down anyways? How could you possibly tease out the drop in tobacco use from one change to packaging? This reminds me of the analysis I’ve seen for marketing campaigns.
- kllvql 3y agoOne way people try to tease out those differences is through methods like "Difference in Differences"[1] which try to estimate causal relationships from observational data. These methods are used in marketing analysis as well. In my experience, it is easy to break one of the many assumptions inherent in methods like Diff-in-diff. Because of this I have little trust in these techniques in general. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Difference_in_differences https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Difference_in_differences
- erfgh 3y agoI don't believe such measures have a significant impact on obesity because they don't target the main causes of obesity which are the easy availability of food and the reliance on private cars for transportation. Furthermore, they push the misleading idea that you can still drive to the supermarket, buy processed foods, load them in your car, drive home, eat them in front of the TV and be fine, as long as you don't buy the high-in-sugar stuff. If you want to beat obesity start by buying just the ingredients and then cooking meals at home. It's not that hard. Then start walking to places instead of taking the car. Taking public transportation is also good because it frequently forces you to walk a non-negligible amount. Also stop eating while watching TV. You can go one step further and throw out the TV altogether. You don't need to work out (although you should for other health reasons); you also don't need to diet; the vast majority of dieters gain all of the weight they lost during the diet and then some.
- XorNot 3y agoWe have effective weightloss drugs now like ozempic and semaglutide. What effect do people report from them? Reduction in appetite. Which tells us the obvious truth: you need to eat less or parity calories in then you do going out. A nutrition professor ate nothing but Twinkies and lost weight[1] while doing so. Probably wasn't fun, but it worked. Someone did the same with nothing but McDonald's[2]. Your entire list is just a list of your perception of "virtuous" activities, and has nothing at all to do with whether or not you'll gain or lose weight. It's lies, judgement and irrelevancy to push an agenda about how people should live, rather then sticking to the observable facts of the matter. [1] https://edition.cnn.com/2010/HEALTH/11/08/twinkie.diet.professor/index.html https://edition.cnn.com/2010/HEALTH/11/08/twinkie.diet.profe... [2] https://www.nbcnews.com/health/health-news/woman-says-mcdonalds-diet-took-weight-flna1c9441428 https://www.nbcnews.com/health/health-news/woman-says-mcdona...
- berkes 3y agoNonsense. There is a clear and proven correlation and causation between those "virtuous activities" and health. From my country, where "everyone" cycles to work, two random papers: https://www.uu.nl/en/news/dutch-bikers-live-six-months-longer https://www.uu.nl/en/news/dutch-bikers-live-six-months-longe... https://www.kimnet.nl/binaries/kimnet/documenten/rapporten/2021/03/11/het-verband-tussen-gezondheid-en-actief-reizen/The+relationship+between+health+and+active+travel_def.pdf https://www.kimnet.nl/binaries/kimnet/documenten/rapporten/2...
- kar1181 3y agoI recently read ultraprocessed people and while it's a bit hyperbolic it's still eye-opening about the state of the packaged food business. My son is allergic to Soya, Nuts, Eggs, Dairy and since he started eating solids we've have to label check everything and in doing so as a family we've basically stopped eating packaged foods alltogether. Do you know just how hard it is to avoid Soy now, it and it's derivatives are in pretty much everything, and even if it's not a raw ingredient it's in the bulk of the 'supply chain'. I think when we look back in 20 years the packaged foods business is going to look at lot like the tobacco one does today...
- pnt12 3y agoCompanies are suing Mexico: if the justice system is as fast as my country, I'd make them go through the normal process, and have a verdict in 5 or 10 years.
- santiagobasulto 3y agoI am a bit torn about these new labels. I'm from Argentina and they were implemented over there some time ago. On the one hand, I think it's great to warn "ignorant" people about the content of their foods. And by Ignorant I don't mean poor uneducated people. You'd be surprised how many college-educated, well-off people in Argentina think that a cereal bar is a "healthy food". Or that corn flakes is a healthy food. So, suddenly, these black scary labels started appearing everywhere and people were like "Oh wow, does this have a lot of sugar in it? I thought it was healthy". So that's a good thing. But on the other hand, they'r extremely simplistic. A label that says "excess fat" can actually be a good thing. If it's some raw, healthy fat (say, Oil, butter, etc), that's a great type of food. But it'll share the same "excess fat" label with a crappy hydrogenated-fat based food. Take for example whole milk, which it is now known that is the ONLY healthy type of milk. It'll have a "excess fat" label. While Skim milk will contain non such labels. Anyway, I think the balance is favorable for those labels. At least "protect" the uneducated people. If anybody wants to learn more about food, they'll put the time and learn to ignore those labels and just focus on the raw macronutrients. EDIT: I know the "whole milk is better than Skim milk" might STILL be a hot take (not for long I hope...). Here's my answer to another comment: > The gist is: fat is not bad; at all. Most of Vitamins contained in Milk are fat-soluble. That means that all the good properties of milk are transported by fat. Also, whole milk is less processed. > Here's a very "intuitive" reasoning, as an exercise: if Vitamin D is fat soluble... how is it possible that Skim milk has MORE Vitamin D (or A) than whole milk? (answer: because it's artificially added). Sources: - https://qz.com/405498/the-case-for-drinking-whole-milk https://qz.com/405498/the-case-for-drinking-whole-milk - https://archive.is/0yBjZ https://archive.is/0yBjZ
- selimthegrim 3y agoHow is whole milk the only healthy type?
- em-bee 3y agoapparently it's because it is less processed than other milk.
- everyone 3y agoKellogg's fruit loopholes!
- tzs 3y agoIf we are going to reform food labels, how about requiring that they include a last update timestamp? When I’m considering buying a food item for the first time I read the entire label to make sure it meets my criteria. It would be nice when buying it again to be able to at a glance tell that it is still the same as when I last bought it.
- ivanmontillam 3y agoI don't think that's needed for two reasons: - Products do not change formulas at random, if they did they'd have to re-submit samples for the label evaluation. - These labels don't have your best interests in mind anyway: If you are a bodybuilder, you will have tor read nutrition info labels yourself and ignore the warning labels, because only you know what quantities for each nutritients you will take to meet your goals.
- shaftoe 3y agoAs a counterpoint to most of the comments in this thread, maybe cereal (even with all the sugar) isn't as unhealthy as people think. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6950451/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6950451/ https://www.twopct.com/p/is-breakfast-cereal-healthy https://www.twopct.com/p/is-breakfast-cereal-healthy
- otikik 3y agoI hope Kellogg loses all the cases and is forced to pay all the legal proceedings.
- dperalta 3y agoThe picture of the article is showing how Argentina already implemented this nutricional labels.
- jasonkester 3y agoThe company replaced sugar with the sweetener allulose. This is so infuriating. Either put less sugar in, or let people eat less of it. Replacing sugar with some random chemical just ruins your thing. Heinz Beans did this in England. They have a "Reduced Sugar" version right next to the normal ones on the shelf. "No Artificial Sweetener" written in the same big font on the label. Cool. Those beans sure are crazy sweet, so it'd be nice to see what a less sweet version will be like. But then you taste it and get that terrible Nutrisweet chemical aftertaste that lingers for an hour, and have to throw out your entire dinner and scramble to make something else. Sure enough, deep down in the ingredients you'll find their "totally natural sweetener that's not sugar, but that we made by combining a bunch of chemicals in a lab." This is one place I'll be happy to see legislation put in place to fix. I don't want your synthetic poison in my kids food.
- ivanhoe 3y ago> I don't want your synthetic poison in my kids food. Allulose is not a poison by any measure, but if you're so paranoid about what your children eat why feeding them with instant foods like FruitLoops in a first place? Breakfast cereals are highly processed food, even without any added sugar - parent as concerned about the food quality as you certainly can come up with a healthier breakfasts for their kids?
- jasonkester 3y agoI’m not. As I said, I’m feeding them beans. Low sugar beans if possible. The point is that I want to be able to buy “food” without this garbage in it. It’s a pretty crap precedent to allow it in anything other than explicitly labelled “diet” food.
- ivanhoe 3y agoI see sugar and HFCS added to salty foods as a much bigger problem because you literally have no way of guessing it's there. FruitLoops and similar cereals are sweet, it's pretty obvious it has either sugar or artificial sweetener added.
- ivanhoe 3y agoFrom everything we know so far allulose is a safe replacement for sugar (it's also FDA approved), so I don't really see how it's such a big problem that it's not specially labeled? It's indigestible by humans so it has no known side-affects on our body, doesn't contribute in calories, doesn't affect insulin and it tastes almost as sweat as sugar. Seems like a win-win move to have it as a replacement for sugar (actually a huge victory of the labeling system), not something to fight against?
- aulin 3y agoFDA is notoriously on the lax side when compared with other regulatory bodies worldwide. E.g. allulose and monk fruit are still forbidden in Europe.
- foobiekr 3y agoErythritol was safe from everything we knew until it wasn’t. Sorbitol was safe … you see the problem? I’m guessing a lot of the keto fad sugars will end up there.
- ivanhoe 3y agoThey both are still safe in expected doses for majority of people (roughly 90%), and even for those 10% with sensitivity the main health concerns are temporarily gastrointestinal problems like flatulence & bloating - more of a nuance than actual health danger...
- foobiekr 3y agoIt’s actually not clear at all that erythritol is safe for anyone. That will likely be determined over the next few years but the persistence isn’t great for the use as an artificial primary sweetener vs the small amounts found in fruits: https://www.nih.gov/news-events/nih-research-matters/erythritol-cardiovascular-events https://www.nih.gov/news-events/nih-research-matters/erythri... Also, I was thinking of sucralose, not sorbitol: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37246822/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37246822/ Technically, you can argue that sucralose-6-acetate is a manufacturing byproduct that is supposed to be totally removed however the testing says it is no, at least for some brands - Likely direct carcinogen.
- MrPatan 3y agoIs it possible to find out how much sugar does a restaurant put in the food? https://youtu.be/YUeEknfATJ0?t=42 https://youtu.be/YUeEknfATJ0?t=42
- cebert 3y agoI love how we see ads suggesting these large processed food manufacturers care about providing healthy options. Actions speak strong than words.
- jsbisviewtiful 3y agoWhy do corporations always throw tantrums when called out for bad business practices that hurt their customers? I highly recommend folks read The Dorito Effect, a book about processed food manufacturing. It changed my perspective and habits on junk food.