6 ms·
As someone who's been interested in tracker defeating since that became a thing around 25 years ago, I'm just a little concerned that something like this AdNaus
by neilv 3y ago
As someone who's been interested in tracker defeating since that became a thing around 25 years ago, I'm just a little concerned that something like this AdNauseum -- if ever adopted significantly -- could invite blowback that also hits more conventional tracker blocking, or other current liberties.
Not making certain HTTP requests seems to be protected right now. However, click fraud, with which this might be conflated, seems to be a very different matter.
Imagine this being used to justify hamfisted legal restrictions on how everyone's browsers may behave. Or used as a reason or pretext to effectively force even more invasive user identity requirements or device attestation. (Which, history suggests, will then be abused for more nefarious and societally dangerous purposes.)
- imglorp 3y ago> force even more invasive user identity requirements or device attestation I think those are both coming. All the major forces are aligned against users: governments, content holders, advertisers, police, and authoritarians everywhere. It's inevitable unless we take the power back.
- paulryanrogers 3y agoWhat does taking back the power look like?
- djbusby 3y agoFire and guillotines?
- 8bitsrule 3y agoSomething more BBS-like. (Something like this: http://www.textfiles.com/100/ http://www.textfiles.com/100/) You send a detailed list of what's being offered, and expected. I return a request for exactly what I'd like to get ... and nothing else ... along with my list of what I'm willing to send in return. If you don't like my list, deny my request. If you deliberately send me something I didn't checkmark, or change your stated expectations, I'll refuse any more of your traffic.
- no_time 3y agoYou basically described soulseek, and to a lesser extent, torrents.
- 8bitsrule 3y agoThanks for pointing out soulseek, hadn't heard of it, will be checking into it. But I meant it in a much more general sense, for most of what happens on the net .... built-in. A LOT of sites want me to enable services that I don't want to deal with. I don't want google-analytics, or apis, or syndication. A LOT of sites want me to subscribe with a long list of personal information. Not happening. A LOT of sites want me to watch advertising; I quit cable-TV long ago. I could just auto-'nope' to all of those right up front and they could just - reply 'nope' and go away. All recorded once and for all, never knock on that door again. uBlockO helps with some of that, but things shouldn't be that complicated, it wastes my time, it wastes a huge amount of bandwidth ... and data center energy needs. Enshittification. Wouldn't have to be all-or-nothing; there could be maybes. By 'BBS-simple' I mean an up-front human-to-human negotiation style. I download something, if the sysop is looking for something and I have it to share, they'll get it, guaranteed, nothing else. Micropayments for their time? Wish we could do that. If I click a link on a specific topic, and with that query I auto-communicate 1) what I don't want (images say, or a subscription pop-up, or an unwanted 3MB list of all their other features, services, plans, site history) and 2) what they're looking for) ... they could just say 'no go', or we could bargain. The machines can keep track.
- aeyes 3y ago“click fraud”? That is very very far fetched. I’m just following links your website serves me. If you don’t like it you don’t have to serve your ads to me.
- badloginagain 3y agoHow "far fetched" this is from click fraud is the central argument, and I can easily see a range of arguments from both sides. On one hand, distributing and marketing a tool that is explicitly designed to harm trackers can be seen- ie lobbied- as fraud. On the other, this isn't a targeted campaign of misclicking, this is essentially random noise on a user by user basis. At scale though, this fucks with a whole lotta peoples paychecks.
- nradov 3y agoThis tool doesn't in any way meet the legal definition of fraud. Any if everyone working on online advertising loses their paychecks then that is an acceptable outcome.
- beachy 3y agoYep, people toss the word fraud around, and lawyers love to use it to scare the shit out of the opposition, but it's a very high bar to meet legally. An automated tool that clicked randomly on web page elements for no financial gain to the user or supplier of said tool would in no way reach the threshold of fraud. Obligatory IANAL.
- j33zusjuice 3y agoExcept a few walled gardens, like search and social media (FB and Google do not share much of your data with advertisers, and nearly none with other adtech companies), ads are bought through real-time bidding. And the bid is paid regardless of how you respond to the ad. The majority of ads are bought this way, so your click does not harm the advertisers whose ad would otherwise have been blocked. This could impact the relative value of the publisher’s website, but the industry in general is not overly inhibited by ad-blocking, so I don’t think this extension would have much impact in any sense.
- jrflowers 3y agoI like this reasoning. Either we voluntarily stop behaving in a way that advertisers don’t like or we will be forced to stop behaving in ways that advertisers don’t like. The only likely or rational future is that we all stop acting in ways advertisers don’t like, one way or another. We may be best served by proactively rethinking all of our computing habits to make sure they more closely align with AdSense’s goals for uh… our benefit.
- j33zusjuice 3y agoI’ve seen an incomplete proposal from an adtech CEO that suggests we have a global user ID that we set somewhere, somehow (the tech details aren’t worked out, but the data would be stored centrally in some ad watchdog type org, something like the PCI-DSS Council), and publishers could offer varying levels of access to their site for varying levels of access to your data for advertisements. The user would be able to remove access to the data from any publisher at any time, delete all their data at any time, and they’d be able to centrally manage their data for all sites. His argument for began with essentially what you said, this is going to happen whether we like it or not, so let’s get ahead of it and create a system that leaves the power in the end-user’s hands. That’s not going to happen in the current structure where Google basically owns advertising because of Chrome’s market share. Google will control things.
- brokenmachine 3y agoAdblocking is also theft somehow... Surreptitiously hijacking people's expensive PCs and network connections that they pay the bills for to download ads that they don't want to see... not theft. Funny how all this works.
- J_Shelby_J 3y agoThe government in which the majority of google employees live under will control everything.
- mratsim 3y agoI have a blockchain idea to pitch to your adtech CEO.
- smfjaw 3y agoIt's an interesting idea, but if we don't push the boundaries out of fear of regulation then we're effectively already living under these controls
- somenameforme 3y agoThis would likely just create a massive backlash. When you look at most of any survey on things like privacy [1] and other topics, people are not apathetic in the least. Most people know their data is being harvested, misused, and exploited. But because this all happens pretty much invisibly, people feel powerless. Trying to create very visible and ham-fisted laws forcing people to engage in behavior that most all of us are opposed to, beyond any typical partisanship, would be amazing in the unified backlash it would create. I also don't even really think this would fly in DC. Advertisers are certainly indulged because they provide an endless mountain of surveillance information to spook organizations, and can also be used to try to influence elections. But most politicians are people too, and with acts like this you'd be passing laws to piss on yourself, your family, and your friends as much as the rest of society.... for the sake of advertisers. I think that would face substantial opposition from DC itself, let alone the small but growing chunk of libertarian or social minded politicians. This isn't like the MPAA or whatever, where your average politicians might think you're talking about rafting if you speak about torrenting. [1] - https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2019/11/15/americans-and-privacy-concerned-confused-and-feeling-lack-of-control-over-their-personal-information/ https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2019/11/15/americans-an...
- qwertox 3y agoI really share your concerns and take your side, but one could also ask what harm is being done here, other than messing with the stats by letting code perform an action a human could do. Something along these lines: We're not asking to get these clickable ads, so if they're sent to us, we might as well just have a script click them. It's doubtful if this is really click fraud, since we're in no contract relationship to the ad platform, unlike the one who uses the platform. Click fraud could be defined as commercially interested parties generating false clicks for profit, either the ad platform or the competition creating these clicks to charge for clicks which never happened or the clients for whichever reason. But from my point of view I'd rather not do any of this as a tracker blocker, you never know if then a capable lawyer meets a bad judge and suddenly uBlock Origin will be (absurdly) ruled as an illegal piece of software.
- Timshel 3y agoWe are already there with chrome between the fact that you can't install this without dev mode and the recent "Web Environment Integrity" ...
- Gud 3y agoDon’t use Chrome. Google is the enemy of the open internet. Use Firefox or any of the now countless privacy respecting browsers.
- e2le 3y agoI suspect the motivation for many to install uBO was to reduce resource abuse (and visual noise). I'm sceptical it would ever be adopted significantly. I'm not sure if AdNauseam can be adapted for autonomous use on a Raspberry Pi, it's unlikely it would replace uBO for me, however an ad-clicking machine running on a Pi is appealing.
- syphermil800k 3y ago[dead]