7 ms·
Windows 11 has made the “clean Windows install” an oxymoron
- aquir 3y agoIn my eyes Microsoft Edge is even more annoying. Even if you install the "business" version you still get that shitty startpage and if you log in to remote desktop that takes ages to render and then you have to a bit of time turn that "start page thing" off. And MS moves the options around all the time! Such a pain! You can't just set about:blank as an empty tab page any more.
- yomlica8 3y agoTelemetry shows moving the option around results in higher use of the start page thing. Every time it moves less people can find it and the uptake of the new feature improves.
- short_sells_poo 3y agoIt's funny (in a bad way) that all this telemetry and optimization somehow optimizes for basically antisocial behavior. If I translate what you write into plain language: "every time we upset people by deliberately altering the interface, they are forced to rediscover things and they might start using some new bullshit we want to push". Imagine if your local supermarket regularly reshuffled all the wares because this would force the customers to rediscover the location of everything again. This is the kind of thing that is being pushed? How do we stop this? To me this seems like a complete and utter resignation of human decision-making and empathy to machine driven metrics. "Computers says that my doohickey metric went up by 30% this month, I'll get a nice bonus".
- fidotron 3y agoYour local supermarket almost certainly does do that for that reason.
- JoshTriplett 3y agoWhich is one of several good reasons to never shop in person.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoI have lived in many US states, and I have never experienced this in 30+ years. The end caps might change periodically, but the location of 99% of items is the same every time I have gone. Costco would probably be guilty of moving things around the most, but I assume this is partly due to their logistics and partly due to them wanting people to browse.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoMy father, an inveterate Costco shopper, has a half-joke about this, because also the cashiers will routinely inquire if you "found everything OK?" He says that this is actually a threshold poll, and if too many people respond "yes" that triggers the Grand Reshuffling of Merchandise overnight! I actually think he's exactly right. Why does a cashier care whether you found everything? You're already checking out, it's too late to go hunting for more, and the cashier can't be the one who could help you look. So it's not an invitation to customer service, it's simply gauging your satisfaction.
- chrisandchris 3y agoMaybe in the US? The supermarkets I go to have the same layout over years.
- fidotron 3y agoI have encountered this in multiple countries in Europe and North America. Part of the reason is I obsessively form a routine and optimize the route around and consequently am incredibly sensitive to changes . . . Which I am not claiming is a healthy habit! UK supermarkets go so far as to randomly drop free promo items “by accident” into baskets for online delivery in the knowledge that people will get hooked on the new thing, so you can’t escape it just by going online.
- 3y ago
- www_harka_com 3y agoSure you can. This is one of the first things I do on a new install: https://www.tenforums.com/browsers-email/167957-truly-blank-new-tab-page-edge-3.html https://www.tenforums.com/browsers-email/167957-truly-blank-... Edit: I have a regedit file with the value "about:blank" and it just takes a double click.
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> Edit: I have a regedit file with the value "about:blank" and it just takes a double click. That's awesome. Just emailed the link to myself to add it to my decrapify scripts.
- aquir 3y agoThis is great! Thanks for sharing
- 5555624 3y ago> You can't just set about:blank as an empty tab page any more. For Microsoft Edge, both on my personal computers and work computer about:blank is my home page and new tab page. (Home: Edge version 115.0.1901.203; Windows Pro 22H2) Under the "When Edge starts" setting, I select "Open these pages:" and add "about:blank"
- vladvasiliu 3y agoCan you combine that with "load the tabs from last session"? I don't use windows very often, so I usually shut it down instead of hibernate so I can access its drive if needed from Linux. So it's a pain to reload all the pages from the last time, because I'll probably need them, that's why they were active. In my case, I've found a "blank tab" or similar extensions which works well enough.
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> Edge is even more annoying. Even if you install the "business" version you still get that crapty startpage and if you log in to remote desktop that takes ages to render Oh Glob yes. De-venoming Edge is part of my RDP setup routine.
- jamal-kumar 3y agoHas anyone become so disillusioned with windows that they just have a windows pc sitting around collecting dust? Sometimes I still need to use some legacy program or whatever on there but I feel like the last time I booted into that thing was over a month ago now.
- misnome 3y agoI started my machine for the first time in a couple of months yesterday; I mostly use it for gaming. The taskbar “Search” box had a new “fun” little icon representing whatever search item they wanted to advertise to me today. Had to find windows “tips” site to work out how to turn it off… Not as egregious as “full screen game adverts on login screen by default” though.
- baal80spam 3y ago> The taskbar “Search” box had a new “fun” little icon representing whatever search item they wanted to advertise to me today. Had to find windows “tips” site to work out how to turn it off… It boggles my mind how people don't find it absolutely infuriating. I watch quite a lot of streams and people always have 3 things enabled that I personally would disable instantly: - huge searchbox taking a good 1/3 of the taskbar (I've yet to see anyone use this control for initiating a search) - the playful icon in this huge searchbox (you mentioned it) - Weather widget in the taskbar (just why?) I assume that vast majority of Windows users just don't care.
- blooalien 3y ago> "I assume that vast majority of Windows users just don't care." Most of them it's not so much that they don't care as it is that they've been literally brainwashed their entire lives to believe that Windows holds the top market position because it's somehow "superior" to other operating systems. They really truly believe the decades old Ballmer FUD about other operating systems. It's impossible in their minds that Microsoft gained such a stranglehold over the PC operating system market through completely unethical, borderline illegal means, and no amount of well-documented historical fact can change their minds about it. It's very nearly a literal cult.
- Corsome 3y agoPhew. After being a Windows user for literally almost two decades I've happily migrated to Linux and couldn't be happier. Yep, it took some time to prepare but let's be frank, developers already use quite a lot of Linux/Unix tools already so why not cut the middleman and just work directly with what we need most?
- gumballindie 3y agoExactly. I made the switch from MacOS and couldn't be happier. The fun thing is that with Linux these days you have the option of a powerful workstation that you can upgrade be it laptop or desktop, can do gaming, and is private. The next thing for me is to "decloud" - meaning remove any and all online services that are not mission critical.
- nateb2022 3y ago> The next thing for me is to "decloud" - meaning remove any and all online services that are not mission critical. These are often useful, so the better option is to host your own privacy-respecting versions of these tools.
- gumballindie 3y agoI should have phrased it better, indeed what I meant is self hosting by "declouding" from public clouds. My only concern is realiable self hosted backups. But I already have my own setup for newsfeeds, document storage, even for calling friends and relatives, and at the fraction of the cost (I factor in the value of my privacy as part of overall cost). I think there is good potential for self hosted products out there. A major pain point though is self hosting emails, since that requires a lot of work around spam protection and availability.
- dagw 3y agoYup, same here. And the sad things is that Windows was getting so close. Between WSL2, the new terminal and ssh, all the support for VSCode and better dev tools and open source language support, I was becoming a bit of Windows 'fan' and this close to seriously considering Windows 10 a fully usable developer desktop. Then they released Windows 11 and completely shit the bed.
- fidotron 3y agoThe modern iteration of the Start menu is a particular travesty and has been rendered all but unusable in order to push you to Bing by accident. Microsoft simply must believe that Windows can survive the users hating this crap, and I fear they are right. For myself 11 was bad enough to finally try out Steam on Debian and was pleasantly surprised. KDE is closer to being the Windows desktop I want than Windows 11 is, which is just insane. Minor point for the article, OOBE is a very widespread term in the consumer technology industry, not MS specific.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Kye 3y agoThe modern start menu (at least what I see) reminds me of the gnome and KDE equivalents. It's a simple little list of apps, a space to pin those I use a lot, and a snappy search box. Bing is there, but it's gotten less intrusive in 11. The search box is better about surfacing what I'm actually looking for and not showing web searches 99% of the time. So I can't imagine I'm seeing the same thing as what's got so many people up in arms about the start menu. Did I get a weird OEM configuration? It's a newish Lenovo Legion laptop. I haven't changed any start menu settings.
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> So I can't imagine I'm seeing the same thing as what's got so many people up in arms about the start menu. Did I get a weird OEM configuration? To answer that question, check out the screenshot in the article. If you have a similar spittoon-load of crapware installed, you have the same experience as ~everyone else and for some reason you aren't registering it. If you don't, something ethical happened.
- Kye 3y agoI guess it comes down to what you perceive as crapware. I accepted a long time ago that I'm not the target audience for anything aimed at the mainstream. There were some icons I unpinned for apps and tool installers I didn't need. None of them were actually installed. They just went to the MS store. No biggie. I'd expect a lot of people to appreciate links to install/access very mainstream things like Office or Instagram. They're trivial to remove and don't affect performance. When I think crapware, I think bloaty nonsense that no one needs or wants like Bonzi Buddy or 900 different browser toolbars. I don't see unpinning a few things on a fresh install as some great burden.
- MikusR 3y ago"A clean installation is one that is done in the absence of any interfering elements such as old versions of the computer program being installed or leftovers from a previous installation. In particular, the clean installation of an operating system is an installation in which the target disk partition is erased before installation. Since the interfering elements are absent, a clean installation may succeed where an unclean installation may fail or may take significantly longer."
- codeulike 3y agoI keep seeing headlines about Microsoft adding adverts to Windows and whatnot but none of it ever appears infront of me. Is that because I'm on Windows Pro?
- skyyler 3y agoWas Disney+ not there when you booted Windows 11 for the first time?
- andromaton 3y agoPro has all the annoyances the article mentions plus more. Maybe your PC has a genetic mutation like people that can't get COVID.
- wildrhythms 3y agoHit the Super key Type a letter 'a' Backspace Your AI Powered Copilot. Say goodbye to endless search results! Try the New Bing. NCAA Footaball Set To Return. Ask Bing about NCAA Football. Top Football Tailgating Spots. Ranking The Best College Rivalries. Today's News Weather And More. Trending News From The Web. Djokovic wins W&S Open. Confronted by Contestant. Meme dog Cheems dies. Yankees lose 8 in a row. Dentist Guilty of Killing Wife. Criticized for Kissing Player. Spain's Hero Loses Father. Tori Spelling hospitalized. Games For You. Amazing Spider Solitaire. Bricks Breaker Deluxe Crusher. Farm Merge Valley. Bubble Shooter HD. ... (If this gets flagged for spam I don't blame it)
- thousand_nights 3y agowhat is a 'super key'?
- translucyd 3y agoIts Linux for ‘Windows’ key.
- owenmarshall 3y agowindows to lisp machine/emacs/Unix keyboard decoder chart: Control = control Alt = meta Windows flag key = super
- LegitShady 3y agoIt's because everyone got super happy to give their money to apple who has a similar experience in ipad etc. Want to setup apple wallet? Oh you're not backed up here's an iCloud offer in your settings menu. Etc etc. It's gross but it's sort of the norm now. Why shouldn't Microsoft do it if that's ok when apple does it?
- twsted 3y agoFrom the article: 'Apple doesn't mandate Apple ID sign-in. Apple does put "helpful" "reminders" about setting up Apple Pay, iCloud backups, and a few other things into its setup screens, but it doesn't take your full screen over again to try to get you to opt in to things you've already said no to. There is a notification in the Settings app asking you to sign in and set a few things up if you haven't, but they're dismissable, and they stay dismissed. Safari doesn't pester you to switch back to it once you've switched away, like a 4-year-old who asks you what time it is every time the clock changes (I don't know if this is a widely relatable example, but it's my lived reality at present). There are no third-party applications installed beyond the under-the-hood open source bits and pieces that are baked into macOS's foundations.' And: 'My frustration is not so much with what Microsoft is doing but how it is doing it. So many of Microsoft's reminders and notifications feel like they happen at the expense of respecting the user's choices.'
- LegitShady 3y agoPersonally I find putting things in the setting screen with a red indicator to be much scarier to the average person. It doesn't say join iCloud in the heading it says "your iPad is not backed up" and uses that to scare people. Personally I find the dislike of both to be reasonable and I don't think Microsoft's is much worse than apple.
- oefrha 3y agoMicrosoft literally flags not setting up OneDrive as a security issue in Windows Defender or whatever the current iteration is called. The warning pops up in routine scans.
- whoitwas 3y agoI'm a lifetime computer user and software engineer with a half bricked laptop caused by Windows 11. Windows wanted me to create a Microsoft account and somehow me not doing that resulted in a boot loop. I installed Linux on it and work around the Windows partition. I did lose a lot of data that's technically accessible, but too lazy.
- nateb2022 3y agoYou can extract your data from the Windows partition and then delete it entirely from the Linux side.
- whoitwas 3y agoRight, but I bought it for gaming on Windows. Since then the games I want have been released on MacOS, so the use case no longer exists. Now I have an expensive gaming laptop in a box somewhere.
- nateb2022 3y agoIn that case, I'd sell it before it depreciates further. Win-win because then it becomes useful to someone else.
- Omroth 3y agoI use Ubuntu at work and at home. It's a great experience and I am so happy to not have my OS controlled by Microsoft. (Or Apple, but those are for different reasons.)
- kmfrk 3y agoI love a lot of things in their Edge browser, but man if the first ten minutes with it aren't spent disabling and removing stuff. Seems crazy to have browsers throw MSN news feeds at you in 2023 but here we are.
- hardware2win 3y ago>A prompt to pair your phone with your PC. >A Microsoft 365 trial offer. >A 100GB OneDrive offer. >A $1 introductory PC Game Pass offer. Whats so bad about those?
- ekianjo 3y agoWalled gardens to keep you in the Microsoft ecosystem forever
- hardware2win 3y agoYou believe that companies shouldnt ad their other services in their products? I disagree. Ecosystems enable better ux, look at Apple. Also nobody prevents you from moving your files from OneDrive to e.g Google Or using Google docs instead of MS Word
- majewsky 3y agoThis is not informing about other services, this is pushing them on them with sleezy tactics. The article calls out that MS refers to this as "second-chance out of the box experience", or in plain English, "you did not want this the first time, but we need this for our bottom line, so get ready to have this shoved down your throat". I would also not be surprised if they are banking on people accidentally clicking Yes to make the annoyance go away.
- hardware2win 3y ago>This is not informing about other services Is there law for that? There was such a thing for browsers, but I dont know about services
- majewsky 3y agoIn Futurama, there is a gag where Fry finds out about ads being injected in his dreams through brain waves or something. When he is upset by this, his peers do not understand him. So he explains: "Of course we had ads in the 20th century... but only on billboards, and buses, and milk cartons, and [list goes on for a while]. But not in dreams! Nuh-uh!" I think what's happening here is two things: First, a personal computing device is fundamentally an extension of your own self into the digital world, functioning similar to how you use your limbs to interact with the physical world. Having a personal computing device overtly act in someone else's interest and not yours is not that dissimilar to having someone else manipulate your arms and legs to force you to go to certain places or interact with things that you don't want to. Second, most ads have the redeeming quality of being ignorable. If there's an ad on a billboard, I can look somewhere else instead or just close my eyes. If there's an ad on a news website, I can (hopefully!) scroll past it. If there's an ad in my dreams (or indeed, on my home screen), it's forcing itself on me and violating that premise of ignorability.
- buro9 3y agoNow it's just like the Apple experience! Anyone who thinks otherwise, do go through a full install and then observe how many apps are installed that you cannot uninstall. And it's true that you can't really uninstall things from Windows either... Xbox 360 Bar... it will be there forever. If you ever touch Windows Hello PIN logon, that will never be disabled again. The only way to have an OS install be minimal is to choose a Linux, a distro will likely give you lots of things you may not want still (i.e. games, the office suite) but at least you can uninstall those all quickly.
- PrimeMcFly 3y agoApple has always been kind of an awful desktop experience IMO. Never understood why so many technical users like it. Windows 11 is becoming so much worse though. Thank goodness for Linux being the solution for 99% of time.
- vladvasiliu 3y agoI'm a Linux user, but you can't always easily remove the random crap that gets installed. An Ubuntu server install will come with "modem manager" (wtf does that even do?!) and a bunch of other crap which isn't exactly useful in a VM environment. Yet if you try to remove them, you'll find that it tries to remove the whole system since it depends on "ubuntu-server" or some such. Sure, you could remove that meta package and reinstall the things you actually need manually, but that's still a terrible pita. At least all this junk doesn't start up random daemons, like windows does.
- deadlydose 3y agoThis sounds like an Ubuntu problem. My web server is running Debian 12 and ModemManager isn't even installed. For shiggles I installed it just so I could remove it. The extra packages it installed are libjim0.81 libmbim-glib4 libmbim-proxy libmbim-utils libqmi-glib5 libqmi-proxy libqmi-utils libqrtr-glib0 usb-modeswitch usb-modeswitch-data and these are exactly the packages it told me I could autoremove after removing ModemManager.
- therealmarv 3y agoI had to install Windows 11 for my parents computer and it's exactly as the article describes. On top of that you also have to run tools like O&O ShutUp10++ to shut off all telemetry settings. It's like Windows is working against me... I just wanted an OS for my parents laptop and instead I have all this bloatware.
- haunter 3y agoWindows 11 Enterprise + activate it with MAS. It's a clean Windows 11 w/o anything. Windows 10 LTSC is the same. (Windows 11 LTSC will come later next year) I use these for years and don't have any problems.
- capableweb 3y ago> Windows 11 Enterprise How much does that cost compared to Pro or Home? I cannot even find the pricing for it.
- PrimeMcFly 3y agoNot everyone wants to cough up for an Enterprise license for a home PC.
- littlecranky67 3y agoThe year of the Linux Desktop is finally here. Not because Linux solved any of it's problems or added long-awaited features, no. Just because Windows gets shittier every day by adding more crapware, dark patterns, telemetry, and nudging dialogs.
- qbrass 3y agoThe standard Year of the Linux Desktop acceptance speech hasn't changed often in 20 years. The, "We fixed X now, so people will actually use it!" one only gets used on special occasions. 'X' being literal in most of them.
- supertrope 3y agoApple’s “post-PC” marketing line became reality for many individuals. Not because they bought Macs and iPhones but because many Windows problems were avoided on mobile operating systems. Mobile browsers and apps have the majority of mindshare. Mobile devices wake instantly. Official app stores are much safer from malware than the Windows software acquisition ecosystem of running an Internet search, the first search result being malware, he website having fake download buttons, and downloading often unsigned .exe files. There’s no anti-virus software bogging down I/O. There’s less maintenance like disk defragmentation, Windows Updates that take an hour and require a forced restart. Users can’t get lost opening a file they downloaded because files are hidden away through the abstraction of apps. If you’re just consuming content you might not even own a PC.
- Waterluvian 3y agoUgh. I’m OS homeless. Windows is full of garbage. MacOS jumped the shark on UI and is irritating in so many ways as it tries to be some Frankenstein’s monster of a desktop and mobile-inspired UI. And Linux is incapable of watching videos in a browser without destroying my CPU (Nvidia lacks hardware video decoding on Linux) and continues with all the classic “engineers don’t do UX” problems. Not one option feels “good” to me. There’s just levels of tolerable.
- NotSteve 3y agoWhat do you mean about the MacOS UI? It sounds like you're talking about Stage Manager (which I love but understand not liking) but it should be disabled by default.
- pseudalopex 3y agoMobile inspired UI includes Catalyst apps, System Settings, Control Center, narrow dialogs with centered text and buttons, all icons the same shape, title bars gone.
- rollcat 3y agoBig Sur's redesign is an unusable mess. Window borders are pure white. Contrast is non-existent, especially on buttons (both light and dark modes). Too much transparency, it's not just distracting - the menu bar is often unusable (depending on your wallpaper). Many builtin apps exercise too much freedom in customising the look&feel, everything is inconsistent. I understand this was done to bring the design language closer to iOS, or to make iOS apps feel more at home on the Mac. They are not - every time you run an iOS app, it really feels out of place. Some of this can be remedied with accessibility settings. Most things will likely stay broken until someone at Apple calls for yet another pointless redesign that will break something else in return.
- thiht 3y ago> Big Sur's redesign is an unusable mess That’s a hot take. Big Sur’s redesign is perfectly fine. The only redesign I hate is Settings (especially since it disallows full screen, WHY?), but the rest is fine, and arguably less « in your face »
- listenallyall 3y agoThe anti-Win 11 complaints here are entirely valid, however a $5 shareware StartAllBack restores many of the things people liked about prior Windows versions, like the Start Menu, clock, Explorer menus, etc. Winaero Tweaker (free) is another similar program for restoring some older features. This doesn't excuse Microsoft for screwing up so many aspects of Windows but a $5 option to fix most of the things that bother me is a no-brainer.
- mjrpes 3y agoPro Tip: If you create a Win 11 USB install drive with the Rufus utility, you can pre-define a local user and get around the cloud account sign-in roadblock when installing Windows.
- beebeepka 3y agoSome modern gaming gear kind of requires windows to setup basic functionality like turning off lights and stuff. Now, windows has been crap for a while, but it really amazed me that multimedia keys that work on Linux and Mac, somehow require the stupid software to enable functionality that is already configured in firmware.
- holografix 3y agoI’m not upgrading to win 11 anytime soon. Zero desire to do so.
- xg15 3y ago> First, Microsoft account sign-in was made mandatory instead of optional (though third-party tools like Rufus can work around this, and Windows 11 Pro still lets you use a local account if you know all the right buttons to click). It's the Microsoft account sign-in that prompts most of the annoying behavior during the OOBE process. I think this is becoming yet another "boiling the frog" strategy: You don't even have to make this stuff completely impossible - you only have to add enough friction and general unpleasantness that the (mental) costs of using a local account exceed the benefits. Then companies have their cake and eat it too: To everyone saying they are now forced to use an account they can reply "oh no, it's technically still possible to use the software without an account, so no coercion happens" while everyone who actually tries to do so will either give up or look like a lunatic.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoI got to tell ya, one of the blissful things about using a Chromebook is that they don't pull this shit at all. Sure, Google's an ad company, and the telemetry is taken for granted, but they don't put animated, undeletable shit in the app menu, there's never a popup to remind me I haven't purchased something, or even that some obscure, irrelevant system process died or needs attention. There's no shovelware; how could there be? Surely they have many years to enshittify this as well, but in 2023, the ChromeOS experience is clean and mature, it's less expensive, and it's easy on your resources.
- high_5 3y ago> I got to tell ya, one of the blissful things about using a Chromebook is that they don't pull this shit at all. Yet.
- scns 3y agohttps://ameliorated.io/ https://ameliorated.io/ A wizard for modification.
- Simulacra 3y agoNot by choice, I was given a new laptop from HP that required signing into a Microsoft account before the computer would continue its initial setup. I to create a throwaway account just to access the computer my office paid for. That and the cloud-basing of all software (can you even get office for desktop anymore?) and increasingly, it seems like the management of software is taken out of the hands of the user.
- daft_pink 3y agoit's really terrible. I recently had an awful experience with apple and dumped all my apple products and moved to windows. I really feel microsoft's multi-monitor support, wsl, compatibility is a lot better, but the built in spyware from microsoft is outrageous.
- delta_p_delta_x 3y agoOkay; very contrasting opinion here: I use Windows 10 Enterprise, and I don't have any of the crud. I'm holding off on upgrades to Windows 11 until there's a killer feature there that I really need on Windows 10, and so far... nothing yet. As a developer, I use Windows... a lot. I can't imagine writing complicated C++ without Visual Studio; the debugger is just that good. I regularly script and administer my installs with PowerShell. I like writing fast GUI code that will run on Windows XP with not much fuss. Now, I like nuance, so I will distinguish between Windows, the OS—which is actually really nice—and Windows the bean-county bit, which sucks.
- thiht 3y ago98 was great Millenium Edition sucked XP was great Vista sucked Windows 7 was great Windows 8 sucked Windows 10 was (is) great Windows 11 sucks At this point it’s a tradition. Stick to Windows 10 until Windows 12 comes I guess
- thebruce87m 3y agoCan’t believe you missed the greatest: Windows 2000
- marklar423 3y agoThis article really resonated with me, I was a Windows fan for 25 years and it captures why I can't use it anymore - it increasingly feels like Microsoft owns the computer and you're just along for the ride. One of my colleagues maintains a Windows box at home, and tells me he hates opening the thing because whenever he does the OS gives him "chores" to do - you _must_ update this bit, you need to listen to this offer, etc. Like, you're the computer and I'm the human! I give you the work, not the other way around. Anyways, the sum of my rant is I finally switched to PopOS. It's been surprisingly smooth, especially with Proton making Linux gaming so easy. If anybody is thinking of doing it, now's the time to try it out.