6 ms·
Tesla owners say they've been trapped inside their EVs after they lost power
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- IshKebab 3y agoWhy don't the door handles just open the door?
- ZeKK14 3y agoThere is no frame around the window. The electrical door handle opens up a bit the window before unlocking the door to free it from the seal. Without power the manual handle needs to do that also, which is more complicated that a "normal" door handle.
- Zetobal 3y agoIt's not really complicated... it would be more expensive though.
- csydas 3y agoI have very little understanding on the power requirements for a window, but couldn't Tesla have just reserved some battery off the main battery as an emergency fallback? Just enough power to lower the windows to a safe route, maybe illuminate some LEDs on the emergency latches or paths to the emergency latches? I'm not really interested in discussing Tesla's intended design, but more from just a mechanical/electrical standpoint if it would be expensive (power wise) to have a reserve like this. Edit: Also, I guess weight also of such a battery, but I suppose maybe the weight can be understood by how much reserve it would need.
- sMarsIntruder 3y agoBecause of the window frame. When you open the door, the window slides down slightly to clear the frame. If you force it manually, the window might break.
- ilyt 3y agoOther cars had frameless windows without that. Tesla as usual tries to reinvent the wheel badly
- sMarsIntruder 3y agoIn 2010, I bought a car with the same Tesla frameless system, but I guess it was even a bit dumber :)
- jdiff 3y agoThe windows have no frame. They slide up into the body of the car. If the door opens, the car needs to roll the window down a bit, then open the door. Without power, none of that happens. And if you use the emergency switch, the window showers you in shattered glass. Quite an elegant system.
- CogitoCogito 3y agoTalk about form over function.
- gorjusborg 3y agoBut, the design is to die for.
- tmpX7dMeXU 3y agoThere’s no car I’d rather die in.
- kwstas 3y agoTruly an inspired design if that is the case. Also the fact that the rear doors either do not have an emergency release or you have to lift the carpet to get to it is a marvel. Donald Norman very early in his book "The Design of Everyday Things" discusses door design in modern buildings focusing on the lack and/or ambiguity of signifiers. These vehicles solve the problem just by removing the ability to open them.
- Nafnlaus 3y ago"Truly an inspired design if that is the case" - it's not the case. "Rear doors either do not have an emergency release" - you mean like every coupé ever built? Since when were you protesting coupés? Rear doors not only do not have to have manual releases, but don't even have to exist. "lack and/or ambiguity of signifiers" - the front manual release handle is not only not ambiguous, but is far more prominent than the electric release button, so most people with no experience with the car pull it instead of the button. It's also, in all this, noting that modern cars have crash sequences. A crash is detected either (ideally) immediately before, or during its occurrence. A wide range of events are triggered, such as brakes, airbags, etc... and among the things triggered is *unlatching all the doors for easy egress* (the specific details depends on the door design - you want the door easy to open but not to pop out during the crash itself). Now, things can go wrong - the prime characteristic of a crash is that it mangles your car, and this can jam doors shut or cause other problems. This is why the Jaws of Life exists. But prepping the doors for egress is something that cars at least try to do during a crash.
- bob1029 3y agoThe term for this is "indexing windows". I believe the original intention was to simply create a reliable, water-tight seal. I've had this style of window on a sports car for about 10 years and never had any trouble. Many situations where battery was dead or winter weather would make it more difficult to open, but never panic-inducing or made me think it was about to shatter. More of a super sticky seal with the rubber.
- extraduder_ire 3y agoI wonder why the windows broke. I assume something got installed out of order during assembly. I wonder if any other cars have such backup systems to open the doors. That part about bypassing the rear doors' child lock could be quite useful on other vehicles.
- chmod775 3y ago> I wonder if any other cars have such backup systems to open the doors. Many cars don't need backup because the car doesn't need power in the first place to open the doors. The ID.4 is a comparable car that does: the emergency door opening engages if you yank the lever hard twice. No need to hunt for some switch in the interior of the car.
- helsinkiandrew 3y ago> The ID.4 is a comparable car that does: the emergency door opening engages if you yank the lever hard twice. No need to hunt for some switch in the interior of the car. That's a great design - gentle pull on the lever and the electronics opens the latch/door, pull harder and (your) mechanical effort opens the door.
- sklargh 3y agoThis probably the only intuitive human factors design element of my ID.4. I mean that literally.
- t_tsonev 3y agoWhile we're on the subject of Tesla, add the control stalks. Supposedly the Model 3 refresh will be dropping these.
- ilyt 3y agoMy Civic lever isn't all that hard to open. I believe the invention called "springs" allowed that to happen, no need for electronics.
- helsinkiandrew 3y agoIt's quite alarming that a guest or child in the back that hasn't read the manual has no chance of opening the doors in the event of a power failure after a crash. That the Model 3 rear doors can't be opened manually on a power failure is truly alarming.
- Rygian 3y agoMost hoaxes are alarming indeed. EDIT: I misinterpreted the comment I was replying to.
- raesene9 3y agoWhen you say it's a hoax, what bit were you thinking of? Looking at Tesla's Website (https://www.tesla.com/ownersmanual/model3/en_au/GUID-7A32EC01-A17E-42CC-A15B-2E0A39FD07AB.html https://www.tesla.com/ownersmanual/model3/en_au/GUID-7A32EC0...), it does say "Only the front doors are equipped with a manual door release."
- lawn 3y agoAlso quite alarming how many people defend this design.
- archo 3y agohttps://archive.is/vn2b6 https://archive.is/vn2b6
- expertentipp 3y agoAs a kid I was sick of mechanical cranks and levers, especially for car windows. Nowadays not only the door opener is electric, but also it probably sends telemetry to at least one political superpower. The next wave of despotism, like during pandemic, will likely bring thrilling new features and service integrations.
- ilyt 3y agoEven door open one ? I never minded those.
- darkwater 3y agoClaim: it is difficult to find the manual release handle for the doors My reality: every single passenger who had never been on a Tesla before always uses the manual release handle instead of the right button, and I get a warning message on the screen and the risk of breaking the window glass. Source: Tesla M3 owner
- vGPU 3y agoThe first time I was ever in an m3 I did precisely that.
- lawn 3y agoSample size: Very few Type of evidence: Anecdotal Statistical relevance: Tiny
- darkwater 3y agoObviously, it was implied by "My reality". Anyway the only real safety issue I can see is that rear doors doesn't have such a system, but I guess the theory here is that there should never be a case when someone is left alone in the rear seat (i.e. Tesla's "dog mode" explicitly tells you that it's just for pet, not meant for humans)
- earnestzombie2 3y ago[flagged]
- lawn 3y agoIs it that hard to imagine that kids might have trouble finding the switch? Or that the person in the front are rendered unconscious and now the persons at the back are stuck?
- darkwater 3y agoI think you are mixing scenarios here. The initial scenario was that the car had no power (and anyway locks are powered by the LV battery, not the HV one), which is not a safety emergency situation. In that case, the person driving can get out of the car using the mechanical lever and open thee rear door(s) using the normal external handle. In case of an emergency, where no power is available anymore, well ,we are most probably talking about a serious enough car crash. In that case, AFAIK, Tesla - just like any other car manufacturer out there - has a system that trigger airbags and unlock doors when detecting a crash. But yet in that case, the ones in the rear seats has less chances to escape from the car, that's probably true.
- blueflow 3y agoVideo of the handles in action: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mu-tJc-BgaI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mu-tJc-BgaI Both functions are not evident (to me) by looking at the handles. Maybe the Tesla's UI is just bad.
- addandsubtract 3y agoCar UI in general is just all over the place. Every car manufacture does its own thing, from door handles to AC control.
- maxerickson 3y agoA small lever that pulls horizontally inwards, from front to back, is almost standardized for the inside door handle. Front doors usually have an interconnect that opens the lock also. For electronic windows, on newer cars it's nearly standard that the switch can be engages by pushing down or pulling up.
- projektfu 3y agoStrange that the article doesn't have a single photo of the manual release apparatus.
- ourmandave 3y agoAssuming you get out with the manual handle and the glass doesn't break, can you close the door or will that break the glass too? Thinking you're stranded on the roadside and can get a ride, but not a tow until the next day. Do you have to just leave the door open?
- chayesfss 3y ago[dead]