5 ms·
> Renewable energy production is almost entirely aimed at the generation of electricity. However, we use more energy in the form of heat, which solar panels and
by mschuster91 3y ago
> Renewable energy production is almost entirely aimed at the generation of electricity. However, we use more energy in the form of heat, which solar panels and wind turbines can produce only indirectly and relatively inefficiently. A solar thermal collector skips the conversion to electricity and supplies renewable thermal energy in a direct and more efficient way.
Ooof. What? The first paragraph and it's just utter bollocks. Combine a solar panel or a wind turbine with a heat pump and despite generation losses it will outperform any thermal collectors - there's a reason these got virtually phased out!
And on top of that: local windmills, that may work out on farms in backwater rural towns with no grid worth calling it that, but good luck getting a permit for windmills in anywhere else, and when there's no wind you're straight out of luck whereas an electric heat pump can always be powered from the grid, or in the case of a massive power outage, from an on-site backup generator.
- IshKebab 3y agoFor wind sure, but is that true for solar? Solar panels are max 20% efficient and head pumps typically have a COP of 2-3, so solar thermal only has to have an efficiency of around 50%. 1 second googling tells me it is 70%. I think the real reason nobody does solar thermal is because it's just so much less practical to deal with pipes and pumps and heat reservoirs than wires and batteries. Also it is useless in the summer when you don't need heating. Wind is always going to be niche for most people for obvious reasons.
- atoav 3y agoHaving a black water tank on the roof for solar heated warm water is not uncommon in southern Europe. Most camping showers work by the same principle. If you need warm water and you have enough sunlight to warm it when you need it, this is not a bad idea
- Zarathustra30 3y agoI misread that as "(black water) tank" and got worried.
- mschuster91 3y ago> 1 second googling tells me it is 70%. ... at full sun visibility, that is. However, in winter where it's cloudy, raining or, worse, there's snowpack on the panel? Now it's at 0%, right when you actually need it the most. So you have to have the solar heating system and a fallback for winter/night, and the headaches of all that extra pipework just don't make it worth the effort because all you're going to get from it is a few hot showers during summer.
- Retric 3y agoSolar thermal still works with clouds and under light snow, you might be thinking of concentrated solar but that’s a different story. Also, storing a few hundred kWh of heat in a hot water tank is vastly cheaper than batteries. The real advantage of solar thermal is it can scale so well, thus allowing the benefit of a heated pool and later driveway without extreme expense. An expanded mindset around heat being so cheap means you can do things like warm an exterior patio for chilly fall days etc etc.
- WalterBright 3y ago> and later driveway Just mix in nuclear waste with the concrete. It'll keep the driveway free of ice, and illuminated after dark.
- littlestymaar 3y ago(Un)fortunately we don't make enough of such waste to be able to do it at scale (even a city scale).
- shagie 3y agoFlorida is trying... though not enough to heat. https://www.npr.org/2023/05/09/1174789570/florida-roads-radioactive-paving-phosphogypsum https://www.npr.org/2023/05/09/1174789570/florida-roads-radi... And if it's enough to keep the snow away... I want to stay way away from it. The Radiological Incident in Lia, Georgia https://www-pub.iaea.org/MTCD/Publications/PDF/Pub1660web-81061875.pdf https://www-pub.iaea.org/MTCD/Publications/PDF/Pub1660web-81... . I will warn that reading Section 5 is NSFL if you know what you're reading. Section 6 is NSFL with pictures that will make clear what section 5 was about. > On a cold day of 2 December 2001, three inhabitants of Lia (later designated as Patients 1-DN, 2-MG and 3-MB) drove their truck approximately 45–50 km east of Lia to collect firewood. At around 18:00, they found two containers — metallic, cylindrical objects — lying on a forest path. Around them, the snow had curiously thawed within a radius of approximately 1 m, and the wet soil was steaming. All three individuals stated that the two, rather heavy, cylindrical objects (8–10 kg, 10 cm × 15 cm) were found by chance while carrying out their usual task of collecting firewood. > One of the three men (Patient 3-MB) picked up one of the cylindrical objects and, finding that it was hot, dropped it immediately. They planned to place the gathered wood in their truck the next morning, and because it was getting dark, they decided to spend the night in the forest, using the hot objects they had discovered as personal heaters. > ... > The three individuals warmed themselves during the night using the open fire on one side, sitting and lying around it, and not far from the hot cylindrical objects, which they placed at a distance of up to 1 m behind their backs.
- rescbr 3y ago> I think the real reason nobody does solar thermal is because it's just so much less practical to deal with pipes and pumps and heat reservoirs than wires and batteries. It very much depends where one is located. My parents' house, in a subtropical climate region, has had solar thermal for over 2 decades. Now they've also installed PV panels, but hot water is still mainly solar thermal with electrical heating as supplement. New houses also have dual setups like theirs. Solar thermal collectors for hot water + PV for other electric usage and selling the excess to the grid. > Also it is useless in the summer when you don't need heating. You still do need some water heating in the summer.
- malloci 3y agoIs that more or less efficient than a heat pump water heater driven by solar though? A quick search shows that the heat pump option can be upwards of 3x more efficient. Plus, you can use the extra electricity generated to power your fans or heat pump cooling system.
- neRok 3y agoIt's just coming out of winter here in Perth, Western Australia. I have 6.6kw solar power and also a 15 year old solar hot water system with thermostat controlled electric booster (so not ancient, but also not the most advanced tech). On cold and cloudy days the booster turns on and draws far more power than my panels are generating at that moment, but even on nice days it turns on over night when there is no solar power. I saw on one particularly bad day that it turned on 3 times in 24h - 2x when dark - and drew over 1.5kWh each time, and I only used the hot water once in the morning. So I turned the booster off a month or 2 ago (can't remember when exactly, but yes it meant some days I couldn't have a hot shower), and on my recent 2-month power bill I had used 215kWh less than last year! (I also replaced my plasma TV with an OLED in that time, so that might have been responsible for a portion.) So whilst I get free hot water for ~8 months of the year, the other 4 months it uses a ton of electricity. My sister recently got a new hot water system and I showed her some data that showed heat pump ones were better, so that's what she got. The data showed that whilst they use electricity during the summer, they use less during winter, and they end up ahead. But actually we can see on her power bill that when it kicks in on bad days, it too can overwhelm her solar generation at that moment. Ultimately I think we need smarter connected systems to get the best efficiency. The booster in my solar hot water is just a basic element like a kettle. Surely it could be "throttled" (supplied with less watts) or cycled during the day so that it only heats when there is solar power available? If I have to have a slightly-cooler-than-hot shower first thing in the morning because I didn't want it boosting at 4am, then so be it.
- beebeepka 3y ago> I think the real reason nobody does solar thermal is... You have a weird definition of nobody. They are not as popular these days but do exist and are very useful. Don't even that much sun to produce warm water
- falsaberN1 3y agoI worked on solar thermal for a while. It was even mandatory to install in new buildings in my country for a while (before all solar was forbidden for personal use until recently, don't ask, I hated it too. Forced me to become a sysadmin though, which was a good move). You can get pretty good efficiency with solar thermal panels and indeed they are more near the 70% mark. Just a "black paint" panel can get "decent" results and it's relatively cheap. I remember back in the training days, our teacher just held a metal pane, painted black, into the sun for a demonstration. And got to 80ºC in a few minutes. In January. They are not so useless in summer depending on where you live. In my region, despite being tropical-tier hot, water comes out really cold from the urban lines, so you always need to use some gas for a heater (butane or city gas). Having a solar thermal setup completely nullifies that (admittedly not large, but existing) expense during summer and reduces it during winter. Since many buildings here already have it as a feature, it's a little expense reduction which is always welcomed. I miss working on that field.
- kQq9oHeAz6wLLS 3y ago> I remember back in the training days, our teacher just held a metal pane, painted black, into the sun for a demonstration. And got to 80ºC in a few minutes. In January. A bit off topic and slightly different tech, but I have a solar kettle which uses reflected sunlight and boils a liter of water in a bit over an hour. The sun has energy to spare, and I always like learning new was to utilize it.
- hattmall 3y agoIsn't there some way to generate electricity from temperature differential? It seems like solar thermal and ground source water could be an avenue for that.
- abdullahkhalids 3y agoMy undergrad thesis was about modeling a home-sized solar-thermal to electricity setup. The answer was (1) you could barely eek out something of value if you really tried (2) it would be beaten by solar panels hands down. The problem is that electricity production is dependent on the difference in temperature between your hot liquid and the environment. And the 70C-30C with water you will get in the summer is simply not enough to produce much. Realistically, you need ten times this difference to do anything useful. The other option is to heat oil, with lower heat capacity. That you could heat to a bit higher temperatures, but then you are going to continuously lose oil that has to be topped up. Unfortunately, despite my dreams, such systems seem economically unrealistic.
- veb 3y agoI have seen these turbines within city limits (in NZ): https://www.powerhousewind.co.nz/thinair-wind-turbine/ https://www.powerhousewind.co.nz/thinair-wind-turbine/ apparently they make a lot less noise. I'm sure some intelligent people will keep iterating on these technologies. They do an awesome solar+wind deal too: https://www.powerhousewind.co.nz/powercrate/ https://www.powerhousewind.co.nz/powercrate/
- landemva 3y agoA friend is thinking of remodel and add solar thermal to heat basement, garage in-floor heat, and another loop for driveway snow melt. The place is well above a mile high. At first thought, it seems very practical during remodeling.
- melenaboija 3y ago> I think the real reason nobody does solar thermal is because it's just so much less practical to deal with pipes and pumps and heat reservoirs than wires and batteries. Also it is useless in the summer when you don't need heating. I am not sure this is true for all use cases and locations. In Spain it is mandatory since 2006 to install solar thermal panels in new buildings [1], it simply preheats water, in this case this seems way simpler than any electrical installation and you already have an energy gain. Hot water is used all year round and Spain has a good amount of sunny days. [1] https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna15698812 https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna15698812
- pmontra 3y agoA long 1" black pipe on the roof can provide plenty of hot water in summer for showers. By the way, pipes are one of those things that are both metric and imperial in metric countries. We have two different series of pipes here in Italy, one with 1/2, 5/8, 1, 1 1/4 inches and one in millimeters. Gardening leans toward inches and those sturdy black plastic pipes are at least 1".
- pjc50 3y agoThe UK does this a lot: items sold with the size marked in metric, as required, but rounded to an _imperial_ size. So you get 6.3mm drill bits and 454g bags of flour.
- aziaziazi 3y ago> Combine a solar panel or a wind turbine with a heat pump Two studies did that and mechanical heat pumps win. Here’s the links from the blog post: https://elib.dlr.de/103317/1/20160224%20-%20Master%20Thesis_NITTO.pdf https://elib.dlr.de/103317/1/20160224%20-%20Master%20Thesis_... https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0960148115003079 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S096014811...
- mlyle 3y agoYou're talking past each other. He responded to a statement in the article comparing solar thermal collection with solar + heat pump. The article mostly talks about mechanical heat pumps, and you leapt to that, talking past him. (I think both the article and him are not strictly correct: solar thermal heating has a place but is not typically a efficiency win).
- Turskarama 3y agoThe place for solar thermal is probably ease of maintenance. No moving parts means a lot less to go wrong, and a lot cheaper/easier to fix if something does go wrong. That said, better house design gets you pretty much all the way there, and in places where you cannot design a house to get enough sun to heat it properly you also probably can't get enough for a solar collector to help much.
- mlyle 3y agoSolar thermal is also great for e.g. heating pools.
- Doxin 3y ago> The place for solar thermal is probably ease of maintenance. Can vouch for this. We've gone through three water heaters and a bunch of maintenance on those, and in the same time the solar collector has been replaced zero times and required no maintenance. It's honestly quite impressive.
- 3y ago
- ForHackernews 3y ago> but good luck getting a permit for windmills in anywhere else Just because silly bureaucracy exists doesn't mean something is a bad idea.
- littlestymaar 3y ago> there's a reason these got virtually phased out! Citation needed. In my country they sell very well nowadays so they don't look as they've been phased out at all. And for good reason IMHO: they are much more rustic than heat pumps and are likely going to live for much longer than the later with cheaper maintenance. Also, as heat can be stored pretty efficiently (and cheaply) compared to electricity, the day/night intermittency isn't so big of a deal.
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- BostonEnginerd 3y agoHeat pumps are somewhat limited in the heat they can provide. For example, it would be difficult for a heat pump to produce several hundred degrees C temperatures for an industrial process. For applications in their wheelhouse, though, they are absolutely amazing.
- stephen_g 3y agoThere's plenty of research going into very high-temperature heat pumps. It's likely that eventually that will absolutely be 'in their wheelhouse'. Sure, the COP might only ever be something like 2-3 instead of lower temperature heat pumps (under 80 or so °C) that can be > 4 COP but still should be more than 1...
- Jiocus 3y agoThe article brings this up towards the end, "These [eddy current heaters/induction heaters] are comprised of a magnet mounted on a rotating shaft, and can reach temperatures of up to 600 degrees Celsius. Using eddy current heaters, windmills could provide direct heat at higher temperatures, making their potential use in industry even larger."
- whatshisface 3y agoThere are a couple physical principles that work together to limit solar thermal collectors: heat flows from hot to cold, and mirrors and lenses work both ways. Together, they imply that a solar collector can't heat up anything hotter than the surface of the sun because if the target was hotter than the sun, it would heat the sun up and not the other way around. The surface of the sun is 5.7 thousand Kelvin. This is enough to melt, but not boil tungsten, which I must imagine is a major issue for the tungsten gas industry.
- berkes 3y agoBut if you compress the energy collected on a large surface onto a small surface, getting higher heat should be possible, not?
- 3y ago
- bialpio 3y agoOTOH, I can probably whip up a small windmill using the scrap wood I have laying around under my carport. I'll need to buy some parts for mechanisms / power transmission though...
- mistercow 3y agoI wonder how difficult it would be to engineer a direct wind powered heat pump. Theoretically, you could just mechanically drive the compressor and fans, and skip electricity generation. (To be clear, I'm sure this would not make sense economically, but it would be really cool.)
- dsr_ 3y agoIf you have really steady winds, sure. Otherwise you're probably going to need to smooth out the RPM with an intermediate stage like a flywheel.
- oceanplexian 3y agoActually you don’t even need a mechanical compressor. If you know how a propane fridge works, they boil an Ammonia mixture until it becomes a gas, it‘s condensed back into a liquid, and voila, refrigeration. With the right materials you could use thermal solar panels to build a silent air conditioner just as easily as a heater with no moving parts, in theory. Here's an old video on the principles behind it (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KDPgGDCdAo4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KDPgGDCdAo4).
- littlestymaar 3y agoSince I've heard about propane fridges I don't understand why we don't use such a thermal-solar AC everywhere. Like using the sun itself to cool you off without even needing moving parts sounds like the holy grail of AC, surely there must be engineering difficulties but what are those?
- Xylakant 3y agoFor a winning combination, you can use combined thermal/solar panels and then drive a heat pump with the electricity on the pre-warmed water. But that adds complexity. The primary reason we use electricity as intermediary is that it’s comparatively easy to transport even for longer distances and can be used to drive almost any that needs energy - produce heat, cold, mechanical work, computers, …
- runeks 3y ago> Combine a solar panel or a wind turbine with a heat pump and despite generation losses it will outperform any thermal collectors - there's a reason these got virtually phased out! Please expand on this. I have no idea how these two compare in efficiency (but apparently you do).
- jaggederest 3y agoThermal collectors, at best, can capture about 90% of the sun's energy. Practically speaking a bit less. Solar panels, at their best, can capture about 25% of the sun's energy as electricity. There exist heat pumps with a coefficient of performance (COP) such that the system as a whole captures more heat i.e. COP >4 I'm not sure the claim is absolutely true universally, especially in challenging environments, but in a broad sense it is true that turning sunlight into electricity and then using that electricity to power a heat pump has a bunch of advantages over direct solar thermal, not least of which is air conditioning.
- runeks 3y ago> Solar panels, at their best, can capture about 25% of the sun's energy as electricity. There exist heat pumps with a coefficient of performance (COP) such that the system as a whole captures more heat i.e. COP >4 Am I understanding it correct that the efficiency is, in this case (25%; COP >4), greater than 100%?
- jaggederest 3y agoYes, because it is moving scavenged heat to where it is useful. So 1/4 of the energy comes from the electricity, the other 3/4 from ambient atmosphere.
- philjohn 3y agoCan't comment on a thermal collector, but if we look at efficiency of solar PV and heat pumps: Solar PV panel: the best ones are up to about 22% efficiency. Heat pumps: again, top of the line approaches 400% You can't just multiply those numbers, however, there's also losses when you invert DC to AC, but it might be a good starting point.
- dacryn 3y agobut thermal collectors are a lot cheaper than heat pumps, thats also important to consider