6 ms·
It used to be said this would fail in passenger markets because windows. The reality of long haul travel these days is that windows are really only "I can lean
by ggm 3y ago
It used to be said this would fail in passenger markets because windows. The reality of long haul travel these days is that windows are really only "I can lean here" choices which restrict access to the aisle, for any trans-oceanic journey.
For domestic flights, I am sure there are window seat aficionado who will continue to pay for window in flight. For everyone else, and by current seating maps there are a LOT more of them, this is just a non issue.
If a BWB design permits reasonable density, aisle access, fuel efficiency and a pleasant flight experience (speed, noise) then I'm all for it.
If it has to be a freight or logistics/materiel/fuel aircraft for the forces before general service, so be it.
- pintxo 3y agoThe real problems seem to be the outside dimensions (primarily width) of the BWB and the question of how to evacuate such a geometry effectively.
- marcosdumay 3y agoWell, you also have more places to put evacuation corridors and extra doors.
- notahacker 3y agoThere are fewer viable spots to put evacuation doors than a conventional tube. The greater internal space means a lot more potential redundancy and width and not necessarily more distance for evacuation routes, but traditional airline economics means packing it with seats.
- marcosdumay 3y agoWell, yeah, if you pack every space available for evacuation with seats, you won't be able to evacuate the airplane. That doesn't change the fact that there is space for more corridors. Airline economics depends on a lot of factors (like fast boarding), and being allowed to fly the plane is one of them. Satisfying that requirement to flying is patently possible, but unless you have some non-public data, none of us can tell if it's profitable.
- xwdv 3y agoIt would fail because people farther from the center of the plain would feel more extreme movement as the plane banks on turns.
- usuallyalurker 3y agoBWB aircraft have a few more issues than just a lack of window seats. They require a higher angle of attack on take-off and landing, and, with passengers sitting much further from the centerline of the aircraft than on a conventional design, passengers are subject to much more g-forces during roll maneuvers. The second issue can be mitigated by avoiding rolling the aircraft and/or by performing less aggressive rolls, but the first issue is something passengers will just have to deal with if BWB passenger aircraft become a thing.
- twic 3y agoI wonder if you could tilt everyone's seats forward during takeoff and landing. I've seen very high density seating in the far east where people are virtually standing. Maybe the seats could start off that way, stay that way through takeoff and ascent, then gently lower to a normal posture in level flight.
- pcardoso 3y agoLike the pendolino trains? Perhaps it could work, but will make the seats more complicated.
- bobthepanda 3y agoYou would certainly need space to rotate a seat. The only seats that do change shape, those lie flat seats, need a fair amount of room around to not bump into something else while changing shape.
- inglor_cz 3y agoI am right now sitting in a Pendolino train, not far from Prague :) Pendolino is a nice technology, but expensive to maintain. And aircraft, unlike trains, is very sensitive to total weight; the actuators for the seats will be extra dead weight that you need to lift, and this extra weight may eat quite a bit of the fuel savings, if not all of them.
- bee_rider 3y ago
- bilsbie 3y agoMaybe we’d gain enough space for a designated viewing area passengers could visit.
- TrainedMonkey 3y agoI love your optimism. There are already designating viewing areas and bars for people who shell out first class $$$. But vast majority of people happen to be rational economic agents who choose lower price tickets. So the reality is - there will just be more seats.
- mikepurvis 3y agoAlso, the best viewing is typically at landing and takeoff when everyone needs to be seated anyway, so I expect it'll end up as a selection of outdoor camera feeds that are available from your seat-back display.
- TulliusCicero 3y agoPerhaps on a few planes, but for most, economics means it'll make more sense to just put more seats there.
- Rebelgecko 3y agoOr maybe put up partitions in the middle of the plane with digital "windows" embedded inside
- moffkalast 3y agoIf this is the only practical solution for hydrogen fuelled aircraft, then it can't fail in passenger markets because there will be no other alternative to compete against once kerosene is too ecologically taxed.
- jaipilot747 3y agoIs there even a hydrogen turbojet engine?
- twic 3y agoMaybe not in service, but it's been done: https://www.reuters.com/business/aerospace-defense/rolls-royce-successfully-tests-hydrogen-powered-jet-engine-2022-11-28/ https://www.reuters.com/business/aerospace-defense/rolls-roy...
- moffkalast 3y agoAfaik it's one of the three H2 airframe options Airbus is pursuing. https://www.airbus.com/en/innovation/low-carbon-aviation/hydrogen/zeroe https://www.airbus.com/en/innovation/low-carbon-aviation/hyd... The general idea is to use liquid H2, like the old KN-88 design. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kuznetsov_NK-88 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kuznetsov_NK-88
- twic 3y agoIf you can make carbon-neutral hydrogen, you can combine it with atmospheric CO2 to make synthetic hydrocarbons (or methanol) that are carbon-neutral. There's an energy cost to doing this, but I'm willing to bet it far outweighs the costs of running an airliner on hydrogen.
- Turskarama 3y agoI'm not so sure. The big issue with Hydrogen is transport, it's an absolute pain to deliver it to fuel stations all over the country. With planes though, you only need to deliver it to an airport. Airports are also very frequently placed next to large bodies of water, so with enough electricity you could make it on site. I'm willing to bet that Hydrogen will never take off for cars, but I think it could have a place for planes and ships, and even trucks in some situations.
- ge96 3y agoImagine if it's designed like this: ---------------- and you're seated here --------|------- Uh pardon me, excuse, pardon me... to get out
- OldGuyInTheClub 3y agoHere's Jack Northrop's view of a flying wing passenger plane. There's a longer version somewhere but I can't find it. Fitting that JetZero is teaming with Northrop Grumman/Scaled Composites on this. I wonder how the workshare divides. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JMTwQ9b5hvk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JMTwQ9b5hvk
- someplaceguy 3y agoThat looks cool, but wouldn't such an airplane have huge drag due to the wing having to be so thick to accommodate the passengers?
- notahacker 3y ago> If it has to be a freight or logistics/materiel/fuel aircraft for the forces before general service, so be it. The challenge for that is economic: those use cases which are generally filled with adaptations of older generation aircraft at the moment probably don't pay back the R&D costs of the programme. Especially since a viable civil aircraft programme also involves worldwide line maintenance capability, a liquid aftermarket etc. Blended wings are are not a novel idea, and the major airframers have produced multiple concepts, often combined with theoretically much more efficient open rotor engines. The first attempt at a blended wing passenger aircraft was actually over 100 years ago (it was years ahead of its time... and it crashed on its first flight). But there are a lot of challenges other than the passenger experience characteristics people have already mentioned: instead of a simple tube, you now have a broad internal space that needs bracing in a way which doesn't add weight or negate space advantages, and novel designs greatly increased uncertainty in an industry whose safety record relies on predictability. And there's commercial conservatism in an industry whose customer base invests billions in new airframes on the expectation of commonality with existing airframes, phased replacements over predictable replacement cycles etc, and where the second entrance to the market sector might well be the most successful.... Military use involves completely different economics, but for related reasons the anticipated greater fuel efficiency is rarely a big deal for the military. Still, if the military write blank checks, that leaves scope for prototypes that airline executives might struggle to say no to
- neltnerb 3y ago> Military use involves completely different economics, but for related reasons the anticipated greater fuel efficiency is rarely a big deal for the military. I think this assumption is wrong, for airplanes. Higher fuel efficiency means longer range for the same amount of fuel, so it's an increase to range for the same weight carried (or an increase in weight carried to the same range, presumably). I think this is extremely important to the military.
- notahacker 3y agoIt's not completely useless, but the US military's existing transport aircraft are not exactly pushing the boundaries of fuel consumption. A regular 777 freighter will get quite a bit further. Ultimately the military don't care about the cost, have many refuelling options, and are relying on much shorter range aircraft in other aspects of any conflict. Plus unlike other areas of aviation, if you solve a range problem with a bigger fuel tank, you don't get beaten to death by the bean counters. That's quite different from an airline, where a 20% saving in their largest expense against a 3% margin in a price competitive industry is game changing
- e40 3y agoIt's been many years since the window next to me was open. So, I totally agree. And for the last flight I took, the windows were a real PITA, since too many people had them open and there was wicked glare. A good 30-60 minutes I spent bobbing and weaving to avoid it being in my eyes.
- KingLancelot 3y ago[dead]
- _hypx 3y agoWindows in planes can be replaced by LCD screens. I don't think they are necessary at all. In fact, they already sell cruise ship cabins with this feature. I've yet to hear anyone talk about this as a showstopper problem.
- zarzavat 3y agoThe windows are there for safety, not just passenger comfort. Pilots need to know what is going on outside on the aircraft.
- jqpabc123 3y agoFor domestic flights, I am sure there are window seat aficionado who will continue to pay for window in flight. The modern solution to the "window seat" is an exterior camera(s) feed accessible from the LCD touch screen in the seatback in front of you.