5 ms·
Things like this are to be expected with shared IP addresses for mail services. This sounds like something Amazon should figure out more than anything. There's
by jeroenhd 3y ago
Things like this are to be expected with shared IP addresses for mail services.
This sounds like something Amazon should figure out more than anything. There's probably something going on with a customer or theirs (misconfiguration, spammer, vulnerability exploited) that's triggering spam detection rules.
At least Google reports the issue back to you instead of silently dropping all of your email like many other mail servers do.
- baobabKoodaa 3y agoGoogle also silently drops mail in some cases.
- jeffbee 3y agoWhich cases?
- betaby 3y agoImpossible to know. But in my cases from any IP with low volume. I.e. I have a bunch of personal servers for 10+ years, there are rarely outgoing emails from them and google happily just black-hole emails from such low volume IPs.
- jeffbee 3y agoI'd be surprised if this was accurate. A low-volume IP might get a temporary failure code 4xx, but that's not silent. If they accept your message they intend to deliver it, or bounce it. Perhaps your return path is defective.
- alyandon 3y agoGoogle used to do this for low volume emails I was literally sending to myself by authenticating with my google smtp account credentials. I could find no rhyme or reason to it. It would claim to accept emails and they would never show up in my inbox or in spam. Sometimes they would get delivered to spam. Sometimes to my inbox like expected. It most often involved security log snippets which would include ip addresses and hostnames that were likely already on "is a known bad actor" list. Bug on their end? Intentional thing to disrupt spammers? I don't know.
- jeffbee 3y agoWell, I won't contradict your personal experience, but I will say that I worked on gmail delivery for six years and if during that time it had ever come to light that any message had been accepted and not ultimately disposed of in some way, that would have been P0 and dozens of people would have dropped everything in order to root-cause and remediate that.
- alyandon 3y agoThat's cool and all and I'll take your statement in good faith. However, how do I as a user report that an email that was accepted by Google's own SMTP servers was not subsequently delivered to my Gmail inbox? I can't call or email support and it is a meme at this point that Google support is only accessible via social media or contacting a Google insider.
- jeffbee 3y agoI only have the perspective from the edges of the organization, and from years ago, but I can’t recall investigating anything other than support tickets that came from account representatives. So you probably need a paid account. That said, these are as little as $1.99/month. I am certain that if you have a case that reproduces even one in a million times the relevant teams will be highly attentive.
- alyandon 3y agoThis was really only a problem 3 or 4 years ago. At some point in time, it just stopped happening and I hadn't really thought about it since then. I am a Google One subscriber so there are probably some support options open to me that I could avail myself to if the issue ever resurfaced that weren't available to me when I wasn't a subscriber.
- baobabKoodaa 3y ago> Well, I won't contradict your personal experience, but I will say that I worked on gmail delivery for six years and if during that time it had ever come to light that any message had been accepted and not ultimately disposed of in some way, that would have been P0 and dozens of people would have dropped everything in order to root-cause and remediate that. How would you even know? Last I checked, I was unable to find any support path to Gmail where one could report email-blackholing-instances and get them investigated. This is what I wrote several years ago at the point when I gave up trying to run my own email server: > Over the course of 2 years that I was actively using my own server to send email from the same domain and same IP, there were periods of time when my emails were landing in Gmail’s inbox. And then there were periods of time when my emails were placed in spam, sometimes outright bounced, and sometimes received and dropped without even landing in the spam folder. You could never know what Gmail would do with your email. https://www.attejuvonen.fi/dont-send-email-from-your-own-server/ https://www.attejuvonen.fi/dont-send-email-from-your-own-ser...
- jeroenhd 3y agoI've never experienced that. When mail gets dropped, my experience is that you either receive a notice from the SMTP service or get a DMARC report that tells you about the percentage of dropped mail.
- baobabKoodaa 3y agoPlease explain how you measured your email deliverability.
- alyandon 3y agoI finally started sending anything from AWS SES straight to trash because the spam on their platform is persistent and they are non-responsive to spam reports. I was getting 30+ fraudulent/spam emails a day in just one inbox alone.
- nostrebored 3y agoThat's untrue. I can tell you that spam reports and bounces are monitored, and customers do have to go through validation of their workflows if they breach thresholds. I had to help multiple customers who had access to SES shut off for valid use cases because they didn't handle events coming back from customers appropriately.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 0ct4via 3y agoYour experience of customers not handling events appropriately - and then having SES access revoked - does not negate or disprove alyandon's experience of getting no responses to spam reports. You may have had a different experience, but that doesn't make their (differing) experience "untrue."
- alyandon 3y agoI can tell you that spam reports and bounces are monitored If they are, I saw no evidence of that (except for the initial auto-response) based on the numerous spam reports I manually submitted with headers, dates/times and body content. If you work for SES, you all aren't acting swiftly enough to shut down egregious spam operators using your platform that are making other people's lives miserable.
- dpifke 3y agoI have never gotten a response to an SES spam report. A quick search turns up 50 or so in my sent mail folder within the past year or two. 3 of the most recent 5 reports are all the same message content (likely the same sender, although possibly using different—maybe hacked—accounts). By way of comparison, I've sent a similar volume of complaints to Twilio Sendgrid, received a response to every single complaint, and a random sampling of recent reports doesn't show any repeat message content. Google doesn't even provide a way to report spam from Gmail users, which is ironic given the OP is complaining about Google's aggressive spam blocking. Spam from Gmail is comparable in volume to what I receive from SES and Sendgrid, and almost all of those messages are obvious phishing and 419 scams. (One would think one of the largest tech companies in the world would be able to implement basic filters to catch these, if they cared enough to do so.) Cf. spam from SES, which is mostly either cryptocurrency pump-and-dump, or semi-legit companies sending to spamtrap addresses that appear on publicly-indexed web pages, in WHOIS, etc. but which have been never used for real correspondence (and have obviously never opted in to any lists).
- nomilk 3y agoVery useful thread. I recently considered SES for a quick app and didn't discover the purpose of dedicated IPs. They're listed under add ons, but seem somewhat essential if the emails are important. Checking out the pricing page, a dedicated IP costs $24.95 per month, which would be more than the actual cost of emails for many small-medium apps (e.g. 100K emails per month would be about $10). Ooc, do other email providers have the same shared-IP problem? E.g. Mailgun, Postmark, Sendgrid? Source: https://aws.amazon.com/ses/pricing/ https://aws.amazon.com/ses/pricing/
- LinuxBender 3y agodo other email providers have the same shared-IP problem? Yes, that is why they let people get a dedicated IP pools and FCrDNS using their corporation name for a price. It is not uncommon for the shared IP pools to get rate limits, temporary blocks, etc... and the corporation specific dedicated IP's are more likely to get through especially if they handle UCE complaints properly.
- nomilk 3y ago> Yes I didn't spend a huge amount of time reading the docs (just enough to get up and running), but I didn't notice this about other providers either. Great to be aware of this for future reference.
- dubcanada 3y agoPostmark spends A LOT of effort to keep their shared IPs perfect. Rather complex setup with verification. And lots of stuff in place to prevent anything spam related. But everyone else doesn't really care much.
- bdcravens 3y agoSendgrid's cheapest plan with a dedicated IP is $89/mo.
- shmoogy 3y agoDedicated can be an issue unless you have sufficient volume, unless I've been mislead in the past.