9 ms·
Broadband monopolies push bill that would crush the ability to stand up to them
- rayiner 3y agoFull disclosure: I represent telecom companies, but I’m speaking only for myself. > [The bill] eliminates the ability of local governments to require rules such as an ISP having to serve the whole community Such requirements kill fiber development. Laying fiber is expensive, and having to lay it through neighborhoods where most people won’t or can’t subscribe just increases the price for everyone. It’s not just the traditional telcos or cable companies. There is a reason Google Fiber has this concept of “fiberhoods” where you need a certain level of demonstrated interest in subscription before they’ll build in those areas. The city of Baltimore wanted to kick out Comcast and have someone build fiber across the city. Verizon wouldn’t do it because of the coverage requirements. Google wouldn’t do it either. The city is now looking at building the network itself, but it has no money: https://www.thebaltimorebanner.com/politics-power/local-government/internet-wifi-high-speed-baltimore-city-digital-divide-H5FWXF2Q75BELPOFBGIYPWVZGU/ https://www.thebaltimorebanner.com/politics-power/local-gove... Many of the other things the article complains about are similarly roadblocks to development. It’s actually the same exact thing as NIMBY regulations that stop housing development. Again, look at the places Google ended up deploying fiber. If you ignore webpass, every deployment is in states that are low-regulation generally (Utah, Georgia, Colorado, Texas, etc.)
- wing-_-nuts 3y agoWhy is running fiber somehow more expensive than dsl, cable, or power cables? Spoiler; It's not. Chattanooga's EPB runs fiber to every home that has power. Internet should be treated like the essential utility it is. If we were successfully able to run electricity to farm houses in the 1930s, I see no reason at all they shouldn't have fiber internet in 2023.
- packetlost 3y agoThe fiber is, to my knowledge, cheaper than the equivalent copper per mile. There's bigger than you'd think costs basically every step of the way to lay a new line regardless of the medium, with the local power utility often times being a major hangup. The question is almost never about the cost of laying fiber vs laying copper, it's about laying a new line (fiber) or laying nothing (use existing copper). You have to get permission from every land owner whose ditch/yard you need to dig up. Using poles is usually not an option because they're typically owned by the local power utility who either won't let ISPs use them at all or drastically increase operating costs to the point where it's not feasible. Power supply for actively powered equipment can be hard in lower density (ie. rural) areas (from a bureaucratic standpoint). Copper nodes can sometimes be passively powered, but there's not much in fiber optics that can outside of GPON splitters.
- gottorf 3y ago> The question is almost never about the cost of laying fiber vs laying copper, it's about laying a new line (fiber) or laying nothing (use existing copper). Yep, exactly. 99.99% of the cost of laying anything (underground, above ground, wherever) is in the permitting and digging/hanging. The cost of the material itself and the labor of handling it is rounding error.
- rayiner 3y ago> Why is running fiber somehow more expensive than dsl, cable, or power cables? Because we’re running fiber in the 21st century while DSL, cable, and power have mostly already been in the ground for decades. The cost of building any kind of infrastructure has increased exponentially over the decades. We literally could not build today a lot of the infrastructure we already have in the ground—e.g. the New York subway. > Chattanooga's EPB runs fiber to every home that has power. EPB got a $110 million grant from the ARRA ($1,000 per fiber subscriber), and also leverages economies of scale because the fiber network is used both for the electric grid and the fiber service. I think that’s actually a great way to deploy fiber, but it doesn’t tell you anything about the economics of a fiber provider that isn’t the electric utility.
- gavinhoward 3y agoUh huh, so is that the only thing the bill does not let local governments decide? Of course not. Let local governments regulate for their city. If they make bad decisions, they will reap the consequences. In any case, telcos should never get immunity from any local laws and regulations. Edit: And it's not like telcos can't go to city council meetings and explain, with numbers, why certain regulations are bad. In addition, I bet that if the telcos were forced to build an entire neighborhood, they would actually lower their prices to get more people to sign up in order to better recoup their costs. That would be a good thing! Telcos want the monopoly without regulations. But if you're a monopoly, you have to be regulated or you're going to abuse your position. So I don't feel sorry for telcos at all.
- ilyt 3y agoAlso building fiber infrastructure for city is multi-decade investment. For corporation its whatever next fiscal year result investment. Small city with fiber everywhere is pretty attractive place for people that can work remotely and that brings money to local economy.
- hiatus 3y agoMaybe they wouldn't have to trench and lay fiber if they could make use of the public utility poles. But even that has been fraught. https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2018/01/att-and-comcast-finalize-court-victory-over-nashville-and-google-fiber/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2018/01/att-and-comcast-...
- axus 3y agoI'd think the local governments know what they're getting into, and if not they figure it out after a few years. Nobody is requiring providers to enter those local markets and be unprofitable. Telecoms could raise local prices until covering 100% of the area is profitable. "Local government requiring customer service standards" might be a harder thing for them to comply with.
- rayiner 3y agoLocal governments don’t care if their regulations keep out fiber, just like they don’t care if their regulations keep out housing development. When I lived in Baltimore, Verizon was trying to wire it up with fiber. The city wanted Google to come in and it wouldn’t. A decade later, there’s still no fiber in Baltimore. https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2013/08/snubbed-by-google-fiber-mad-at-comcast-baltimore-seeks-its-own-fiber/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2013/08/snubb... Raising prices doesn’t work, because the other customers won’t pay that much more for fiber versus cable. My parents just switched from fiber to cable because they liked the TV packages better.
- tw04 3y ago>Such requirements kill fiber development. Laying fiber is expensive, and having to lay it through neighborhoods where most people won’t or can’t subscribe just increases the price for everyone. Odd, laying fiber was deemed "too expensive" to lay in a community where we have a family cabin. Instead, someone formed a co-op. Everyone is getting wired, and the speeds:price is SIGNIFICANTLY less than Comcast, with symmetric up/down to boot. I appreciate you've got a job to do and a talk track, but it's simply not accurate. What you MEAN to say is: wiring everyone in a community results in a margin profile that's below what large Telco executives find acceptable, so they focus on areas with high adoption rates and low deployment costs and tell community's that it's just "too expensive" to do anything else.
- jjoonathan 3y agoI wish we gave companies even 1/10th the flak that we give people for acting entitled. This right here is a perfect example, but it happens all the time.
- gwright 3y agoYour two examples leave some questions. You seem to be saying that your cabin community was able to find a solution that would not be acceptable to a large telco. Why isn't that OK? Why should the large company be forced to do something they don't want to do if, by your example, other organizations are capable of servicing those communities? To rephrase the question: What, if anything, prevents smaller organizations or non-profits or niche companies from servicing areas that large telcos will only do through regulatory mandates? Can the business/regulatory climate be improved to facilitate these smaller organizations? Are there existing regulations (for example access to poles or conduits) in some areas that block smaller organizations?
- jjoonathan 3y ago> Why isn't that OK? Ask the telcos lobbying to stop it. That's the problem.
- tw04 3y ago>You seem to be saying that your cabin community was able to find a solution that would not be acceptable to a large telco. Why isn't that OK? Why should the large company be forced to do something they don't want to do if, by your example, other organizations are capable of servicing those communities? Because they're also actively lobbying to kill any local co-op formation. Successfully in many states. They tried here and got shot down, then proclaimed they were going to build out fiber themselves in the co-op's targeted service area (they didn't). There are states where they were successful in getting laws passed preventing "wasteful government spending on broadband networks" - the end result of this will be people who literally have no possible way to EVER get broadband.
- mint2 3y agoThe bill does way more than that, all horrible things. Care to comment on them? Also, I lived for a time in Irvine Ca, one of the nation’s high tech hubs. Apparently Irvine did not have a whole community requirement on fiber. Parts of the city had google fiber and also att fiber. But Guess what att offered my neighborhood? My neighborhood was one of the fairly central areas developed in the 70s and they only offered 5mb/s DSL. In one of the highest tech areas of the nation and surrounded by fiber networks, my neighborhoods internet options was cox cable or att DSL that they happily charged the same price for their 5/1 DSL service that cox charged for 50/10. Not only that, they spammed adds for att fiber just to add insult to injury. Sounds like community requirements are very much needed to prevent neighborhood red lining.
- JJMcJ 3y agoEven Silicon Valley did not really get residential fiber until about 10 or so years ago. Speaking of tech hubs.
- rayiner 3y ago[flagged]
- mint2 3y agoWhy do people try to make everything about red versus blue? Are you saying all red states are 100% fiber covered meccas? Sounds like your area is good but so was the block half a mile over in irvine. Congrats on living half a block over? The point about internet companies having more lobbying power is odd as internet companies should want more connectivity not bad DSL. And the OC is traditionally a Republican stronghold in CA and only recently changed. The city of Irvine has switched back and forth between dysfunctional politicians from both parties. Why are you jumping to an us vs them red blue scenario in every situation?
- rayiner 3y ago[flagged]
- sheepshear 3y ago[dead]
- mindslight 3y agoThe communications monopolies are quasi-governmental entities whose primary business is crafting plausible sounding narratives about why they can't be bothered to do anything without one-way handouts from the de jure government. In reality municipal fiber has no problem building out out complete cities and towns, with obvious mandates to the serve the whole population, and from what I've seen they're doing a great job. Regardless of density, infrastructure has an intrinsic capital cost that needs to be accounted on the order of a decade, and moribund dinosaurs based around short term revenue extraction aren't capable of doing that. It sounds like Baltimore's problem is, as you said, having no money. Getting an advance from a loan shark when you have no money is a poor idea, as you will be under their thumb and paying it back forever. My own experience: GPON. moderate density (power goes out at least several times a year due to trees), under $80/mo fixed (no continual price hikes, no deliberately confusing fees, no contract), full gigabit up/down with no usage-based gouging, no incentive to surveil my traffic and sell the proceeds. If in 30 years 1Gb is considered slow and it's stuck there because "government", I'll let the municipal fiber doomers say I told you so - assuming Ma Bell isn't still offering 384k ADSL on the two pairs of copper they'll have left.
- JJMcJ 3y agoThey get the monopoly without the universal service requirements that the utility and wire-line phone companies have.
- rayiner 3y ago> It sounds like Baltimore's problem is, as you said, having no money That’s true of most municipalities. And they have higher priorities for infrastructure expenditures. Cities and states need to spend $745 billion just to bring water infrastructure up to existing health and environmental standards. Broadband is way behind lead pipes or crumbling bridges on governments’ list of priorities. > Regardless of density, infrastructure has an intrinsic capital cost that needs to be accounted on the order of a decade, and moribund dinosaurs based around short term revenue extraction aren't capable of doing that. I heard this a decade ago, when Google was going to show up the “dinosaurs.” How is that going?
- 3y ago
- stupidmanager 3y ago> Such requirements kill fiber development. Laying fiber is expensive, and having to lay it through neighborhoods where most people won’t or can’t subscribe just increases the price for everyone. I'm sorry, but I just don't see it. I've worked with and for several telcos, I know the value of a customer that is locked into older infrastructure. Fiber is not more expensive, it's upgradable and properly done it's reasonably future-proof and Telcos know it. So no, these requirements do not kill fiber. These requirements force telcos like comcast to be competitive and not selective where fiber is installed. I know this because directional drilling is a very low-cost installation at about $10 a foot, permits for a neighborhood run you about $5000 and fiber runs will cost another $6 a foot. Now fiber network gear can be expensive, but again I remind you that I've worked with telcos... they already have most of the big bad gear in place and only need to put in more expensive singlemode runs to rural areas. So I call bullshit. So heres my life because of telcos that make these complaints and politicians just don't give a shit: I've been in my house for a few decades and until this year my only choice was Comcast for anything over 100mbit internet. I spend $250 a month because Comcast forces me to bundle my internet with TV and Phone (and they call often to have me add cell and security). Then a local company came into the neighborhood this year offering Gigabit fiber for 1/4 the cost I'm spending now. All of a sudden, Comcast, Centurylink and even the local utility company are out spending money I guess they didn't have to upgrade their networks to support fiber. 7 months of my yard (easement and telco junction) has been home to a variety of heavy machinery, as they run new upgraded infrastructure using directional drilling. Somewhere in June I get an email from comcast that my internet was upgraded "for free" and now I have 1.2gb/40mbit, doubling my paid speed and if I sign a 2-year term today (with 6mo payment penalty for canceling), I'll pay 50% less and receive unlimited internet if I put in their modem. Let's just say I signed up with the local company and that activates this next month for synchronous 1gb fiber for $59 a month. > It’s not just the traditional telcos or cable companies. There is a reason Google Fiber has this concept of “fiberhoods” where you need a certain level of demonstrated interest in subscription before they’ll build in those areas. You know why google fiber wasn't successful? It's because people are lazy. If I wasn't motivated to kill off TV and Phone services that I NEVER use, I'd just stay with Comcast. Comcast will match the Internet only service price of $59 for 1gb internet the day I call to cancel. I have zero reason to change, but amazingly I can and NOW Comcast is flexible with pricing and options.
- ilyt 3y agoThe town doesn't want to connect few streets to the internet. The town wants internet available everywhere because even if boomer parent might not care, their kids when grow up might want to have stable internet for work, same with any new developments, good internet becomes number one priority for many people buying homes. It might be difference between small town slowly dying and prospering (because people moving in to work remotely will spend in local economy). Yeah there will always be cases of cities not being reasonable and wanting telco to fork in on putting 10km of fiber per farmer living in vast area (which would be better served by radio), but overall giving for-profit big corporations so much power for city development is insane.
- MisterBastahrd 3y agoGood. Because the end result is that someone eventually WILL bring fiber or a fiber alternative and the other company will be SOL for having a service that is never available for part of the community. Right now I have a situation where AT&T has fiber across most of my city, but not my neighborhood. And Spectrum has fiber in my neighborhood, but not my side of the street. So I'm stuck with T-Mobile wireless after having used AT&T DSL for the past 4 years because neither Spectrum nor AT&T will run fiber The aforementioned requirement would have pushed fiber everywhere. There's zero difference between the homes on my side of the street and the other side. Or the homes in my neighborhood and the next one over. Same size, same prices, same sort of people in the same tax brackets with the same economic conditions. I'd rather see a company lose out on an entire market than establish itself only over part of it. Internet access is opportunity.
- JamesBarney 3y agoYou'd rather no one had fiber than some people have fiber?
- MisterBastahrd 3y agoYes. Because full demand is better than fractured demand.
- flangola7 3y agoWhy do you come here and tell lies?
- wing-_-nuts 3y agoHaving access to fast municipal internet is going to be a requirement for every home I buy going forward. That restricts my possible relocation options, but it's worth it to not have to deal with monopoly companies that can simply dictate whatever terms they like. Imagine if other utilities were private and had similar powers.
- taylodl 3y agoFrom a consumer perspective it's the worst of both worlds - they operate like a utility in that there's physical infrastructure needed to provide service to your home, but unlike a utility there's little to no regulation and oversight.
- gottorf 3y ago> That restricts my possible relocation options You're underselling the problem! That would limit you to a handful (or a fistful, if we're being generous) of municipalities in the whole country. I've lived in places where there was no municipal internet, but had two or three competing broadband providers. That kept prices down and services fast, and may be a suitable alternative.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoThere's been a couple of stories about people (usually fairly young couples) that brought houses, on the specific guarantee from their local "broadband" monopoly, that they would have the service, and found out only after moving in, that they did not, in fact, have the service, and would need to pay many thousands of dollars, to get substandard service. The companies that made the guarantees were allowed to say "oops, we goofed. Our bad.", without having to pay a dime, or even say sorry.
- barbazoo 3y agoHow would one get such a guarantee, surely it's not just the availability check by address because I wouldn't expect that to be binding.
- 3y ago
- tivert 3y agoSpeaking of telecom regulation, whatever happened to net neutrality? Why has the Biden administration not managed to install a new FCC commissioner (so I suppose we're still technically in the Ajit Pai era)? I mean, we're already starting to get into the next presidential election cycle, for pete's sake. It seems pretty clear to me that doing the right thing on this stuff isn't a priority for anyone.
- delfinom 3y ago>Why has the Biden administration not managed to install a new FCC commissioner Because Trump gutted the government so badly that it's taking years to do the congressional dance to approve replacements for many departments. Congress isn't helping either being basically a failed political body.
- lesuorac 3y agoGood thing that the Constitution allows for the Executive branch to immediately appoint and replace any vacancy while Congress is out of session for the summer. > Article II, Section 2, Clause 3: > The President shall have Power to fill up all Vacancies that may happen during the Recess of the Senate, by granting Commissions which shall expire at the End of their next Session. Too bad the Democrats are intentionally hamstringing Biden by pretending to be in session all summer long despite not actually working.
- dragonwriter 3y agoWere the Democrats to move to adjourn without a pro-forma session, every Republican + Joe Manchin and Krysten Sinema would vote against it, since it would end-run their hostage-taking on nominees. (The GOP led House would also object, and their consent is usually required for a recess sufficient to trigger recess appointments, but that disagreement itself would allow the President to use the extraordinary, and never yet exercised, power of his office to declare an adjournment in the case of a disagreement between the houses of Congress on the matter, so while it would be a major escalation to bypass it, the House objection wouldn’t be insurmountable — the failure of a majority in the Senate, though, would.) (Still think they should do it, even though it would be a break from long-established [0] practice, but it wouldn’t have any practical effect other than setting up another debate for the next election.) [0] long enough to be a bipartisan norm, actually not that long in historical terms.
- Philorandroid 3y agoIt's fascinating that the author implies more regulatory power over telecoms would solve this, even though they're plainly buying that same regulatory power when it's advantageous. If "the vast majority of politicians are feckless cardboard cutouts with little real interest in market or consumer health" anyways, it'd seem a superfluous effort to give an agency more power only to sell it out later, right?
- thfuran 3y agoMost government agencies aren't primarily staffed by politicians.
- pempem 3y agoThey are just primarily gutted by politicians
- nielsbot 3y agoof course, some regulation is good and some is bad. more regulation is not always bad as libertarians would have you believe.
- jrh3 3y agoThe Telecom Act of 1996 started the current mess. I argue it was partly responsible for the dotcom bust. It killed the incentive to create broadband, and the internet without broadband is not that useful. It's a regulatory mess.
- joecool1029 3y agoYou're probably being unfairly downvoted by people associating this act with the CDA but you're absolutely right. That act basically killed the booming industry for last-mile fiber by forcing the incumbent companies to lease out last mile access. Fast forward a few more years to 2004, the startups that put those lines in are gone and the incumbents won the ability to stop leasing most of their infra out: https://web.archive.org/web/20160818001129/http://www.ictregulationtoolkit.org/en/toolkit/notes/PracticeNote/2895 https://web.archive.org/web/20160818001129/http://www.ictreg...
- josephd79 3y agoHow about Verizon and ATT give us the fiber connections they promised us 30 years ago. We've already paid them for it.
- e40 3y agoSonic.net moved into my area last year and offered 10Gbps service for $40/mo (now $50). At the time, I was on Comcast. 65/15 Mbps for $130/mo. I had this service for 10+ years and I was unable to upgrade to faster speeds without paying more. I was one of the first people in my area to switch. Once I did, I got a call from Comcast saying they'd lower my bill to $50/mo. I saw their (and AT&T) trucks in my area and got ads in my mailbox for $40/mo 1Gbps connections. The problem is, most places in the US do not have competition and Comcast and AT&T will not lift a finger to provide better service.
- linsomniac 3y ago"We don't care, we don't have to, we're the phone company."
- dctoedt 3y ago> We don't care, we don't have to, we're the phone company." Hah! Haven't thought of that one in years. (You're dating yourself, BTW.) For young whippersnappers, this is from https://vimeo.com/355556831 https://vimeo.com/355556831 — a Lily Tomlin bit on SNL in the 70s, reprising one of her famous recurring characters from Laugh-In in the late 60s.
- rolobio 3y agoThere was a similar situation when Google Fiber was rolled out in Provo Utah. Comcast essentially had a monopoly (they're the only ones allowed to put their cables on the power lines), they charge huge amounts for their internet, Google Fiber buries their fiber lines and suddenly Comcast drops prices begging people to stay. I had to use Comcast for years, they lied to me many times and I finally escaped to a place with a different provider. Suddenly, this year Comcast comes and buries fiber lines in my area. I will deliberately avoid Comcast, competition is absolutely required to keep prices down.
- TuringNYC 3y agoCant wait for Elon and Starlink to disrupt this industry. A good product offering would cut thru the incumbents like a hot knife through butter.
- trailingComma 3y agoI can't wait until its more than just Elon doing it. Replacing one monopoly with another is not the way to go.
- p1mrx 3y agoStarlink is only a monopoly in locations without traditional broadband. It's not even a very good alternative in dense locations, where you compete with neighbors for bandwidth. Though perhaps they can serve enough users to influence prices a bit.
- SenAnder 3y agoIt's not replacing, it's adding a player, and diluting the monopoly.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- meltyness 3y agoAnd also get rid of MVNOs.
- SenAnder 3y ago[HR 3557] “Eliminates cable franchise renewals and eliminates the ability of local governments to require rules such as an ISP having to serve the whole community, the local government requiring PEG channels, or the local government requiring customer service standards.” This is a federal bill, but aren't federal powers limited to regulating inter-state commerce? Yet the powers it strips from state legislatures are clearly aimed at intra-state commerce.
- phrz 3y agoCongress's Commerce Clause power in the Constitution is notorious for being very broadly interpreted in the modern era. Here, Congress is either regulating a "channel" of interstate commerce (the internet) or intrastate economic activity that interferes with interstate commerce (local ISP rules making nationwide ISP business more burdened).
- LocalH 3y agoWickard v Filburn broke that, in ruling that a man growing more than the “legal limit” of wheat for his own use was nonetheless “affecting” interstate commerce.
- zlg_codes 3y agoFriendly reminder that the Obama Administration invested billions in broadband companies, in an effort to encourage them to build out their fiber plants and improve access speeds. Do you know what they did with that money? Blew it on useless upgrading projects like digitizing their old drafts. May as well have flushed it down the toilet. I'm perfectly fine with government imminent domain-ing that shit and selling it back to people at fair prices. Business didn't build those networks, government hand-outs taken from citizens' tax revenue built the network in this country. There will be a point where people strike back against ISPs by attacking the infrastructure itself. If they won't upgrade it, damage it and make them upgrade it.
- switch007 3y agoShould have used the billions to create competition instead
- Thetawaves 3y agoGovernment money is regularly used to build access to new / remote places. Should I provide examples or would that be considered cherry picked evidence?
- zlg_codes 3y agoYou're missing the point. ISPs did not build out their plants to support more bandwidth with Obama money. Serving a handful of remote areas to have the appearance of it isn't enough. Why isn't the US covered in fiber? We spent the money to make it happen, and it didn't happen.
- Thetawaves 3y agoI think I disagree on this premise - government subsidies for telecommunications over the last 20 years have largely served to connect new and under served markets. If you have broadband (by the pitiful FCC definition) you have not been a target of investment.
- MrMorden 3y ago