7 ms·
From Reuters... > In 2022, revenue doubled to $4.6 billion, helping the company reduce its loss last year to $559 million from $968 million, the WSJ reported.
by bell-cot 3y ago
From Reuters...
> In 2022, revenue doubled to $4.6 billion, helping the company reduce its loss last year to $559 million from $968 million, the WSJ reported.
> The company reported about $5.2 billion in total expenses for 2022, up from $3.3 billion the year earlier, according to the report.
That $5.2B of expenses got 61 successful, production Falcon rocket launches in 2022. Vs. some pretty-reasonable estimates put the total cost of NASA's "Space Launch System" at ~$5B per individual launch.
- cypress66 3y agoFalcon isn't really comparable to the SLS, but yes the SLS is awful cost wise. Starship will almost surely be between one and two orders of magnitude cheaper per launch vs SLS.
- pfdietz 3y agoA rational return to the moon program that had to choose between Falcon and SLS would choose Falcon.
- stetrain 3y agoIf the primary goal is sustainable payloads to the moon. I think Congress considers this a secondary goal over funding and jobs being directed at their states.
- fooker 3y ago> funding and jobs being directed at their states. This is more important than it seems on the surface and is often a good thing. You want to train and preserve local expertise with heavy industries. That ensures generations of successful companies rejuvenating your economy as opposed to relying on federal handouts.
- pfdietz 3y agoIt completely fails as a justification for SLS, though. It's preserving nonsense that needs to die, instead of pushing the actually successful part of commercial space.
- fooker 3y agoHow do you recon Spacex has managed to recruit several thousand US citizens with the proper expertise? These people don’t grow on trees(/classrooms).
- avmich 3y agoSurprisingly NASA, or ULA, couldn't recruit those very same citizens.
- yazaddaruvala 3y agoI think you’re missing the point. NASA and ULA like programs trained and built expert training to create those citizens. Being able to recruit them is a non-goal.
- avmich 3y agoThe missing is all yours :) . The citizens aren't the goal, the space achievements are. And that's where NASA and ULA were left in the past.
- yazaddaruvala 3y agoThe only goal of any democratically elected government program is: improved citizens. It is in the definition: “for the people”.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoIt's a good thing during down times. But now is not down times. Experienced, qualified space & rocket engineers are in high demand. Employing them to do useless make-work means they aren't available to work on rockets and space systems that will actually be useful in the future.
- oivey 3y agoYou’d probably have to figure out on orbit manufacturing, then, so I don’t think that is at all clear.
- pfdietz 3y agoOn-orbit assembly, the demonstration of which was the single actual real accomplishment of the Space Station program. And yet NASA just threw that in the garbage. If we can't do something as simple as assemble modules in space, exactly what sort of future do you imagine is waiting for us in space?
- oivey 3y agoMaybe they used that experience decide that it would be cheaper to just build a huge rocket? The ISS also had the benefit of the shuttle, while US flights to LEO were in turmoil when the SLS was funded. It also wasn’t clear in hindsight how completely and utterly inept Boeing was and how effective SpaceX was going to be.
- pfdietz 3y agoIt's grossly more expensive the way they are doing it. They were originally going to use smaller commercial launchers until Senator Shelby and others held a political knife to their throats. SLS has absolutely no redeeming features. You're sunk deep in Stockholm Syndrome if you're still defending it.
- vyodaiken 3y agoIt's ironic that Musks two big successes were funded by the Obama administration against vehement Republican objections. Shelby repeatedly tried to kill Space-X and without the $400million DOE loan Tesla would never have been able to start production - and without the electric car tax credit - it never would have been able to sell.
- pclmulqdq 3y agoFalcon rockets can't get to the moon. You need a lot more fuel to do that. That's why SLS and Starship are both being developed.
- pfdietz 3y agoSLS is needed only because they were not allowed to adopt on-orbit propellant transfer. With rockets like the Falcons, propellant (which is most of the mass needed to get something to the moon) is launched in smaller quantities and accumulated. What sort of future in space do those advocating SLS imagine for us if moving a liquid from one tank to another is too challenging?
- pclmulqdq 3y agoOne where we just launch one rocket instead of building a giant orbital bomb slowly (accumulating fuel) and transferring all those explosives through a complex series of difficult rendezvous maneuvers? One rocket is risky enough. There's a huge amount of extra risk involved in that sort of idea, which is why NASA isn't doing it, which can just be avoided with SLS and Starship.
- pfdietz 3y agoIt's actually less risky. Most of the launches are of propellant, which is completely replaceable. Reliability of a launcher is achieved by using it many many times, exposing all the gotchas. SLS will launch so infrequently it will be extremely risky. And you didn't answer my question, so I will answer it for you. If simply transferring a liquid from one tank to another is too risky, then there is no future in space. No activities of any significance could ever be done there. With that established, we can shut down the human space program and lose nothing of value.
- pclmulqdq 3y agoThere is plenty of future in space by limiting propellant transfers to times when they are absolutely necessary. We can do them today, and have been able to for 30 years, and yet we rarely do, and never for the volumes of fuel you are proposing.
- mrguyorama 3y agoAnd NASA will probably be very happy to use such a cheap system once they are convinced it meets their reliability standards. The point of SLS IMO is to keep a backup option if SpaceX has some horrific, unpredicted setback or design problem. Surely people understand redundancy in aerospace right?
- grimwall 3y agoThe point of SLS is pork, full stop.
- pclmulqdq 3y agoAnd yet only one of SLS and Starship has reached orbit.
- lamontcg 3y agoSLS is about maintaining the ability of the US to build rocket engines like the RS-25 and those massive SRBs. The Government is worried about waking up some morning and China has leapfrogged us to the Moon and it'll take 20 years for us to institutionally remember how to get back there. And SpaceX has not yet demonstrated the ability to land humans on the Moon while NASA has. They're making sure that we can definitely still use big dumb stupid expensive technology to get there. If Starship works they may wind up pivoting away from SLS in the future, but then SpaceX will also get to take its pick up the remains of that program and their engineers (if they aren't already benefiting from a lot of cross-pollination).
- jve 3y agoPart of those expenses are probably building starlink and starship r&d. I suspect F9 no longer has significant r&d expenses. I wonder if your NASA figure also includes first launch, that may include r&d?! Because for a single launch, when you substract r&d or even spread out across all planned launches - can't be that high... I'm just for comparing apples to apples not apples to oranges.
- bell-cot 3y agoBrief, if almost 4-year-old article: https://arstechnica.com/science/2019/11/nasa-does-not-deny-the-over-2-billion-cost-of-a-single-sls-launch/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2019/11/nasa-does-not-deny-t... The ~$5B figure is in the final para. And that still sounds like it excludes ground systems and Orion development costs. (Plus ~4 more years of ever-growing bloat, obviously.)
- nordsieck 3y ago> The ~$5B figure is in the final para. And that still sounds like it excludes ground systems and Orion development costs. (Plus ~4 more years of ever-growing bloat, obviously.) There is a much more official and up to date figure: > We project the cost to fly a single SLS/Orion system through at least Artemis IV to be $4.1 billion per launch at a cadence of approximately one mission per year. https://oig.nasa.gov/docs/IG-22-003.pdf https://oig.nasa.gov/docs/IG-22-003.pdf From what I understand, that number does include ground systems. For what it's worth, NASA leadership continues to contest this value, although they refuse to publicly give their own value. To be fair to you, the $4.1B figure does not include development costs. I don't think there's an agreed upon way to include them, so everyone just mentions them separately. And they are quite... large.
- inhumantsar 3y agoAnd that's while reusing as many shuttle components as possible, including the motors and the SRBs. Kind of sad that the last living pieces of the shuttle will be dropped into the ocean and left to rust away
- nordsieck 3y ago> some pretty-reasonable estimates put the total cost of NASA's "Space Launch System" at ~$5B per individual launch. SLS is bad, but it's not quite that bad. A full launch of SLS + Orion is ~4.1B. A launch of SLS without Orion (a theoretical cargo mission) is "just" ~$2.8B.
- sidewndr46 3y agoThe SLS is designed to reach political goals, not financial targets.
- bell-cot 3y agoYep. Nicknamed the "Senate Launch System" for very good reason.
- bell-cot 3y agoFWIW, here's a fairly deep (and charitable) article on the SLS by Eric Berger - https://arstechnica.com/science/2022/08/the-sls-rocket-is-the-worst-thing-to-happen-to-nasa-but-maybe-also-the-best/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2022/08/the-sls-rocket-is-th...
- oblio 3y agoIt's ridiculous what amounts of money these ventures can siphon away in the US. See Uber, AirBNB, etc. I'm not saying they don't pay off, but these businesses literally choke most international competition. There are probably 1-2 countries in the world that can afford to keep running a business with losses at around $1bn per year.
- pixl97 3y ago$1b loss in the space industry is probably the smallest loss for any business in said industry in history. Every launch of the space shuttle was a few billion used up. There has been no completion here, because before SpaceX everyone else was launching 100M-1B+ of rocket that was never reused and other than the payload was a write off. It is always financed by government because there is typically a much larger generalized payoff for the nation state involved regarding capabilities.
- oblio 3y agoYeah, I'm not talking strictly about SpaceX. I don't know if I have the exact name, but I'm quite sure that one of the big unicorns, probably Uber, was running for several years with multi-billion dollar losses. Again, that's utterly unthinkable for Mercedes or Renault or Mitsubish or Samsung or... They'd just go under because the rest of the world still has economic gravity, i.e. everything must come down in case of no profits.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mcpackieh 3y ago> Every launch of the space shuttle was a few billion used up. Almost all of that money was dumped back into the same economy from which it was collected, albeit inefficiently, so it didn't really disappear. They "used up" a few million dollars worth of material each time. The damage to the economy was not as bad as you suggest. However the opportunity cost was massive. Decades wasted on a dead-end program. A staggering number of engineer careers essentially wasted, and now they're doing it again with SLS.
- reso 3y agoYou can't compare falcon to SLS because Falcon cannot do what SLS does. You can't compare SpaceX's figures to NASA because NASA has many, many more reporting obligations than SpaceX. Every report on Falcon 9 costs has made this mistake forever. SpaceX does not release their full costs. What numbers we have for them are PR releases. Meanwhile, NASA's budgets are public and comprehensive, and they have legal parameters on what they have to include in their statements about costs that SpaceX does not have.
- resolutebat 3y agoAt time of writing, it's the opposite: Falcon is launching humans into space on a regular basis, something SLS has entirely failed to do to date.
- ISL 3y agoSLS hasn't yet been asked to launch a human.
- toss1 3y agoOnly because SLS has so far failed to qualify to launch a human. SLS was on the schedule to launch humans several years ago. However, failing to qualify means that NASA can NOT ask them to launch a human
- anticensor 3y agoUnless the Congress makes an act to force them ignore the certification status of SLS.
- Teever 3y agoHe says, implying that this is the only thing stopping that from happening. Is SLS even certified to carry people into space yet?
- nordsieck 3y ago
- Fordec 3y agoIn other news it cost me $1500 to do a year of grocery shopping trips while it cost $1500 for one transatlantic return trip holiday. Apples to oranges comparison. 400km to low earth orbit is not compatible to a 384400km trip to another gravity well.
- avhon1 3y agoDistance is almost completely irrelevant for comparing launch vehicles. Also, Falcon 9 has delivered multiple payloads to lunar orbit. Examples are ispace's Hakuto-R Mission 1, SpaceIL's Beresheet, and South Korea's Danuri. In interplanetary space, the Double Asteroid Redirection Test was launched on a Falcon 9.
- Fordec 3y agoBeresheet: 1,300 lbs Danuri: 1,495 lbs Hakuto-R: 2,200 lbs DART: 1,340 lbs Artemis 2: 112,000 lbs Even by your examples there remains a 10,000% to 5,000% fold scale difference. And SpaceX agrees with this. This difference in scale is why they are working on Starship.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoIt takes 9400 km/s of delta-v to get to LEO, but only 3260 km/s of delta-v to get from LEO to Lunar Intercept Orbit.
- HWR_14 3y agoThat ~$5billion per launch includes a lot of amortized R&D and other costs that you are not counting in the 61 successful Falcon launches. It may be that the Falcon launchers are significantly cheaper, but the accounting methods are too different to just compare numbers.
- alemanek 3y agoYour right that figure isn’t accounting for the $23.8 billion cost of the program so far. That $5billion per launch figure is based on an optimistic number of SLS launches which haven’t happened yet. SLS and Orion are dead ends. I wish them well and I am huge space geek but that program is just a gigantic waste. I wish we could take that budget and use it for unmanned missions or public/private space station partnerships with some of the new space companies.
- Veedrac 3y ago$5B (2023: $4.7B) is actually the current yearly run rate for SLS+Orion+EGS. Thus, $5B is what the marginal launch cost would be if SLS was launching yearly, excluding $54B to-date costs of the three. Even NASA's official projections (which are always optimistic) don't show yearly launches, but if unreasonably optimistic numbers still make the point, why quibble over the details?
- Veedrac 3y agoNo, it's the other way around. SpaceX's yearly spending would include the 61 flights, but also literally thousands of satellites, presumably a huge number of commercial dishes, their human flight overheads, their Starship development program including ground support and production and testing of about a hundred Raptor engines, their sales and outreach, their specific contract work like HLS, and their mug business by the side. If you were to amortize SLS's total dev costs (incl. Orion and SLS-specific ground support but excluding Constellation) over its reasonably expected lifetime flights, you'll be lucky as heck to get <$10B/flight, though of course we don't know how that adds up and so report the much smaller marginal numbers instead.