6 ms·
Students foot the bill for flagship state universities
- oliviajamie58 3y ago[dead]
- susandavid2315 3y ago[dead]
- johnny99k 3y agoWhen you have students taking out Federal loans, the University getting paid with virtually no risk, and they don't if the student can get a job or pay off the loan, they have no incentive to curb spending. The federal government need to force these universities to take the risk and loan out money directly.
- echelon 3y agoIt's all about risk. Currently the loans don't factor in the associated risks, and therefore are unlimited streams of funny money. The expected value of the degree, the cost of the degree program, chance of graduation, chance of employment, student risk factors (grades, attendance), etc. are important, yet not considered. When pricing is artificially kept independent of the underlying risk model, it leads to the kind of huge distortion we see today. All of this is immediately obvious, of course. But the counter argument has weight too -- that putting risk into the equation isn't equitable. Poor and underserved students won't receive the same access. A healthy medium might be to allow federal loans to continue for only programs with an expected value in four years that exceeds that of the degree program cost plus loan interest plus double the cost of living. Basically, just STEM, nursing, radiology, etc. at mostly community colleges and state universities. If you want an art school history major, you need a real loan.
- haldujai 3y ago> Basically, just STEM, nursing, radiology, etc. So "Basically, STEM or STEM-adjacent"? (depending how consider nursing) > The expected value of the degree To society or the individual? Calculated how? > If you want an art school history major, you need a real loan. So only rich people are allowed to be educated in the humanities unless you're willing to get what will be a very expensive and likely cost-prohibitive private loan? This seems like a step backwards. > A healthy medium might be to allow federal loans to continue for only programs with an expected value in four years that exceeds that of the degree program cost plus loan interest plus double the cost of living So basically only engineers? This wouldn't apply to anyone getting a graduate degree or even most other professions. A mathematician from MIT entering academia wouldn't meet this calculation. Neither would almost all physicians, even if you ignore years spent in residency, unless they're moving somewhere with a very low COL. Respectfully, as someone with a humanities undergraduate and two graduate STEM degrees, I find your proposition incredibly shortsighted and fails to consider the individual and societal value of non-STEM degrees beyond direct salary. I would argue my undergraduate degree has provided me far more value, financial and otherwise, than either of my other degrees.
- lsmeducation 3y agoHow much is the cost of your undergraduate major on average nationwide? Do you believe it is accurately priced in comparison to a STEM major? It’s a pricing issue. If we don’t agree it’s a pricing issue, then let’s pay everyone the same salary regardless of profession. There’s ideological value in everything, but we’re talking business here. The colleges CHARGE you something. They don’t gift you anything out of virtue. So talk money. I’d be willing to even accept a Nicotine warning label of sorts that colleges tell an English major at the start (and the parents). “hazardous warning label: hey, we are going to charge you 15k a year for this. you won’t likely make more than X in the real world with this degree. You cool with it? No refunds.”
- haldujai 3y agoI don't know the national average of my major. I paid something around 35-40k/year in tuition for an english literature degree. My MD and MS (CS) were more expensive but also done later. All undergraduate degrees in the US have a pricing issue. I don't believe anyone should be paying 30-60k/year for one. > There’s ideological value in everything, but we’re talking business here. No, we're talking about university education which should not be a business. I don't consider an undergraduate degree training for a specific job, that's what technical colleges are for. If you want to argue we shouldn't subsidize university in general I could understand that but think it's a bad idea. I don't agree that STEM degrees are inherently more valuable than the humanities from a general education perspective which is what I view undergraduate degrees as. If we treat it as a business we should only subsidize courses essential for the workplace. Why am I subsidizing a web developer or a physician taking undergraduate calculus and physics? Having worked as both I have needed neither. > “hazardous warning label: hey, we are going to charge you 15k a year for this. you won’t likely make more than X in the real world with this degree. You cool with it? No refunds.” I think it's common knowledge that STEM graduates earn more, this was the case when I was in high school during the 2000s.
- abeppu 3y agoI think the federal government just needs to have a 'fitness standard' for schools to be eligible to receive federal loan dollars. Like, >80% of tuition dollars must be spent on instruction staff, instruction-specific facilities that serve students, students must be able to opt-out of substantial non-instruction services (e.g. dorms, recreational facilities), etc. If you want to build a new building that doesn't have classrooms, you need to find some other source of funding than students. I know people hate this, but I also think it would be reasonable if you weren't eligible to receive federal student loans until you had filed your own taxes without being anyone's dependent, or been out of high school for 2 years, or _something_. What if we still agreed that federal programs can help make college accessible and affordable -- but we should want students to have some perspective on what they want their life to look like, and what it will mean to pay off a giant pile of debt over years, and what kind of education might give them a chance at balancing those concerns.
- tyoma 3y agoRe: fitness standard. The federal government already has the bureaucracy for this in say the DCAA (https://www.dcaa.mil/ https://www.dcaa.mil/). I would very much like any universities accepting student loans to be audited and publish audited financial statements detailing where the money goes.
- Manuel_D 3y agoIn theory, that's what accreditation is supposed to represent: a set of standards to ensure students are educated to a certain minimum bar for a given major. However, the cynical reality is that university is as much about signalling competence relative to the rest of the population as it is about learning. Fun fact: Stanford's computer science program is not accredited. The department explained that it's a mountain of paperwork to get accredited and it wouldn't benefit Stanford at all because it's already so prestigious.
- aoki 3y agoBy ABET. The institution as a whole is accredited. The question is whether accreditation from an engineering org is worth the limits they place on your curriculum. Stanford EE and CS and Cal EECS all say no, they’d rather give their grads more flexibility than have them jump through ABET hoops.
- dv_dt 3y agoIt would also help to require administrative salaries to be below a certain percentage in order to qualify to accept federal loan money. (I would think 8% or lower).
- WalterBright 3y agoMore regulation to micromanage things is never going to work. For example, what if you've got an opportunity to hire Feynman, but he expects 9%? Maybe you'll skirt the 8% requirement by giving him a company car to use. Nobody is smart enough to write a regulation that can't be gamed.
- haldujai 3y agoRegulating administrative overhead as a single line item with a fixed percentage is micromanaging?
- ssivark 3y agoYes, because somebody might innovate an education model where administrative salaries are 90% of the cost but students learn well, and earn well. An 8% cap would close off such avenues for progress. In general (going back to basic cybernetics/control theory), it’s better to regulate outcomes (what you actually want) rather than inputs, unless you’re sure you have the correct model of the system. So it’s much better to make collages share the risk, rather than the government footing the risk and instituting regulations and processes.
- lsmeducation 3y agoI always had a very simple way to do student debt forgiveness: 1) Have universities foot the bill, not the tax payer (shocking, I know). A literal refund. 2) Institute an audit every 5 years on their price to success rate on a per major basis. Have them refund north of 50% of the tuition if overpriced. Cool, now run your little game. This is literally a consumer protection issue and this industry has hid far too long under the veils of sanctity of “but tis’ but education, maaaaan”. —- Like many have already mentioned, the federal loans going toward these costs are essentially like donating to a charity that you will never get actionable data on. Did the money go to the right place? Did it work? No? Okay, stop donating to that charity, as nice as it feels to be charitable. If a charity doesn’t work, it doesn’t work, doesn’t matter how great it sounds. Even a charity named Education.
- sokoloff 3y agoWhat does “work” mean in this case? If a student goes to university and gets a degree in medieval French literature and then serves coffee for life as a job, the university did its job iff the student demonstrated a level of mastery of medieval French literature. The inadvertent economics education that came later was not the university’s doing and they take no credit nor blame for it.
- musicale 3y ago> What does “work” mean in this case? That the money was spent responsibly, for some definition of responsibly. Probably this doesn't mean the sort of abuses detailed in the article. > If a student goes to university and gets a degree in medieval French literature and then serves coffee for life as a job, the university did its job iff the student demonstrated a level of mastery of medieval French literature. I'm unconvinced that it would be good to disband humanities departments, or to ban non-STEM degree programs and/or degrees that don't involve training for a specific career path. Last I checked, even MIT has a humanities school (though it seems to be combined with art and social sciences.) Our society seems to have enough react programmers and could probably use more medievalists, as well as other humanities grads - people who understand the human condition, have some sense and understanding of history, know how to exercise critical thinking skills, and can read and write well. These are skills that could serve someone well in a variety of jobs. [Moreover, as more jobs (including supposedly highly skilled tech jobs) are automated out of existence, many of us are likely to end up in low-paying service jobs - at least until the robots take those as well.]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mrtesthah 3y agoThat's the wrong argument to be making. Education should be free. https://www.brookings.edu/articles/is-free-college-a-good-idea-increasingly-evidence-says-yes/ https://www.brookings.edu/articles/is-free-college-a-good-id...
- sieabahlpark 3y ago[dead]
- AdamJacobMuller 3y agoAgreed, simple solution though. Students pay a maximum of N% of their income over Y years and anything above this is forgiven. The university has any forgiven amounts deducted from their actual cash payments for future student loans.
- beej71 3y agoThis is an Income Share Agreement, which I certainly approve of. Another option available to public schools is that you can use tax as a mechanism for collecting that money.
- sowbug 3y agohttps://archive.is/wwB4A https://archive.is/wwB4A
- 29athrowaway 3y agoOverproduction of elites https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elite_overproduction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elite_overproduction
- throwawaaarrgh 3y agoI thought it was common knowledge that it's a racket? You pay exorbitant fees to get a piece of paper with a famous name attached hoping it will get you a job or contacts. They know this so they keep raising prices as long as the money keeps flowing.
- WalterBright 3y agoIf there's no math requirement for major X, you can be assured that there are no jobs in X that pay more than minimum wage. Besides, there's no excuse for not googling "starting salaries for X" before committing to it.
- Aurornis 3y agoThe catch is that universities must spend on impressive new facilities, buildings, housing, and sports if they want to remain attractive to their customers (students). Most universities are still competing for students. Many students survey a lot of universities and do campus tours to determine where they want to attend. The short campus tours don't really show them anything about the education they receive, but the state of the facilities and leaves a lasting impression. Given the choice, undecided students tend to be drawn to universities with the nicest campus, most impressive facilities, best sports arenas, and other expensive things. Universities know this, so they spend like it's an arms race.
- spicyusername 3y agoI'm not saying it's true or not true, but this is definitely the same story the school administrators are telling themselves.
- figassis 3y agoWhy. It just maintain them well, instead of building new structures every quarter?
- lumost 3y agoThis doesn’t really make sense for state institutions. If I am a state institution, why do I need to compete for students? If students have choice, then isn’t my job complete? I’d suspect that spending on premium faculty would have a better chance at business generation than saddling students with debt for stadiums.
- WalterBright 3y agoI must be weird, because I paid no attention to facilities, etc., when I looked for a university. I looked at the value of the engineering education they provided, and that was about it.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoI would argue that they're not competing for students, they're competing for Prestige. Most universities have a wait list a mile long, so they're not going to run out of students. However, very few colleges want to be the university that produces an adequate education with extremely low cost. They all want to be the most prestigious University, costs be damned. If you want to get a sense of the differences, community colleges are focused on students, not prestige. Community college costs is California are $550 per semester, while UCs are in the $13-14k/yr ballpark. Undergraduate lecturers can actually be better at a community college IMHO, because they are career teachers, not career researchers.
- mech7654 3y agoThe college bubble is popping. Enrollment is down 15% from its 2010 peak. My intuition is that the bigger state schools will be well insulated financially, but smaller independent colleges will have a bloodbath.
- m_0x 3y agoUntil companies ditch the stupid degree requirement for jobs that obviously do not require a degree, everybody is going to suffer. Fewer colleges mean: 1) People out of jobs. Teachers will lose their main income and the remaining colleges will have no incentive to increase their payroll because where are they gonna go? 2) Getting into a college will be even more competitive. As companies will still look for people with degrees, colleges can charge even more and candidates to study there will have less choices. This will only change when NOT studying at a college has no impact in your future income. Or the impact is lesser than today.
- SoftTalker 3y agoWhile many jobs do not in reality require more than a high-school level education, a college degree is a valuable filter for people who can commit to something that requires learning and applying what has been learned, and seeing it through over a period of 3-4 years. For jobs that require a college degree, but the major subject of study doesn't matter, that is what they are using it for. A High School diploma used to mean a lot more, when education was compulsory only to 8th grade. A modern high school diploma pretty much just certifies that you showed up, and the only people who don't have one are people who dropped out.
- jostmey 3y agoOr, staying at a previous job for 3-4 years can signal the same level of commitment. Dare I say, staying at a job for the same amount of time as a degree signals more commitment, as staying in college could just indicate 4 years of partying.
- 3y ago
- endominus 3y agoThere's a common belief that education is being underfunded in the United States, that the problem with schools is that they lack the budget to improve their learning outcomes. Statistically speaking, total spending on education had increased year on year, accounting for inflation, per student, since the 1970s. Conversely, test scores have remained relatively stagnant (see https://slatestarcodex.com/2017/02/09/considerations-on-cost-disease/)This https://slatestarcodex.com/2017/02/09/considerations-on-cost... points to the problem lying elsewhere.
- sohex 3y agoIs total spending per student really sufficient as a means of tracking whether enough is being spent though? I'd imagine that the costs per student have risen a greater rate since the 70s than spending has. Between things like needing to pay for computers and IT infrastructure, accommodation programs for those with special needs, and so on it seems to me that it's actually remarkable in someways that test scores have even managed stagnancy rather than a decline.
- WalterBright 3y agoComputers are not necessary for K-12 education. They're more likely a hindrance.
- mlyle 3y agoStudents getting experience doing computer things is nice. And there's things that are awesome to demonstrate with simulations. Spending a huge fraction of your educational day on them is dumb and ripe for abuse. This is a potential silver lining of the whole LLM thing: computers being used for writing assignments, etc, may become untenable.
- vxNsr 3y agoI had a teacher 15 years ago who didn’t trust us not to have family members edit our work to the point where it was no longer our work so he only gave in class writing assignments. Homework was always research or reading.
- rayiner 3y agoIt’s worth understanding the trade offs countries like France make to offer near free university education: https://voices.uchicago.edu/euchicago/the-problem-with-french-universities/ https://voices.uchicago.edu/euchicago/the-problem-with-frenc...
- WalterBright 3y ago"The accessibility of French universities—both from an admissions and financial perspective— paradoxically has had negative consequences on students." That's pretty obvious to anyone who understands that people tend to not place value on things they get for free. Like public high school education in America.
- flexie 3y agoHere in Denmark, all universities are state owned and with no tuition. In fact, you get paid to attend one (around 900 euro monthly). But I can assure you that Danes place a lot of value on the free universities. Some universities are considered slightly more prestigious (often the older ones), and some programs are also more prestigious than others, for example the ones that are difficult to get into, or that lead to jobs with higher salaries, or which are considered particularly difficult. So how does one compare the "free" (tax paid) Danish universities to the US/UK ones? By citations? Nobel laureates? Amount of foreign students? Salaries of alumni? Patents? GDP per capita? Number of high value companies per capita? I think you'd find that as a whole, Danish, and other Scandinavian universities, easily compete with Anglo Saxon universities, and that the main drawback of Scandinavian universities is the language.
- WalterBright 3y agoThanks for the response. I'll start with I know nothing about Danish universities. When I refer to "free", I mean more than just no cost in terms of money. If there is a cost in terms of the university being very difficult to get admitted to, then humans tend to value it. This sounds from your post like it may be the case here. American public schools are valued so little that truancy laws (for 1-8) were passed to force attendance. Large numbers of high school students simply drop out and wander off. On the other hand, becoming a Marine is free (they'll even pay you!). But the selection process is grueling, and hence the status of getting through that is valued. Even more selective services, like the Navy Seals, have correspondingly more status and value. In the Air Force, being a fighter pilot is the hardest to achieve, and has top dog status, despite being paid to go through the process.
- dang 3y agoRecent and related: Colleges spend like there’s no tomorrow - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37074472 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37074472 - Aug 2023 (8 comments)
- AlbertCory 3y agorecent, and inadvertently wrong: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37090403 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37090403 I did archive the same story, but failed to include the URL. Duh.
- vxNsr 3y agoCan we all just agree that colleges not the US government should be on the hook for unpaid loans? I’m all for loan forgiveness if it comes out of the universities’ coffers. In fact let’s take this to the next level, automatic wage garnishing but still ensure former students have a livable income, but after 15 years if the loan isn’t paid off, the university is on the hook for the rest.