5 ms·
> Won't a photon climbing out of a huge gravity well have a huge redshift, Yes > thus confounding estimates of distance from us and estimated age? Not if you
by ben_w 3y ago
> Won't a photon climbing out of a huge gravity well have a huge redshift,
Yes
> thus confounding estimates of distance from us and estimated age?
Not if you know, or can get a good estimate of, the potential well it's climbing out of.
That said, Brian Cox does sometimes joke that astronomers round π to 1; while I wouldn't know about the reality, it's probably safe to infer at least some frustration on his part about the precision of things in this field.
- hutzlibu 3y agoI also don't know how accurate that description is, but this comic comes to mind: https://xkcd.com/2205/ https://xkcd.com/2205/ But I mean, space is really, really big and we are observing from one single spot with (on cosmological scale probably) primitive technology. So of course most of it is guessing and when you "guess" a lot of things, it maybe does not matter a lot, if you have 3.41 Pi or 1, when the data you have are rough estimates anyway. But sure, when you do sloppy math, when you could have precision - that would be just wrong and unscientific.
- dylan604 3y agoWhat if you have 3.14Pi?
- dotancohen 3y agoThen you're so close to 10 that you can just use 10. I actually did that on a physics exam once. Somehow I had a value with pi squared. I just replaced it with 10. I don't remember if I got that question right or wrong - I'm hard pressed to think of a situation where pi squared actually legitimately shows up.
- nvrgngvup 3y ago[dead]
- rmu09 3y agoSurface area of a Torus?
- dotancohen 3y agoNot that I remember, or really relevant to undergrad physics - I'm pretty sure it was physics. Fusion and accretion disks are above my pay grade!
- olddustytrail 3y agoThat's pretty much pi squared. Which, for weirdly good reason, is close to the value of G in meters per second squared.
- dylan604 3y agoonly on this particular rock
- olddustytrail 3y agoNope, on all rocks.
- marcosdumay 3y agoThe joke was way more true at the 20th century. There were many really important measurements where we got unprecedentedly precision, enough to say it's X, 100X, or something in between. Nowadays astronomy got a lot more precise. But there are disagreements on how much confidence to put on that extra precision.
- dylan604 3y agosometimes, i wonder if astronomy/physics were to only use unsigned numbers, if things would just make more sense. you'd get much more precision, and then you wouldn't have to worry about "but the math says it's possible" issues by taking everything by * -1.
- labster 3y agoJesse, what are you talking about?
- dylan604 3y agoWell, Mr White, if you look at all of the "weirdness" in physics with theories coming out because "the math says it's possible", then you'd see that it would be much more simple if we were not allowed to have negative numbers because we're only using u64 integers. we'd have more digits for precision as well.
- nickpeterson 3y agoI find that weird outliers are usually evidence that the underlying model is flawed in some fundamental way, but sometimes I think people believe the exceptions are fundamental, and a lot of effort goes to the wrong place.
- quickthrower2 3y agoI was confused... the symbol π is actually Pi, but it renders as something that looks like a different alphabet entirely on HN.
- gpgn 3y agoThese are somewhated dated but well worth watching; the professor does all kinds of approximations. Frontiers/Controversies in Astrophysics with Charles Bailyn: https://youtu.be/ZiK4lg3Tzfs?t=1628 https://youtu.be/ZiK4lg3Tzfs?t=1628