11 ms·
JWST spots giant black holes all over the early universe
- scotty79 3y agoMy belief is that all supermassive black holes are primordial. They were "seeds" of the galaxies from the start.
- whiw 3y ago> Galactic spectra, which JWST started to send back in earnest at the end of last year, are useful for two reasons. > First, they let astronomers nail down the galaxy’s age. The infrared light JWST collects is reddened, or redshifted, meaning that as it traverses the cosmos, its wavelengths are stretched by the expansion of space. The extent of that redshift lets astronomers determine a galaxy’s distance, and therefore when it originally emitted its light. Won't a photon climbing out of a huge gravity well have a huge redshift, thus confounding estimates of distance from us and estimated age?
- ben_w 3y ago> Won't a photon climbing out of a huge gravity well have a huge redshift, Yes > thus confounding estimates of distance from us and estimated age? Not if you know, or can get a good estimate of, the potential well it's climbing out of. That said, Brian Cox does sometimes joke that astronomers round π to 1; while I wouldn't know about the reality, it's probably safe to infer at least some frustration on his part about the precision of things in this field.
- hutzlibu 3y agoI also don't know how accurate that description is, but this comic comes to mind: https://xkcd.com/2205/ https://xkcd.com/2205/ But I mean, space is really, really big and we are observing from one single spot with (on cosmological scale probably) primitive technology. So of course most of it is guessing and when you "guess" a lot of things, it maybe does not matter a lot, if you have 3.41 Pi or 1, when the data you have are rough estimates anyway. But sure, when you do sloppy math, when you could have precision - that would be just wrong and unscientific.
- dylan604 3y agoWhat if you have 3.14Pi?
- dotancohen 3y agoThen you're so close to 10 that you can just use 10. I actually did that on a physics exam once. Somehow I had a value with pi squared. I just replaced it with 10. I don't remember if I got that question right or wrong - I'm hard pressed to think of a situation where pi squared actually legitimately shows up.
- nvrgngvup 3y ago[dead]
- rmu09 3y agoSurface area of a Torus?
- dotancohen 3y agoNot that I remember, or really relevant to undergrad physics - I'm pretty sure it was physics. Fusion and accretion disks are above my pay grade!
- olddustytrail 3y agoThat's pretty much pi squared. Which, for weirdly good reason, is close to the value of G in meters per second squared.
- dylan604 3y agoonly on this particular rock
- olddustytrail 3y agoNope, on all rocks.
- marcosdumay 3y agoThe joke was way more true at the 20th century. There were many really important measurements where we got unprecedentedly precision, enough to say it's X, 100X, or something in between. Nowadays astronomy got a lot more precise. But there are disagreements on how much confidence to put on that extra precision.
- dylan604 3y agosometimes, i wonder if astronomy/physics were to only use unsigned numbers, if things would just make more sense. you'd get much more precision, and then you wouldn't have to worry about "but the math says it's possible" issues by taking everything by * -1.
- labster 3y agoJesse, what are you talking about?
- dylan604 3y agoWell, Mr White, if you look at all of the "weirdness" in physics with theories coming out because "the math says it's possible", then you'd see that it would be much more simple if we were not allowed to have negative numbers because we're only using u64 integers. we'd have more digits for precision as well.
- nickpeterson 3y agoI find that weird outliers are usually evidence that the underlying model is flawed in some fundamental way, but sometimes I think people believe the exceptions are fundamental, and a lot of effort goes to the wrong place.
- quickthrower2 3y agoI was confused... the symbol π is actually Pi, but it renders as something that looks like a different alphabet entirely on HN.
- gpgn 3y agoThese are somewhated dated but well worth watching; the professor does all kinds of approximations. Frontiers/Controversies in Astrophysics with Charles Bailyn: https://youtu.be/ZiK4lg3Tzfs?t=1628 https://youtu.be/ZiK4lg3Tzfs?t=1628
- mkoubaa 3y agoMy understanding is that a particles, like photons, don't have wave shifts. That's an emergent property of many particles
- alecst 3y agoThe conventional Doppler shift and the equivalence principle imply a gravitational redshift for a photon. See page 102: https://preposterousuniverse.com/wp-content/uploads/grnotes-four.pdf https://preposterousuniverse.com/wp-content/uploads/grnotes-...
- stopping 3y agoNo, individual particles can indeed be redshifted. The particle's wavelength is a fundamental property.
- blueprint 3y agoYour comment is a bit strange. Light doesn't travel as photons. Photons exclusively exist at the site and instant of detection of the wave of probability of detection that light really travels as. When light is redshifted, it loses energy, therefore the wavelength becomes longer.
- tsimionescu 3y agoThat is not the current understanding of quantum mechanics, as far as I know. Wave/particle dualism says that different experiments can either view light as a wave or a particle (never both) and that speaking about the nature of light when an experiment is not being performed is non-scientific by definition. Importantly, light very much behaves like a conventional wave in many real experiments - the interferometer experiment being one of the oldest and most well known. It is not a probability wave in that case, but an actual physical wave (now known to be an oscillation in the electro magnetic field, but long assumed to be a mechanical wave in the luminiferous aether).
- _0w8t 3y agoExperimentally one never observes waves. Light is detected based on its interaction with electrons and that is always by an electron absorbing a quanta of energy, not via some continuous process as would be the case with waves. Classically one can imagine that as if electron was hit by a particle. But then we have light diffraction and interference, which classically is described as a wave. So from a classical point of view light travels as a wave but interact as a particle. As of nature of the light, then consider that there is a reformulation of a classical electrodynamics that eliminates electromagnetic waves all together. There are only electrons that interacts with each other directly with no waves in between. Feynman spent quite some time trying to develop quantum electrodynamic based on that. He failed. Still the point stands that we never observe light directly but only through its effects on electrons and other charged particles. So it could be that what we call light is a theoretical artifact and there is no light in reality.
- pdonis 3y ago> Won't a photon climbing out of a huge gravity well have a huge redshift It depends; the key factor is not how "huge" the gravity well is (in terms of how massive the object is), but how close to the black hole horizon the light is emitted. The vast majority of the light JWST is seeing from black holes is not from very close to the horizon. It's from the accretion disk, which is much further from the horizon and so the gravitational redshift is much smaller.
- ajross 3y ago> Won't a photon climbing out of a huge gravity well have a huge redshift, thus confounding estimates of distance from us and estimated age? Of course it will. It will also have a redshift related to the expansion of the space it's been travelling through. Both of those corrections are absolutely part of the model. It's not nearly as simple as "Astronomers forgot about General Relativity!". But I guess it's true (to be clear: I'm just an amateur in this field) that the ΛCDM model for cosmological evolution that we've all been looking at for the past decade or two isn't holding up well at all. It looked like it was pretty much there and just needed some fine tuning. Then we got a bunch of new data and everything's a mess. That's kind of exciting all by itself, though it's also leading to a bunch of nattering from the existing iconoclasts (MOND nuts in particular) whose theories are also not working very well to explain JWST observations. New insight needed, basically. We're all watching for updates.
- xigency 3y ago> Both of those corrections are absolutely part of the model Is there a way to gain a better understanding of how these parameters are modeled and what the scientific evidence is for the various phenomena in astrophysics? It's somewhat perplexing to me as an outsider of the field to understand how things like mass and distance of stars and planetary bodies are determined when 1) the scales are so outside of conventional experience 2) observation is limited to 2D imaging of the night sky 3) the observations in general are not consistent with our knowledge of gravity and relativity without adding hidden parameters.
- antognini 3y agoI know Terence Tao (yes, that Terence Tao) is working on a book about the cosmic distance ladder, but sadly it's not out yet. (I guess he probably has other projects he's working on.) But he does have some slides from talks he's given: https://terrytao.files.wordpress.com/2020/10/cosmic-distance-ladder.pdf https://terrytao.files.wordpress.com/2020/10/cosmic-distance...
- antognini 3y agoThe photons that are getting observed are emitted from the accretion disk, which is not very close to the event horizon. You can estimate how close to the event horizon the disk is based on how broad the spectral lines are. The part of the disk that is coming towards you will be blueshifted and the part of the disk that is rotating away will be redshifted. From that (which is independent of the overall depth of the potential well) you can figure out how fast the disk is rotating. And from that you can figure out how far away the disk is from the black hole.
- quakeguy 3y agoWell, this is awesome.
- Smoosh 3y agoSometimes I despair for humanity [see advertising/social media/politics], but then I see something like this and think, we're doing pretty well for self-taught primates.
- dylan604 3y agoand then we see all of the belief systems to mock, punish, or worse people that are trying to expand human knowledge. looking back at history, you have to wonder where we might be now if there wasn't this attempts at mass eradication of learning. there are times i wonder if we're heading in that direction again. this time, rather than burning the Library of Alexandria or locking everything in catacombs, if we're not just trying to get there on a low-n-slow approach.
- hattmall 3y agoI mean it really depends on your personal experience to how your perspective or "where we are now" feels. It's not like everyone is even remotely concerned with or benefitting from this "advancement." A lot of the so called progress has done nothing but destroyed and distort an enjoyable and peaceful existence.
- codethief 3y ago> Won't a photon climbing out of a huge gravity well have a huge redshift Yes. Though see the sibling comments on why the (remaining) gravity well the emitted photon has to climb out of is not particularly huge here. > thus confounding estimates of distance from us and estimated age? Generally speaking: No, because people are not stupid. :) See the integrated Sachs-Wolfe effect for a very similar situation (CMB photons traveling through gravitational wells) -> https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sachs%E2%80%93Wolfe_effect https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sachs%E2%80%93Wolfe_effect
- javajosh 3y agoThis is super cool. I think it's funny how Quanta writes, "It is expected because JWST was built, in part, to find the ancient objects." "Ancient" is equivalent to "distant" because of special relativity. It's an odd thing, astronomy - it's a real world time-traveling observation, except we're limited in resolution and we can't look here only there. If it was a game mechanic I'd call it a cunning way to impose internally consistent limits on what the player can know.
- ijidak 3y ago> internally consistent limits on what the player can know Interesting thought. Can you expand? What do you mean by this?
- r2_pilot 3y agoNot the original author but my first interpretation is that this means, if it were in a video game, it would be a way to self-reinforce "fog of war" where you can only have extremely local information and you don't want extra information to leak to the players.
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoHas anyone re-written a classic RTSG with a slower speed of light? Like, Red Alert, but with time dilation.
- r2_pilot 3y agoNot to my knowledge, but there is a game called A Slower Speed of Light, which probably needs no further clarification. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Slower_Speed_of_Light https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/A_Slower_Speed_of_Light
- mekkkkkk 3y agoWouldn't that be incredibly hard, considering that the players perspective is disconnected from the units? I observe my base and order a group of units to go to some place on the minimap. I see them moving along on their way, and decide to scroll to them. Only to realize that they already arrived and got massacred by the enemy. I go back to my base only to realize that it was destroyed ages ago (in its frame of reference) and I'm dead. Game over. Thanks for playing SR Red Alert.
- mvdtnz 3y agoI wish stories like this were a more straight forward counting of the interesting facts and relevant input from experts. I don't really need the origin story of the conference this finding was discussed at.
- andai 3y agoYou can ask GPT to rewrite it according to your preference. (Not being facetious: I often ask it for bullet points or "explain like I'm 13.")
- burnished 3y agoI'm not sure this is good advice, especially considering the context is around novel material.
- louislang 3y agothe problem with GPT is that you're not guaranteed to get something that's _accurate_. I'd definitely prefer some input from an expert over GPT.
- teaearlgraycold 3y agoEnglish text transformation is a task it’s exceptionally good at. You just need to prompt it to only use the source material you give it for summarization.
- atoav 3y ago"Explain me something, I don't care if it is true, because I wouldn't be able to tell anyways"
- andai 3y agoGuilty as charged! But to be fair, this applies to human writing too: “Briefly stated, the Gell-Mann Amnesia effect is as follows. You open the newspaper to an article on some subject you know well. In Murray’s case, physics. In mine, show business. You read the article and see the journalist has absolutely no understanding of either the facts or the issues. Often, the article is so wrong it actually presents the story backward—reversing cause and effect. I call these the “wet streets cause rain” stories. Paper’s full of them. In any case, you read with exasperation or amusement the multiple errors in a story, and then turn the page to national or international affairs, and read as if the rest of the newspaper was somehow more accurate about Palestine than the baloney you just read. You turn the page, and forget what you know.” – Michael Crichton
- somat 3y agoSo this is one of them "shower thoughts", you know, those stupid things you think about while working on something else.That is, purely science fiction. Can an analog be drawn between galaxies and solar system creation theories, with several orders of magnitudes in time required for formation due to scale difference. That is, the galaxies we see with their billions of stars are actually young proto accretion disks. while mature galaxies will have most of the mass localized in a small(1-2) number of points with a few(~10) point masses orbiting it. a sort of galaxy sized solar system if you will. However due to the scale of things involved all these late stage point masses would be black holes.
- deanCommie 3y agoI'm here for shower thoughts-driven discourse. But I missed the point. Stars eventually wind up as black holes. So it stands to reason so would galaxies. But then why would they be all over the early universe?
- consilient 3y ago> Stars eventually wind up as black holes. The vast majority of stars will end up as white dwarfs. Stars need to be about 10 times the mass of the sun to undergo core collapse, and about 25 solar masses (or more, depending on composition) to form black holes. > So it stands to reason so would galaxies. Galaxies are loosely bound clouds of dust with a few stars here and there, relatively speaking; stars are dense roiling balls of plasma. Their dynamics are extremely different.
- mr_toad 3y ago> But then why would they be all over the early universe? Stars can form quite quickly (relative to the age of the universe), possibly as early as 150 million years after the Big Bang. And the earliest massive stars would have had very short lifespans.
- cooper_ganglia 3y ago[flagged]
- jsbisviewtiful 3y agoIt's pretty cool how much JWST has caught in such a short amount of time. Give it another 5-10 years and we may have some absolutely groundbreaking new celestial theories.
- mabbo 3y agoIt's really worthwhile to compare it to the hubble in that regard. Pre-hubble, the question was whether the universe would contract into a big crunch, expand slower and slower forever, or balance out somehow in the middle. Then hubble got a good look at universal expansion and we noticed it was speeding up and now we've got Lambda-CDM from that. From this we know what the long term fate of the universe is. That there are galaxies we can see that but we can never reach. That the universe will end from the slow burn out of heat death and not return to the singularity. Just imagine what we'll know after 5-10 years of JWST.
- dotnet00 3y agoHeat death is one of the possibilities, but it's still very much an open question, as it depends on the curvature of the universe and the nature of dark energy.
- empyrrhicist 3y agoI'll take heat death over the big rip. Don't forget vacuum collapse though...
- tadfisher 3y agoIf conformal cyclic cosmology is to be believed, heat death is indistinguishable from the singularity as entropy is infinite in both cases, so heat death "may as well be" the singularity.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- afterburner 3y agoThe universe is draining. Don't worry, there's still time.
- claytongulick 3y agoCan someone who really knows this stuff clarify my understanding? I've been given to understand that black holes remain a physics theory that has not been directly observed or proven. I thought that we had a fair amount of observational evidence that suggests their existence, but no "smoking gun" proof of it, and that these types of "observed a black hole" articles are a little misleading - that in reality, what was observed was much indirect, interpreted data that is consistent with black hole theory, but could also be something else. Am I off base here?
- thehappypm 3y agoScientist recently got a good picture of one
- claytongulick 3y agoSee, this is my beef with the reporting on this stuff and the source of my question. The "photo" you're referring to was constructed by a super computer massaging enormous amounts of data to fit a model and constructing an image from weighted averages of thousands of data images across the spectrum from an enormously complex array of detectors in an unfathomably noisy environment [1]. It was presented by the media as a "photo", but it seems to me like it's more similar to the "image" we get from reconstruction of wifi signals in a room to determine interior object's shape. Or maybe a better example would be the "photos" of atoms, which are not photos at all but a reconstruction of miniscule electromagnetic resistance readings from a STM whisker driven by a piezoelectric crystal. I think we're supposed to get the ability to have better "photos" with the activation of LISA in 2037 [2] but until then, claiming that we have photos of black holes seems a bit misleading (not by you, I mean the science reporting). [1] https://eventhorizontelescope.org/blog/astronomers-reveal-first-image-black-hole-heart-our-galaxy https://eventhorizontelescope.org/blog/astronomers-reveal-fi... [2] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laser_Interferometer_Space_Antenna https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laser_Interferometer_Space_A...
- Keysh 3y agoLISA is a scaled-up version of LIGO, and won't produce "photos" any more than LIGO does. Of course, LIGO has provided extremely good evidence that black holes exist (most of what it detects are the gravitational waves from two black holes merging), but if you don't buy that, then you won't buy LISA's observations, either.
- _8j50 3y agoI've wondered how blackholes have a similar 2d shape as with hurricanes and whirlpools where the center is empty. What if the inside of a blackhole is devoid of all things including spacetime, although that doesn't make good scifi.
- andrewflnr 3y agoI believe this actually is one of the hypotheses about black hole interiors, though I forget the name. Nothing to do with terrestrial storms or vortices, though; a black hole doesn't have to have any rotation at all.
- _8j50 3y agoCool. > a black hole doesn't have to have any rotation at all. How about the gravity or hawking radiation it emanates. I am actually surprised that matter falling into a blackhole isn't whirlpooling around it.
- andrewflnr 3y agoInfalling matter usually is "whirlpooling", see "accretion disk". That's a separate question from the structure of the black hole itself and whether there's anything inside the event horizon.
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoThere are rotating black holes (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rotating_black_hole https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rotating_black_hole).
- andrewflnr 3y agoYes, obviously most real black holes are rotating. I didn't say otherwise.
- AnimalMuppet 3y ago
- hxegon 3y agoA part of CCC[1] is giant black holes outlasting the end of the universe to be around for the beginning of the next one. Is this a potential explanation? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conformal_cyclic_cosmology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Conformal_cyclic_cosmology
- searealist 3y agoIn CCC, black holes all evaporate before that.
- hxegon 3y agoDo they? One of the papers in support of CCC found patterns in the CMB that might have been black holes remaining from the last cycle. I wonder if they'd start eating the new matter created by the big bang and survive.
- andrewflnr 3y agoThey (think they) found traces of the last black holes evaporating. That has to finish happening before the next CCC cycle.
- marcus_holmes 3y ago> Over the course of a year, Chandra stared at the cosmic lens for two weeks — one of its longest observation campaigns yet — and collected 19 X-ray photons coming from a galaxy called UHZ1, at a redshift of 10.1. Those 19 high-octane photons most likely came from a growing black hole that existed fewer than half a billion years after the Big Bang, making it by far the most distant X-ray source ever detected. This blew my tiny mind. 19 photons over 2 weeks. That's such a tiny amount of light. How are we able to conclude anything from such tiny amounts of light? (I'm not disputing that we can, it just blows my mind that we can). And those photons - 13+ billion years speeding through space, all that vast empty time and distance, to end up hitting a detector during those two weeks when doing so will change the way we think about the universe. And of course the photon itself hasn't experienced any of that time. For the photon, it was all the same moment. Also blows my mind that any time I'm standing outside I'm being hit by photons that have been traveling for billions of years to reach that point. Of course they're overwhelmed by photons from the Sun, but still. Some photon left a sun billions of years ago, sped through the universe for all that time, and ended up hitting my retina. And I don't even realise when this happens. I understand why theists don't like science. How can your puny god compare to shit like this?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mr_toad 3y agoYou used to be able to tune a TV between channels and listen to the hiss of the cosmic microwave background. That’s light from millions of years before the first stars. Digital TVs just don’t have that 2.73 degrees above absolute zero sound to them.
- mikeInAlaska 3y agoNow imagine that the Chandra telescope has a 1.2 meter diameter aperture that those 19 photons passed through. That represents 1.13 square meters of light collecting area, peering into that expanding spherical wavefront at the point where it is 26+ billion light years in diameter. That would be a sphere with a surface area of 2,123 square light years. I wonder what it would add up to if you had the 19 photons for all those other 1.13 meter chunks of area in one place.
- sinuhe69 3y agoMaybe I’m a bit naive here, but I thought finding of many supermassive back holes in the very early universe should be expected, and not a surprise. My chain of thoughts is following: - Blackholes are collapsed masses. In our phase of the universe, they are normally the results of supernovae but only because today stars are the only source of dense masses. - Because the total mass of the universe is constant and the early universe has a volume of dozen orders of magnitude smaller than the universe in later stage (the universe we normally observe), collapsed masses should happen much more likely than in later stage. - Those masses do not necessarily come from the stars, which are masses with a visible fusion processes but could come directly from mass-lumps, left after the Big Bang. - In fact, I think the idea of a super homogenous universe right after the Big Bang is suspect. Even the CMB is only homogeneous on (very) large scale (3000 mega parsecs), ways too big for blackholes. - Therefore, I think after the Big Bang, there should be a large number of primordial blackholes. - We can only observe blackholes with an accretion disk, but the primordial blackholes with no visible accretion will stay invisible unless there is a collision/fusion in progress. Consequently, we will find a lot more blackholes in the early universe, the more we look. They are super massive because of the bias: only supermassive blackholes with accretion disk were producing radiation, powerful enough so we can detect with our current technology.
- andrewstuart 3y agoGreat ideas tend to be obvious in hindsight.
- lenkite 3y agoLets say the number of actual black holes is even more - several orders more than what is even mentioned here. Would it be enough to account for the "Dark Matter" conundrum ?
- sinuhe69 3y agoIn fact, primordial blackholes are a candidate for dark matter hypothesis. They are still invisible but at least we could devise a theory to detect them (light focusing/bending for examples)
- kune 3y agoThe density of black hole decrease by the inverse square of the mass of the black hole. That means massive black holes have a much lower density that small black holes. So they are more likely to form than small black holes. Dark matter will have played an important role in the creation of those early black holes. If there is no dark matter and some form of MOND theory of gravity is correct, the Schwarzschild formula will require a modification for large black holes. In that case galaxy centers will not require large masses to see the same effects.
- whimsicalism 3y ago> So they are more likely to form than small black holes. Based on your previous sentence would it not be the opposite?
- micw 3y agoWhat exactly is the "density" of a black hole? As I understand, a BH is a singularity, so all mass is at one point which means all BHs have the same (infinite) density. Is it a kind of "virtual density", e.g. the mass of the singularity devided by the schwarzschild radius or the event horizon?
- zycon 3y agoDensity is mass divided by volume. Volume of BH is defined by event horizon. Singularity is a result of applying a theory of relativity in a case where we know relativity doesn't work, so it's unlikely it's real.
- codethief 3y ago> Volume of BH is defined by event horizon. The event horizon is a three-dimensional null hypersurface, though, encompassing a four-dimensional spacetime "volume". You are probably referring to the two-dimensional apparent horizon, which depends on the spatial slicing.
- codethief 3y agoI suppose OP defines it as the mass of the BH, divided by the apparent volume taken up by the BH (more precisely: the apparent horizon), as seen from the outside. Put differently, for a Schwarzschild BH: Density ~ M/R³ (modulo constant prefactors) ~ 1/M², since the Schwarzschild radius is linear in M.
- FreshStart 3y agoSo if it's equally distributed matter antimatter at the start, what are these holes made off?