13 ms·
US inflation means families are spending $709 more per month than two years ago
- axpy906 3y agoAssuming $709 an average number over all cost of living locations. We’re spending more than that.
- maxlamb 3y ago709 is the average increase, not the spend
- zranger 3y agoToo pedantic I assume to point out that by definition inflation means they aren't actually spending more?
- candiddevmike 3y agoAs a parent with kids, I really don't know how folks are getting by with the prices of everything. I know folks who keep eating out, buying new vehicles, and even building new houses and I'm left scratching my head wondering how they afford all of this. I'm not saving nearly as much as I was years ago and I think my "lifestyle" has decreased post COVID (few vacations, eating out is a treat, gifts are for birthdays/holidays). Is everyone swimming in debt?
- throwaway2203 3y agoyup, with daycare costs we're technically top 10% and still kinda hand to mouth in a MCOL area.
- coffeebeqn 3y agoMy savings accounts look wistfully as I spend more on daycare per kid per month than I used to pay for rent not too long ago
- candiddevmike 3y agoI think the concept of cost of living areas is out the window. Mortgage and rent may be relatively COL dependent (kinda, but everyone is incentived to even it out nationwide), but for everything else I actually think the competition within big cities/"HCOL areas" drives down prices. In my "LCOL" flyover area I'm seeing $30+ pizza and $18 burgers, along with $10 beers at bars. It's insane.
- mjn 3y agoThat matches my experience. Of places I've spent significant time in the past year, the one with the most reasonably priced food for eating out is NYC, of all places. It has very expensive places too, of course, but a lot more sub-$10 options than anywhere else I've been recently. There are even a few 99-cent pizza slice places still in business (not as many as 10 years ago, but they exist, and $2-3/slice places are abundant).
- gruez 3y ago> In my "LCOL" flyover area I'm seeing $30+ pizza and $18 burgers, along with $10 beers at bars. It's insane. "$30+ pizza and $18 burgers" doesn't say much when you consider that there's a huge price/quality range between basic and premium offerings. For instance, a $18 waygu beef burger at a gastro pub doesn't seem very out of place at all, but a $18 mcdonalds burger would be outrageously expensive.
- hotnfresh 3y agoI live in a—4th tier is selling it short, but 3rd tier seems generous, call it 3.5th tier—city, and am always shocked at how much cheaper good restaurant food, baked goods, et c. are in "real" cities compared to here. Anything non-shit is basically 20-50% more expensive here than in HCOL cities. Makes no sense, these places should have like 1/5 the rent costs and lower labor costs than the major coastal cities, yet, prices are sky-high and quality's often not even that good. Groceries are about the same price. More expensive for some things, cheaper for others. Health care's more expensive here, with lower quality, because it's a flyover red state. HCOL only seems to apply to housing. Everything else is about the same or cheaper in "HCOL" cities. May not hold for other smaller/poorer cities, but very much does for ours.
- fullshark 3y ago> Is everyone swimming in debt? Probably https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CCLACBW027SBOG https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/CCLACBW027SBOG
- fuckthisshit3 3y agoDebt is a socialized hallucination. If people refuse to give up on it, we can just take the money back from the rich too through taxes. Reaganomics legalized looting pensions to invest on Wall Street. There's precedent for expropriation of wealth of the dying. What are a bunch of retirees going to do? Fight back against 20-30 somethings? Boomers benefited from New Deal then killed it. There is no market, just a legalized generational Ponzi scheme.
- 01100011 3y agoNot so bad when adjusted for inflation but not great: https://usafacts.org/articles/the-state-of-household-debt-in-the-us/ https://usafacts.org/articles/the-state-of-household-debt-in... I'm not sure what it looks like if you adjust for population growth. Debt to GDP is looking good, but with wealth inequality as bad as it is(thanks Jerome!) I'm not sure that matters as much.
- 01100011 3y agoI don't know how most people are doing it. For me it's because the asset bubble has inflated my stock income. I suspect a lot of folks who owned homes, stocks and other assets are feeling the wealth effect. For the rest of society, I don't know why they're not in the streets with pitchforks.
- Geee 3y ago"It is well enough that people of the nation do not understand our banking and monetary system, for if they did, I believe there would be a revolution before tomorrow morning." - Henry Ford
- 542458 3y agoNot an actual Henry Ford quote fwiw. https://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/18247/did-henry-ford-predict-revolution-if-people-understood-the-banking-and-monetary#27316 https://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/18247/did-henry...
- eurleif 3y agoYour link says it's a paraphrase rather than an exact quote. It still represents his sentiment accurately. But quoting Henry Ford, particularly his views on nefarious bankers, is a pretty questionable choice considering what he had to say about Jews.
- spiderice 3y agoThis is a logical fallacy. His view on Jews has no effect on whether his statements on nefarious bankers are true. You can quote me saying 1+1=2, even if 2 is my favorite number. Now if he’s being misleading and you have evidence of that, then his feeling toward Jews might explain why he is biased
- eurleif 3y agoYou misunderstand the scope of formal fallacies, which only apply to formal arguments. Most arguments aren't formal arguments, and that's ok; they aren't supposed to be. Instead of proving a conclusion from a set of premises, they rely on heuristics to draw probabilistic inferences. In the context of a formal argument, the act of quoting Henry Ford would have been either the fallacy of appeal to authority (if the quote's provenance were meant to demonstrate its veracity), or the fallacy of bare assertion (if it were meant to stand on its own). I didn't invoke those fallacies because I understand that, outside the context of a formal argument, appeal to authority is a reasonable heuristic, rather than a fallacy. There's nothing fallacious about saying, for example: "Most doctors recommend getting vaccinated, so you should probably get vaccinated." In this context, my reply is also not fallacious: it's reasonable to doubt the reasoning ability of a vicious anti-Semite, particularly on the subject of nefarious bankers, which is closely intertwined with anti-Semitic conspiracy theories.
- paulpauper 3y agowages have gone up too
- qbasic_forever 3y agoNot nearly as much as inflation. Groceries alone are up something like 40% in the last 2-3 years. Your and everyone else's wages have not risen that fast on the whole.
- bluGill 3y agoGroceries are for many a tiny part of their expenses, and other things they buy are not up as much. Calculating inflation is difficult for the above reason.
- Auracle 3y agoOn the whole? No. People that were making near minimum wage before absolutely have though, and I think that's been a huge driver of the inflation. Pre-pandemic, the Walmart in our area had a starting wage of $10 or $11 an hour. It's now $18.
- brnaftr361 3y agoCan you verify the position, hours, benefits, and expectations of those offers? 'Cause I can offer (up to!) $18.50 and then negotiate down. I can also give somebody 10 hours a week and duly provide no benefits. When I worked there they took me on PT no benies, and only after proving myself did they extend an offer for FT employment. PT can be highly flexible as to the definition. Whether it's a permanent or temporary position is also something noteworthy. I think these are just some of the elements we should be considering if we're going to say wages have risen.
- Auracle 3y agoI can. I do high school senior photography and I asked the kids last year where they worked, and how much they made doing it. Oddly, that doesn't seem rude to ask 17 year olds. The ones working at Walmart absolutely made $17 an hour (then). It's Walmart. They aren't playing games with stuff like that. I'm sure they're mostly doing under 32 hours a week where possible with their employees as usual.
- silisili 3y agoSame. I make decent money and used to save thousands per month. Now I'm lucky to stash away high hundreds a month, but any expense like new brakes wipes that out. I wonder how in the world everyone else is getting by. Maybe we're all just smiling and pretending here...
- xenospn 3y agoI live alone and just realized I’ve been spending $1300/month this year on groceries. For one person.
- xgbi 3y agoI don’t understand how you can spend so much. Even with inflation we (family of 4, cooling all meals at home) are at less than 800€/$ per month. And we eat meat nearly all meals.
- josephd79 3y ago325/week ?? You live in a big city? We spend that for a family of 5 but we don’t buy a lot of snacks….
- ghaff 3y agoGroceries? That seems insane. I rarely eat out when I'm not traveling and I would be surprised if I spent a third that when I was home and don't especially go for cheap food.
- silisili 3y agoGroceries are definitely my biggest pain point today. In 2018, for a family of 3, we used to spend about $120 to $150 per week in groceries. Justed check July, and we spent over $1400 in groceries. That's from Walmart, not Whole Foods or some such. And we're in a low to medium COL city. Sure, we could cut back to more staple stuff(more beans, less meats) if needed, I'm just illustrating how much the price of things have increased!
- renewiltord 3y ago
- qbasic_forever 3y agoThere is a _LOT_ of debt being added, household debt is up to something like 17 trillion dollars from like under 10 trillion pre pandemic. IMHO vehicles are huge drivers of debt. There are almost no cars under $30k now, and the average sale price of new cars is pushing up near $50k. This is for bog standard stuff like Hondas and Fords, not luxury cars. Used cars are incredibly expensive too. People are financing cars for well over 5 years now--I've heard of people on 6 and 7 year loans now just to make monthly payments possible. It's nuts.
- gruez 3y ago>IMHO vehicles are huge drivers of debt. There are almost no cars under $30k now, and the average sale price of new cars is pushing up near $50k. This is for bog standard stuff like Hondas and Fords, not luxury cars. I went on toyota.com and a base level corolla is only selling for $22,795. This includes a "Delivery, Processing & Handling" charge of $1,095. If for whatever reason you think that driving a compact car is beneath you, you can have a mid sized car (toyota camary) for only $27,515.
- helloooooooo 3y agoNow get a dealer to order that base Corolla from factory. Hint: it ain’t happening’.
- sylens 3y agoExactly. It’s the SUVs and trucks that are suffering runaway prices. Driving a new Camry or Honda Accord is still doable
- qbasic_forever 3y agoI just went to Toyota's site and mid range V6 Camry with a few options like navigation, driving assistance, etc. is over $45k sticker price. If you want a hybrid it's over $50k. For a Camry!
- kittensmittens 3y ago
- syntaxing 3y agoSAME! I barely saved this year so far and I haven’t been splurging on anything. The car I bought before the inflation burst is now 25% more now. I make good money relatively but I still feel like we’re drowning. Every grocery run is over $200 even if don’t get meat, just the fruits alone are eye watering nowadays.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- matsemann 3y agoIn addition to inflation, the 4 percent points bump on interests also hurts. (Where I live we mostly have non-fixed mortgages)
- Waterluvian 3y agoI think a lot of people get into a mindset that a 25 year mortgage is meant to be paid off in 25 years, so that mindset guides their entire frame of reference for how large a lifestyle to adopt. I’m not saying to rush through a mortgage. Do whatever you want. But consider not getting into a situation where you’re somehow struggling even though you’re one of the lucky few who can afford to even own a home. When times get tough they’re no more secure than those who make less. I’ve seen this with many peers who have Teslas and 1.5M homes who are now struggling despite such an income.
- fullshark 3y agoIs it not meant to be paid off in 25 years?
- lotsofpulp 3y agoDefinitely pays off to invest more than the minimum required payments over 25 years. Not going to find better non callable leverage.
- scarface_74 3y agoWhy? I refinanced in 2021 and my mortgage rate is 1.97% fixed.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoI meant invest into other equities, such as the public stock market, not invest into paying down the home principal.
- Auracle 3y agoshrug It kind of depends on your mortgage rate. If your rate is low it technically makes more sense to invest your money, as that'll have a great return. If your mortgage rate is high, you might be better off paying extra each month against the principle as it'll drastically reduce how much you pay in interest over the course of the loan.
- xwdv 3y agoDebt slaves.
- ren_engineer 3y ago401K early withdrawals are up almost 40% YoY and credit card debt is also up massively. If interest rate increases do lead to eventual job losses things will get ugly fast real estate is the thing to watch, if even a small number job losses happen people will have no choice but to sell even if they want to keep their low interest rate(home prices have stayed relatively flat because everybody is staying put, so low inventory on paper). Interest rate increases have resulted in significantly lower buying power, so home prices will have to drop. Forced sales will cause others to rush for the exit and cause even further price drops
- coolbreezetft22 3y agoWith kid moving up to public school from pre-k we'll be saving an extra 2500$/month now. And in a couple years when our younger one is old enough that'll be another 2500$/month saved so I'm feeling pretty optimistic.
- Auracle 3y agoThose prices are insane. I'm in a rural area but our daycare is $150 a week.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoNow that is an insane price. I don’t think it even pencils out assuming the daycare is following minimum teacher student ratios and minimum wage, which means there is under the table pay going on or corners being cut somewhere.
- Auracle 3y agoIt's a home daycare. She has 5 kids that she watches, and only one infant. I think that might be the maximum she's allowed - certainly only one infant. The infant price is more expensive as well. Keep in mind that daycare centers themselves need to profit, so going "direct" would be cheaper.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoYes, so that is a different product than the previous poster’s $2.5k per month daycare. If workers are hard to find in your rural area, a comparable daycare might not be too far from $2.5k per month.
- Auracle 3y agoWe looked at a (YMCA) daycare center and it was more expensive, but certainly not as expensive as that. The infant section in particular was...dystopian, though. Also, no windows. They built it in an old mall. I couldn't get past those two things.
- Aurornis 3y ago> I know folks who keep eating out, buying new vehicles, and even building new houses and I'm left scratching my head wondering how they afford all of this. You can never judge people's financial situations from their spending habits. Someone in my extended family spent years living large, buying new cars, building new houses, and wearing nice clothes. They had a family business and always said that the business wad doing well. Several years later the husband died unexpectedly. His wife was suddenly struggling to make ends meet, despite nothing actually changing with their "business". As we later discovered, they were experts at amassing debt. The business wasn't really successful but they had used every possible angle to get more lines of credit, debt, "investments", and loans. They had even made a habit of "buying" supplies from vendors with Net 30 terms, reselling them, and then never paying the vendors back. They moved from state to state to scam new vendors every time they were blacklisted by the all of their local vendors. That's an extreme example, but it highlights how appearances can differ so much from reality. More commonly, I think a lot of people just never learned how to save anything at all. I know an alarming number of people in their 30s who still haven't bothered saving anything more than the $1-10K they have in their checking account at a given time. When the number goes up, they spend it back down. You could have the same net income as these people but never achieve their level of lifestyle spending because you're doing some savings. On the other end of the spectrum, many people are actually doing well. Wages are up (contrary to what you see on social media) and people's investments have done very well in recent years. Many of my friends are doing quite well for themselves by simply getting working a little harder to get jobs that pay a little above average and then carefully budgeting and investing over the long haul. Do this for a couple decades with some careful attention paid to where you live and the job you get and it's not hard to get a rather comfortable financial position by 40, especially in tech.
- HenryBemis 3y agoI have been listening to plenty of "finance gurus" (i.e. my favorite is Dave Ramsey). I see (here in EU) that young people have 1-2 credit cards. I understand that in the US the number is higher. The dream for any young (female) professional at the tender age of 25 is to own a couple of very expensive bags ("because I deserve it" using credit cards of course). Consumerism going steady. At least in the US you have the 401k. When I begin a discussion with friends/ acquaintances on "hey guys anyone got a decent EFT? I go my VOOG and SOXX all set up but I am looking to diversify further with some water, consumer, international, etc" and they look at me as if I speak some ancient language. So.. most save minimal, invest nothing. Paycheck-to-paycheck is a big thing in the US and it is happening in the EU now. (and don't get me started on parents of 14yo kids buying their kids the new iPhone every darn year)
- lotsofpulp 3y ago> (and don't get me started on parents of 14yo kids buying their kids the new iPhone every darn year) Yes, you should not get started because according to Apple’s 10-K, it does not happen on any meaningful scale. Objectively, phones are being used for longer and longer time periods.
- scarface_74 3y agoI really struggled trying to reply to this without sounding snarky and that’s not my intention. But it’s simple numbers. They spend less than you do or make more.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> I really don't know how folks are getting by with the prices of everything There is a lot of regional variation in production [1] and income [2][3]. On the whole, real disposable income and savings rates are up [4]. But someone in the midwest (income up, annualized, 7 to 11% Q4 '22 to Q1 '23) or Florida (7.9%) is seeing a very different economic landscape than someone in California (0.7%) or Indiana (-1%) [5]. [1] https://www.bea.gov/news/2023/gross-domestic-product-state-and-personal-income-state-1st-quarter-2023 https://www.bea.gov/news/2023/gross-domestic-product-state-a... [2] https://www.bea.gov/system/files/rpp1222b_0.png https://www.bea.gov/system/files/rpp1222b_0.png [3] https://www.bea.gov/data/income-saving/personal-income-county-metro-and-other-areas https://www.bea.gov/data/income-saving/personal-income-count... [4] https://www.bea.gov/news/2023/personal-income-and-outlays-june-2023 https://www.bea.gov/news/2023/personal-income-and-outlays-ju... [5] https://www.bea.gov/news/2023/gross-domestic-product-state-and-personal-income-state-1st-quarter-2023#home https://www.bea.gov/news/2023/gross-domestic-product-state-a...
- asdgioanionio 3y agoBecause their pay also increased. People can generally afford higher prices. Real wages have remained remarkably stable in the last few years. The article itself says this. Somehow, it manages to spin it into bad news. >Even though prices have soared, real earnings, which adjust for inflation, are stuck at late 2019 levels. People can afford the same lifestyles they could a few years ago. The US weathered the outbreak of war in Europe and the worst pandemic in generations without serious economic hardship. Somehow, in CNN's view, this is a problem. Real wages haven't been stable. They haven't been resilient. No, they've been "stuck".
- lacrimacida 3y ago> As a parent with kids, I really don't know how folks are getting by with the prices of everything. I know folks who keep eating out, buying new vehicles, and even building new houses and I'm left scratching my head wondering how they afford all of this. I hear you perfectly. What I did a while ago was to fully embrace a more frugal lifestyle where attention and time are the most valued. So consumption went to a minimum and all that. Now after prices jumped up we’re where we started and despite being frugal we’re left with a lot less. It is quite unsettling to be honest…
- markus_zhang 3y agoMany SWE, for example, are getting good salaries so they can definitely afford that. Just a few hundred samples cam skew one's observations.
- wonderwonder 3y agoIt's death by a thousand cuts. New backpack for the oldest, new shoes for the youngest, oil change for the wife's car, leaf guards for the gutters so they don't clog the French drain I had to have installed due to my living room flooding. Dog has to get shots or heartworm meds... Choose the month and there is guaranteed to be $250 - $2000 in incidentals as a homeowner with kids. Wife's student loans kick in next month, $750 a month. It's crippling and I am lucky enough to do fairly well financially. I'm complaining but I'm aware that millions have it way worse than I do.
- AndrewKemendo 3y agoSingle Father of three here. I’m not swimming in debt but I’m definitely reducing my spend every month significantly. The price of meat is going wild - on track to double this year
- oneTbrain23 3y agoConsidering China and middle east largely dumping USD transactions and debts, you will see whatever pricing you have today to double in coming 10 years (assuming Joe and very similar to Joe quality controlling America government for coming decade - mostly now fraud so elections result wont change much). Park your money away from USD (e.g. gold or Bruneian dollar) and prepare your kids for other things than America-centric such as learning to code, and learning Chinese. My nieces are even learning Russians and Koreans beside Chinese and they are in their 20s.
- prepend 3y agoI switched from regular grocery stores to aldi/lidl/walmart. And from eating out 2-4 times a month to eating out 1-2 times. I also switched to more staple foods like lentils and beans and rice and canned vegetables instead of fresh vegetables. And to buying ground beef on sale and freezing. It seems kind of crazy that prices keep going up and even simple “luxuries” like a coffee while networking went from $3.5 for a small latte at my local coffee shop in 2019 is now $5.5. I think for some people it doesn’t seem to affect them and they just pay the higher prices but base costs seem to have really gone up a lot for my family. Fortunately some big expenses are fixed (mortgage and transport) but if they had to change it would be extra rough.
- l5870uoo9y 3y ago> Most of that increase in spending is driven by housing costs… I am casually investigating the possibility of moving from Berlin to Copenhagen and some of the apartments in Copenhagen that I am looking at have risen close to 30% in the last few years. This burden of course mainly falls on the younger generations.
- ModernMech 3y agoEvery year for the past 5 years I’ve gotten a “merit raise” which hasn’t met inflation, so I’m effectively making less than I was when I started at my job despite having 5 years more experience. My organization puts a negative value on experience, and the only way I can get an actual raise is to jump ship. The story of my generation. Meanwhile they complain about a hiring and retention problem. Gee, I wonder why?
- taway9021000 3y ago>> Meanwhile they complain about a hiring and retention problem. This happens at every company because they realize most people dont leave, or so few leave that it is worth the few that leave. You have three options 1. Leave 2. Work less given your effective pay increase. Invest the time into finding a better job and into leetcoding 3. (not ethical, but commmon) work less given your effective pay increase. invest the free time into freelance work to make up for lost pay.
- Auracle 3y agoI get a kick out of our local A&W that's had the usual "please be patient we don't have enough workers" sign up for at least a year, with another sign under it saying they're hiring starting at $10 an hour. I wonder why they don't have enough workers when almost every other retail business around pays 50% or more than that, and it's not like their employees would have to go through a grueling tech hiring process to jump ship.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoBecause as long as they’re still able to be in business, they’ll just keep dragging along without paying more. Scale this across the economy appropriately. Is the customer still showing up and living with “please be patient”? Then why reduce margins by paying more?
- the_only_law 3y agoReminds me of when I was visiting a couple years ago, seeing commercials being run by companies desperate for skilled labor, while paying less than the local McDonald’s…
- bko 3y agoWhat I don't understand is this 2% price target. Prices could go up 10% one year, and well call it a success if next year we "tame inflation" by only having our prices go up 2%. Why can't we target to get prices back down? For those on a fixed income, this is money we lost forever. We expect (and see) some prices go down every year (mainly electronics) and it works fine. But god forbid the price of milk goes down a bit after rising 20% in two years.
- TuringNYC 3y ago>> What I don't understand is this 2% price target. It is statistical trickery and a headline number used to make people think things are OK. It is also a convenient number for COLA increase targets which make people think their incomes/pensions are going up (when effectively they are not on a real basis.) Also, as you note, we re-baseline each year and dont talk about the cumulative compounded inflation e.g., over the past 5yrs. Americans on fixed incomes (e.g., pension, social security) and those without wage elasticity (e.g., restaurant workers) are absolutely miserable right now because they are squeezed from both sides, even after modest wage increases in 2021/2022. This is not good for a Democracy.
- dublinben 3y agoLow wage workers have actually seen the most wage growth recently. https://www.epi.org/publication/swa-wages-2022/ https://www.epi.org/publication/swa-wages-2022/
- TuringNYC 3y ago>> Low wage workers have actually seen the most wage growth recently. Yes and no(?) From the study "Real wage growth across the wage distribution, 2019–2022" shows 9% real wage growth. The "real" portion is compared to engineered inflation figures. In the day-to-day world where people pay actual prices, price increases have not be 2% or whatever CPI claims them to be, they are much worse. We can back into rosy numbers, but the real numbers are felt by people. I'd suggest speaking to a variety of people and see how they feel. Ensure to also speak to someone on social security income. I speak to my mom and see the numbers on a weekly basis.
- kevmo 3y agoAmerica should have elected Bernie Sanders.
- ndesaulniers 3y agoDNC wouldn't let us.
- cscurmudgeon 3y agoAmerica should elect someone who acknowledge the scientific reality of the law of supply and demand.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- VancouverMan 3y agoBased on the situation in Canada today, I don't think that would be a good idea. Pretty much every economic problem and distortion in Canada today can be directly attributed to the socialist policies put in place by the various left-wing and "right-wing" (who are still quite left-of-centre) governments over the last half-century or so. For example, significant taxation and public debt are needed to pay for the bloated, inefficient, and low-quality provincial public health care and education systems, as well as the various government bureaucracies. Large, unaccountable bureaucracies have resulted in there being intrusive regulation all over the place, even when it's completely unnecessary. The high taxation, the intrusive regulation, and onerous bureaucracy make starting and operating businesses in Canada far harder than it should be. Things that should be simple and routine, such as hiring and paying an employee, becomes a significant burden, especially for small businesses. Ever-increasing minimum wages, which in many cases are economically infeasible relative to the real wealth that the employees would be creating, discourage job creation, and introduce economic distortions throughout the supply chain. Excessive regulations have also made it unnecessarily challenging and costly to build homes and buildings for businesses, resulting in high property and rental costs. The extremely high levels of immigration have only exacerbated many of the aforementioned problems. That's all just the tip of the iceberg. Socialist policies have been quite detrimental to Canada, and have noticeably decreased the standard of living over time.
- allthecybers 3y agoMy spouse and I have been talking about this quite a bit lately. Even with two incomes from tech employment we are watching our budget since it feels like everything is extra expensive lately. The income gains we’ve made have only allowed us to maintain versus climb to the next level of lifestyle. It makes me wonder where we will start falling behind. Obviously we are fortunate to not live on credit cards and have our bills paid, but it feels like we worked hard to get here to be no better off than we were. I wonder how other folks in the middle class are making ends meet especially trying to afford a home with employers forcing RTO/RTH to HCOL in many cases.
- SomaticPirate 3y agoI feel like these anecdotes make more sense with numbers. What is your combined household income? > $250k? I mean, if this is where people are feeling pinched I agree I have no idea how the middle class is surviving
- allthecybers 3y agoOur household income has been in the ballpark of ~$200k for the last three or so years.
- scarface_74 3y agoI bet wherever you are living you have a household income in the top 20% locally. I bet you’re spending a lot more on “something” than the median wage earner in your metro area.
- allthecybers 3y agoInteresting assumptions. In our case you are incorrect. We really don’t ‘spend a lot more’ on anything. Our house was purchased in 2020 under what the bank would fund us for. We are already priced out of our own neighborhood. We have one car paid off and another will be paid off this fall. Our last real vacation was in 2018 and we don’t have kids or pricey hobbies. However we have observed the cost of everyday goods to be growing more expensive every day.
- decremental 3y ago[dead]
- TuringNYC 3y agoI feel blessed to work in Tech, where -- however bad the economy is -- most of us dont face absolute deprivation as those in some other industries. That said, basic expectations of things growing up are just unreachable for many. My parents lived much more comfortable lives than I do. My grandparents even more so. Recall how food inflation was a major suspected cause of the Arab Spring (https://www.pbs.org/newshour/world/world-july-dec11-food_09-07 https://www.pbs.org/newshour/world/world-july-dec11-food_09-...). US leaders should be careful. People get upset when they have nothing to feed their children. I hope we solve these problems with sensible fiscal and monetary policy.
- rayiner 3y ago> That said, basic expectations of things growing up are just unreachable for many. My parents lived much more comfortable lives than I do. My grandparents even more so. My wife’s grandma got married as a teenager to a trucker passing by because her family couldn’t support all their kids. This was not unusual in that generation.
- TuringNYC 3y agoFirstly I'm sorry to hear about your family's situation. I certainly dont mean to imply everything was rosy. I will compare very roughly and anecdotally across generations. I'm an Engineer (CS). So was my father, though he ended up doing accounting. So was my grandfather (civil.) My grandfather owned a home by 23 on his engineering salary. My father owned a comfortable home by 35 on his salary. The salary:homeprice ratio was almost 1.5:1 My salary:homeprice ratio for the same exact house as my father is 4:1. Arguably, i'm better educated than my father and grandfather, and have much better credentials. Im not trying to be ungrateful for what has been given to me, but the ratios seem completely off.
- rayiner 3y agoYou’re talking about perceived downward mobility within a relatively elite segment of society. I recognize your original comment was about your grandparents, but it’s important to recognize that on average our generation is far better off than our grandparents. Two generations ago, the disparity between the north and south was comparable to the disparity that currently exists between the US and Panama.
- supernova87a 3y agoI think a big problem, especially with companies, is that as soon as any cost of some input touches a new price level, that price now starts to get baked into the planning. Even if it was only for a very short blip, and even if the actual average costs later go down. It gets very sticky, but only in the up direction. Have you talked to any kind of building work contractor, insurance company, etc. lately? They've all jacked up their prices just because their supply prices touched a certain level and now they have to plan for it. And to be sure, some of them are using the cover of inflation to test how willing people are to pay more. Inflation really is a vicious cycle. And I don't think we've in recent memory seen prices actually decrease after an inflationary cycle. Do things pegged with CPI even allow for negative inflation?
- nine_zeros 3y agoThis is accurate. Once the unit price is calculated with the temporarily higher input price, they are not going to reduce the unit price for as long as possible, even if input prices go down. And what's worse? The FED does not want negative CPI. They want slowly rising CPI. A negative CPI is deflation, something they want to absolutely avoid. They don't want prices to go down. They only want them to rise up slower. Which leads to us humans always stuck on the hedonic treadmill. If one is relying on wages, one is absolutely fcuked in this system. The only way to keep up is to keep switching jobs to a higher pay.
- jliptzin 3y agoIt’s a pretty easy problem to solve, just have wages increase automatically on an annual basis in line with changes to the CPI. That would be in addition to any raises due to good job performance or a promotion. Or even on a monthly basis during periods of high inflation. Obviously, companies avoid this simple solution because they make money on the delay between raising the price of the product they sell and when they actually start raising their worker salaries. Ideally, they want you to keep your head down and never ask for a raise.
- nine_zeros 3y ago
- Madmallard 3y agoBeing on disability SSDI adjusts for inflation. However, if you get coverage from multiple providers, they may not all do this. In my case, half of my disability coverage was provided by a private insurer, who does not adjust for inflation. So I just lost $354 over the last two years per month. Pretty toxic cancerous environment for the disabled.
- mjevans 3y ago(this) Inflation is driven by rent seeking. If there were enough housing for everyone to live reasonably close to the jobs they can work there would at least be a check/balance against that destructive economic activity. However be it 'neighborhood character preservation', review processes biased towards failure rather than with clear goals and approval if met, or tax structures that fail to encourage socially beneficial outcomes; too many factors are against new generations (generally) building wealth, including that of social communities where they have stable career paths.
- kleiba 3y agoIt is my understanding that the US has been able to control the inflation rate relatively well. Our fiscal policy has brought it down relatively quickly as compared to other nations. Is that not correct?
- DougHolland 3y agoIt is paranoid of me to envision conversations planning this, a conspiracy amongst corporations? I don't remember ever seeing prices rise so steadily, so quickly (and I am old).
- WalterBright 3y agoTake a look at any graph of deficit spending, and compare it to inflation. You'll see what the problem is.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- predictabl3 3y agoYes, it's a conspiracy called "unchecked late-stage capitalism", and "feckless anti-monopoly policies". You don't need much of a conspiracy when virtually every industry, everywhere has gone through significant consolidation. It's even a problem for the military. Private contractors are gouging the US Government to the tune of *billions* and we can't do anything about it because critical parts, once produced by a few competitors, now have only one producer.
- Auracle 3y agoI'm not a high paid tech worker like the rest of you, but I've never really considered the price of individual grocery items as a factor in buying it. If something was on sale - great, and I'd prefer that over other options. Otherwise I'd just fling stuff in my cart. Now? I regularly don't buy things after seeing their price. It's not that we can't afford it, but I simply can't stomach the price. I'm not paying $11 for two shrinkflationed bags of "regular size" Doritos apparently on sale. An empty calorie snack like that just isn't worth it for me, and it pisses me off that they'll charge that much for what's basically a small amount of corn...and that enough people still buy it to maintain that price. Eventually I may adjust to these new prices, but in the interim I'm regularly shocked at what things cost and it's causing me to spend less.
- Fraterkes 3y agoJust out of curiosity, what are people here spending on groceries weekly? (Around 40, 50 for just me I think)
- zer8k 3y ago$150 or so. That's my fault because I like to eat good food. However, even then, my bill has gone up about 30% or so. I love coke zero and I have had to cut back, probably for the better, because a 12 pack has not moved off the $10 mark for a year now. The real killer has been gas, electric, water, property tax, etc.
- pb7 3y agoCan you give a quick summary of what meals you eat for $50/week?
- indymike 3y agoFamily of seven. We've largely stopped eating at restaurants and started buying store brand instead of name brand at the grocery store.
- karaterobot 3y agoInflation has not been that high over the last two years. That $709/month is due to profit taking, I imagine. Inflation in the U.S. has not exceeded single digits in 40 years, and has been <3% for about a year (slightly over 3% last month).
- dopylitty 3y agoIt's always seemed extremely disingenuous to lump all price rises into a single number called "inflation". It makes "inflation" seem like some kind of magic force that just happens and can only be solved by the equally magic application of something like fiscal policy. But it's not magic, price rises are the result of active and deliberate choices by companies and countries which could be solved with actual policy changes. Housing prices go up because there is a shortage of housing and the housing that exists is being used as investments. The solutions could be to make it easy to build more housing and also to make policy changes to encourage other ways to save money. Energy prices go up because we've wedded ourselves to fossil fuels that are controlled by very few players who can set whatever prices they want. The solutions might be to diversify energy sources and reduce energy consumption. Food prices go up because of energy prices and because food companies are gouging for profits. The solutions might be to reduce the dependence on fossil fuels for food production and to not allow food production to be a for profit enterprise. The prices of other goods went up because there was a global pandemic that disrupted supply chains around the world. The solution might be to build a more resilient system for providing goods rather than one that's cut to the bones to increase profits. There are real solutions to the problems that cause price rises but as long as we treat "inflation" as some sort of magic force in the universe those solutions will continue to be ignored in favor of magical thinking and political arguing.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pessimizer 3y agoWTF is "typical" supposed to mean? It's in the source, too, which is a tweet. [edit: and apparently a personal email to CNN?] Teacherman @jboyd33488892 Replying to @Markzandi Is that extra $700/month a mean or a median? Also in the replies from @David_Charts: Hourly wage gains have exceeded inflation vs. pre-pandemic: +20.5% wages of prod & non-supv workers +17.4% inflation (CPI-All) +15.5% inflation (CPI-Core, ex food & energy) Yes, workers have more purchasing power now than in the vaunted 2019 economy. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?graph_id=959796 https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?graph_id=959796
- WalterBright 3y agoIt turns out that printing money to fund deficit spending isn't free at all.
- Dig1t 3y agoIt seems like this might be a new form of taxation. Instead of taxing people directly, which requires voter approval and creates bad press for the politicians involved, why not instead just create the money you need and pass the costs down to taxpayers in the form of inflation? It is the worst kind of tax though because it affects the poorest people the most, since rich people have their assets that rise with inflation.
- lotsofpulp 3y agoDevaluing currency (and promised benefits) is not a new form of taxation. My grandparents used to tell me the the things they bought with eights of a penny. Social Security retirement age and benefit formula “bend points” have been repeatedly altered to reduce the value of the benefit.
- missizii 3y agoHow are families coping? In my friend group: - Homeschooling at-home parents take on a side hustle (teach piano lessons, mobile notary, dog sitting) - Buy a side of beef - Buy beans in bulk (25# boxes) - Grow a small garden for salad greens and herbs - Don’t eat out - No extracurriculars that cost money - Use the library whenever possible - Vacations are now camping with 2nd hand gear - In general, buy used. As a result, prices in 2nd hand market are also inflated.
- sharts 3y agoIt’s not hard to end inflation. FDR did it overnight. But some solutions are simply too taboo because they would disproportionately affect the wealthy. Guess we get what we vote for in the end