4 ms·
We're All Wrong About AI
- version_five 3y agoI agree that we haven't found a "killer app" or really figured out what it's good at. We may not. Look at blockchain, there was lots of promise and it's actually pointless. AI wont be like that because you can do stuff with it, but maybe it wont coaless into something really game changing the way computers have. Maybe it will. Anyway, what's interesting to me it getting to the core of what it really is good at. You can do a lot of things with AI but it's a poor tool for a lot of them. So what fundamentally is it uniquely helping with? There was the book "prediction machines" that proposed AI is reducing the cost of prediction. It's now outdated and useless but not before it wasted countless businesses time looking for predictions they could automate. At least it was an interesting framing. I haven't really seen one since.
- koheripbal 3y agoIt has already surpassed blockchain in utility as evidenced by many people paying $20 / mon for the service. I use it daily.
- ChatGTP 3y agoPotentially the most substanceless article I've read this year.
- invalidname 3y agoReally? I found it rather basic and substance free. It doesn't bring anything new to the table. Yes, we're at the start and new use cases will come along. So?
- throwaway3618 3y agoThink you're agreeing without realising
- invalidname 3y agoDamn... I read "substanceless" and "substantial" ugh.
- vouaobrasil 3y ago> Anyone who makes the argument that AI’s can never be creative, and that you need humans for that, probably understands neither human creativity nor the working of the current generation of AI. I agree with this, and this is why AI should be stopped. Intelligence as an emergent phenomenon is likely what happens in us. Why can't it happen with AI? In that case, AI has a good chance of being dangerous and caring even less about our biosphere than we do. And even so, we are simply not prepared for the consequences of AI, and by replacing our human connections with AI, everyone will become more disconnected than they already are because of technology. Just imagine if AI could have the capability of being creative, or at least simulating a good approximation of how we are creative. It will be an infinite low-cost resource of creativity, but paradoxically it will cause creativity to lose all meaning. That is because creativity does not operate in a vacuum. It expresses not just aesthetic value but a communicative value between humans and adding AI to the mix will only make the world worse and less comprehensible. (If you think this is hype, just look at how incomprehensible the world already is with technology. Most humans cannot fathom all the information out there, and for those of us that try, it leads to neuroses and psychological disorders.)
- andrepd 3y agoIntelligence is an emergent property of matter. A bag of rice is matter. Therefore, intelligence can arise by stirring a bag of rice. See the problem with this statement? There is as of yet no hard reason to believe AGI can arise from token-predicting neural networks.
- vouaobrasil 3y agoEven if AGI cannot arise from neural networks, it is irrelevant. What is relevant is that AI as it is (even if stupid as a rock) can still cause significant damage due to its current and likely future capabilities.
- bootsmann 3y agoI’d say that we should consider that this technology is currently saving lives (by aiding drug discovery for instance) and banning it due to potential, unproven unknown future capabilities is much more harmful.
- nathan_compton 3y agoAbsolutely vacuous.
- t43562 3y agoI feel very tired of the whole LLM discussion now. It's going to put everyone out of work or it's going to be a helpful tool. I find it currently lacking somehow but what's the point of saying that to one of the enthusiasts? I feel that no matter how much value it has, there will never be more hype about it than at the beginning.
- te_chris 3y agoIt’s the religiosity. It’s incredibly tedious.
- mnd999 3y agoYou’re not alone. Every time I’ve tried a GPTx it’s come out with utter rubbish and proven to be a total waste of time. But any mention of AI raises a crap ton of VC money so gotta keep that sweet sweet founder bandwagon rolling.
- corethree 3y agoThis is illogical. The popularity surrounding gptx stems from the fact it produces great output for many people. That is the only rational explanation for why it's popular. One reason that it may not produce good output for you is that you may just be a really smart person. The answers it gives you just seem too stupid to you because you're just so incredibly intelligent that any response it gives seems useless. Other people like me who aren't as smart as you feel the output is at times relevant and at other times irrelevant. It's not a total waste of time to most of the population as we aren't as smart as you. In fact smart people like you including the preeminent AI guy Geoffrey Hinton who repopularized AI in the last decade thinks LLMs are trivial in the same way you think of it. Or maybe I'm wrong here. Maybe it's not so clear cut as "total waste of time."
- mdp2021 3y ago> feel the output is We have given you books, we have given you masterpieces...
- yellow_lead 3y agoAI's ability of transforming people with no actual domain knowledge into armchair experts is truly fascinating.
- adhesive_wombat 3y agoEvery big media "story nexus" generates a large population of apparently completely self-assured experts in whatever it happens to be. Everyone suddenly appears, due to self-selection of those who want to be visible, to have very strong opinions on virology/public health, climate science, energy generation, geopolitics, electoral politics, constitutional politics (not only the US document, to be clear), military strategy, whatever that month's "big story" happens to be. If you don't have an opinion on the story du jour, you don't get airtime, clicks, ad impressions, a buff to a CV, whatever. If you want the airtime, then, you must have an opinion, and it must be novel or contrarian enough to be noticeable. This is nothing new, but it used to be mostly confined to boors at dinner parties, and perhaps the letters page. There were only a few opinion columnists. Now anyone can monetise an opinion. AI is just another tedious episode, but the show will never end.
- mdp2021 3y agoWhat you are witnessing and the article suggests is probably more a homeopathic ("poison to cure poison") phenomenon of laypeople correcting laypeople. But Arnold Kling is not exactly "layman": > Arnold Kling earned his Ph.D in economics from MIT in 1980. He worked at the Fed and later at Freddie Mac. In 1994, he started one of the first businesses on the Web, selling it in 1999 Maybe he never coded an ANN engine, he is probably following the evolution with interest from his own perspective. And the conclusion is the opposite of "«armchair expert[ise]»" - if anything, it is too underdeveloped: > I do not believe that we know enough to predict with any accuracy which uses of AI will take off and which will prove to be either too trivial (recipe tracking) or too elusive (maybe it’s too much to hope that AI will allow children to escape from school-prison). The best way to find out is to work with it, not to dismiss it
- laborcontract 3y agoDo you find it at all ironic that you wrote this comment likely without having read the article? Sorry but your brand "I'm going to boldly make a statement without reading the article or addressing any of the content in the article" is polluting this site and it's tiresome to have to wade through it on HN. Kling has written publicly for over a decade and a half. What assertions do you disagree with? AI may have given people the ability to be armchair experts about anything but armchair critics are a tale older than time.
- te_chris 3y agoWho is this person and why did I read some of that?
- croes 3y ago>All it takes for an AI to be creative is for it to try to add vectors that have never been added before. >For an AI to be creative, it will have to be able to extract from many possible vector combinations those rare syntheses that are worth retaining. Sounds like a summer project.
- mdp2021 3y ago> Sounds like a summer project Yes, the Summer of '56.