12 ms·
There's a lot of hate any Firefox and the "blessed apps." But come on, chrome and Safari don't sorry add-ons at all! I know there are other apps that support a
by godelski 3y ago
There's a lot of hate any Firefox and the "blessed apps." But come on, chrome and Safari don't sorry add-ons at all!
I know there are other apps that support add-ons but the fact is that Firefox is __the only__ "mainstream" browser that does this (quotes because it's 0.25% in the US, as the 4th most popular, behind Samsung fucking Internet).
It's popular to hate on Firefox, but this is the nerdiest of nerd issues and if we're being honest, all this has accomplished in the last decade is a decrease in market share and keeping Safari and (more so) Chrome dictate the Internet and user experience. Firefox being so low puts no pressure on Chrome to add add-ons. Firefox being so low just means Chrome can continue pushing the ad first Internet.
Yeah, it's fun to complain, but which do you hate more? That Firefox only provides 80-90% of what you want (when major competitors provide __0%__), or Google dictating the Internet (like AMP)? Complain, but maybe tone it down a bit. This is not the holy war you want.
- drozycki 3y agoiOS Safari has supported declarative content blocking extensions since iOS 9 in 2015 and a full extension API since iOS 15 released about two years ago.
- cubefox 3y agoDoesn't count.
- drozycki 3y agoDoes too.
- tbossanova 3y agoOh I'm sorry, is this a five minute argument, or the full half hour?
- boredumb 3y agoI laughed entirely way too hard at this for it being 6am
- the_gipsy 3y agoDeclarative blocking is the weakest, it barely removes the simplest ads. uBlock doesn't exist for iOS because it is made impossible by apple, their extension API is not a "full" API.
- drozycki 3y agoI haven’t seen ads on mobile Safari for as long as I can remember. Whether you choose to believe that is up to you. Can you point to an example where an extension like AdGuard would let an ad slip through? Precompiled declarative blocking is more performant and power efficient than running a content script in a JS VM at page load, which matters on a CPU and battery constrained device. I was responding to a comment claiming that mobile Safari doesn’t support add-ons. Which is simply not true!
- _thisdot 3y agoIf anything, my problem is sometimes it’s too strong. Searching for a product on Google and clicking the Amazon links don’t work
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- eipi10_hn 3y agoIt's not only the ads slipping through. Safari is so lacking in terms of API that for many sites with anti-adblock, the only way to bypass those are allowing tracking / ads connections. Check the `@@` filters for `ios` here: https://raw.githubusercontent.com/AdguardTeam/AdguardFilters/master/BaseFilter/sections/antiadblock.txt https://raw.githubusercontent.com/AdguardTeam/AdguardFilters... Adguard's default settings already do not include many tracking connections blocking filters, due to the lack of Safari's API for redirecting to neutered sources which could easily lead to breakages / anti-adblock. In terms of privacy-protection, Safari is one of the worst.
- the_gipsy 3y ago> Can you point to an example where an extension like AdGuard would let an ad slip through? Yes, see Twitter. I have AdGuard installed on iOS and I do see ads. I do not see them when opening on Firefox desktop with uBlock Origin. If I disable uBlock then I do see them like on Safari. As I said, precompiled declarative blocking only works for the weakest of blatant ads. Of course it's "more performant and power efficient" because it only runs on the bare HTTP requests. That's not what I want. > I was responding to a comment claiming that mobile Safari doesn’t support add-ons. Which is simply not true! Fair enough. But personally I don't count Safari's extensions as real extension, just like I don't count Firefox' previous approach of a handful of "blessed" extensions for Android as real extensions.
- Dalewyn 3y ago>It's popular to hate on Firefox, I don't hate Firefox, I hate Mozilla.
- autoexec 3y agoI'll always love Mozilla, or at least some fictional idealized version of it, so I'm stuck being increasingly disappointed in Mozilla while holding out for the times they do something right. Giving add-on support back to firefox users is a good thing so here's hoping it won't be done in a way that disappoints me. I hope they bring back about:config next.
- godelski 3y ago> or at least some fictional idealized version of it This might be the most real comment here. All our perceptions are some fictionalized version of <insert company/product here>. Doesn't matter if it is Apple, Google, Mozilla, or whatever. Our judgements are based on narrow experiences and highly affected by the PR generated around them.
- Nextgrid 3y ago> Our judgements are based on narrow experiences and highly affected by the PR generated around them. When it comes to Firefox, a lot of users' judgements might be from actual experience using the product back in its heyday (before it was lobotomized), as opposed to PR? However, bringing PR into the discussion is a good point. Mozilla turned from a browser/web tools maker into a PR agency with unclear profit motives that happens to make an increasingly-lackluster browser.
- kibwen 3y ago> I hope they bring back about:config next. I've never had to use about:config on mobile before, but I just checked and it works fine for me.
- cpeterso 3y agoWhich settings would you like to change in about:config?
- Nextgrid 3y agoThe other browsers you mention though don’t pretend to be on your side and don’t use every possible opportunity to tell you about it. Firefox on the other hand, despite having a lot of user-hostile functionality and design decisions, will constantly nag you pretending to be on your side, misleading you into a false sense of security.
- cycomanic 3y agoThose arguments always remind me of this comic: https://www.cjr.org/wp-content/themes/cjr2017/images-body/NY1.jpg https://www.cjr.org/wp-content/themes/cjr2017/images-body/NY...
- veave 3y agoMost of Firefox's publicity is based on the fact that they are "on your side". That means that they are held to a much higher standard. Pretending to be on the side of the user and then screwing users up over and over seems like wanting their cake and eating it too? It's funny because, you know, I expect chrome to screw me over while I expect firefox not to screw me over but chrome has screwed me over fewer times than firefox over the years.
- shinryuu 3y agoPerhaps that is because they screw you over in secret? Whenever Firefox makes a mistake it gets very publicised, but whenever chrome does it it's just business as normal so no one really publicises it.
- Nextgrid 3y agoAs far as I know Chrome doesn't use every possible opportunity to nag you about self-righteous BS on how they're better and more private than everyone else? It's one thing to make a mistake or do user-hostile decisions inline with your business model. But it's another to loudly shout about how "good" you are (and everyone else is bad) and then do the exact same thing. Same reason why a policeman or some law-enforcement figure gets more outrage for committing a crime than a normal citizen.
- mrguyorama 3y agoAre you pretending that chrome doesn't advertise? Every single fucking day for a decade now, google.com told me to install chrome, and would even render "pop up" dialogs to that effect on google properties!! What are you all smoking?
- Nextgrid 3y agoAn ad telling you to install Chrome is one thing. I don't believe any Google nor Chrome ad had self-righteous BS about privacy, "improving the web" or similar like Mozilla constantly does. Also, ads on websites are one thing. Ads/nags within the browser itself (which I'm already using) are another. I'm pretty sure Google doesn't bother advertising Chrome to users who already use Chrome.
- batrat 3y ago>behind Samsung fucking Internet Supports adblock (addons) and shows tabs on top just like desktop so it's easy to switch, dark mode for all websites, etc. It's relative fast and lots of options. I use FF with no addons for some websites.
- godelski 3y ago> shows tabs on top just like desktop Honestly, I hate this on the phone. But I get it. I had that initial cognitive disruption when FF did this. But once that was gone (idk, like 30 minutes?) I realized it was a lot nicer because I could actually reach the address bar and tabs without needing to stretch my hand. Or if I have a bigger phone, use a second hand. I mean there's a reason navigation buttons on the phones (for the OS) were always on the bottom. It's just easier. But yeah, you gotta get through the initial cognitive disruption. But you know what? I also got used to when Android switched the time from being at the top right to top left and I'm willing to bet most people did too and don't really think about it anymore. As for the dark mode... well you got a point there. Though dark reader was one of the first add-ons on FF mobile. Though as much as I love dark mode, some websites are just unreadable with it and it drives me nuts. Specifically anything with a transparent background...
- solarkraft 3y agoI don't mind cognitive disruption at all, as long as I'm getting something better. While the mobile switcher scales much better (how many can the desktop tab bar hold, like ten?), it can take a while to open and sometimes loses your scroll position or puts a tab in a random place in the list. The previews are also so large that it's hard to get an overview. This can make it much slower to switch tabs than on desktop.
- ZeroGravitas 3y agoNote you can slide over the URL bar to switch tabs left or right.
- mrguyorama 3y ago
- matheusmoreira 3y agoI see people hating on Mozilla, not Firefox. They absolutely deserve it too. They got one billion dollars and they're reducing software development spending to focus on agenda pushing instead. One would think they'd try to fix the web by making Firefox the dominant browser.
- flutas 3y agoHalf that billion has probably been spent on interviews that they randomly decide they no longer are hiring for right before they take the entire company to Hawaii. I'm not salty about the 6+ interviews or anything.
- nfriedly 3y agoHa, you made it to 6, that's impressive! I only got scheduled for one interview, the interviewer was a no-show, and they never answered any of my attempts to reschedule or even find out what happened.
- flutas 3y agoI honestly don't remember the total number, but it was up there. I know they said it was the final interview before an offer would be given. The manager of the team I would have been going on (FF for Android funnily enough) knew of some of (and said he actively used) my past work which was probably a leg up. In the end they were far from the worst interviewers (hello Hopper for that title*), but it soured me against Mozilla after putting that much time and effort into it and just getting a "we're no longer hiring for this position" form email. *: Never paying out their tech screening "payment", to rejecting me over an answer I never gave (we didn't like when you said "XYZ").
- stevehawk 3y agowhat the eff do they need more than 6 interviews for
- deprecative 3y ago
- synergy20 3y agowhy hate firefox? I use it rarely on linux desktop but I use it a LOT on my android as it eliminates so many ads for me, from websites to youtube, it worked well.
- captainmuon 3y agoI think Firefox's addon policy is one of the reasons they lost market share. Moving from oldscool extensions to webextensions they lost their unique selling point. Firefox was the only browser that you could really theme. It's adblock existed earlier and was better than others (and is soon again due to Manifest v3?). Especially for non-tech-savvy people, who don't know what a browser is, if they need a certain feature then you just replaced their chrome with firefox + this feature and they were happy. But if Firefox is just another Chrome clone, then it is neccessarily an inferior one.
- dawidpotocki 3y agoFF has had better adblocking capabilities than Chromium before Manifest v3 was announced https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock/wiki/uBlock-Origin-works-best-on-Firefox https://github.com/gorhill/uBlock/wiki/uBlock-Origin-works-b...
- mgbmtl 3y agoFirefox lost power-users because 1) performance was bad 2) Chrome does very aggressive marketing and various Google sites break randomly on Firefox. And performance was very often bad because of extensions. Perhaps anecdotal, but whenever I ask a Chrome user why they don't use Firefox, that's the main two reasons they cite. I do ask often though. What "certain features" do non-tech-savvy people need? I know lots of devs who rarely even know or care which browser they're using. Not to mention non-tech-savvy people..
- Firmwarrior 3y agoFirefox randomly broke all my extensions and workflows one day in the pursuit of some obscure technical goal, via forced update that I couldn’t roll back. I asked about it, and they banned me from their subreddit, so I deleted that stupid browser and never went back
- donkeybeer 3y agoAnd their constant user hostile redesigns. Suddenly tabs are floating separately from their pages. And now if a page is playing audio you can no longer see its favicon, etc Speaking of mobile firefox where did Save as PDF vanish and why? and so on edit: I have been told in a reply the save pdf feature still exists but has been changed for no reason to a different location in the menu
- nfriedly 3y agoI've complained a lot about the crippled add-on support on Android and other poor decisions Mozilla has made, BUT I also donate monthly and encourage everyone who asks to just use Firefox. So I think that on the balance, I'm a supporter. This decision, to finally re-enable add-ons on Android, is a good one and I applaud Mozilla for making it!
- causi 3y agoall this has accomplished in the last decade is a decrease in market share You are confusing cause and effect. We've been saying the same things as we watch Mozilla slowly strangle Firefox to death for a decade. That said, this is great news. I'm very much looking forward to being able to capture embedded videos on Android and maybe even get back my precious DownThemAll.
- mrguyorama 3y agoHere's the thing: Mozilla could literally be shipping 2012 firefox, and I wouldn't give a fuck, and I would still use it. Why? Because they don't spend their days trying to make the internet a more ad infested dumpster fire and prevent me from blocking ads. Google is actively doing that every single fucking day with thousands of people working towards this goal, with Chrome being an essential tool in that process, as whatever chrome does, everyone else will be forced to do. Why the fuck would you enable that, even for a little "convenience"?
- FeepingCreature 3y ago> Mozilla could literally be shipping 2012 firefox That's called "Waterfox Classic".
- godelski 3y ago> We've been saying the same things as we watch Mozilla slowly strangle Firefox to death for a decade. Absolutely not true. I still hear people talking about FF as if it is pre-quantum. They complain about how slow it is. But quantum made it faster and more secure overnight. There's still a lot of people who are complaining and have just never tried it after the big issues were fixed. Or they try it, there's a small cognitive dissonance because checks notes "the interface is horrible", and so they call it slow attempting to justify why they dislike it rather than making an actual criticism or giving it a fair shot. Come on, the UI is almost identical across the board with browsers. And we're doing this for what... to give Google more power over the internet? I'm sorry, I think it is you who are confusing cause and effect. You participated in the monopolization of browsers and are suffering the consequences of it. Because of a little convenience. The path to hell is indeed paved with "good intentions." Little steps is all it takes to make progress over decades. Unless you can tell me there's a huge major problem with FF that outweighs the ad focused internet, then you have it backwards.
- shultays 3y agoall this has accomplished in the last decade is a decrease in market share A crazy idea but maybe Mozilla also have some fault on that
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jauntywundrkind 3y agoIt feels like Chrome's original protest was that extensions would be too slow. But phones are so much faster now! And with MV3 chrome claims they have prevented a variety of ways extensions might be slow. I don't know how Chrome can keep justifying this old old choice.
- KingOfCoders 3y agoWith Web DRM this is over. Firefox dropped the ball and would only be useful with a high market share. As soon as there is Web DRM in most major sites, Google controls what browser is allowed to view a website and Firefox is out, Chrome will drop ad blockers. This is the long con. (~30y Mosaic/Netscape/FF user)
- robertoandred 3y agoHaha what? Since when does Safari not offer add-ons?
- paulryanrogers 3y agoOn mobile? From 2007-2022, and it's still not as fully featured as FF.
- robertoandred 3y agoAnything is more fully featured than Firefox, since it didn’t have them at all.
- paulryanrogers 3y agoDid you mean "Safari"? Because it was Firefox that had them the whole time, albeit significantly fewer after Quantum update.
- robertoandred 3y agoExcept the story you're commenting on is Firefox getting them soon.
- paulryanrogers 3y agoFirefox is restoring access to more add-ons. Most were actually available to folks running Nightly or Fennec, yet with no guarantees all APIs had been ported. Regardless, my point stands, Safari mobile lacked extensions for over a decade while Firefox was offering some on Android. Can iOS browsers even offer meaningful extensions so long as Apple forces them to be a skin on Webkit? (With Safari getting privileged access of course.)
- donatj 3y ago> Safari don't sorry(sic) add-ons at all iOS and iPadOS Safari has supported extensions for a while now. https://support.apple.com/guide/ipad/get-extensions-ipada7ca2a18/ipados https://support.apple.com/guide/ipad/get-extensions-ipada7ca... https://support.apple.com/guide/iphone/get-extensions-iphab0432bf6/ios https://support.apple.com/guide/iphone/get-extensions-iphab0...
- paulryanrogers 3y agoOnly 11 years after the competition! Courage
- lapcat 3y agoThis comment makes no sense. The competition is mobile Chrome, which has no extensions, and mobile Firefox, which has only a limited number of chosen extensions. Literally from the linked article: > For the past few years Firefox for Android officially supported a small subset of extensions If you're referring to desktop, on the other hand, Safari has had extensions since 2010.
- paulryanrogers 3y agoFirefox Android had broader extension support before it was temporarily restricted, in response to an architecture shift. Still, there has been an addon capability for many years before Safari mobile saw any.
- lapcat 3y ago3 years is "temporarily"? https://blog.mozilla.org/en/products/firefox/introducing-a-new-firefox-for-android-experience/ https://blog.mozilla.org/en/products/firefox/introducing-a-n... And again, mobile Chrome, a much bigger competitor than Firefox, has no extensions.
- paulryanrogers 3y ago
- barbariangrunge 3y agoMy wishlist for firefox on ios: just make the important addons built-in: ublock origin, facebook containers, cookie auto-delete... really, that's about it.
- dzek69 3y agoI'd love 50% of the world use Firefox. I personally can't - had some visual issues with it (each time I tried it, on different machines - sounds like unbeliveable bad luck, eh), I just don't like it, all the small annoyances just piles up. I'm sad that Vivaldi uses Chromium under the hood, but that the only thing that has UX I need (and I don't even care about its slow UI and random crashes every few days). But I'm always happy to hear someone uses Firefox.
- CatWChainsaw 3y ago(Samsung Internet isn't too bad for another forum website I use. At least it has the option to do tabs in lists as opposed to the unwieldy grids Chrome forced on users, deprecating tab lists...)
- scoliosis 3y agoSamsung Internet is actually a shockingly good browser for Android, with native adblocking and dark mode for websites (that isn't atrociously slow like Dark Reader on FF)