8 ms·
Perils of not being attractive or athletic in middle school
- mensetmanusman 3y agoI’m glad I was an outcast in middle school in hindsight. It prepared me for being okay with some social isolation required in college to study like crazy and end up with a great career.
- skavi 3y agoI assume you mean such social isolation was required for you? I know a fair number of people who were able to study like crazy while maintaining a rich social life.
- fnordpiglet 3y agoAgreed but I wish I hadn’t suffered. I plan to do something like take my daughter out of school and home school for those years or live internationally. She is both attractive and athletic, but I wouldn’t want her to be on the other side of the equation either.
- orev 3y agoI understand the desire to protect your children from having bad experiences, but isn’t that exactly the time when she would need to start learning how to handle these things on her own? If you isolate her, how’s she going to learn how to handle the politics of high school, college, and adult work life? At what point do you decide to throw her back into the pool, that’s now full of peers who already had the chance to figure out how to navigate the social intricacies? It seems like providing open communication and support for her struggles would be more constructive for her future.
- fnordpiglet 3y agoI didn’t find middle school behavior to be particularly material for further social interactions in life. High school, college, yes. Pubescent bullies and cliques? Not so much. Puberty is hard enough without swimming in a sea of it. My experience was middle school was nothing like high school, college, or life afterwards. It was like some weird collective psychotic break for a few years then everyone went back to being normal. Sounds like a great time to explore the world and gain social skills that way.
- porkbeer 3y agoMy parents did this to me. Please don't. It was a huge burden on my social development at a critical time. The trials and tribulations of school suck, but are needed challenges in a teens life.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Waterluvian 3y agoIt’s a bit of a false dichotomy. Perhaps it can be a silver lining, though.
- hackernewds 3y agoWhat is the opportunity cost though? Guess we'll never know without a control group, but possible to do both
- Aurornis 3y ago> It prepared me for being okay with some social isolation required in college to study like crazy and end up with a great career. I’m glad it worked out for you, but social isolation isn’t the only way to study and land a good career. Even my friends at notoriously difficult universities had good social lives as long as they had a modicum of time management.
- xwdv 3y agoI got the shit beaten out of me nearly everyday in middle school, and it contributed to my bitter cynicism about the world and justice in general, and shattered my ethical compass.
- bentcorner 3y agoI didn't get beat up but have been hit and was bullied a lot. Middle school was a terrible experience and I wouldn't wish it on anyone. Luckily it gets better but I wish there was a different way. Educating our children should not be so haphazard.
- jethronethro 3y agoSomewhat similar to what happened to me. Not everyday, but regularly. Until I'd had enough and beat down the jock who happened to take some issue or the other with me that day. After that, no one messed with me. Which is good, because I didn't want to get into another fight. That sort of thing should never have to happen. Sadly, I'm sure it's worse nowadays.
- xwdv 3y agoI never dared to fight back because I was weak and I knew it wasn’t going to be enough to just win a fight anyway. If I fought back they’d beat me up even harder, I really felt like I was going to die in middle school, and no one would care. I often fantasized about just killing off all the bullies, and finally be at peace forever.
- MattPalmer1086 3y agoI had a similar experience for a few years, although not as bad as you had it I think. I would also regularly fantasise about killing the bullies. My tormenters eased off as we got older though. Some of the worst had been expelled by then for assaulting teachers. I was still mostly a social outcast but acquired a weird kind of nerd cool.
- geebee 3y ago
- lostgame 3y agoI wasn’t attractive or athletic in high school, I spent all my time obsessed with programming, from basically grade 5 onwards; it didn’t make me popular and I not only didn’t fit in but was regularly bullied. It’s turned into a fantastic career and the resilience I gained from being bullied made me a stronger and kinder person growing up. Wouldn’t wish it on anyone, but long term I would say it personally did not harm me.
- victor106 3y ago> and the resilience I gained from being bullied made me a stronger and kinder person growing up. How do you teach resilience to a kid? What are some things you can do from they are toddlers to teach them?
- 0xcde4c3db 3y agoSeveral fairly prominent psychologists have spent the past couple decades trying to figure out the answer to this question, but as far as I've read there is nothing close to a proven method or validated theory yet.
- the_only_law 3y agoMiddle school was weird for me. The first day it was like a switch flipped. I went from being a quiet, weird kid, to being very aggressive and borderline psychotic. I ended up getting in a good bit of trouble and narrowly dodged some bullets that I probably deserved to be hit by. I was always respectful to teachers and staff though, which led to a weird dynamic where I could squeeze out of trouble where other kids couldn’t. I remember getting in a fight towards the end of sixth grade and getting off Scott free when a coach stopped us and asked me if [other kid], who was a notable trouble maker, was messing with me. Of course this was all probably exacerbated by a turbulent home life at the time. It didn’t do much for my social standing. I guess I was bullied less, and had a bit more respect, but a lot of people really didn’t like me at the time, particularly girls. On the other hand, it was also when I developed my interest in computers and programming, which would serve me well for at least a while. Luckily by high school, I cooled down, figuring it was best just to keep my head down and graduate so I could move in with my life, but it was also pretty boring and forgettable.
- Aurornis 3y ago> Of course this was all probably exacerbated by a turbulent home life at the time. In my limited experience working with kids of this age in an educational environment: Home life was far and away the strongest correlate of behavioral problems that I anecdotally observed. It was sad watching good kids suddenly become troubled, then to eventually learn that something traumatic had happened in their home life right around the time of the change.
- brewdad 3y agoMy mom went through a lot of health problems starting when I was in 7th grade. my dad was working 28 days a month to keep the family afloat and I was the oldest kid so a lot of responsibilities fell to me. Fortunately, my advanced math teacher was also the middle school drama teacher. She got me into the drama and improv clubs and it gave me an outlet to deal with my emotions in a healthy way. I was glad I could return the favor and bring her onstage as my most influential teacher at high school graduation, especially since she was a tough teacher who most students at that age were disinclined to like.
- HeWhoLurksLate 3y agoOn the one hand, being an outcast and not having nearly any friends led me to an (eventual) strong sense of self-worth and decent street smarts. Being picked on, beat up, and bullied has definitely left some scars, and left me socially way behind the curve, but I don't think I would trade my experiences for anybody else's.
- skybrian 3y agoPaywalled but the study was done in a "large metropolitan area in Florida" and a "small community in Lithuania". It's good that they tested in two places that are far apart, but it would be interesting to see how things vary by school and over time. When does it get better or worse?
- mcpackieh 3y agoBrains vs brawn is a harmful false dichotomy perpetuated by the media which becomes a self-fulfilling prophesy when bright kids fall for it and lose interest in athletics. In truth, a healthy body and a healthy mind compliment each other and make each other stronger. Just stay away from the sports which are likely to cause traumatic brain injury, like American football. Smart nerdy kids can flourish in track & field or swim teams; co-ed sports are best for social development. Hiking and cycling are also great options for getting fit, but perhaps not as great for socializing.
- the_only_law 3y agoI’ve always wondered how true those 80s coming of age movies where there’s a stark divide, between the nerds and jocks were. In my experience, school was never such a simple dichotomy, particularly in high school. On the other hand, I’ve heard a lot of crazy stories from people who were in school at the time, so I wouldn’t be particularly shocked.
- mcpackieh 3y agoIn my school, the football and basketball teams acted like those 80s movies, and I think they were essentially playing out the roles they saw portrayed in media. But swimming and track were very supportive, with nerds and jocks getting along well and some of the best performers being both the smartest and the fittest (more than myself in both regards tbqh.) What it taught me is that people can be strong, smart and compassionate all at the same time; life isn't like an RPG where you have to spec into one at the expense of the others.
- the_only_law 3y agoFor me, middle school was a bit more stratified, but particularly later in high school, I never felt much vitriol or division across such simple categories. I was mostly cool with everyone, without ever belonging to a particular group. I learned to adapt and “code switch” among different people pretty very well, which has also carried over to adulthood. Though I do admit it’s been pretty isolating.
- snvzz 3y ago>The study included 580 middle school students who ranged in age from 10 to 13. >They also described how often they felt lonely and how often they drank alcohol to the point of intoxication during the past month. These two phrases put together shocked me. 10-13 yo drinking alcohol to the point of getting drunk? Who sold alcohol to them? Where are their parents?!
- blovescoffee 3y agoIt doesn't take that much alcohol to get a 13 year old drunk. And they likely took it from their parents, have older siblings/cousins/etc. or robbed a store. "Where are their parents?!" - not every child has great parents. Besides there are numerous ways imaginable for a teen to conceal that behavior.
- snvzz 3y agoIf I was unclear, this is culture shock to me (grew up in EU). The age at which my school peers were introduced to alcohol was in high school, 16-18 range, when everybody started going out at night. I do not remember anybody even joking about drinking alcohol before then.
- Swizec 3y agoGrew up in EU. We thought it was edgy and cool to drink alcohol around 13/14. We couldn’t acquire serious quantities so not much drunkenness happened. We’d like share a beer between 10 people and think we’re soooo drunk
- ginko 3y agoGrew up in EU as well(Austria). When around 13 we’d buy alcohol with the old “I’m getting it for my dad” excuse. (Obviously my dad needed some 4% alcoholic lemonade in the early afternoon) Cashiers didn’t really care. At least back in the 90s. Starting high school (~age 15, legal drinking age is 16) we’d go to bars to have a beer.
- 3y ago
- mtgentry 3y agoIs being interested in computers in middle school still seen as uncool, given how mainstream tech has become?
- hackernewds 3y agoAbsolutely
- noahjk 3y agoI think there's two different types of "tech", and it's cool to have stuff (apple gadgets, social media) but it's still uncool to be into computers. Apparently colleges are having problems because new students have no concept of how to use an actual computer, can't grasp how filesystems work, are used to apps just being a button on the home screen. Modern phones have obfuscated pretty much all back-end stuff save for a few switches on a settings screen.
- PrimeMcFly 3y agoFor a while it wasn't, but since smartphones computers are not used by most kids anymore, to the point employers have trouble hiring people with even basic computer skills.
- the_only_law 3y agoI was never bullied for it. In fact a lot of people thought I was some master hacker who could help them out. It was mostly novel or intriguing to the other kids I interacted with, until high school when I met other people who were interested in that stuff.
- xcdzvyn 3y agoI gained some air of notoriety with "popular" kids in secondary school after getting in some publicised computer-related shenanigans. I'd also imagine computery-type teenagers are often introverted, which doesn't help.
- mycologos 3y agoThe relevant paper appears to be behind a paywall here: https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10964-023-01835-1 https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10964-023-01835-1. The leader of group that wrote it has a pretty interesting publication history: https://psy.fau.edu/laursen-lab/publications.php https://psy.fau.edu/laursen-lab/publications.php. Some recent titles: > Adolescents with few friend alternatives are particularly susceptible to influence from friends > In defense of peer influence: The unheralded benefits of conformity > Classroom seat proximity predicts friendship formation > Off on the wrong foot: Task avoidance at the outset of primary school anticipates academic difficulties and declining likeability > Being fun: An overlooked indicator of childhood social status Uncharitably, this guy makes his money conducting studies that support common knowledge and then putting them behind paywalls. Charitably ... well, it would be easier to be charitable if I could see any of these papers.
- jprete 3y agoResearchers get nothing from the paywalls and generally would prefer that they don’t exist.
- mycologos 3y agoAs far as I can tell, Springer journals, like the Journal of Youth and Adolescence featured here, allow preprint sharing [1]. [1] https://www.springer.com/gp/open-access/preprint-sharing/16718886 https://www.springer.com/gp/open-access/preprint-sharing/167...
- jefftk 3y ago> this guy makes his money conducting studies that support common knowledge and then putting them behind paywalls The money from paywalls goes entirely to the journals; academics don't get a cut.
- felipeqq2 3y agoEven though social isolation may make someone more resilient, I don't think there's any good advantage to it. You can study better if you're not alone, and these relationships give you knowledge that'll be used in the workplace years later, when you need to manage a team. You can get proper resilience from bad relationships, not the lack thereof. And, well, the study also said that it can lead to stuff like alcohol misuse, which is not cool at all. This is mostly another consequence of social media use by kids and teenagers. Why are 14 year-olds so worried about being attractive anyway?
- the_only_law 3y ago> Why are 14 year-olds so worried about being attractive anyway? Because they’re going through puberty and are probably pretty horny?
- sanderjd 3y agoYeah I was 14 way before anyone had heard the word "instagram", and people were pretty obsessed with being attractive as a means to being able to express and experiment with budding sexuality. Social media seems to make this worse, but mostly when this stuff comes up I just think "same as it ever was...".
- poisonborz 3y agoThey shouldn't be worried, but it puts a lot of unwanted attention on them. They start to see it as a measurement and a prime metric to be judged by. I saw a lot of otherwise magnificent personalities bend because of how groups pressed them into roles.
- PhasmaFelis 3y ago> This is mostly another consequence of social media use by kids and teenagers. Why are 14 year-olds so worried about being attractive anyway? I suspect that predates social media by centuries if not millennia.
- jgalentine007 3y agoAnd now those unfortunate to be both unattractive and athletic, have quickly dwindling opportunities with the increasing cost of college and advances in AI and automation. The intelligent, introverted, artistic are ducked.
- porkbeer 3y agoOnly if they share ypur defeatist attitude. I would wager most folks on HN were 'ducked', yet we seem to be thriving. Odd.
- LeonardoTolstoy 3y agoI find it interesting that the study asked about being athletic (positive), attractive (positive), and unpopular (negative). Anecdotally the people I knew (at the time) who were drinking in middle school didn't fit into any of those boxes and actually I wouldnt have called attractive, unattractive, athletic, unathletic, popular, or unpopular. I do wonder if they had asked about a different set of three (or all six) dimensions whether the result would have changed.
- krapp 3y agoResults, published in the Journal of Youth and Adolescence , show that low attractive youth and low athletic youth became increasingly unpopular over the course of a school year, leading to subsequent increases in their loneliness and alcohol misuse. Put simply, the peer group punishes those who do not have highly valued traits such as being good-looking or being good at sports. Yeah... that's just what we used to call normal life. It was far worse before the internet. If you weren't pretty or athletic, you had to at least be funny, and by funny I mean being open to getting abused as entertainment. If you were too socially awkward or ugly or creepy though, you were just shit out of luck. Now at least no matter who you are you probably have a whole online community, subreddit, social movement and identity ready for you.
- svaha1728 3y agoTook my son to a middle school ice cream social / find your locker day today and can confirm. Lots of jocks and athletes. I grew up in the rust belt, so all the athletes I knew faded quickly after high school. Now that we live in a nice neighborhood I’m guessing these kids grow up and go into law and business? They certainly have no future in sports.
- l33t7332273 3y agoThat just makes sense for the most part I think. Generally, people who have a lot of positive social interactions generally continue to, and that leads well to success in people oriented professions.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- b20000 3y agothis will never change unless those affected work actively to change society to benefit them for example work towards replacing sports programming on TV by science and engineering programming
- latch 3y agoThis sounds like blaming video games for gun violence (especially since, at least in the summary, no such conclusion or link to television are mentioned). "Replacing" one with the other presents a false dichotomy. There's nothing wrong with enjoying sports, either as an activity to participate in or to watch.
- PhasmaFelis 3y agoYou're at least a decade late for TV to be the great corruptor of youth.
- nine_k 3y ago> suggesting that they must endure the indignities of powerlessness to remain attached to the peer group Beside other things, already said here, I'd like to add that the ability to disregard your peer group and consciously detach from it is pretty useful in further life, even though attaining this ability is painful, especially as a kid. (Disclaimer: I was both highly popular and pretty unpopular in middle school, at different schools.)
- freitzkriesler2 3y agoOn the flip side, imagine the perils of attractive or athletic in middle school IE peaking! I knew a few people whose peak was in middle or high school. Nice folks now but they yearn for their teens which is sad.
- wrp 3y ago> ...life is harder for [individuals] who are not attractive and for those who are not athletic. This has probably been the case for every society of conscious creatures in history.
- xcdzvyn 3y agoWhich, given those are traditionally desirable traits, isn't that surprising.
- hintymad 3y agoIs this American-specific culture? Athletics seem disproportionately more important in a school than academics or anything else. That's just bizarre. In the country I came from, students who work hard or are good at a subject, any subject, would earn respect, just like those who are good at sports.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ojhughes 3y agoMost other countries don’t consider extra curricular activities when applying for university but American colleges do
- lexa1979 3y agoI guess it is American-specific (I'm from Belgium, lived a year in California 25 years ago): sport is one out of hundreds of options you have to take to get a full schedule in school. Everyday is the same day, be it monday or wednesday. You get 5 hours of class - from 8am to 3pm - and they're the same everyday. I don't know where you're from, but in USA (at least where I lived a year), math, geography, biology, chemistry, physics, sport, choir,...all are options. There are only a few mandatory classes: english (obvious), economics, and I forgot the last one I had. The other hours, you go to the class you chose. So, if you're not into academics or art, you choose some sport and it takes almost half of your school schedule. And you get the same high school diploma than someone who took math and chemistry. That's how athletics becomes so important in their schools, but arts can be too, or any subject. In Belgium, our school system went for the "a brain discovers a lot of subjects" teaching style, in US it's more "a brain (or a body) nicely trained on one subject". update: tried to clarify differences between Belgium / US styles.
- lorrainefloyd 3y ago[dead]