7 ms·
The average Manhattan rent just hit a new record of $5,588 a month
- chiefalchemist 3y agoAverage without median is a recipe for misperception[1]. CNBC should know better. But if it's supposed to be clickbait then great job! [1] For example, this type of article headline feeds the belief that the little guy/gal is being priced out of the market. However, the increases could be at the upper end, which also moves the average up. In fact, in theory, the middle and bottom can fall, and the average can still go up is the upper and top increase more than that fall.
- fernandotakai 3y agobut the median ($4400) is literally right in the article.
- chiefalchemist 3y agoAnd what is in the headline? What are most people going to read and immediately draw a conclusion? A conclusion that once is in place gets more and more difficult to move (read: correct)? Journalism, real journalism, doesn't trade in such tactics.
- DarkNova6 3y agoI wish more people would understand this about averages.
- mattbrewsbytes 3y agoI guess only above average people do.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ctvo 3y ago> Average without median is a recipe for misperception > The average monthly rent in July was $5,588, up 9% over last year and marking a new record. Median rent, at $4,400 per month, also hit a new record, along with price per square foot of $84.74, according to a report from Miller Samuel and Douglas Elliman. It’s the second line in the article.
- Affric 3y agoAh good thing we dodged the psy-op where they were trying to convince us that Manhattan was out of the reach of the little guy.
- ghaff 3y agoIt's not clear what the $84.74 price per square foot represents as it divides out to a totally unreasonable size into either of the other figures. It would be odd for an American publication but it's probably pretty close if it were square meters (so you end up at an average of 500 sq. ft. which seems about right). Or it may be for something that isn't directly related to the other two numbers.
- add-sub-mul-div 3y agoThere's a annoyingly large community of hall monitor types here who in every thread jump to point out every bit of nuance to a topic that didn't happen to fit in the headline. Whether it was present in the article body or not. The witch hunt against clickbait has become far more annoying than the practice itself. So many people litter these comments with context that they're absolutely sure is over everyone's head but theirs.
- chiefalchemist 3y agoIt got shared. It should not - in the form - have gotten shared. Evidently someone didn't realize that (i.e., "average" in the title === clickbait). So pointing out the stupidity of average is on me? God bless you. The irony of your comment is also entertaining.
- chiefalchemist 3y ago
- dmarchand90 3y agoAsking users who live in New York. How much does this matter? Is the commute from Brooklyn or Queens reasonable? If so how are the prices? The Bronx has a bad reputation (as a foreigner) but is that even true?
- ethanbond 3y agoPrices pretty much reflect the commute. Live near a subway line or closer on that line to Manhattan: it’s in the price. NYC real estate is pretty shockingly efficient. If you think you found a great deal, you are almost certainly in for a bad time. Parts of each of the Boroughs are pretty sketchy. Again, the parts that are not: priced in!
- bombcar 3y agoThis is how it is. To get a “good deal” you have to change yourself. Perhaps you’re like Gaston and the size of a barge so sketchy doesn’t bother you - savings! Maybe you’re a dwarf who lives underground - savings!
- thebigjewbowski 3y agoDepends on where you’re going but neither are that bad, depends on where you live specifically in either of those places. The Bronx has higher crime for sure.
- kulikalov 3y agoSubway is filthy and unsafe. No one I know would use it late at night. Most of the worthy cultural events are happening around Central Park and downtown. So, if you want the good parts of New York experience without a slight risk of being stabbed by a crazy person, you better live in a walking distance to one of these locations or commute on a car all the time.
- leveredequity 3y agoThis is so disingenuous I don’t even know where to start.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoWith a median rent of $4400 - you need to make ~$53k post-tax just for rent. That's basically ~$75k pre-tax just to afford rent. Then you have a ~36% marginal tax rate, plus a ~10% sales tax (~46% total) on everything else you buy to thrive instead of just survive... You need to make A LOT of money to live anywhere within reasonable commuting distance to Manhattan - unless you've been on rent control for 30 years or your parents bought you a flat or something.
- quickthrower2 3y agoHow much space is that buying? Can 2 or 3 share that?
- pclmulqdq 3y agoIn Manhattan proper that is about a 1 bedroom unless you want a very crappy building. 2 can comfortably share one of those in a roommate situation (one gets the bedroom and the other walls off a part of the living room), but 3 people can live in one if at least 2 of them are willing to share a bed (ie a couple).
- iamdamian 3y agoWhile it's not a perfect solution (or a likely option for most people on HN), there is such a thing as affordable housing in Manhattan and other boroughs. Affordable housing units cost far less than what you've shown here, and I think it's a mistake not to include them. In particular, I think it invalidates your conclusion about the need to make a lot of money to rent in Manhattan.
- iamdamian 3y agoThis is a first. I got a couple of downvotes, and I don't know why. I think the parent comment is wrong about what they're saying and I'm only really stating facts in my comment. Anyway, for the record, I stand by the above.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- flexie 3y agoIt's astonishing to think of the fact that NYC's total population is down from 8.8 million in 2020 to 8.3 million. That's a steep drop. With merely 48 percent of office space occupied, and desks in the so-called occupied offices partially empty due to people working from home a few days every week, it's not hard to imagine that the service sector is hurting: restaurants, cleaners, shop owners etc. Many of the people employed in these jobs lived in the other NYC boroughs. It's not unlikely that the NYC population will decline further in the coming years.
- danuker 3y agoHow is rent setting record highs, in spite of the population drop?
- bombcar 3y agoIf the population is dropping because lower income workers are leaving, average rents will go up as occupancy goes down. Think of it this way - you probably won’t move to a cheaper house just because one becomes available- but you might move to a nicer one of the financials worked.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoWorking class people are also more likely to have multiple roommates. So if one roommate leaves, maybe the others can no longer afford the full rent so they move too, now the landlord white washes the walls and jacks rent and it goes to a single high income individual who can afford three bedrooms themselves in manhattan.
- spread_love 3y ago> Brokers say the lack of apartments for sale, due to higher interest rates, have forced many would-be buyers to rent
- badpun 3y agoAlso, rents numbers are usually not given after adjusting for inflation. It makes breaking record a phenomenon you’d expect, similarly how Hollywood keeps constantly breaking its blockbuster records.
- dangus 3y agoBecause of the way inflation works the rent in any given city will always be at “record highs” unless there’s some kind of economic turmoil.
- ruddct 3y agoCouple things to note here: * As the numbers here show, the high end of Manhattan rentals is very, very high. ~10%[0] of listed rentals at the moment are >$10k/mo. >$100k rentals are not unheard of. Looks like the highest market rental right now is asking $175k/mo. * ~50%[1] of Manhattan's rental stock is rent stabilized, meaning the rent adjustment rates are set by the city. These units rent for considerably less than market-rate rentals. * For a variety of reasons, rent-stabilized units often stay in the informal housing market (i.e. not on real estate listing services), which AFAIK these reports do not measure. * There are a variety of cultural factors here that are a bit unusual for the US, including: - It's fairly normal here for people with 'good' jobs to have roommates into their 30s+ - The informal housing market here is massive (e.g. I've lived here for 10+ years and have very few friends who've ended up in market-rate rentals) - Manhattan builds very little new housing (e.g. zero units approved last month) - It's Manhattan, so there's a LOT of money floating around here. So yes, Manhattan is getting more expensive, but these market-rate rental reports are not the entire story. [0] From Streeteasy, a local real estate listing service [1] https://www.nyc.gov/assets/hpd/downloads/pdfs/services/rent-regulation-memo-1.pdf https://www.nyc.gov/assets/hpd/downloads/pdfs/services/rent-...
- jareklupinski 3y ago> >$100k rentals are not unheard of these are not 'normal' rentals and imo should be excluded from stats, since they don't apply to typical families living year-to-year in nyc a majority of those are short-term entire floor/home rentals, often rented out for less than a month at a time, to be used for production companies putting up A-listers for the length of a project, or even used as the set itself: sometimes the listing will say 'used for the filming of y reality show in 20xx!' like a selling point
- flandish 3y ago> typical families I think this depends on the indented audience in the metric or report. If we are just talking numbers, include all of them. If we want to focus on typical families, we need to define what that means.
- 3y ago
- max_ 3y agoThe average house hold income in Manhattan based on a quick Google is also about $150k. Making the annual rent of $60k about 40% of one's household income. In urban planning I heard that a fair rent refers to onee spending 30% of their income on rent. So I guess it isn't that bad.
- screye 3y agoNYC's main issue is that transit transfers between services are painful. Transfers between PATH, LIRR, NYC Ferry, MTA & the Air-Train can add a lot of unnecessary precious minutes. The MTA's newly minted OMNY payment system does not work on any of these either. The NYC transit system is expansive, but people stick to a select few locations because the transfers are so painful. Fixing this would be the easiest & cheapest solution to release some pressure from the housing market. Then there is NYC's generosity which follows (Blue city?) America's quintessential 'spend a lot, but never address the problem' approach. Between 50k-100k illegal migrants are being housed in NYC hotels right now ! Really ? The world's most expensive real-estate is the best place for housing illegal-migrants in country with the world's most hospitable area ? About 100k people are in homeless shelters in similarly prime real-estate. Same issue with rent control. In NYC, Roughly 1,006,000 rent-stabilized homes make up about 28 percent of the overall housing stock and 44 percent of all rentals. That's insane! Rent stabilized/controlled apartments face inevitable dilapidation while heavily limiting new housing supply in a city. Rent control is one of the best-studied : 'methods that do not work'. (In NYC rent stabilization is more common, but effectively follows the same patterns as rent control) Afaik, this does not include 500,000 housing projects residents, a lot of whom live in prime residential space in NYC. Social welfare & housing assistance are all well & good. But, no one should be entitled to a zip-code. NY's expansive rail network means that you can live 30 miles out of town, and still be within 30 minutes of your workplace. Let the location of housing assistance get decided by the free market. You can have your rent controlled apartment or NYCHA assistance. But, you aren't entitled to live walking distance from the WTC just because you're poor or have been renting since 1970. I agree that sustainable urbanism & dignified living should be central parts of 1st world city policy. But, blue cities in the US seem to be hellbent on looking at issues from the worst possible lens. Their solutions always answer the question : "What is the best way for us to maximize spend, minimize guilt and somehow lead to everyone being worse of ?". I had long thought that this pathology was limited to west coast cities, but the infection appears to have spread to the North East as well.