8 ms·
Planetary defense test deflected an asteroid but unleashed a boulder swarm
- tastyfreeze 3y agoIt is absolutely amazing that deflecting an asteroid is something we can even test. Depending on the size of the flung off boulders it may be preferable to the larger asteroid impacting. However, I suspect that when a potential impactor is considered for deflection it will be big enough that cast off pieces could still pose a threat.
- mmmmmmtoes 3y agoIf the size of the flung-off objects is proportional to the size of the asteroid that may be the case, but it's also possible it's mainly proportional to the force of the deflecting impact. Regardless between a potential extinction-level impact and hundreds, even thousands, of smaller, "Hiroshima-sized" impacts, the latter would still be massively preferable. Statistically the majority would hit the ocean and do little to nothing as well.
- EthanHeilman 3y ago> Depending on the size of the flung off boulders it may be preferable to the larger asteroid impacting. In nearly all cases, breaking an earth impacting asteroid into smaller pieces, many of which will burn up or have less bad impacts, is better unless of course the asteroid would have missed the Earth but some of the smaller pieces hit.
- EthanHeilman 3y agoThis thread has changed my mind on subject. I'd delete the above but Hn doesn't show a delete button.
- frud 3y agoDue to the chaotic nature of orbital mechanics, small changes in initial conditions become large observable differences in behavior over time. It's also helpful that there is essentially no turbulence in space so every observation over time results in more and more precise estimates for the true orbital parameters of the body under observation.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoI wonder if they used a nuclear warhead instead of a slug, would there be less material ejected due to maybe the rock being vaporized?
- gremlinsinc 3y agodoes a nuke do the same damage in space, in a vacuum, with zero gravity, and no oxygen and other factors? would it do anything to a rock that's essentially as dense as earths core adjusting for size? I think it'd be a cool test for them to do though.
- mannykannot 3y agoMy guess is that the rapidly-expanding vapor and debris cloud produced by the explosion is likely to dislodge and eject more material than would result from a passive impactor capable of producing the same deflection. To get the same deflection, you need the same impulse, and in both cases, the impulse is applied as a sudden shock, but if you are using a passive impactor, all the energy is directed in the direction you want the change of the asteroid's momentum to be - so you need less energy overall?
- kjkjadksj 3y agoPerhaps the nuke could be made sufficiently large enough where all of the asteroid material would be consumed in vaporization vs a portion deflected?
- mydriasis 3y ago> ... the collision also shook off 37 boulders, each measuring from 3 to 22 feet across. None of the boulders is on a course to hit Earth, but if rubble from a future asteroid deflection were to reach our planet, Jewitt said, they’d hit at the same speed the asteroid was traveling — fast enough to cause tremendous damage. Holy hell! OK -- do they burn up on entry? What's the criteria for that?
- NotYourLawyer 3y ago> Space rocks smaller than about 25 meters (about 82 feet) will most likely burn up as they enter the Earth's atmosphere and cause little or no damage. https://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/asteroids/overview/fastfacts.html https://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/asteroids/overview/fastfa...
- bongobingo1 3y agoCould we wrap the planet in some kind of space safety blanket? Like say an thicker atmosphere full of CO2 or methane?
- esotericimpl 3y ago[dead]
- ethbr0 3y agoAh, the Venus Defense.
- bell-cot 3y agoToo much work. And prime real estate on Venus is dirt cheap, if you're smart enough to get in before the big rush.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoWhat if I told you I could get you a cubic mile in the Venusian atmosphere for only $99??
- eggy 3y agoWe will get better at landing a device on an asteroid ala SpaceX, and use long-burst jets to veer the single rock off target. It will require identifying them when they are far off. Ramming into them will be plan B!
- smcl 3y agoSpaceX rockets took a NASA probe to space that crashed into an asteroid, while JAXA have actually landed something on an asteroid (Hayabusa2)
- knappe 3y agoDetecting the objects is the hard part. The planet killers are all likely to be highly elliptical objects with large orbital periods (on the order of thousands of years). With that kind of orbital period, we'd be lucky to see it before it has impacted.
- AnimalMuppet 3y ago> The planet killers are all likely to be highly elliptical objects with large orbital periods (on the order of thousands of years). Not saying you're wrong, but... what is your basis for claiming that this is true?
- Thiez 3y agoPlanets, by definition, have cleared their orbits around their respective star. So a planet killer threatening earth cannot share the earths orbit, or earth wouldn't be a planet. So a circular orbit shared with the earth is ruled out. But if it had a circular orbit that did not intersect the earths orbit, then there would be no chance of it hitting earth, so not really a planet killer either. The possible orbits that remain must be elliptical. Now if a planet killer passed us every year then we probably would have hit them by now (or provided a gravity slingshot to alter its orbit!), so it follows that it must have a large orbital period :p
- knappe 3y agoThe snarky answer would be to just leave this link https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orbital_mechanics https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orbital_mechanics. But to more fully answer the question look to https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elliptic_orbit https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Elliptic_orbit Notice that the object with an eccentricity of 0.8 has a much faster speed as it approaches the mass it is orbiting. So, to extrapolate, objects with a high eccentricity will be moving much faster as their semi major axis decreases (as they get closer to the mass it is orbiting). Faster means less time to detect the object. Less time to detect the object means we have less time to react to the object. Less time means planet killer. And keep in mind the time periods we're talking about for some of these objects measure in the tens of thousands of years. So we don't really get a chance to record these objects for "next time".
- j1elo 3y agoWe're just living the untold years before futuristic space defense systems that exist in so many books, movies, and videogames. All that stuff must have passed through numerous iterations of failures and catastrophic mistakes, in their respective fictional worlds. So here we are, in the real one.
- appplication 3y agoConsider me skeptical we’ll ever make it there. Not because it’s beyond technology, but because I don’t have a lot of faith that humanity will be surviving the next 200 years.
- calciphus 3y agoHumans are like mammalian cockroaches. Some will make it.
- gabereiser 3y agoWe lack the radiation-proof shell to withstand ourselves.
- 1970-01-01 3y ago2 meters of dirt is all you really need
- virgildotcodes 3y agoHow many self-sufficient human civilizations have been sustained under 2 meters of dirt?
- 1970-01-01 3y agoThere are several civilizations that accomplished this. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kaymakli_Underground_City#See_also https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kaymakli_Underground_City#See_...
- jeroenvlek 3y agoI've known of the risk of blowing an asteroid up into a swarm that's potentially more dangerous already for years, how is this unexpected according to the article?
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> blowing an asteroid up into a swarm that's potentially more dangerous For starters, that is not what is suggested.
- jeroenvlek 3y agoIt says "Smaller rocks flying off into space could create their own problems" so that's potentially more dangerous, maybe not likely, but still potentially :)
- JRKrause 3y agoThe word 'unexpected' doesn't appear in the article. It's a fairly safe bet that the team of people capable of hitting a 581 foot object 6 million miles away with a 13,000 mph slug would have expected the ejection of material from the impact.
- jeroenvlek 3y agoYou're right, I interpreted "unintended" as "unexpected", because I assumed that if you know this before you do this then you know what to expect, so it must also be intended.
- RecycledEle 3y agoCorrect. NASA knew there would be rubble put into orbit around the asteroid. The idiot author of the article has embarrassed himself, his company, his industry, and his advertisers by thinking orbiting ejecta was "unexpected."
- mannykannot 3y agoCertainly, but to the person who wrote the sub-heading (I suspect an editor rather than the article's author), it presents a "previously unanticipated risk." The further you get from the source...
- excalibur 3y agoHow the hell was this unanticipated? You think ramming things into asteroids is not going to create any debris? I thought NASA was full of smart people.
- jdiez17 3y agoIt is an asteroid redirect test. It has not been done before, so it is normal that unexpected consequences happen. It is very difficult to even get high resolution pictures of asteroids.
- ansible 3y agoThe scientists had known for a long time that this was a possibility. That's part of the reason why the Dimorphos / Didymos asteroids were selected, their current orbit (even if altered a little) and any debris generated will never come close to Earth.
- vpribish 3y agoit's a garbage clickbait article.
- Workaccount2 3y agoI can't help but feel that this piece was written at the absolute limit of what academia would consider "not clickbait".
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoPaper: https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.3847/2041-8213/ace1ec/pdf https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.3847/2041-8213/ace1ec/... This is observational evidence regarding the swarm. Not anyone expressing incredulity at a collision producing ejecta.
- JRKrause 3y agoTo think the UCLA article didn't even include the photograph of the asteroid taken by DART prior to impact.
- dtx1 3y agoI suspect if we didn't just dart a small probe but a large thermonuclear bomb into an asteroid we'd see a much different result
- AnimalMuppet 3y agoYou'd see more energy, but no more momentum transfer. Unless one of two things happened: 1. The nuclear warhead sent the back part of the rocket backward (that is, away from the asteroid) hard enough that (with respect to the asteroid) it has negative momentum, so that the part that hits the asteroid has more momentum. 2. The energy of the radiation from the warhead ablades material from the asteroid, turning it momentarily into a rocket motor. The momentum of that material leaving the asteroid causes an equal momentum change on the asteroid itself.
- dtx1 3y agoBut also smaller fragments i'd assume.
- fencepost 3y agoThe momentum of the whole system would likely be similar, but it'd be spread over a much wider debris field - in the case of an asteroid impact, a field probably large enough that much of it would completely bypass instead of impacting. From a practical standpoint, anyone debating between nuclear and non-nuclear options would probably have to look at the risks of a more complex projectile (reliability), whether an explosion would allow use of a smaller projectile (energy cost for getting there, terminal speed, accuracy at various speeds), and of course regulatory concerns with launching nuclear vs kinetic impactors.
- kvgr 3y ago"previously unanticipated risks" really? we will smash it, it will be ok... oh it launched rocks? how unanticipated
- sneak 3y agoThis article fails to mention anything about whether or not the magnitude of deflection was considered successful.
- nycdotnet 3y agoThis is a profoundly dumb summary of the referenced research article - rather astonishing for UCLA. Studying the boulder swarm - amazing! Saying the boulders that came off are like shrapnel from a hand grenade - sure. Observing that the boulders keep the relative velocity of the original body and that they could cause damage if they hit something... ok yeah? Interplanetary velocities are energetic - true - and that this is similar to the energy of the Hiroshima atomic bomb - technically true also, but this is where it veers into sensationalism. It's rather telling that this part is put as "Jewitt said" but not quoted. This could very mean that Jewitt said it would have X amount of energy, and the author decided to put in the nuclear bomb angle because it was a similar energy. Asteroids this size just burn up. "In theory" they could hit something in orbit but space is mind-bogglingly huge and this is exceedingly unlikely. And weighed against surface impact of something judged worthy of a planetary defense scenario? Unanticipated risks?
- sproketboy 3y ago[dead]
- RosanaAnaDana 3y agoWouldn't breaking up a planetary defense worthy asteroid into medium to even large boulder size asteroids be considered a win? Whats the limit on asteroid size that can make it through the atmosphere? And even then, intuitively, it would seem like the destructiveness is going to scale with the size of the individual asteroid, so a rain of many smaller asteroids making it to ground would be far lower than one large asteroid..
- icegreentea2 3y agoIt depends on what the threshold for 'planetary defense worthy' is I guess. If you shattered an asteroid, but all of the asteriod pieces still entered the earth's atmosphere, then you're going to end up releasing pretty much an identical amount of energy. At "city buster" size of impact, this would probably be beneficial. But beyond that? Probably not hugely beneficial. Probably effectively the difference between a ground detonation and a partial airburst.. so maybe less ejecta (reduced global dimming after). But... probably not a meaningful change.
- JRKrause 3y agoI always wonder how you do the risk calculus for this kind of scenario. Clearly if the certainty of a world-ending impact is 100% then committing the entirety of humanities resources to deflecting it would be justified and expected. But what about if the the certainty is 90%? 80%?
- marcosdumay 3y agoJustifiable, yes. Expected, certainly not. What does "committing the entirety of humanities resources" even look like? Anyway, this is certainly something that will never happen. But committing a lot of resources, yes, we'll do that if it's 1% too.
- cubefox 3y agoAs important as the DART mission was, we are still quite far from actually defending against a mass extinction sized asteroid or even comet. The Dimorphos asteroid, which was hit by the DART craft, has a mass of only about 5 * 10^9 kg, while the Chicxulub asteroid (which caused the Dinosaur mass extinction) had a mass of 1 * 10^15 to 5 * 10^17 kg. That's six to eight orders of magnitude difference, or a factor of one million to 100 million. Somebody has probably calculated the details, but I suspect if we have to hit such a large impactor, we have to launch as many hydrogen bomb equipped Starships at it as we can. And our time window might be quite short. The worst case is if it's actually a comet, as these are hard to detect in advance, since they aren't aligned with the plane of the solar system. By the way, if you Google for "DART mission" or "Chicxulub impactor", be careful, something might hit your search results...
- tambourine_man 3y ago> if you Google for "DART mission" or "Chicxulub impactor", be careful, something might hit your search results... That was cool, thanks. I enjoy the traces of whimsical-not-evil old Google that still resurface every now and then.
- fiftyfifty 3y agoBut if detected early enough it might not take much more than a DART sized nudge of even a Chicxulub sized asteroid to change it’s course enough to miss the Earth. The whole reason DART targeted a two asteroid system was so we could measure how much we changed Dimorphos orbit around Didymos. If we have to blow these things into rubble shortly before impact we might be in big trouble.
- cubefox 3y agoWith a ten kilometer Chicxulub class asteroid, blowing it into rubble is not on the table anyway, even with rather large hydrogen bombs. We can only hope to deflect them.
- LorenPechtel 3y agoDART nudged it's target about 2.7mm/sec. To ensure a miss you need a sideways deflection of up to 4000 km (depends on the geometry.) To generate a miss by Dimorphos assuming the worst case you're looking at 1,481,481,481 seconds of lead time. That's about 47 years. Against the dinosaur killer you're looking at a lead time far beyond our ability to predict orbits. Note, also, that if you're throwing kinetic stuff at your target you get little choice in how it hits, you very well might not be able to shove it to the side. Despite the refusal to consider the option there really is only one choice against a major threat: Orion. We know it works (it has been flight tested with conventional charges, it has been tested with single impulses with nuclear charges), while there are some serious question marks about whether you could actually build an Orion capable of launching form Earth (how do you keep the pusher plate from getting too hot??) that does not apply if you're using it against an asteroid. You don't care what shape the asteroid ends up in, just that it get out of the way. Your only limit is that you don't want to make any given shove big enough to risk breaking the asteroid. By a crude approximation you can easily get 10% of the bomb energy to show up as impulse, this can be increased by putting the bomb closer (remember, you don't care about damage short of destruction) and some still-classified data says that it's possible to build a shaped charge that directs the majority of it's energy at the asteroid. Obviously, exact numbers are not known to us mere mortals.
- fencepost 3y agoThis article seems to be a fine example of "perfect is the enemy of good." Could boulders from an asteroid be dangerous? Sure! Would the asteroid they came from be more dangerous? Oh hell yeah. This is like complaining because when a missile or drone was shot down the debris landed on a car. Basic physics says in any kind of energetic collision there's going to be debris, and basic statistics says that some of that debris has a chance of hitting something that we'd prefer not be damaged. Such is life.
- Jeff_Brown 3y agoRegarding the atomic bomb factoid, they might have usefully added that 10,000 times that much energy reaches the Earth in the form of sunlight every second. (sunlight per second = 1.2e17 joules; the Hiroshima bomb = 1.5e13 joules.)
- ted_dunning 3y agoI read these numbers in a profoundly different way from the article. Based on these results, it looks feasible to divert the main mass of a potential impactor. That appears to run the unsurprising risk of ejecta that would themselves impact. But this just means that the first impact decreases the problem measured in energy by (roughly) four orders of magnitude. This is because the ejected masses are much, much smaller than the original mass and because most of the ejected masses won't impact. Nothing prevents applying the same technique to a few selected ejected masses. If the ratios apply again, we can decrease the thread by another four orders of magnitude. This is enough to reduce the KT impactor to a level that will burn in the atmosphere.
- justinclift 3y agoWhy is the article saying this was unexpected? Surely slamming an asteroid with a fast moving mass (or explosive weaponry, etc) is expected to knock chunks off it? That has to be the most logical, obvious-as-all-hell result yeah?