6 ms·
I think a realistic description/story from real experience I've had as a security engineer might help some people understand why this will end up so bad. I've
by freedomben 3y ago
I think a realistic description/story from real experience I've had as a security engineer might help some people understand why this will end up so bad.
I've worked with banks, who are among the most security-minded of organizations. It's not because they're security nerds, it's because the cost of getting hacked is astronomical, and because regulations require them to be "as secure as possible."
Banks won't be chomping at the bit to implement WEI because they hate the open web or they hate Linux users. They'll be chomping at the bit because if they don't it will be a liability, and a "you're not doing all you can for security" type of risk that can open them to lawsuits, regulatory punishments, and even higher insurance costs. WEI is not a requirement right now because it doesn't exist. Once it exists though, you can be sure it will become a standard practice requirement, and anyone arguing against it might as well be arguing that using CC cameras is a privacy invasion: they'll seem absurd and won't last long in that position.
In short order it will be implemented by all the CDNs like Cloudflare, and it will be a simple checkbox for site owners to add to their site. Failure to implement this would be a fiduciary disaster, so they will have no choice. Once that is there, nobody who cares at all about security for their site (which is pretty much all people) are going to uncheck that box.
- JohnFen 3y ago> Once it exists though, you can be sure it will become a standard practice requirement Yes, this seems inevitable. At which point, I will no longer be using the bank's website. > they'll seem absurd and won't last long in that position. I'm not sure what you mean here, though. People who object to ubiquitous surveillance don't seem absurd to most (even those who aren't so upset about it), and they certainly aren't changing their position.
- freedomben 3y agoHey John, I love that we are in the same threads on HN so much :-D > I'm not sure what you mean here, though. People who object to ubiquitous surveillance don't seem absurd to most (even those who aren't so upset about it), and they certainly aren't changing their position. Yeah good question/clarification, I'm referring to the CCTV cameras in the bank itself (such as in the vault, in the lobby, etc).
- JohnFen 3y agoHooray for shared interests! :) > I'm referring to the CCTV cameras in the bank itself Ahh, I see what you mean. I do know people who hate even those cameras, but they do also understand why they're there and just silently put up with them while minimizing the amount of time they spend on-premises. I think there's a bit of a difference, though. If I'm in a bank branch, it's effectively "their house, their rules", so CCTV cameras don't offend me there. But if the bank required me to be searched when entering the place, I'd be strongly offended by that. To me, WEI is more like being frisked than being surveilled (although neither analogy is great).
- illwrks 3y agoYou'll likely be ushered to their mobile app instead.
- JohnFen 3y agoI don't do mobile apps. What I'll do instead (and, honestly, this is what I already mostly do anyhow so it's not really a sacrifice) is physically go to the bank branch to conduct my business.
- wiredfool 3y agoAt my bank, they will then send you to the online banking, or the phone (with it's 20 min plus waits). The Mobile app is required to use the debit card anywhere but card present, because 2fa. The Mobile app is required to do interesting things on the website, because of their 2fa. The iPad can't use their website (because reasons, they think it's mobile) and can't use the mobile app because it's not the configured phone with the account. Credit cards really aren't a thing in this country, and if they are, they will generally have a phone based mobile app for 2fa/strong auth.
- JohnFen 3y agoIf things were like that where I live, then I'd have to have a different response, obviously. I'm sorry that your options are so limited. I'm not sure what my response would be, but I'd probably lean toward having a separate device that's acceptable to the bank and that I use only for banking purposes. But I don't know.
- yason 3y agoI don't know about your country but here the only people who physically go to the bank are 80+ grannies and granddads who think they're too old to learn this bloody computer stuff, and who are also willing to pay exorbitant 10-30 monetary units for each bill paid by a physical person in the physical bank, and to do even that they must accept that it's ok if you have to book an appointment at the bank's counter in advance.
- knodi123 3y ago> I will no longer be using the bank's website That's a great temporary measure, but once this has rolled out everywhere and is part of standard commercial experiences, are you really willing to completely opt out of online banking because you're not permitted to send fake browser identification? It's a fine philosophical position, but it feels akin to refusing to use public streets because of the existence of surveillance cameras.
- JohnFen 3y ago> are you really willing to completely opt out of online banking Sure, why not? It's not like it's a huge sacrifice on my part. It's just a little reduction in convenience. No big deal. > because you're not permitted to send fake browser identification? That's not the issue for me at all. The issue is if sites require me to use specific browsers, to not use specific extensions, to not be able to modify the browsers, or to adhere to specific requirements in terms of the OS I'm using. Having to maintain a completely different environment in order to use certain websites really is a loss of convenience that I object to. Don't get me wrong -- I don't see this as a huge moral issue. Sites can do what they want, and if I don't like what they want, I don't have to use them. Opting not to use them strikes me as a reasonable and proportional response. The only thing that makes me a little sad is that it's just another thing that makes the web worse and less useful.
- knodi123 3y ago> It's not like it's a huge sacrifice on my part. It's just a little reduction in convenience. No big deal. Sure, I get that. I just feel like it's only a little inconvenience now, but in a few years it will be a big one, and so on. After all, the US is _already_ way behind the rest of the developed world in mobile payment/banking tech. > The issue is if sites require me to use specific browsers, to not use specific extensions, to not be able to modify the browsers, or to adhere to specific requirements in terms of the OS I'm using. Ah, I didn't think about that angle. That would be pretty draconian. I foresee a shift to dedicated embedded apps for that, like a restricted VM inside of a browser tab. We'll see!
- mvnuweucxqokii 3y ago
- tga_d 3y agoGiven that most people don't use ad blockers, I suspect most people will not stop using the website, at which point, it becomes safe to assume most people will have a browser it works with. Once that point is reached, there's no reason it wouldn't proliferate to any number of sites, including ones you likely do use.
- JohnFen 3y agoIndeed, and this is why I'm very opposed to the WEI idea. It will make the web even smaller and less useful. > Given that most people don't use ad blockers In the US, 40% of people do use ad blockers. That's certainly not "most", but it is a large enough number to be significant.
- volkl48 3y agoWhile I'm willing to believe banks are very security minded in terms of their core infrastructure, banks do not appear to be with regards to their customer access and usually seem to move very slowly to secure that end of things. Hell, many/most of these large institutions seem to still only support SMS for 2FA and even that's a relatively recent introduction to actually mandate. Which is to say, I expect banks to be about the very last significant account you use to mandate this technology (if it takes off), not the first.
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> I expect banks to be about the very last significant account you use to mandate this technology Unless Google happens to make fat campaign donations or post-office job offers to elected officials who can insure WEI becomes mandated for banks. In the face of this, what banks want won't matter much.
- JohnFen 3y agoIf Google wants to force WEI to become common, all they really have to do is mandate that sites have to implement WEI in order to be listed in their index.
- generic92034 3y agoBut that would be fuel for another antitrust case.
- tremon 3y agoAre you saying the outcome of previous antitrust cases (especially against big tech) hurt those businesses sufficiently that they act as a deterrent? It doesn't look that way from my position here in the peanut gallery.
- WarOnPrivacy 3y agoI absolutely agree. I was making the case for how Google could manipulate a theoretically-resistant banking industry. I get banking is regulated from a variety of directions. However, the path of lobbyist influence->federal manipulation is so well worn it impacts many (probably most) exertions of power.
- djha-skin 3y agoThen we'd better find ways of fooling or defeating WEI. "Tamper proof" indeed. It's just OS DRM. We've cracked DRM, we can crack this.
- freedomben 3y agoI suspect cracking this will involve attacks like the recent Tesla one that require an extreme amount of technical skill and risk of destroying/damaging the system in the process. Then cue the cat & mouse game. Widespread breaking of it is not going to be remotely practical.
- EvanAnderson 3y agoThe idea of relying on cracks / security flaws to get basic freedom causes me great anxiety. Sure, it can be cracked. It shouldn't have to be because it shouldn't exist to begin with. Meanwhile, arms race being what it will, the freedom gained will be short-lived and can't be relied-upon.
- shrimp_emoji 3y agoMr. Anderson... don't you like the idea of a future where caring about privacy and control means you're marginalized to the sewers of a Matrix arcology, eating nutrient slurry on the Nebuchadnezzar?
- kevincox 3y agoThat sounds like a cat and mouse game that I would rather not play. Look at iOS jailbreaks. They were fairly common early on and still regularly occur. But they are not frequent. Maybe a full jailbreak every year or two. The verifier for WEI can also revoke access to old versions of the software. I don't want to be playing that game to access critical services such as my bank.
- notatoad 3y agomy experience with banks has been the opposite - they're always a ways behind the rest of the web on security measures. some banks are still rolling out 2fa. and look how horrifically insecure credit cards are. not because they don't care, but because they see technical measures as only a small piece of their overall security strategy, and online access as only a small part of their business that they consider untrustworthy no matter how much security is implemented. where most of the web treats authenticated users as trusted, banks still treat an authenticated user as mostly untrustworthy, and all of their actions as still being a potential risk, so securing the authentication isn't so important.
- freedomben 3y agoSome banks are definitely behind on the curve, but notably I think that tends to be around customer-facing stuff. Given that whatever they use has to work for very elderly people as well young people, it surely makes it difficult to move/change things. WEI though is entirely on the backend though. It can be implemented as soon as the major OSes have it integrated, and it requires nothing from the user (besides installing their updates, which is mostly forced).
- dredmorbius 3y agoAs others have noted, banks are governed by (often multiple) regulators, at the local, state/regional, and national levels typically. As Brian Krebs has noted, on top of the already-oligopic banking sector is an even more ologopic banking-computer-services sector: "What Is Your Bank’s Security Banking On?" (2018).[1] Sadly, the industry is dominated by a small handful of banking platform providers. Four, Fiserv, Jack Henry, FIS, and CSI, serv over 80% of the market. Bank regulators, responding to Krebs, said that "small to mid-sized banks are massively beholden to their platform providers, and many banks simply accept the defaults instead of pushing for stronger alternatives." This does also suggest that there may be a small number of points of control over which to enact useful change, though of course there's also a concentrated lobbying interest in avoiding or counterinfluencing same. ________________________________ Notes: 1. <https://krebsonsecurity.com/2018/03/what-is-your-banks-security-banking-on/ https://krebsonsecurity.com/2018/03/what-is-your-banks-secur...> (HN: <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20203482 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20203482>)
- bravetraveler 3y agoWhile I tend to agree, let's temper this a bit. We're not all condemned to FIPS ciphers everywhere because banks are, and so on. I'm hopeful there's some option to it, like how you don't need 2FA often until doing something like changing the password
- delusional 3y agoI work in a bank. Until a year ago, our passwords are 8 characters max, no special characters, upper and lowercase letters are equal. We were running IE7 up until 2 years ago. A huge amount of the business is still organized around sending excel sheets to each other, with no sidechannel validation. The fact that you recieved an excel sheet from some email is treated as proof that it's valid. Last I checked we were also operating an unauthenticated SMTP relay. They will shit on actual security while telling me that I have to run windows on my work laptop because otherwise they can't run their favorite RAT powershell script to recursively unzip every jar on my system to look for log4shell (yes, still). The same people who instituted and backed these rules and practices are also running the core system for clearing in the national bank of Denmark. Banks are not secure. They are conservative and political. They will do everything to tell you they are secure. They will make your life hell to uphold their security theater, but it's just a facade. I have no doubt they will implement WEI, but it will not bring security. Banks do have a pretty good trackrecord of protecting people's money, but they do that through a defense in depth strategy of having a bunch of compliance officers manually reviewing transactions for suspicious activity.
- thrown1212 3y ago> I have no doubt they will implement WEI, but it will not bring security. This is precisely OP’s point. WEI will quickly dominate despite having nothing to do with securing anyone.
- factormeta 3y agoWEI sounds like another security theater play by Ad corp. When web first come out it is because it's sandbox that made it so attractive. The server doesn't need to know what client it is, as long as it is speaking http. With intro of html5, (webgpu, webgl, web audio api), that sandbox has being slowly opened up.
- realusername 3y agoThat will be pretty much the same situation as on mobile where the third party rom developers and users are pretty much the only ones affected by design by this concept. Who will have some trouble with this new concept on the web? Smaller browser maker, software developers and crawlers from competitors Not a single scammer or ad fraud will be affected, same as on mobile. Easy to see why Google wants that, its attacking the competition
- amadeuspagel 3y agoRight now, many banks require a mobile app, which can only be installed from an app store, which is only available on devices that you don't control. Even if they have a web interface, you need the mobile app to login.
- flangola7 3y agoWhat banks are those? My grandma isn't going to buy a smartphone to use her bank.
- amadeuspagel 3y agon26, for example.
- fragmede 3y agoLike with cheques, she might get left behind. Which is terrible.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 18pfsmt 3y ago[flagged]
- jsty 3y agoI don't get how this would be seen within banks as any different to the existing endpoint security offerings offering remote attestation that - by the same logic - they would already be mandating customers to use to access banking platforms, because doing otherwise would mean not being "as secure as possible" and getting dinged by the regulators.
- LinuxBender 3y agoall the CDNs like Cloudflare, and it will be a simple checkbox When this happens will this accidentally create a new business model of people selling VPN-like access that mimics WEI or uses a farm of cell phones to create a proxy farm of sorts? What else might people do to circumvent this?
- Temporary_31337 3y agoThis is already explained in the article- it shifts the burden on the honest consumer and in many cases is actually already illegal. In other words in no way is it a good development if I have to buy a service of questionable legality from some questionable 3rd party just to keep my browsing private like I want to.