9 ms·
What comes after Zoom? (2020)
- MongoTheMad 3y ago"Zoom" ... according to that one Mazda ad.
- PaulHoule 3y agoThe thing is Skype had video calling but it didn’t have the “Hollywood squares” experience. Watching these things come and go over a long period of time the baseline scenario is a low-grade of “enshittification” in that there is a lot of expensive and boring detail work to keep the experience low friction and no vendor seems to want to do this work once it has gotten established — So inevitably it becomes a matter of “it just doesn’t work” and somebody will tell you “You gotta meet me on XYZ” and when you’re skeptical they’ll say “XYZ works as good as Zoom did back in the day” and the simple feature that the product is in the honeymoon stage and attending to all the little details and not in the harvesting stage where every developer they can let go of is profit is more important than the headliner features in which the product is really innovative. A counter to that is that one of these companies really can decide that it wants to be permanent, to some extent Facebook has done that, they saw what happened to MySpace and Yahoo and know it will happen to them too if they don’t keep up, which has often meant buying “the next thing” and also heavy investments in what could be the next platform. To play that game takes real courage because there will come a time you need to kill your cash cow so you’ll have another cash cow, something Zuckerberg can do because he controls so much of the company.
- marktani 3y agotangent, this is the fifth time very recently I've seen the word "entshittifaction" on HN, and it's always quoted as well. It reminds me of the German word Entnazifizierung ("de-nazi-fication"), which was relevant post WWII. Where is this new word coming from?
- groceryheist 3y agoCory Doctorow
- bjelkeman-again 3y agoI thought it was older than last year, but I must be mixing up presentations I saw recently by Cory. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/enshittification https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/enshittification
- ydant 3y agoIt feels older to me, too. It definitely gained a lot of momentum recently around Reddit's recent API pricing changes, but Google Trends shows it having a lot of interest in 2004 and then sporadic interest over the years. https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&geo=US&q=enshittification&hl=en https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&geo=US&q=e... I don't use Google Trends enough to know how to interpret that data, so maybe there's some quirk of Google Trends that makes it look more significant back then. It would be awesome if some service had a similar feature to Google Ngram Viewer, but for content on the internet instead of books. Search interest isn't quite the same as how much it's being written in content.
- passwordoops 3y ago"Here is how platforms die: first, they are good to their users; then they abuse their users to make things better for their business customers; finally, they abuse those business customers to claw back all the value for themselves. Then, they die." I forgot exactly when Cory Doctorow introduced the term, but this blog post pretty well hashes out the concept https://pluralistic.net/2023/01/21/potemkin-ai/#hey-guys https://pluralistic.net/2023/01/21/potemkin-ai/#hey-guys
- PaulHoule 3y agoIn this case the push for more money is not the problem but cost reduction is. The analogy of the honeymoon where you start a relationship and are careful to do all kinds of little nice things and then you start to take the other person for granted is closer to it, rather than the scenario of Google becoming play-for-play and pushing up ad loads to the human limit of withstanding. For me the quotes reflect both that difference and my discomfort with the word “shit” which use to be just way too popular on HN and in startup culture though I think the situation has largely corrected itself.
- lancesells 3y agoI use: https://whereby.com https://whereby.com I don't know if it can handle sizable calls but it works well for me. It's simple, seems to have a decent privacy policy, and has always just worked. The only drawback for me is they raised $10M a couple years back.
- verelo 3y agoAlso earlier versions only worked about 75% of the time. The reliability impact on brands that were pre-zoom (webex, etc) made them less attractive well before the pandemic.
- euroderf 3y agoOr, for "Hollywood Squares" substitute "Brady Bunch".
- shortcake27 3y agoFaceTime is incredible. Everything else I’ve used - Zoom, Meet, Slack etc, has insane lag/delay even when I’m having a one-on-one with someone in the same city. Then I made a FaceTime call to the opposite side of the world and it was like we were sitting next to each other. No delay. No weird interruptions. No “sorry, you go”. And I was on shitty pub wifi. I don’t know what the deal is. Do all these other services route through slow-ass servers in the US? Bad client-side processing? FaceTime proves the possibility of near-real-time communication across the globe, why is no one else even close?
- nicolaslem 3y agoFaceTime has terrible echo cancelling. If any participant is on speaker the conversation is basically half-duplex. I personally can't stand it and unfortunately my relatives do not have the reflex of using headphones for calls.
- EGreg 3y agoI think you just got lucky. All these services use roughlu the same technology.
- petra 3y agoThere are video chat applications for musicians that focus on low delay. For example:farplay.io .
- wkat4242 3y agoFacetime is pretty cool but being limited to Apple is a total dealbreaker. But perhaps in the US it's viable because iphones are so common there. Here I don't see even iOS / macOS users using it because there's simply almost nobody to call with it.
- blessedwhiskers 3y agoFaceTime is also available in browser from Android and Windows. https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT212619 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT212619
- 3y ago
- fnordpiglet 3y agoI find coscreen to be the evolution of Zoom - https://www.datadoghq.com/blog/pair-programming-coscreen-datadog/ https://www.datadoghq.com/blog/pair-programming-coscreen-dat... (N.b., lack of Linux support is damning and the promised release has been long delayed)
- delogos 3y ago(2020)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- minsc_and_boo 3y agoI think the video conference market success is also linked to increased prevalence of camera us - i.e. mobile plans finally support streaming, laptops carry a camera as standard, etc. (Covid also increased demand) If you're going to speculate on what's next for communication, it's probably best to follow the technology.
- ghaff 3y agoThe market was pretty well primed pre-COVID. We were already doing a fair number of video calls at work, webinars (though usually just with slides) were very much a thing, and I guess a fair number of people would at least sometimes use Facetime to see the grandkids or whatever. As you say, webcams were getting pretty ubiquitous and mobile networks were improving. When everyone switched to more remote interactions during the pandemic, it was natural to just really ramp up the technology they were already using and a lot of people were upgrading their video and audio gear to make videos anyway. Not clear to me what is next. I'm pretty sure most people don't want a more immersive experience most of the time and some percentage of people resent peer pressure to be on video as it is--as noted in various comments. ADDED: I do agree with one of the points I think Ben is making. There is still a lot of UX work that could go into simplifying screen sharing and other, for lack of a better term, multi-mode interactions.
- sdfghswe 3y ago> Zoom is the Skype of video - it turned a technology few people used much into a mass-market product. But next we’ll get the equivalents of Instagram and Snap - products that ask different questions. Zoom solved getting into a call, but why are you in the call? Complete garbage. I know why I'm in a call, it's none of your business, and I don't want products asking questions.
- BryanBeshore 3y agoAgreed. Also, who thought it would be a great product improvement to update as you are launching a call? In addition, a few more things that suck about Zoom: - No I don't want my screen to go to Zoom/fullscreen when someone shares their screen - When the call ends, just end. Don't show me anything more with zoom, or make my screen go to a zoom/call ended modal. 1 click on/ 1 click off. Just be simple!
- Infinitesimus 3y ago> - No I don't want my screen to go to Zoom/fullscreen when someone shares their screen There's a setting for that. Settings > Share Screen > Window size when screen sharing > Maintain current size I'm sure you can imagine why this isn't the default. Many people work off their laptop screens and low res monitors. Few have 32" 4K ultrawide magic beans ones so full screen helps them actually see the content. > - When the call ends, just end. Don't show me anything more with zoom, or make my screen go to a zoom/call ended modal. I wonder if this is so that people don't panic, wondering whether the call _really_ ended or the window just disappeared by the other person can hear them.
- jonas21 3y agoYou're taking this too literally. The product will not be asking you what you're doing. The product designer will ask these questions of themselves and create something that better serves these use cases.
- sdfghswe 3y agoI get it. But I don't want to the product designer to be asking these questions either. It's very obvious what I want, I want something that always works with no effort. I don't want something that is quirky or interesting or engaging, because someone somewhere is trying to hit some engagement metrics and aiming that increase my usage time. Just get out of my way, and I will love it. I love linux, I love git, I love vim, I love torrents. All of those just get out of my way and give me what I want without someone somewhere asking questions.
- jeron 3y agoJust like we had Before the Common Era and Common Era, we will have the Zoom Era and Post Zoom Era
- xwdv 3y agoWhat comes after Zoom? A regression to simpler lightweight tech. Most people here don’t even turn on their cameras. There’s no point. It wastes bandwidth, makes people self conscious, and adds little to no value. Increasingly, we see the use of impromptu Slack huddles going up. Easy to jump in and out, feels more like a hallway or deskside conversation compared to the formal meeting room experience of Zoom. With the remote work revolution happening on a large scale, we are learning what works and cutting out that which is unnecessary. Full camera setups are unnecessary: the digital equivalent of managers wanting to lord over rows of peons sitting at desks. If you want to “team build” with coworkers then go setup a VR ping pong table happy hour during work hours and chat in your little metaverse, or take turns reading lines from Macbeth.
- bipson 3y agoSo much vitriol :( I can say from personal experience that people tend to drift off more easily if their cameras are off, no manager present. My team even just agreed themselves to enable the cameras during refinements. Is the main problem boring meetings? Of course it is! But you won't get people involved by not having any team meetings at all... Sometimes the spark needs to catch first. VR ping pong table??? Not every company here can and will afford VR headsets for everyone just for kicks. And it is beyond the point. Trust is built by sharing, not by playing VR games. It can work, but it is neither necessary nor sufficient. This statement is so cliche SV.
- randomdata 3y ago> But you won't get people involved by not having any team meetings at all... Having worked from home for decades now, back in my day the connectivity wasn't good enough for meetings. I never found it limiting in that way. In fact, it was easier to get involved as you had time to get involved, not wasting away in useless meetings. In my experience, the main problem is that most people working remotely were thrown into it during the COVID age and never took time to develop remote working skills, leaving their office skills they had built up to lean on, with everyone hoping they would carry over. But it doesn't work like that. Being skilled in one thing does not mean you are skilled in all things. Likewise, my career has been spent working from home. If you threw me into an office, where I have no experience, I'd equally be a fumbling around disaster. They are entirely different skillsets.
- LambdaComplex 3y agoI really think Discord could pivot themselves to the SMB space if they wanted. Their audio/video call quality is better than anything else I've used, including both Zoom and Skype.
- rajeshp1986 3y agoDiscord's video quality is laughable. May be it depends on where in the world you are using it but it has the worst video quality in my experience.
- vulcan01 3y agoI think the GP is referring to the video quality with Discord Nitro (their subscription service), which is not bad.
- WorldMaker 3y agoDiscord seems rather good at picking data centers for chat channels optimized for good voice quality, but not always as good at picking data centers for video quality. There's some latency graphs you can discover "hidden" in Discord's desktop interface. (It's a hover over the right part of the call "bar".) You can use that information to manually override the data center for the channel. I've had some good experiences with switching data center to closer to the people experiencing the worst video quality. (Of course, you need to be a channel admin to manually change the data center. It will also kick everyone else and force a rejoin to connect to the new data center, so it is something to add to a tech rehearsal ahead of time if relying on the channel for important meetings.)
- pathartl 3y agoI think the most compelling feature behind Discord is having text and voice/video channels. By allowing people to just jump into a channel instead of having to call individual people or scheduling a call, it would allow remote teams to function pretty easily. Scheduled meetings become "here's this persistent channel for our team, this meeting calendar entry just links you to join that channel"
- 3y ago
- jnsie 3y agoI'm still not 100% clear on what zoom solved that led to such a surge in popularity. I'd used WebEx and other tools for work for years and they always seem "good enough". I probably prefer Zoom, but am not sure it improved life _that_ much...
- TuringNYC 3y ago>> I'm still not 100% clear on what zoom solved that led to such a surge in popularity. Little things matter. When I send a zoom link, it is ~20 characters and I can alternatively just give you a room number. When I send a MS Teams link, the invite is 5 line long with hundreds of strange characters in the middle.
- marktani 3y agoI also think in an (enterprise) company context, the sum of all those little things matters more. Corporates need out of the box integrations and processes, built-in auditing etc., and it seems that Zoom catered to those needs well.
- rajeshp1986 3y agoIt made video calls more accessible. They used mobile first approach so it was more accessible to lot of people. WebEx was a pain the ass use on desktop and it still is. Eric Yuan begged Cisco to invest more in WebEx and got frustrated and left and built Zoom.
- dfxm12 3y agoYeah, me neither. In my enterprise, we already had Teams in place (via o365). After Zoom's surge in popularity, we still have Teams in place, but now we're spending money on both Zoom and Teams. I doubt this is due to vendor redundancy because it would be the only enterprise service with this feature. I personally prefer Teams because I always have Teams open, it integrates better with Outlook and it's more or less included with o365. I guess it's a different story if you didn't already have a solution in place... In my personal life, um... video chat with many people is not really a part of it. I just used Google Duo/Meet when needed.
- 3y ago
- herodotus 3y agoI have a weekly Zoom call with a small group of photographers, or weekly one-to-one calls. I don't think I really need a centrally managed server for these - the scaling requirements are small. I would love a low-cost alternative where the host ran the server and it was always invitation only. Of course there would have to be simple client apps for MacOS, Windows, Linux, iOs and Android. If such a solution came along, I would use it and get rid of my monthly Zoom fee. PS: end-to-end encryption would be good....
- tomrod 3y agoJitsi?
- mxmilkiib 3y agoDoes Jitsi still have that problem with over a certain number of Firefox users making things lag or such?
- tomrod 3y agoPer the OP's mention, > I don't think I really need a centrally managed server for these - the scaling requirements are small I think that's not a concern for the use case. But, maybe?
- overgard 3y agoOne potential flaw I see with this thinking is why would I want to use a built-in video chat feature if I can just send a zoom link? If you've ever watched the thousands of parody videos of things that go wrong with meetings over video, we all know what a pain it is to get everything configured right -- right webcam, right microphone, not blasting people's ears off or being too quiet, knowing where the mute button is, etc. If I have all my Zoom stuff already set up, I don't think I really want to do that for each individual app unless they have some sort of super compelling feature. The only thing I can really think of off the top of my head is using AI to modify the video stream (where that's like the primary purpose of the app). But I don't know, that seems more frivolous fun than something truly compelling.
- zackkitzmiller 3y agoSkype is the skype of video. I couldn't even get passed that part.
- ttul 3y agoFor me, the best post-zoom thing is calls WITHOUT video. Video calling is extremely tiring. A couple of Zooms whacks me out for the rest of the day. Note that I am considered a “geriatric millenial” so your mileage may vary.
- ubermonkey 3y agoI work for a 100% remote company. We have lived in GoToMeeting sessions -- internally and with customers -- since inception, but we never, ever, ever turn on video. We use the meeting to share screens for joint testing, or investigation, or discussion of feature planning, or whatever. Video was never appealing; it'd just be a drag on the performance of the rest of the meeting. When COVID happened, some of our customers went all-in on Zoom and camera-on conferences, and couple of especially entitled ones suggested "we like it when cameras are on!", like they could passive-aggressive us into complying. Nah. Furthermore, for lots of work-at-home people, turning on video just CLOBBERS their whole connection because they're on like 10mb down/3 up or whatever.
- bipson 3y agoI fully agree, Video-calls are tiring. But I would say the same is true for all calls (where I cannot freely drift off or even work on something else). I would try to reduce the number of calls you're in :S
- joeyguerra 3y agoDiscord. Discord comes after Zoom.
- petra 3y agoIf you look at the social sciences research about video conferencing, it's clear that zoom is bad for creating trust between participants(even on a 1-1 call) and that phone calls do a better job than zoom in decreasing loneliness. So my guess is , whatever solves that problem comes after zoom.