7 ms·
Norway to fine Meta $98,500 a day over user privacy breach from 14 August
- _lvbh 3y agoNot enough
- weebull 3y agoEspecially as it only runs until November.
- codetrotter 3y agoIt’s funny because to me as a Norwegian, 1 million Norwegian kroner sounds like quite a lot per day. But that’s because I am using my personal income per year as reference. But to a company like Meta, this is probably pocket change.
- mnky9800n 3y agoThe last time this was posted someone did a back of the envelope calculation showing that this accounts for maybe 1/3 of all daily income from Norway so it is a sizeable amount that is proportional to everything.
- Marcan 3y agoStill not enough, if by a simple calculation they make 200,000$ of profits per day. The fine should be higher than the profit, period.
- varispeed 3y agoFine should be based on revenue, not the profit. If it's based on profit, then it is just cost of doing business.
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoFines should be proportional to the damage they deter and compensate for. Fixing fine to revenues means tech companies can make a mockery of the law, as penalties must be ruinous for every other industry or laughably low for tech’s margins.
- varispeed 3y agoFine fixed to profit will do no damage as oppose to fixed to revenue, because profit comes after all expenses so the fine will have no effect, apart from maybe hurting shareholders a little. I agree with your general sentiment though.
- frumper 3y agoShareholders are the owners of the company. I would think that's where you'd actually want the fines to hit. The shareholders should be responsible for putting in sensible leadership that doesn't get them fined.
- Snafuh 3y agoHow much are they making in Norway? Why would global revenue/profit be relevant for a fine in Norway about Norwegian users?
- lnxg33k1 3y agoBecause GDPR accounts for fines to be relative to global turnover https://gdpr-info.eu/issues/fines-penalties/ https://gdpr-info.eu/issues/fines-penalties/
- McDyver 3y agoIs there an instance where this was actually applied? We read about privacy related fines here and there, but none really seem to take into account the global revenue
- lnxg33k1 3y agoAs European I've lived through the crisis of 2008, when people were killing themselves due to lack of money and the only concern of EU was pleasing markets, save banks without any repercussions to those who caused all that pain, etc. I am aware that EU is a PR stunt, probably will make some regulation here and there, but nothing exceptional, it's still a neoliberal/corporativist sewer at the end of the day
- robertlagrant 3y agoThat doesn't mean it should always be applied. We shouldn't be attempting to annihilate companies. Just make sure the fine outweighs the benefit of doing something - just as we would with most fines.
- lnxg33k1 3y agoI am not sure we shouldn't try to annihilate companies, is a good strategy, or at least not for any company, Meta is useless for society and constantly lying, stealing, omitting, exploiting, endangering, we shouldn't be willing to annihilate companies who make mistakes, probably we should aim to annihilate companies which consistently behave at the edge of civilization
- kaliqt 3y agoWe're assuming that's profit and not revenue, two different things.
- NorwegianDude 3y agoIt's estimated to be around 15 % of Meta's daily income in 2021 from Norway.
- thumbuddy 3y agoProbably closer to dropped it on the ground but in too much of a hurry doing something else to pick it up money.
- runarb 3y agoFrom what I can remember from other cases here in Norway, the daily fines will be increased if the regulatory body sees that they do not have any effect. The goal here is compliance. So the regulators will first try guidance, then a formal warning, then daily fines, then increasing the fine, fine (local) directors personally, and finally dissolvent of Metas local company. Metas local company is named "Facebook Norway AS" and in 2022 did have a revenue of about 6.6 million USD, with a profit of 3.6 million USD according to https://www.proff.no/selskap/facebook-norway-as/oslo/reklamebyr%C3%A5er/IF5JLYW01DI/ https://www.proff.no/selskap/facebook-norway-as/oslo/reklame... . They have 27 employees. The revenue from Norway are however much bigger and was speculated to be 233 million USD in 2021: https://e24.no/naeringsliv/i/A3r1Mz/facebook-bokfoerte-bare-54-millioner-kroner-i-inntekter-i-norge-i-fjor https://e24.no/naeringsliv/i/A3r1Mz/facebook-bokfoerte-bare-...
- chx 3y agoThis is the thing: the corporate nuke as a tool is available in most jurisdictions -- how could it not be? -- but at place like Norway I can very well see it being used. There was talk California should've used it on Uber for Greyball.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> the corporate nuke as a tool is available in most jurisdictions “Corporate nuke” is a corporate lobbyist’s term for distracting from massive fines. Barring expropriation, once you ask what happens to the nuked assets, corporate death penalties all come down to massive fines with extra steps. If you want to “nuke” a corporation, revoke its licenses (not applicable here) or levy a massive fine.
- gmerc 3y agothese fines need exponential escalation over time to work.
- BiteCode_dev 3y agoWith a little jitter to make sure the fining system don't get overloaded by all those criminal companies.
- arcticbull 3y agoNorway is the home of wealth-based speeding tickets. I'm confident it's not just a flat rate with no additional recourse options.
- NorwegianDude 3y agoWell, that's not at all true... Speeding tickets are high, but they are the same for everyone.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- alkonaut 3y agoI think that's Finland
- arcticbull 3y agoYeah I knew there were some high-profile Finnish cases, the Nokia guy in particular. [1] I did some cursory looking before I posted to because I thought Norway had it too, looks like they have wealth/income based fines for drunk driving, not speeding. [2] [1] https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2015/03/finland-home-of-the-103000-speeding-ticket/387484/ https://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2015/03/finland... [2] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/nov/17/norwegian-heiress-katharina-g-andresen-23000-pound-drink-driving-fine https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/nov/17/norwegian-heir...
- 3y ago
- Jamie9912 3y agoOr what? What is Norway gonna do? Force ISPs to blackhole DNS to Meta services?
- jakewins 3y agoWhat do you mean? They will pay the fine or the NO courts will extract them; Meta has legal entities with bank presence to charge for ads and (I assume) pay employees in NO.
- mongol 3y agoExactly. As Meta certainly wants to sell ads to Norwegian companies, this is inevitable.
- allisdust 3y agoWhat if they only accepts payments to their out of Norway bank accounts
- ben_w 3y agoUltimately they go to any friendly country where Meta does have an account and say to a local court "Meta broke our laws, here's the court ordered fine, make them pay up." This kind of thing, even though the details are different, is also why Kim Dotcom got arrested for violating US law despite not being in the US.
- sebzim4500 3y agoTrue, although the ability of the US to impose its will on New Zealand is probably much higher than the ability of Norway to impose its will on the US.
- ben_w 3y agoDoesn't need to be the USA directly, it could be anywhere in europe where Meta has assets. I'm also not sure if the courts in the US default to cooperating in such situations; I seem to remember something about Congress passing a law saying that Americans didn't need to pay fines for (libel?) imposed by (UK courts?) or something like that, suggesting that such was the default before then.
- amelius 3y agoThe cost of doing business.
- rvz 3y agoMeta makes more than that in a hour, which means that they can afford to continue these violations for a very long time. Instead fine them in the billions of dollars and at most in the tens of billions for repeated violations and privacy breaches just like what is happening to Google. [0] [0] https://www.theverge.com/2023/8/7/23823878/google-privacy-tracking-incognito-mode-lawsuit-summary-judgment-denied https://www.theverge.com/2023/8/7/23823878/google-privacy-tr...
- bjornasm 3y agoThis is a common misinterpretation of the story. Its not like Norway is the only country able to issue fines. Yes, Norways fines wont bring down meta. But how large will the fines become if rest of Europe follows their example?
- Closi 3y agoOn a global scale it's tiny, but on a regional scale it could really impact profitability. Assuming 85% of Norwegians have an account: * 98,500 a day = $35 million per year * $35 million / (5 million Norway population * 85% assumption) = $8 / year fine per Norway user. * I can't find Norway-specific revenue, but Meta's average revenue per user is $18 across Europe, but Norway could be higher than average. Outside Europe the highest is USA at $60. Assuming revenue / user is half way between this - $39 - this fine would be 20% of revenue. * $39 per user would mean total revenue of $200m in Norway. * Facebook turns 32 billion of revenue into 7.79 billion of net profit (24% of revenue to Net profit). This would mean profit of c£47m in Norway before the fine, and $12 billion after-fine. This is with a fairly optimistic view of revenue per user - at the Europe average of $18 per user it would be a loss of $13m. Another way to look at this is that if you population-adjust the fine to the world, it would be c$60 billion per year (although this is less accurate as it does not account for the fact that many regions have less users or are less profitable). Either way, Facebook can handle these fines in a handful of regions, but they can't handle these fines in all regions.
- phatfish 3y agoIt also feels like each country going after them using their own local GDPR enforcement (or equivalent) is better than some EU level action (if that is even possible). It ties up Meta resources having to make more legal challenges, and it probably happens faster as well. Just need EU countries to work together in a coordinated way so it starts having an effect on quarterly results. Rather than each fine being picked off one at a time.
- whimsicalism 3y agoMuch of the GDPR is fine and I think we are right to crackdown on cross-website tracking, but the recent attempts in Europe to basically ban behavioral ads of all kind (a reversion to newspaper style ads) is, in my view, clearly a protectionist effort aimed specifically at American companies because Europe feels they cannot compete (of course missing the fact that the adhoc, ex post facto & bill of attainder-style of regulation in Europe is a large part of the story of why they have been unable to compete) There are lots of small, niche businesses that literally could not exist without this targeting. e: Is the discussion in this thread really so without value that it should be hidden?
- LunaSea 3y agoSimply a tit-for-tat for all the EU companies that were sued in the US the last ten or fifteen years.
- valdiorn 3y agocan you elaborate? what companies? why did they get sued?
- LunaSea 3y agoSure: Airbus, Alstom and Technip are a few examples. They were usually sued for corruption in developing countries to obtain contracts. They were however sued in the US even though they are not headquartered there, had to pay huge fines that brought said companies to their knees and were later, surprisingly, bought by American companies.
- whimsicalism 3y agoOnly one of those was bought by an American company and also they literally were bribing politicians
- LunaSea 3y ago
- xwdv 3y agoFines like this are a nice little tax write off, just another business expense.
- runarb 3y ago> Fines like this are a nice little tax write off, just another business expense. The fines seem to be leveled at Meta's local company in Norway. As I understand it, fines are not deductible in Norway. (I am not an accountant, and my company has never gotten a find, but looking up this in the accounting system I use, it seems it is not deductible: https://kontohjelp.fiken.no/as/medMoms/7799?sok=7799 https://kontohjelp.fiken.no/as/medMoms/7799?sok=7799 ( in Norwegian)).
- xwdv 3y agoThere’s gotta be some financial engineering that ultimately results in deduction somehow.
- dghughes 3y ago> fines are not deductible in Norway. If a company tried I think it should be viewed as contempt of court. A company trying to get money back for which it was fined would basically be them thumbing their nose at the fine. Maybe that is why fines are not deductible.
- xwdv 3y agoSee that’s the thing about being a global company: You can pay off the fines in one country as part of an expense for a branch in another, where it can then be deducted from taxes in that foreign country. So yea, fuck you courts.
- hkt 3y agoCheap as chips. Meta will be pleased. I've said it before and I'll say it again: the only way to make fines have any teeth for companies like this is for states to fine companies in equity, not cash. Shareholders will force change if the state might realistically become the majority shareholder and in doing so dilute everyone else's holding. 1% a week per breach ought to do it.
- robertlagrant 3y agoMaking all companies state-owned might have some historically-evidenced downsides.
- hkt 3y agoThere's no reason they can't be sold off again. And well, we're living through a period where we're rapidly accruing evidence every day of how bad the alternative is. For what it is worth, I'd like to see companies like Meta, Alphabet, and Amazon turned into global cooperatives governed by their employees and users. These would be the largest democracies the world has ever seen and would almost certainly be governed more sensibly than they are today.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> no reason they can't be sold off again Just levy a fine. From the corporate death penalty to this stuff, it’s all just fines with financial engineering. Cut out the bankers and lawyers and just levy a bloody fine. Every problem you think you’re solving by adding extra steps simply compounds the complexity of levying massive fines while distracting from them.
- robertlagrant 3y ago> There's no reason they can't be sold off again. Of course there is: who would buy shares that can be stolen by the state? This is why moralisers shouldn't design systems: they miss even the most glaringly obvious consequences of their OTT punishments.
- chakhs 3y agoThe amount makes it sound like they just want to look like they did something without actually doing something
- deely3 3y ago~1 mln per 10 days, ~100 mln per year? Thats not so much, but its only Norway.
- sharts 3y agoWhy do countries fine so little for egregious problems. But then fine poor people a relatively insane amount for forgetting to put some change in a parking meter after it expires?