8 ms·
Orb is a free and open source web desktop
- metadat 3y agoIt doesn't seem to work properly on mobile - I can't get notepad.exe to open, and tapping to try clicking a box in 2048 does nothing. Unfortunate, because this looks nice. Demo site: https://desktop.leisink.net/ https://desktop.leisink.net/
- voytec 3y agoSomewhat more eleaborate than 2 sentences-long README would be welcome. Including a screenshot[1] there would be nice for a GUI project. BTW, I've been out of touch with PHP for years. How are its performance and security these days? [1] https://gitlab.com/hsleisink/orb/-/blob/master/screenshot.jpg?ref_type=heads https://gitlab.com/hsleisink/orb/-/blob/master/screenshot.jp...
- aspyct 3y agoPerformance is adequate, security is up to the dev.
- ale42 3y ago> security is up to the dev. As in basically any web app development... mostly independently of the chosen implementation language. PHP hast lost its insecure beginnings (like injecting variables using GET arguments...) since long.
- ChymeraXYZ 3y agoGeneral question: Is there an actual use for this kinds of projects, beyond showing what can be done? I have seen many different "web desktop" projects and while most of them were impressive in their own (technical) ways, I could never see the an actual use case for them.
- calini 3y agoMy Synology NAS uses something like this for its navigation and even if it's initially strange, you instantly miss it when you access it from your phone, when the UI turns into this nested list which is not intuitive at all
- oaiey 3y agoI personally hate this from Synology. While their apps are meaningful structured and look good, it is just a natural mismatch to put sub windows into a parent window. Anyone remembering multi sub window apps in the Microsoft office suite in the 90s/00s. Was also horrible without a browser/html involved. This is definitely a taste thing
- teddyh 3y ago> Anyone remembering multi sub window apps in the Microsoft office suite in the 90s/00s It was called MDI: <https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Multiple-document_interface&oldid=1121579532 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Multiple-document...>
- Propelloni 3y agoYes, and from day one Opera (when it was still called Multitorg) used it to give us something like "tabbed browsing". I think that was in the mid-1990s ;)
- ptx 3y agoStarOffice (precursor to LibreOffice) used to take this one step further and replicated the taskbar and start menu inside the application window: https://winworldpc.com/product/staroffice/5x https://winworldpc.com/product/staroffice/5x
- wpietri 3y agoYeah, same. I have a synology NAS and the desktop-of-windows-in-a-window aspect of it just seems archaic to me. I have a browser with tabs, thanks. If I really need two things going, I'll open two tabs or two browser windows.
- sneak 3y agoWhy don't we see more of these, given that canvas and webgl and fullscreen are a thing now? Shouldn't this have put Citrix et al out of business?
- jillesvangurp 3y agoBecause this is not actually useful in any way whatsoever. The point of citrix is accessing legacy desktop applications running on some server via a light desktop client. The whole point of that is not having to replace those legacy applications and not having to install them locally. The business is allowing companies that have ancient stuff being able to continue to use that. It's worth a lot of billions because lots of companies just have decades worth of software that their businesses depend on. You are right that citrix should be able to dumb down what they have to basically a glorified web application that accesses their servers. Which apparently is a thing for obvious reasons (as in they thought of that too, many years ago).
- DrScientist 3y agoI suspect the complicated bit of Citrix isn't the client, rather at the server end to manage multiple instances of apps running efficiently - where these apps are design to expect they own everything in the enviroment.
- oaiey 3y agoBest comment here. Never thought about if from that angle, considering my hate for window in window.
- BurningPenguin 3y agoIs it really being reset every few minutes? Because those open text editors seem quite... "interesting".
- yard2010 3y agoI had to go through too many windows to see a penis. The internet has changed
- BLKNSLVR 3y agoIt looks as if it remains constant as long as you remain connected, but it if you disconnect then reconnect, you will reconnect to a new / different session than the one you disconnected from - I'm assuming the 'old' one is lost as part of the reset.
- hliyan 3y agoI took a peek at the "Explorer" app code base. PHP + JS + jQuery, but surprisingly readable (but a lot of practices in there that are not exactly considered "best" today). Perhaps we have sunk too deep into the SPA/API rabbit hole that we can no longer appreciate simplicity. https://gitlab.com/hsleisink/orb/-/blob/master/public/apps/explorer/explorer.js?ref_type=heads#L420 https://gitlab.com/hsleisink/orb/-/blob/master/public/apps/e... https://gitlab.com/hsleisink/orb/-/blob/master/public/apps/explorer/explorer.php?ref_type=heads https://gitlab.com/hsleisink/orb/-/blob/master/public/apps/e...
- FpUser 3y ago>"but a lot of practices in there that are not exactly considered "best" today" Considered by whom?
- DGCA 3y agoI still identify with the “frontend developer” title, even though my skill set has grown beyond it. Best practices are framework dependent, the tooling one should choose is dependent on their problem space, and we do appreciate simplicity. No one is forcing people to use React, Svelte, Vue, etc. The sentiment of wishing for a simpler time has never felt right to me, cause no one is policing what people use. If you feel like people are forcing you into frameworks, I’m sorry, and I feel like I have a piece of advice. If you truly believe a framework isn’t worth it, tell your team why. You might be right, and you might be wrong. I’ve worked at large and small companies; discussions about what technologies to use have always been welcome. I’ve advocated for and won when making a case for “simpler solutions,” when it makes sense. All that said if you think using a framework framework === complexity for the sake of complexity, you’re wrong. OP I’m not saying you think this, but I have to imagine that it’s the sentiment of at least part of the folks who made this the top comment.
- Takennickname 3y agoWe are, indeed, in a world where Jquery is now the preferable choice. Frontend development is going through what video games went through in the 80s, so much new shovelware every day that people are eventually going to get tired of it.
- NayamAmarshe 3y agoI wonder how things would have been if we had JavaScript based WMs and DEs. I'd have loved an HTML/CSS supported DE, imagine the possibilities! and seeing how performance of web-based DEs is amazing, I really hope we can get a Linux distro with a HTML/CSS/JS based DE.
- James-Livesey 3y agoThis is what I've been working on with LiveG OS, whose desktop environment, gShell, is written in HTML/CSS/JS: https://liveg.tech/os https://liveg.tech/os The OS is also designed to run on mobile devices, so there's some cross-platform consistency between the system on desktop and mobile devices. It's currently designed to run web apps, but the hope is to also include support for typical Linux GTK and Qt apps (or any app that uses Xwindows) soon to aid daily driveability. The current release can't do much yet, but we'll be releasing our next Alpha version in about a week or two which include a few more useful features on top of what's already available on our site!
- NayamAmarshe 3y agoAwesome! Do you have a Telegram channel or a waitlist? I'd love to join!
- James-Livesey 3y agoWe don't have Telegram, but we do have a Discord community — the link to it is at the bottom of the website at https://liveg.tech https://liveg.tech!
- NayamAmarshe 3y agoSorry, discord is a NO NO for me. I think you should create an email waitlist, that would be a bit better :)
- James-Livesey 3y ago
- adlpz 3y agoThe demo was exactly what I expected. That being said, quite nice and responsive. Not sure yet what the general purpose desktop metaphor solves in-browser, but nice nonetheless.
- 3cats-in-a-coat 3y agoCheck Synology DSM. When all your access to a machine you use every day is over the web, having a GUI is really nice. And web is the most obvious way to deliver this GUI to you given there's no video card on the machine.
- 3cats-in-a-coat 3y agoFrom the bottom of my heart, close the damn windows.
- junon 3y agoVery strange, I was in high school I made a flash-based "web desktop" by the same name as a fun project. Funny coincidence.
- omgmajk 3y agoNice to see a C64 emulator in there, pretty fun!
- adr1an 3y agoHow does it compare to other similar tools? Is this like https://filebrowser.org/features https://filebrowser.org/features?
- Avlin67 3y agobut user don't need anymore a paint, a notepad and a clock...
- hulitu 3y agoSpeak for yourself :)
- ComodoHacker 3y agoTheir demo[0] session is actually shared among all visitors, with all expected consequences like spam, dickpics etc. 0. https://desktop.leisink.net/ https://desktop.leisink.net/
- rchaud 3y agoThat would explain why the demo login appears to have been disabled. The button is still there, but it tells me the auto-filled demo PW is incorrect.
- ComodoHacker 3y agoWorks for me, but ReadMe says: "The content of this demo account will be reset every 5 minutes."
- izoow 3y agoNot exactly the same thing, but I had good experience with KasmVNC. Despite having VNC in its name, it isn't fully compliant with the VNC protocol and doesn't support regular VNC clients. Instead, it exposes a web client that you can access to connect to the machine. It also felt surprisingly snappy and nice to use compared to my previous experiences with regular VNC. https://github.com/kasmtech/KasmVNC https://github.com/kasmtech/KasmVNC
- navotgil 3y agoThe Demo sandbox is completely unusable :(
- outsidetheparty 3y agoWent to the demo, instinctively used `cmd-w` to close one of the "desktop" windows, and was quickly reminded of one of the limitations of building an application like this inside a browser. Note to developer: you may want to add an `onbeforeunload` handler
- ranting-moth 3y agoROTFLMAO!
- gabereiser 3y agoI heard you can fix that with Alt+F4. Seriously though, this is my biggest gripe with building for the web. You are limited in interactions to what the browser allows and at the end of the day it’s an app inside a sandbox-ish container with an app inside a shadow-dom. WASM full-screen, full-hardware, experiences have yet to take root. It’s getting there.
- wcerfgba 3y agoThere have been a few of these over the years. The one I remember best was eyeOS: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EyeOS https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/EyeOS
- sangupta 3y agoThe demo login seems broken. I would suggest adding a video to the project's README.
- jrochkind1 3y agoI'm interested. No screenshots or docs of any kind linked to, just a demo, becuase "The demo account has temporarily been closed due to abuse. Come back soon." This is one reason why screenshots and docs are good!
- DustinBrett 3y agoI love seeing more web desktops as I think it's an amazingly fun side project. It's interesting to me seeing how far people will go with these. I've been working on mine for several years now. Also open source if anyone is interested in checking it out. https://github.com/DustinBrett/daedalOS https://github.com/DustinBrett/daedalOS
- lostgame 3y agoOne of my biggest pet peeves that frustrate me more about Open Source projects is this bizarre tendency not to put screenshots in the main description; especially for projects that are mainly UI/UX-based. I realize there's a demo, but what if I'm on mobile and I'm just curious as to what the project looks like; or what if I just want to see what it looks like before I try it out? Is it a nerd thing, where we're just kind of wrapped up so far in our own projects that we forget such a basic thing? Why does this happen so often? Genuinely asking.
- samsquire 3y agoI really like the idea of a web based desktop, but I would like to see innovation in the user interfaces of computers. One idea I am playing with is the idea of "thunking" behaviours on a graphical user interface by chaining together operations, like a typed runqueue. You can interact immediately with what is on the screen but you are presented with options as if the operation was successful and then you can queue up the next thing based on the result of doing that. EDIT: The idea is that we decouple updates of the GUI with execution and the types of the return values of previous operation. In other words, the types of every operation are known by the system in advance, so you know what data is available at any given point in time. A desktop which is like a real time strategy game.
- nrdgrrrl 3y ago[dead]
- axonasif 3y agoCheck out https://github.com/kalcaddle/KodExplorer https://github.com/kalcaddle/KodExplorer