6 ms·
The Earthsea Trilogy (2003)
- vector_spaces 3y agoMy favorite quote from the first book: “You want to work spells,” Ogion said presently, striding along. “You’ve drawn too much water from that well. Wait. Manhood is patience. Mastery is nine times patience. What is that herb by the path?” “Strawflower.” “And that?” “I don’t know.” “Fourfoil, they call it.” Ogion had halted, the coppershod foot of his staff near the little weed, so Ged looked closely at the plant, and plucked a dry seedpod from it, and finally asked, since Ogion said nothing more, “What is its use, Master?” “None I know of.” Ged kept the seedpod a while as they went on, then tossed it away. “When you know the fourfoil in all its seasons root and leaf and flower, by sight and scent and seed, then you may learn its true name, knowing its being: which is more than its use. What, after all, is the use of you? or of myself? Is Gont Mountain useful, or the Open Sea?” Ogion went on a half mile or so, and said at last, “To hear, one must be silent.”
- chromakode 3y agoThis is a concept I often draw upon in programming. To understand or create something you must learn its true name. If you don't know what to call the thing you're creating, it's a sign to step back and take a broader view. A good name can give you the power to work with huge ideas.
- PaulDavisThe1st 3y agoLast week I committed a change of a type name from "TimeThing" (always just a tentative placeholder) to "TimeDomainSwapper" precisely because I finally (?) understood what is was.
- chromakode 3y agoAs an Ardour subscriber and user for almost 2 decades, imagine my delight at seeing your reply! Thanks for all that you do.
- cfiggers 3y agoI like this. In a way, a program is a paragraph-length name for something.
- kedean 3y agoMy interpretation is that the name is the name. If you can't properly name, say, a class, then you don't truly understand it and don't have real power over it. And that's dangerous. Once you have full understanding of the code, the proper name should reveal itself. You didn't chose the name, it was simply not clear to you yet.
- dontmobile 3y ago[flagged]
- Nition 3y agoYou have done well at mimicking Le Guin's style here, but this isn't actually from Earthsea, is it? Did you write this yourself? Or this being Hacker News, did you ask an LLM to continue the except above? I don't think Le Guin would have said that reality as a complete concept is something like an unspeakable horror, and I'm not sure I like the idea of presenting a creative fictional except as if it's legitimate.
- dontmobile 3y ago[flagged]
- Smaug123 3y agoIt's not too surprising that the reviewer describes the setting as "Taoist". Ursula Le Guin has even published a translation of the Tao Te Ching. (I agree with everything in this review, and will probably grab my old and battered copy of the Quartet from my parents this weekend.)
- macrael 3y agoNit, it's not a translation since she did not speak Chinese. That said I adore her Tao and have read it a few times.
- dudinax 3y agoIronically Earthsea is almost exactly anti-Taoist. One of the key ideas in Taoism, that incidentally sets it way beyond Platonism, is the name that can be spoken is not the true name. LeGuin asks, "what if we could speak it?"
- mostlylurks 3y agoThere's a section in the Parmenides which addresses this particular idea, though as a part of a larger argument on the nature of the one. Later platonist / neoplatonist thinkers also occasionally had similar notions. It would be incorrect to say that this idea is absent from platonism.
- dudinax 3y agoBut it wouldn't be incorrect to say the idea was contrary to Platonism.
- jacknobody 3y agoThen we would have transcended earthbound, mortal illusion, and would also have transcended the need for speech... ??
- Smaug123 3y agoAh, I stand entirely corrected - cute framing!
- thesaintlives 3y agoLoved that series. Brilliant!
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoJust do not, under any circumstances, see any TV shows/movies based on it. I saw an animated one that ... was not perfect. I think there may be some live-action version out there, as well.
- philips 3y agoThis video essay about the Ghibli version is interesting and sad in a way. https://youtu.be/2FcxccVUN94 https://youtu.be/2FcxccVUN94
- aleph401 3y agoWow, I'm just impressed that this site has been active for over 30 years! (First review is dated 1992)
- dark_star 3y agoFrom _A Wizard of Earthsea_, the first book, near the end: And he began to see the truth, that Ged had neither lost nor won but, naming the shadow of his death with his own name, had made himself whole: a man: who, knowing his whole true self, cannot be used or possessed by any power other than himself, and whose life therefore is lived for life’s sake and never in the service of ruin, or pain, or hatred, or the dark. In the Creation of Éa, which is the oldest song, it is said, “Only in silence the word, only in dark the light, only in dying life: bright the hawk’s flight on the empty sky.”
- vidarh 3y agoOf course what started as a trilogy now contains 5 novels and a short story collection (the additional ones being Tehanu (1990), Tales from Earthsea (2001) and The Other Wind(2001)). In addition the there's the novella The Daughter of Odren (2014) and the short story Firelight (2018). The new novels are both familar and sufficiently different that it's hard to judge whether someone who liked the original series will still enjoy the new ones. Part of it reflects Le Guin's reassessing her own writing, and give the female characters more space; part of it is a change of pace, and more focus on the characters and less on classic fantasy tropes.
- bediger4000 3y agoI used to think that between Lord of the Rings, Earthsea, and Narnia, all of fantasy was tapped out. Harry Potter did nothing to dispel this idea. Only Grossman's The Magicians has proved my thinking wrong.
- OfSanguineFire 3y agoThe three classic works of fantasy you mention don’t have the twist (as in Vance’s Tales of the Dying Earth) where the seemingly fantastical world turns out to be a far-future version of our own world. Or, in Delaney’s Neverÿon series, a distant-past version. So, there was room for new developments in fantasy outside those big three you list. But I definitely understand your sentiment. I remember reading the first book of Stephen R. Donaldson’s “Thomas Covenant” series and quickly abandoned it because it followed Tolkien too closely.
- MattPalmer1086 3y agoAh, Covenant is really distinct from Tolkien. Not so much in the world building (giants, etc) but in the appalling pain and self obsession of Thomas Covenant. It took me 3 attempts to finish the first book, but after that I was hooked for the first two series.
- snowwrestler 3y agoThe first Covenant trilogy intentionally mirrors Tolkien in order to provide a familiar “fantasy” background against which to cast a completely non-fantasy character: Thomas Covenant, grumpy disbeliever. It’s an intentional choice. (The second trilogy abandons this constraint and is a much better fantasy story for it.)
- AlotOfReading 3y agoThere's lots of excellent fantasy out there beyond the big names. Wolfe's Book of the New Sun is a good example of a very creative series, though it can be much harder to read.
- 3y ago
- pdimitar 3y agoPlease don't be petty and don't me give me the gray treatment because we don't share tastes (I really am looking for some explanations of what might I have missed) but... I have to be dead-serious and honest here: I had huge trouble going through the 5 books at all. It was torturous 95% of the time. Only the first book was kinda sorta nice fantasy book, it dragged a bit but was full of promise and the world-building was nice. Sadly the ending I saw a mile away but was still semi-enjoyable until we got there. From then on though, it was just downhill, with each book getting harder and harder to read. Especially book 4 could basically be summarized as "the dark thoughts of an old woman, mixed once every 50 pages with the name 'Ged', the word 'garden' and the description of a disfigured girl". :( Like, don't crucify me please, but I could probably compress that book in 20 pages, easily, without skipping a single plot element. Book 5 was a slight improvement, all the underworld / dead people descriptions were pretty eerie and I managed to get some immersion. Was okay, though still very watered down and prolonged and sadly again, the ending was easy to guess. Books 2 and 3? I don't even remember them now. I only remember how extremely excruciatingly slow they were. In any case, I know there is always the universal will-never-go-anywhere cop-out of "it's just not for you, man" but I would still be interested if anybody can elaborate what made the book click for them. TL;DR I found the books extremely watered down, full of dark thoughts and rather meaningless stoicism, and Ged was basically a burned out veteran before he hits 30 years old which is a bit disappointing, isn't it? Not to mention, again, too much focus on the mental struggles of old people. And there isn't even any revelation or motivation anywhere, it's basically "life sucks man, what can you do". Before you ask or claim: I really like reading fantasy and I picked these books several years ago due to their reputation. And I was -- and I still am -- legitimately confused what's so great about them.
- EdwardCoffin 3y ago“If you have to ask what jazz is, you'll never know.” —Louis Armstrong.
- PaulDavisThe1st 3y agoI hate to contradict such an authority as Louis Armstrong, but as a general matter, he was wrong. There are plenty of people who consider themselves to play jazz, but are told by others that they do not. There are even a few people who don't consider themselves to play jazz, but are told by others that they do. The nature of "what jazz is" is (and likely always will be) an ongoing debate, just like its corrollary "what is jazz". If Louis had lived until the 2000s, I suspect he might have rephrased this: "If you care about what jazz is, you'll probably never know; you're not much likelier to know even if you don't care".
- vintermann 3y agoI think Le Guin radically reinterpreted her own work in the two followups to the trilogy. Spoilers, obviously. The original trilogy has interesting gender roles. One one hand it's very rigid in its ideas of gender, as you'd expect from someone into Taoism. On the other, those roles were far from one-dimensional. I'd say that it presents an unconventional, but surprisingly positive view of the masculine gender role in the wizards of Roke, and a grim but original and compelling view of death. Both men and women can be cruel, but even at their worst you don't necessarily lose sympathy for them. In Tehanu, that's all rolled back. There the men are evil, and the women are victims, period. And Ged kills a guy (which he didn't in the first three books) and gets to have sex right after, pretty explicitly as a reward - that was a bit of a "what the hell, author?" moment. And the grim afterlife is apparently the fault of those patriarchal wizards. It seems Le Guin was embarrassed at her earlier work that it wasn't feminist enough, or that it wasn't feminist in the right way. And maybe it wasn't Taoist enough either (I for one could never understand how she could combine those two). She's still a great storyteller, of course, so it's certainly possible to appreciate those books, just know that they're written 20 years later when the author had a completely different view of many things.
- nostromo95 3y agoTehanu is my favorite in the series; I'm sorry you feel that way! > And Ged kills a guy (which he didn't in the first three books) and gets to have sex right after, pretty explicitly as a reward - that was a bit of a "what the hell, author?" moment. Two people with a long-standing attraction having sex after a life-or-death experience seems completely natural to me. Your framing of them having sex BECAUSE Ged killed a man is a misrepresentation of what happens in the book.
- exmadscientist 3y agoIn the author's own words (excerpted from the Introduction to The Books of Earthsea, Complete Illustrated Edition, 2018): ... I have written so often of how and why it took me so long to write the six books of Earthsea that the story has become like the book you have to read to your four-year-old every night for weeks—You really want to hear it again? Oh well, okay, here goes! I wrote the first three books in five years: ’68, ’70, ’72. I was on a roll. None of them was closely plotted or planned before writing; in each of them much of the story came to me as I followed what I wrote where it inevitably led. I started confidently on the fourth book. The central character was Tenar again, of course, to balance it out. I knew she hadn't stayed and studied wizardry with Ogion, but had married a farmer and had children, and that the story was going to bring her and Ged back together. But by the middle of the first chapter, I realized that I didn't know who she was—now. I didn't know why she’d done what she’d done or what she had to do. I didn't know her story, or Ged’s. I couldn’t plot or plan it. I couldn’t write it. It took me eighteen years to learn how. I was forty-two in 1972; in 1990, I was sixty. During those years, the way of understanding society that we’re obliged to call feminism (despite the glaring absence of its opposite term masculism) had grown and flourished. At the same time an increasing sense of something missing in my own writing, which I could not identify, had begun to paralyze my storytelling ability. Without the feminist writers and thinkers of the 1970s and ’80s, I don’t know if I ever could have identified this absence as the absence of women at the center. Why was I, a woman, writing almost entirely about what men did? Why because I was a reader who read, loved, and learned from the books my culture provided me; and they were almost entirely about what men did. The women in them were seen in relation to men, essentially having no existence unrelated to male existence. I knew what men did, in books, and how one wrote about them. But when it came to what women did, or how to write about it, all I had to call on was my own experiences—uncertified, unapproved by the great Consensus of Criticism, lacking the imprimatur of the Canon of Literature, piping up solo against the universally dominant and almost unison chorus of the voices of men talking about men. Oh, well, now, was that true? Hadn't I read Jane Austen? Emily Brontë? Charlotte Brontë? Elizabeth Gaskell? George Eliott? Virginia Woolf? Other, long-silenced voices of women writing about both women and men were being brought back into print, into life. And my contemporary women writers were showing me the way. It was high time I learned to write of and from my own body, my own gender, in my own voice. The central character of The Tombs of Atuan is female, the point of view is hers. But Tenar is just coming out of adolescence, not yet fully a woman. I had had no problem in 1970 writing out of my own experience of what it is to be a girl-child, an adolescent girl. What I couldn't do then, and hadn’t yet done in 1990, was write a fully mature woman at the center of a novel. Strangely enough, it took a child to show me the way into the fourth book of Earthsea. A girl-child, born in poverty, abused, maimed, abandoned, Therru led me back to Tenar, so that I could see the woman she had become. And through Tenar I could see Earthsea, unchanged, the same Earthsea as eighteen years earlier—but seeming almost a different world, for the viewpoint was no longer from a position of power or among men of power. Tenar was seeing it all from below, through the eyes of the marginal, the voiceless, the powerless. The essay “Earthsea Revisioned,” reprinted in this edition, discusses that change in viewpoint. When Tehanu came out, a good many critics and readers saw it as mere gender politics and resented it as a betrayal of the romantic tradition of heroism. As I tried to say in the essay, not to change viewpoint would, for me, have been the betrayal. By including women fully in my story, I gained a larger understanding of what heroism is and found a true and longed-for way back into my Earthsea—now a very much greater, stranger, more mysterious place than it had ever appeared before. Though Tehanu is named for the child character, neither it nor the two books after it are books “for children” or definable as “young adult.” I had abandoned any attempt to suit my vision of Earthsea to a publisher’s category or a critic’s prejudice. The notion that fantasy is only for the immature rises from an obstinate misunderstanding of both maturity and the imagination. So, as my protagonists grew older, I trusted my younger readers to follow them or not, as and when they chose. In the PR-driven world of publishing, that constituted a real risk, and I am very grateful to the editors who took that risk with me. ...
- dudinax 3y agoThe second trilogy is great. The last book is a masterpiece of an author reexamining her own work from within her work.
- fmajid 3y agoI’d say The Farthest Shore is not a “children’s book” either, nor arguably The Tombs of Atuan.
- jacknobody 3y agoI think the world is fast-tracking to hell, right now. Le Guin's protagonists know spiritual effort and reward, and her novels encourage me to believe that there's more, and better, to be gained in life than material gain at the expense of my fellows.
- DubDouble 3y agoI just... like an hour ago... bought the Far Shore.