8 ms·
Will browsers be required by law to stop you from visiting infringing sites?
- avidiax 3y agoI doubt it. It's much easier to make the ISP's block DNS, and perform deep packet inspection. Require domestic TLS to chain to the government's root-CA, so you have to allow government MITM. Trying to force this in the browser is too difficult technically, and too easy to circumvent.
- ravenstine 3y agoAlso, corporations and governments should be careful what they wish for, because an iron fist may eventually convince a substantial number of people to either use alternative DNS servers or use Tor and [hopefully] I2P. Possibly not the majority, but enough that any overzealous IP-protection measures on the clearnet will be self-defeating.
- Retric 3y agoI think that’s optimistic, China etc also crack down on VPN’s and related technology. You can also subtly discourage such things. Add a few random lag spikes to all encrypted traffic and see how people respond.
- guerrilla 3y agoAnd then they'll ban those. Don't forget that in the end the state has a monopoly on violence.
- kibwen 3y agoIn the case of US users and Tor, the situation is more complicated. The US military encourages Tor use because it helps to mask their own traffic (Tor was developed by the US Navy for this purpose, after all). It's unclear who would prevail in a political struggle between the copyright cartels and the military.
- vinceguidry 3y agoYep, at the end of the day what prevents tyranny from taking over everywhere is the fact that the ruling class has to live in the same world and use the same economy as everyone else. You see this dynamic up and down the government. Big business needs to be able to access machines that don't have all this locked-down crap. I'm not super-worried about the copyright lobby's fervent wish to make it impossible to use a general purpose machine. They're going to eventually run right up against corporate America's full-throated embrace of open source. Sure, ordinary people already are heavily spied on and restricted. But the machines doing the spying and restricting have to run their own OSes as well. The inverse of the 'who watches the watchers' problem.
- hattmall 3y agoWith 20,000+ non-statw homicides in the US last year it's hardly a monopoly.
- Kamq 3y agoYeah, they misquoted the original phrase. It's supposed to be monopoly on _legitimate_ violence. Which is why organized crime and vigilantism are generally so much higher up on a government's priority list than single acts of violence. They represent legitimate threats to the government.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pessimizer 3y agoThey represent subgovernments. All governments are overgrown street gangs. Royalty in Europe are the descendants of Roman generals who divided up the land between them after Rome fell.
- Kamq 3y agoI've always conceptualized them as competing governments personally (or, possibly, potential governments), not subgovernments myself.
- zlg_codes 3y agoViolence isn't a market, and continuing to parrot that nonsense gives a false credibility to forces which amount to efficient bullies that entrenched themselves by enslaving or genociding native populations. None of us signed actual social contracts, none of us signed forms agreeing to be governed. Violence is a choice that no government can take away. They can only threaten violence of their own. What validity does a government have when it claims it has the sole right to hurt others, including you? That is a fiction that led to the current state of things. What right does sovereignty give a state to oppress its people?
- guerrilla 3y ago> What right does sovereignty give a state to oppress its people? None, I'm just telling you what will happen. The argument was not that people consented, but that first they'll outlaw circumvention and then hunt you down for continuing to try. The point is that there is no technological solution to oppression. Some people here have a certain naïveté that everything can be solved with technology but that view ignores actual power in the actual world.
- pessimizer 3y agoThis is a silly objection. The reason the state has a monopoly on violence is because it took a monopoly on violence, through the application of violence and threats of violence. > What right does sovereignty give a state to oppress its people? Rights are given by states. Without states, you don't have rights, only capabilities. Rights come into existence when an alliance with a lot of capacity for violence imposes rules on the people within its reach that it allows itself to be bound by. Governance is not a contest where you are awarded rule for being the best, or a trial where a wise man gives governance to those who deserve it. Governance doesn't care if you give it "credibility" or what "social contract" you have signed unless it decides itself that it cares about those things. The only credibility that a government needs is your belief that it will unleash violence upon you if you do not do what it says. You have rights under government. Governments themselves don't need rights, unless they are subgovernments of more powerful governments that have granted them. Don't retreat into abstractions and fantasy. You can't defeat fascism by proving it wrong; it's not a Star Trek computer.
- almostnormal 3y ago> Don't forget that in the end the state has a monopoly on violence. People have a monopoly on casting votes.
- vbezhenar 3y agoWhen Kazakhstan tried to MITM with untrusted certificate, Google quickly blacklisted this certificate. Hopefully it'll do the same for any other government or company, so nobody would even think of it.
- paganel 3y ago> Hopefully it'll do the same for any other government or company, so nobody would even think of it. The security services in my country, Romania (an EU and NATO member), are already doing that, or something similar to that. For example trying to access https://sputnikglobe.com/ https://sputnikglobe.com/ sort of times out, either way, it doesn't work.
- 8organicbits 3y agoLooks normal to me: https://www.ssllabs.com/ssltest/analyze.html?d=sputnikglobe.com https://www.ssllabs.com/ssltest/analyze.html?d=sputnikglobe.... Can you clarify what you mean?
- paganel 3y agoThat website (and others like it) is blocked in my country based on a political decision. Interesting that the guys from the Romanian secret services aren’t doing that by messing with security certificates, but the website is blocked nonetheless.
- computerfriend 3y agoSounds like they're sniffing the SNI header and blocking based on its value. Completely unrelated to the Kazakhstan root CA fiasco.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- leesalminen 3y agoThey could do that because Kazakhstan doesn’t make them much, if any, money. This amounted to cheap good will marketing. If this were the EU or US, and Google risked losing access to that market, they would comply. Way too much money on the table.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoThe browser already has built-in controls to prevent the user from visiting "dangerous" sites, and to say that "browser or DNS or SPI" is mutually exclusive is to ignore the Defense in Depth strategy of using all methods in concert, to ensure that at least one will catch the bad requests. In Chrome, it's called "Safe Browsing", and it's currently optional, Standard, or Enhanced.
- _trampeltier 3y agoSo a list with all blocked sites is distributed to all browsers. Sounds like a good idea.
- cabirum 3y agoIn theory, an easy workaround would be a clean fork stripped of blacklists etc. But that is why there is an effort to introduce drm in browsers: to make you unable to use unsigned/non-lcomplying browsers to use the web at all.
- ezfe 3y agoA non compliant website wouldn’t care about that though
- rolph 3y agoA non compliant website wouldn’t be indexed as well.
- izzydata 3y agoSounds like this would spawn an entire second internet.
- malermeister 3y agoTor already exists!
- izzydata 3y agoThat seems more encrypted then would be necessary. There would be the locked down DRM verified by Google internet then there would be the internet that just requires an open source browser and only works to get to all the non-DRM internet websites. Basically you would simply do nothing to DRM your site and you'd automatically become part of the open internet rather than the DRM internet.
- mattnewton 3y agoAfraid to point this out, less people get the idea to enforce web integrity at the ISP level, like some of the efforts against music piracy / torrenting.
- mkoryak 3y agoIs wget and curl next? Seems like a really flawed approach.
- GuB-42 3y agoWget and curl mostly likely don't count. Browsers are explicitly defined as applications for end-users, which wget and curl are typically not. The idea here is to make it harder for the public to access banned websites. Tech savvy people will be able to recompile their browser from source anyways, just like they can easily work around DNS-based blocking and pretty much every blocking attempt, even the "great firewall". It is mostly a punishment for services that don't comply with the rest of the law. By blocking it in the majority of browsers, it will drive away a lot of traffic. Anyways, I don't expect that part of the law to pass, and if it does, it will be very unlikely to be enforced, France is a major economy, but I don't think it has the international power to do that, call me back when the entire EU or the US is on it.
- pessimizer 3y ago> Browsers are explicitly defined as applications for end-users, which wget and curl are typically not. By no coherent definition, though. Just by professional convention.
- GuB-42 3y agowget and curl give out html files, these are useless to the end user unless they are opened with other software, typically a browser. I don't know of any online service that expects end users to use something like wget and curl, maybe in niche cases, or for personal use, but I don't think it can be considered a primary use case for these software.
- Zuiii 3y agoWhat if I write a small proxy that uses wget in the backend[1] to fetch files and only use browsers to render the webpage/resources? Blocking at this level makes little sense. The French government is shooting itself in the foot (as usual). [1] which I would absolutely do if legislators are stupid enough to pass this law. No one gets to control what I read.
- zarzavat 3y agoIronically at the same time as the Digital Markets Act makes it legal to use third party browsers on the only platform this could affect: iOS. Missed the boat much?
- harha 3y agoThat's pretty bad - I don't think it's a good government pattern to move policing to corporations or the population. It messes quite badly with established principles such as innocent until proven guilty because corporations or individuals won't want to face the risk and it's also inefficient for each entity to figure out a process (and implement that badly).
- version_five 3y ago[flagged]
- harha 3y agothat and KYC
- croes 3y agoWhich one?
- lampshades 3y agoI'm assuming he's referring to the constant attempts at suppression of information.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- croes 3y agoMuch of this information was also BS. The vaccinated are still pretty much alive and didn't die because of AIDS
- cscurmudgeon 3y ago1. That is not the point. Truly liberal and progressive societies should tolerate and be immune to disinformation without censorship. 2. What is known to be false now may be true later (and vice-versa). No matter how big the govt. or a company gets, it won't be omniscient. 3. Remember the well documented flip flop about masks. At one point, CDC/Fauci were the ones spreading disinformation. During the flip-flop, real information was censored. Also, the lab leak theory was initially ruled out to be 100% impossible and heavily censored, now the same folks are saying that it might have been possible.
- pmarreck 3y agoA wonderful idea if we could always know that the government was always a good actor acting in good faith. Since that is impossible, this is not a wonderful idea.
- petermcneeley 3y agoAre banned books good ideas? Maybe the ring of power is in of itself a bad thing.
- pessimizer 3y agoYou can ban books and censor websites however you want as long as you are a good person acting in good faith i.e. me.
- brudgers 3y agoPassing a law would be too much work. Easier to just get it adopted as a W3C standard as with past DRM lockdowns. That way all the browser manufacturers are just following orders. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Encrypted_Media_Extensions https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Encrypted_Media_Extensions
- zlg_codes 3y agoThis is precisely why I turn a skeptical eye to any standards efforts. Just like with law, if you control the spec, you control the ecosystem.
- xyzzy4747 3y agoThis law would inadvertently be a good thing for the open source movement.
- rdl 3y agoThis would cross a line in the US where there would be 1A challenges, although there have been other stupid things accepted which are even more obviously unconstitutional. If they do this, I hope they do it on a very broad basis so the vast majority of people evade and it feels "normal", followed by legal, electoral, or other action to address the underlying problem.
- Nifty3929 3y agoUsually corporations are used to side-step 1A protections, because corporations are not subject to the 1A. Corporations were routinely "encouraged" to censor information throughout the last election and covid, at least. It was likely going on before that, and continues today.
- MarkPNeyer 3y agoVivek Ramaswamy argues that these actions are still first amendment violations because the government pushed corporations to do this, under something called “state action in private enterprise.”
- simple-thoughts 3y agoYes, but while it takes years to work these cases through the courts USG can continue rights infringement with no consequences for its staff. And once the court cases rule against USG, it can either ignore the case or find new workarounds. 1A only works with popular support that it doesn’t have, most people only support free as in beer.
- Kapura 3y agoFeels like this would be akin to requiring a car manufacturer stop the car if it detects you trespassing. Feels both intrusive & difficult to enforce, which is always a horrifying combo.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoe-Scooters and eBikes are already geofenced in this way. For example, speed limited to 5mph if you're in the wrong place (happened to me on a 35mph road) or they'll stop altogether if you enter a college campus, or attempt to leave the service area.
- kortilla 3y agoRentals yeah, but not the ones you own.
- warkdarrior 3y agoYou don't own software, not even open source software. You just license it.
- pessimizer 3y agoNah, you own free software. The problem is that you don't own the bike if they don't let you swap out and edit the software at will. If somebody sells you a safe but doesn't allow you to open it, they haven't sold you a safe, they've let you hold theirs.
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agohttps://xkcd.com/1150/ https://xkcd.com/1150/
- javajosh 3y agoInstead of passing a law, the French government should publish a blacklist and encourage their citizens to use it.
- BLKNSLVR 3y agoThe French government has been covering itself in glory of late hasn't it?
- dsign 3y agoI've been writing some science fiction that interpolates where things are going with the Internet and online surveillance (ala 1984 v2), but reality always trumps fantasy; this one hadn't occurred to me.
- freefaler 3y agoCory Doctorow has a prescient talk: "The coming war on general computation" from 2011 (12 years ago) in which he argues that all general computing platforms (OS, phone OS, browser) would face challenges by governments and corporations. This looks like another way to control content distribution and put more control in Google's hands. They've made a great strategic choice in building Chrome browser and effectively superseded Microsoft and Apple on desktops as a platform. The talk can be found here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HUEvRyemKSg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HUEvRyemKSg When people have means to consume or produce content without control any governmental bureaucrat will try to control this activity. History supports this argument. No printing press > no cheap books > illiterate population > easy to control what spreads as information and what do not. Printing press arrived > cheap books > growing literacy > control over the presses. Lenin's first targets were the post/telegraph (communication), bridges and railways (movement of people) and all big printing houses (Lenin's Full Collected works - vol. 32, page 282) Radio arrived > Fixed Frequencies Radio sets sold & Governmental Radio jamming stations TV > Licence to broadcast Internet > Big Firewall of China & etc... And don't even think about moving money freely as experienced by requirement to show why are you paying someone and those nice people from bank compliance departments. The cost of enforcement in digital economy is way cheaper than before. The tools are there or can be built cheaply and sadly they're only built one way, from the government to the people. Open governmental data and strong society control over governmental actions is almost non-existent. "Brave new world" is here. There should be a way to support important open-source projects with fundraising drives for features and etc ... Open source is one of the very few ways to sustain important digital freedoms.
- Nifty3929 3y ago"more control in Google's hands." I'm much more worried about more control in the government's hands. In theory at least, there can always be browser or search alternatives. And even if not widespread there will be options for motivated individuals who want a more permissive browser and internet experience. But I can't escape the government - certainly not without the risk of imprisonment or other legal trouble. I don't want to be controlled by either corporations or the government, but more and more they seem one-in-the-same. The government uses corporations to administer the control, with the force of law to back it up. As in this case - this is censorship that the government wants, but they force browser companies to administer that censorship under penalty of law.
- meindnoch 3y agoPlease do it, by all means! It's high time we go back to Gopher.
- notPlancha 3y agoSo is this a counter example to Betteridge's law of headlines
- sneak 3y agoThe browsers all already have a centralized, real-time censorship registry. It's called "Safe Browsing" and run by Google and is used to block "malicious software". Everyone (incl Safari and Mozilla) uses it. It's got something like five billion clients. Occasionally, there are false positives and you hear people screaming about it on HN because their personal site is now a giant red malware warning in 99.9% of browsers. Google AFAIK has not yet been compelled to use it to censor at the behest of the state. It has existed now for many years.
- stainablesteel 3y agosounds like a censorship mechanism i'm certain that any website "suspected" of breaking the law will go through multiple bureaucratic hurdles where they need to prove their innocence to a committee, as opposed to someone else proving their guilt in a courtroom. in the mean time, sorry, your website is blocked because its election season and we don't want this information getting out right now.
- im3w1l 3y agoI'm sorry, but even that is too optimistic. Your website will be banned and they wont tell you why. They will provide an appeal button that says denied when you press it.
- xadhominemx 3y agoThis is easily achievable already and yet it is not happening. So consider that you are wrong?
- im3w1l 3y agoThat's because there isn't much legal pressure on browsers to censor. The pattern I described can be seen where there is such pressure.
- perihelions 3y ago- "There were ways, of course, to get around the SPA and Central Licensing. They were themselves illegal. Dan had had a classmate in software, Frank Martucci, who had obtained an illicit debugging tool, and used it to skip over the copyright monitor code when reading books. But he had told too many friends about it, and one of them turned him in to the SPA for a reward (students deep in debt were easily tempted into betrayal). In 2047, Frank was in prison, not for pirate reading, but for possessing a debugger." https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.en.html https://www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.en.html ("The Right to Read" (1997)) It was a very short time ago when ideas in this concept-space were, like, "this is colorfully paranoid nonsense and RMS needs to cut back on the acid", and not, like, "well obviously governments are going to do something like this, that's expected and normal".
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pixl97 3y agoThe entire AI thing has lead to creators going full Right to Read mode recently asking for insane levels of copyright protection, which had they been under, would likely have had issues with their own stories. Too many people want a locked down future and it's scary.
- Ferret7446 3y agoPeople will always prioritize their own interests. "It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it." This is going to be invective, but creators who feel insecure are naturally going to lash out against anything that they perceive to affect their income and/or reputation/image. Great creators, great creations benefit from open sharing, per Gabe Newell's well-known quote. There will always be piracy, but that doesn't impact the creator because people who like a work want to support the creator if they can afford to. Fear of piracy comes from insecure creators, and that insecurity comes from the lack of skill or perceived lack of skill. To put it bluntly, content creation is extremely oversaturated and most people don't create things that justify their price. I wish they could do what they love and not worry about sustaining themselves, but economic reality is economic reality.
- m-p-3 3y agoLaws are only as strong as the enforcement can be. For commercial entities the government can go for financial or operational penalties to encourage compliance, at least if they operate commercially in the country in question. But for open-source web browsers, which might not have any commercial entities operating in the country, how could they even enforce that law? There's nobody to punish, nobody to coerce.
- donmcronald 3y ago> But for open-source web browsers, which might not have any commercial entities operating in the country, how could they even enforce that law? They’ll put something like a WEI token outside of the encrypted payload and force ISPs to refuse transit for anything that’s not attested by the “good guys”.
- chopin 3y agoWhich encrypted payload?
- donmcronald 3y agoWeb traffic (https). Think of an “anonymized” attestation token in the same place as SNI.
- the8472 3y agoMuch simpler: They'll make WEI-verification mandatory for all government sites. And then banking. And then anyone doing commerce.
- trinsic2 3y agoIf I was a browser developer and that law passes, I would just block France from downloading our browser. Solve that problem right there. Maybe they would stop Microsoft's ridiculous strategy to integrate their browser into the operating system.
- slim 3y agoof course they will. keyword here is "infringing websites" which means there is such a thing as "illegal information" and that law enforcement must prevent you from accessing that information
- pessimizer 3y agoThere's absolutely no way that the West could go back to the long ago dark days of "illegal information" way back in [checks watch] 1995. Of course, in 1995 I could download the Anarchist Cookbook; hell, I could buy it at the bookstore. I'm starting to suspect that secret police were always focused on illegal information, surveillance, and the prevention of communication between potential conspirators.
- jdjdjdhhd 3y agoHopefully no... But seeing government actions I would say yes... Fuck the way the web is going
- tuetuopay 3y agoWhile I’m proud my country has made it to the HN frontpage, I’m ashamed that it’s always for the wrong reasons :( Of course this law will pass, like all the authoritarian bullshit other laws that did the past few years. Remember the one about the government legally using your phone’s camera and mic? This was mere months ago.
- maerF0x0 3y agoThe absurd thing about this is that a browser is just a single kind of IP client. If you want to stop that content you have to actually stop IP connections to the host IP address(es), and to all non-compliant IP addresses (vpn / tor servers) . It'd make more sense to have the ISP do it, as they actually could have a meaningful effect on what you can / cannot connect to.
- forinti 3y agoIt does not make sense: you would need region-locked browsers. That's already an impossible target. But then how would you deal with people just using proxies, VPNs, ssh tunnels? It would just be easier for a government to block these sites at the ISPs as the article mentions and even that could be circumvented if the site is in another country.
- SergeAx 3y agoI am eager to see how they going to enforce these requirements on a locally built fork of Firefox.
- Incipient 3y agoOne thing I like to think about, when we debate these "how could this be abused?" laws...is how many unrealised futures we've already missed, both good and bad, when enacting laws. Eg if absolutely no one fought for net neutrality, would we be in a world where we're all comfortable with IPSs dropping traffic "they don't like". I do realise this example probably isn't far enough in the past to truly have had a cultural impact like this, but you get the point.
- jj999 3y ago"Cruelty and injustice, intolerance and oppression. And where once you had the freedom to object, to think and speak as you saw fit, you now have censors and systems of surveillance coercing your conformity and soliciting your submission. How did this happen? Who's to blame? Well certainly there are those who are more responsible than others, and they will be held accountable, but again truth be told, if you're looking for the guilty, you need only look into a mirror. I know why you did it. I know you were afraid. Who wouldn't be? War, terror, disease. There were a myriad of problems which conspired to corrupt your reason and rob you of your common sense." -- V for Vendetta