6 ms·
Italy is betting big on train travel
- veave 3y agoThe title mentions "climate change" but then the article says nothing about how Italy is "grappling" with it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- alanfranz 3y agoThis spring/summer we’re experiencing floods, frequent and intense thunderstorms, and extreme heat. All together, depending on the day and the region. Last year we suffered an absurd drought.
- Pepe1vo 3y agoA couple of week ago the south part of the country was dealing with near record high temperatures, while the north was dealing with floods.
- rsynnott 3y agoI mean... the author might just assume that most readers will be aware of recent events in Southern Europe; it doesn't really seem necessary to belabour the point. The curious can look it up fairly easily. If every news article had to go into full detail on every point that most people know anyway, they'd end up kind of ungainly. "A train is a large motorised vehicle which runs, generally on a regular schedule, on steel tracks. Steel is an alloy of iron and carbon. An alloy is..." Beyond people who actually still deny climate change (they're still out there, though, perhaps unsurprisingly, in the developed world they're concentrated in the US, Canada, and Australia, all big fossil fuel producers... "It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his salary depends on his not understanding it"), I don't think many people would argue that it's not a _fairly significant issue_ for Southern Europe.
- inglor_cz 3y agoI took the Frecciarossa twice this May and the ride was extremely enjoyable. What wasn't as enjoyable were the prices - on order to get a reasonable price, you need to book your trip weeks in advance. For adult business passengers, this is tolerable, but for families with kids ... ? If the trains are full (and, judging from my experience, they are), there need to be more of them.
- LaurensBER 3y agoPart of the issue with public transport is also very much a service issue. Switzerland has a fantastic "Easy ride" system where you swipe a button in an app to check-in and swipe it at your destination to check-out. It automatically combines trips and applies any relevant discounts. In The Netherlands you can check-in using a bank card so you don't even need an app. If we want to encourage people to use public transport more, we need to have such a system Europe wide. Grabbing a train should be more convenient than booking a flight, for a family with kids, making a reservation weeks in advanced , at a specific time isn't always reasonable and it's definitely not convenient.
- xenonite 3y agoMaybe this works in Switzerland, where delays are rare. But in Germany, where delays are frequently more than one hour, EU law requires the train company to pay back a part of the price because of the delay. But if you cannot show when you would have arrived with no delays, because you used such an app, it does make such an app unattractive.
- k8sToGo 3y agoEasyRide is quite buggy and at the end you still have to double check if what they charged is right.
- tremon 3y agoThe Netherlands you can check-in using a bank card How does that work for a family with kids? FAFAIK you can't check in twice using the same card, so does every child need its own bank card or travel pass? In that case, when travelling with a group, I'd choose the app over a stack of plastic cards any day.
- julkali 3y agoSaying this as a non-Italian, instead of focusing on (presumably) pricey train tickets targeting tourists, they should rather extend the common network which is also accessible and usable to the population without a tourism-adjusted overprice ...
- kwhitefoot 3y agoAlso non-Italian here. In my experience of a few years ago local trains in Italy are quite cheap, certainly much cheaper than the UK.
- thefz 3y agoSaying this as an Italian, we never had so much choice and fast, reliable trains.
- jaclaz 3y agoSaying this as an Italian, your statement misses a [1]. In the last 20-30 years there have been huge improvements on a handful of (highly trafficated) routes, and a corresponding amount of worsening in all the rest. Besides the so-called "digital divide" (widely different possibilities of access to the internet depending on your location), there is a clear "railroad divide", the biggest/main cities are well connected, all the rest is at the same level as (or worse than) the '60's (or even earlier). There is a way to draw maps abstracting from geometrical projections (anamorphic), based on some given parameters, if you choose "travel time by train" what you will get will be a "time cartogram" where Italy is very short (north-south) but very, vey thick (west-east). [1] on selected routes
- Iulioh 3y agoAs an Italian lving in the northern part of the country: The trains are used pretty extensively and they works. The Trenitalia has fixed fares on the low speed lines (so no need to buy them weeks before) and are resonably priced. I the south...EH. Would use them only for an extensive trip (from a big city to another big city) But by nature Italy HAS to use a lot of air travel as the country is very long and that's problematic. (don't forget than Sicily has 5M people and the 2 main airports see 9M people transit a year)
- kefabean 3y agoThe problem is that many tourists will still arrive and depart by air. Whilst there are some new cross continent routes coming online, overnight rail routes have been in decline since the 1990s. It takes quite a bit of persistence to make this work especially if travelling with a young family. For example travelling from London to Rome (although surprisingly can be done in a day) takes 16 hrs and involves 3 changes including slogging across Paris. https://www.seat61.com https://www.seat61.com is a good resource for planning trips involving European train travel.
- pluc 3y agoThis will be the case until trains are cheaper than airfare. AMS to FCO is around $100 by air. The train from Frankfurt to Basel alone is that price and about a quarter of the journey.
- Iulioh 3y agoI would LOVE to take a train but even IF it would cost the same I would still buy an airplane ticket because for the router I usually take I only have to fly for less than 2h instead of 14h-21h for the train route. And taking the train for that does THINGS to your body. It would have to be way cheaper to convince me. Like the airplane ticket costs usually 70-120€
- gbear605 3y ago> The train from Frankfurt to Basel alone is that price No? Maybe if you’re trying to book tomorrow, or at a very specific time, but looking on RailEurope for an arbitrary date (September 1), I see plenty of tickets for under $50. On the other hand, trying to go the whole way from Amsterdam to Rome does get a lot more impractical, because of all the transfers making the trip take around 24 hours, but you can get tickets for only around $150. I do agree that if you live in Amsterdam, it’s probably worth it to just fly to Rome because of a lack of good direct routes. Other routes that are about the same distance are a lot more feasible though. Paris to Rome can be done with only one stop, for example.
- 3y ago
- alanfranz 3y agoIn the last 10y, train service quality in Italy has improved quite a lot; Frecciarossa and Italo are great services. That’s when it works. What is really terrible about trains in Italy is disruption handling. You won’t know that your train is late until it’s very late already. Sometimes you’ll be sold tickets for trains that have been canceled already. Getting money back or trips replaced is a nightmare. From a UX point of view it seems we got the happy path working right, but anything else is absolutely bonkers. Source: italian regularly using italian trains.
- IshKebab 3y agoThat's one think the UK does almost right. Getting money back for a trip is relatively easy. You can do it online. I say almost though because a) every operator has their own web page to submit refund requests through (why??) and b) a train has to be 30 minutes late before you get anything. What a joke.
- switch007 3y agoThe government is making the railway actively hostile now, now they directly control large parts of it. That includes lying to deny Delay Repay claims and accusing people of fraud claims. (Ditto refunds for abandoned journeys) This shouldn’t put anyone off, quite the opposite. Be prepared to push for what you’re entitled to. If you need any assistance then http://railforums.co.uk http://railforums.co.uk is full of experts willing to help. (Btw some train operators have 15 minutes as the minimum delay (eg Avanti))
- dbetteridge 3y agoProbably because every operator is its own independent private entity. No shared infra.
- IshKebab 3y agoNonsense, they have a ton of shared infrastructure. I can buy tickets without caring which operator it is. Why can't I get a refund in the same way?
- bluGill 3y agoThis is what results from building train systems cheaply. You can afford to build a lot and thus get a large network. The rest of the world (worst in English speaking areas, but even France or Japan are not great, they have been building for years so there are some results but they could do more) spend so much money building that they cannot afford to build a lot of rail and so their network suffers. The cheaper you can build the more you can build, and the smaller the city you can get to. This larger network means people can get more places and so they are more likely to use your train. If you want this in your country you need to demand cost control. Politicians shouldn't be be choosing routes, opening large stations, or any of the other things they do or allow that increase costs.
- Knee_Pain 3y agoRegional trains only need 4 things: - to be on time - to be clean and well kept - to be spacious - to be safe and simple this is utterly lacking in Italy and in many countries
- jillesvangurp 3y agoTrains are fine but also very expensive. And rail networks are already very congested. And also very outdated in large parts of Europe. People like the idea of trains but not the practice of high ticket prices, disruptive delays, multi day journeys to cover the distance you can fly in 2 hours, etc. The main issue with aviation is that fuel is burned, which is bad for the environment. However a lot of short haul flight can transition to battery electric pretty soon. Probably before any significant amount of new rail gets built. That removes the major environmental concerns. And lots of small planes can fly point to point so you remove the dependence on big central hubs as well.
- mikepurvis 3y agoI think a lot of short haul flights make less sense than people think when you account for travel time to the airport, security, boarding, taxiing, etc. Trains suffer from intermediate stops of course, but overall it's really important to do a comparison of the true door to door time.
- saintkaye 3y agoIf K99 turns out to be real in any sense there’s a strong chance all transport moves electric/battery opp.
- ChumpGPT 3y agoI spent a month travailing in Europe this Spring and while not horrible, I can see why most people want to take planes or drive. If you are traveling between countries nothing matches up. You land in Europe and decide to take a train from Frankfurt to Prague and the schedules don't sink up. You spend an ungodly amount of time waiting or sitting on a train in the dark. Then if you want to travel to Poland from Prague you end up arriving to your destination 10 hours later in what would be a <4 hour car trip. I can understand why most Europeans I spoke to would much rather fly or drive and leave the trains for tourists. Tourists also don't have time to burn adjusting their schedule to the train schedules. With the Schengen Zone you only have 90 days every 180, where as before you could spend a year travailing across Europe you're now screwed because you have 90 days instead of 90 days for each individual country.
- 3y ago
- mytailorisrich 3y agoIn many cases air travel is more convenient and cheaper to operate than rail (no infrastructure needed). Air travel is not going away so there should be efforts made to decarbonise it instead of pooping on it at every opportunity.
- orwin 3y agoAir travel is almost as subsidized as road travel, I don't think 'cheaper' is a good argument for it (not even counting externalities). Convenience though is a great argument for air travel.
- uxp8u61q 3y agoAir travel is not convenient. How do you get to the airport? How long does it take you? Do you take your car and pay for parking, do you pay $$$ for a cab? Do you take public transportation and take hours? How long in advance do you need to get there? How much time do you waste in ID checks, security checks, taxiing...? Meanwhile, where I live, I take a metro car and I'm at the train station in 30 min. I get there 10 min before the train leaves just to be safe. Then I just... get on the train? And when the train arrives, I just... get off it. And that's it.
- wkat4242 3y agoHigh speed trains in Europe have security checks too. Though they're not as rigorous and time consuming as those for air but you still need to plan for them.
- uxp8u61q 3y agoI must have taken the TGV a hundred times in my life, and high speed trains elsewhere in Europe several times. I have never been through a security check. The only time I had to, it was the Eurostar. I don't know what you are talking about or where your information is coming from.
- alfiopuglisi 3y agoInteresting. I am Italian and I had no idea. From the sound of it, these tourist-specialized trains will be a small niche. To be fair, trains are already heavily used for domestic tourism, in addition to personal or business travel. Most biggish towns are well connected by local trains, and big cities in the north and center are easy to reach with the high-speed lines. For example, the popular Cinque Terre destination in Liguria is well-connected by a train route that touches all five towns with a frequent schedule, every 20 minutes or so. If you don't need to move too much at your destination, a train is often the most convenient way of reaching it. Something I often use is the bicycle transport on local trains, allowed with a very low fee, like 3 euros: starting from home, follow any scenic route that ends in a town with a train station, and use the train to go back home. Bonus points if the route touches multiple towns, so if you are too tired after 4h on the bike, you can cut it short and go back anyway.
- rurban 3y agoSome countries want to catch up to Switzerland, also Austria
- switch007 3y agoAwesome for tourists because hiring a car and driving in Italy is crazy. I’ve rented cars all over Europe and Italy has the worst service, trashiest cars and craziest drivers. (I love the country, don’t get me wrong) Trains are so much more relaxing! No worrying about the damage €2000 deposit they’re holding on your credit card.
- mimd 3y agoThe Smithsonian is rehashing a press release on available tourist train choices in Italy? Couldn't they spend some more effort, like an examination of one of the historical trains?
- haltingproblem 3y agoSadly, in the era of non-existent budgets this is what counts for journalism. It might even be that it was just LLM generated and then just touched up.
- mimd 3y agoTrue, and it's mostly a rehash of an already released CNN article. But I don't like that the Smithsonian wants to be a general news service. Their a museum group. But the reduction to being general news/click bait seems to infectious.