7 ms·
Uber CEO stunned by $52 fare for 3-mile ride
- damnesian 3y agoisn't it interesting how the words "cab" and "taxi" don't any appear in stories like this anymore. Don't they still exist? Aren't they cheaper? I've never understood the appeal of Uber or Lyft, and now in the era of surge pricing I really don't understand it.
- lowboy 3y agoWhen they first got started, booking a cab was: 1. Pick a cab company, look up phone number. 2. Phone, usually get a dispatcher but sometimes busy signal. 3. Tell them where you are. 4. Get very loose estimate on pickup time. 5. Wait with no updates. 6. Most of the time cab comes, if it doesn’t, GOTO step 1 by phoning back or trying another company. Compared to 1. Open app. 2. Hit button. 3. “Real time” updates on car location and estimated time I don’t like the gig economy model and I don’t use Uber and still use cabs, but I can see the appeal.
- syspec 3y agoNot in NYC where the article takes place
- ljf 3y agoOut of interest, which bit of the flow they described is different in NYC? It was similar to that in London 10 years ago - the most 'fun' thing used to be booking a cab for an airport drop - would they turn up at 3am as planned? If not, what will you do - as their office may now be closed... I ended up nearly stuck at the airport one night after my booked cab (pre paid!) didn't turn up, so had to get a black cab at twice the cost, and only after I convinced him I had the cash at home, as I didn't have any on my and my card had been cancelled while I was on holiday (for using the card abroad). Fun
- temp_praneshp 3y agoI'm not from new york, but I think you just hail the cab down in the street, no? The described flow is what I'd have to do in atlanta to go basically anywhere.
- ljf 3y agoYeah, anyway outside of the centre of London and even there outside of peak hours, and waiting in the street for a cab can be a long wait.
- Groxx 3y agoYeah, where I grew up it was even worse. The main nearby company constantly had multiple cabs parked and people idling for huge amounts of time, but they demanded at least 24 hour notice and a 3 hour pickup window regardless of the time. For trips taking ~10 minutes. I'm honestly surprised they still exist. I have no idea whose money is keeping them in business.
- throwawaymaths 3y agoif you're of certain minority groups, the cab experience was: 1. Go outside 2. Put your hand up 3. Never get a taxi > Most of the time cab come This got really bad in many cities because of a cycle: If the rate of dispatched cabs get low enough, people make multiple requests to the dispatchers, so more than one cab would go to the spot, and you take whichever cab gets there first and the rest are "dropped". So the other cabs can't service dispatch requests, the servicing rate drops, so that further incentivises multiple request...
- jjoonathan 3y agoI'm sure it's worse for minorities, but "cab supposedly dispatched but never shows" is definitely not a rare experience even with maximum privilege in play.
- throwawaymaths 3y agoI didn't mean to suggest that the two phenomena were connected, sorry!
- jjoonathan 3y ago6. Most of the time cab comes It does? That's not how I remember it.
- ferbivore 3y agoIt does appear in this story: "By comparison, the base fare for a yellow cab from Manhattan to JFK Airport is $70, according to NYC’s Taxi and Limousine Commission" (vs. Uber's $113)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mason55 3y ago> and now in the era of surge pricing I really don't understand it. Hasn't surge pricing been a part of Uber from day 1? I remember that being one of their original pitches, dynamic pricing being touted as a feature that will help get more drivers on the road when there are shortages.
- qmarchi 3y agoI didn't realize that MSN rebadged to Microsoft Start. Website looks clean if you're using an ad blocker, I can't imagine what it looks like without it.
- macintux 3y agoMicrosoft recently renamed Yammer as well. I think middle management is bored and looking to justify their jobs.
- glxxyz 3y agoThe MSN brand is still limping along: https://www.msn.com https://www.msn.com - it seems that just the news aggregator is Microsoft Start: https://www.msn.com/en-us/feed https://www.msn.com/en-us/feed
- jeffrallen 3y agoIf he thinks that's bad, he should try earning the same wage as his drivers and try paying that taxi fare.
- pavlov 3y agoThis happened in NYC which is the only American city where you can get around using public transport pretty much anywhere 24/7. So working class people don't need to pay these extortionate rates.
- HlessClaudesman 3y agoThe Saudi > Softbank > Uber subsidy ride is over.
- Analemma_ 3y agoYeah, what's actually happening here is that Uber fares are now climbing to what they "should be" in a functional market; the people accustomed to 15 years of artificially-low prices will need time to readjust. (Edit: the people elsewhere in this thread saying things like "Uber used to work better than taxis, but lately drivers have started refusing to take me to out-of-the-way locations" are arguably seeing the exact same phenomenon. This is just what taxi drivers do in a normal market, because they're rational actors maximizing their hourly earnings. That was disrupted for a while by the entry of new players making the market topsy-turvy, but now that those distortions are smoothing out it's back to business as usual. You should get used to it.)
- makestuff 3y agoIn NYC the Curb app is honestly way better. It pairs you up with a taxi (they could've killed uber years ago if they built this app in 2012) and you pay significantly less as there is no surge pricing, you are charged based on the yellow cab fare rules.
- dmonitor 3y ago> By comparison, the base fare for a yellow cab from Manhattan to JFK Airport is $70, according to NYC’s Taxi and Limousine Commission. This makes $52 (which includes the driver tip) seem pretty reasonable. Am I missing something?
- lotsofpulp 3y agoIt is just clickbait. Everyone knows that the time the driver has to spend has to be incorporated in the cost, so omitting the time it took for the trip is an overt attempt at making something out of nothing. There are also tolls. And the fact that no one forced them to pay $52, they could have used a taxi in midtown Manhattan. I am guessing traffic was particularly bad or something, or the supply of drivers was more constrained for whatever reason.
- iamben 3y agoUnless I've read the article wrong, the $52 journey was "to travel a short distance through downtown Manhattan to Uber’s corporate offices to interview him back in May." The airport stuff was a different trip/person.
- goalonetwo 3y agothat was for a different ride. The comparison was with 113$. >>> ”I got in the Uber to go to JFK. I was on my phone so I wasn’t paying attention. When I got to JFK, I looked to see what the price was to see what I’d tip. I saw $113. I was shocked. I was annoyed,” she told The Post Wednesday. Also, PSA: Not sure it is still uptodate but years ago, official taxicab had set prices (~60$) to all NYC airports (JFK,LAG).
- swozey 3y agoSomeone needs to make a rideshare aggregator app that will compare local taxis, uber and lyft. I haven't used a taxi in maybe 15 years because the last experience I had in one was so bad. So I'm not familiar with how different the pricing is between them. Two mile ride in Miami and we get to the destination and the guy tells me his card reader doesn't work. Not the first time I've had one pull that scam. edit: I'm getting some responses that I should've just hopped out. I did. Copy pasting the story I just posted in another comment - --- > I had him drop me off at the mall so that I could grab a belt for a wedding that was happening an hour or two later. He told me his reader wasn't working and I didn't have cash. I was literally wearing swimming trunks and looked like I'd just come out of a pool, because I had. I said sorry mate you need to warn someone when they get in and not after the ride. I hopped out to go in the mall and grab a belt and he followed me screaming at me the entire time. This probably wasn't even a 2 mile ride. Hotel to Miami mall. For some reason I can't remember the outcome. Maybe I got so sick of him I went to an atm. I hope I didn't. I don't know what other outcome would've happened. This was when I was young and hot headed and absolutely not afraid of this guy screaming at me.
- potatototoo99 3y agoMany apps already do this, including google maps.
- o1y32 3y ago...until Uber pulled out of Google Maps.
- jjoonathan 3y agoYeah, Taxis try the "card reader broken" scam more than 50% of the time IME. Fortunately, it always manages to magically fix itself when I make a show of pretending to not have cash.
- tempest_ 3y agoaha when I was younger and they tried that shit I would just shrug and say I guess they were not getting paid then which as you say seems to be the magic incantation to fix these readers.
- iamben 3y agoI've noticed they've started amending the quoted price (after the ride) in London as well. Albeit not to this level. Completely anecdotally, Uber was great when the drivers didn't know where they were taking you. You booked, someone turned up, you got in and they drove you there. Now if it's 2am and you're going to a part of town that's in the slightest bit out of the way, good luck (and watch the price surge as you struggle to get someone to take you). And don't get me started on the jobs that get accepted when the driver is "2 minutes away," but are clearly doing a job on another rideshare app and don't turn up for 15 minutes...
- tedivm 3y agoIt may have been great for you, but I regularly had drivers refuse to take me or abandon the ride once they saw the destination. The worst part is that they report you as not showing up, and then uber/lyft both will add no show fees for the ride that you then have to fight over. When Uber was a black car service it was great, although expensive. Now it's just expensive.
- iamben 3y agoBut at this point haven't they already accepted the journey / aren't you already in the car? As annoying as it is, seems like an easy case to argue/win - they have your GPS location, that of the driver and the fact you've got in the cab?
- tedivm 3y agoYeah, I've literally been kicked out of cars before. "As annoying as it is" is my point, it's super annoying and I shouldn't have to do it.
- zo1 3y agoThis is purely Uber trying to keep the truth from both sides. They know drivers don't want to take short/crappy/long/etc drives. They know these drivers use various means to avoid taking those rides, yet they do nothing about it because if they did they'd lose half their "taxi driver" contingent of drivers. So instead they play this cat mouse game that just drags the problem out whilst everyone is equally unhappy.
- wnolens 3y agoInteresting, the video pauses when you navigate away from the tab. Never experiences that behavior on a website before. Thoughtful UX? or ensuring ad views?
- jrockway 3y agoThe subway and bus remain $2.75.
- 762236 3y agoThat caused Daniel Penny a lot of trouble. If the police won't keep the peace, and since we're not allowed to protect ourselves, then the next solution is paying for gated communities, private schools, Costcos, and private carriage.
- stavros 3y agoI didn't know who Daniel Penny is, and, after looking him up, are you for fucking real? The subway caused him a lot of trouble because he murdered a homeless guy? Yes, that's quite the inconvenience, I avoid the subway nowadays because all these life sentences add up. What am I going to do, not murder homeless people?
- hotpotamus 3y agoIt got political fast, and I believe there was some disagreement about whether or not it counts as murder when done to the homeless. It seems the compromise was to call it manslaughter.
- stavros 3y ago:(
- 762236 3y agoThat's a real intellectually honest representation of the situation. Why did Daniel Penny have to defend himself and the other passengers from the violent, crazy dude? Why would I put myself in the same situation, exposing myself to the violent crazy people? I'll take Uber. Or move to Europe.
- BizarroLand 3y ago
- zhivota 3y agoI've noticed this in other contexts as well (new cars, restaurant prices, tipping norms skyrocketing) - Americans don't seem to value frugality anymore. Despite all the complaining about these prices, people are obviously still paying them. Same goes for new cars - SUVs and Minivans are now upwards of $60k, yet there seems to be no pressure on the carmakers to lower the price. And why should there be if people are paying those prices? Personally I have a hard time identifying with it. Moreso, I am concerned that what appeared to be transitory inflation becomes permanent when consumers do not moderate purchasing in the face of prices rising at multiples of overall inflation levels.
- UncleEntity 3y ago> Despite all the complaining about these prices, people are obviously still paying them. Because they have no other choice. Reminds me of the bus strike when I was driving cabs in Phoenix, people paid the price but nobody was happy about it as the other option was not having a job. Destroy the competition then charge whatever you want.
- soupfordummies 3y agopeople have a choice to buy a brand new car or go to restaurants
- autoexec 3y agoMany people in the US need cars to work. If their car dies or gets totaled in an accident they'll need to buy a new one. Used car prices aren't that much better than new car prices, and with a new car you can avoid inheriting problems with cars that were previously owned and rejected. You're much more likely to get a reliable car that will last longer buying new than used.
- UncleEntity 3y agoMost people don't buy new cars or go to restaurants very often.
- 3y ago
- zwieback 3y agoI enjoyed the brief time where VC money was directly shuttled into my pocket but I knew it wouldn't last. Taking public transport whenever possible.
- avalys 3y agoUber has so many little annoyances that make it a miserable experience. I generally don't engage in the "recreational corporate hate" thing but it's one of the few companies and products I actively dislike. The app is misleading and insulting to users' intelligence. Multiple times, I've requested a ride, been connected with a driver, and it's completely obvious that the dude is still sitting in his house and hasn't gotten into his car yet. Yet the app will show A) The car moving around pointlessly on the map, B) The wait timer diminishing from 10 minutes, to 9 minutes, 8 minutes, etc. It's so transparent that some asshole PM in San Francisco thinks he's really clever and that lying to users will improve retention or whatever. Which also means he thinks users are clueless rubes that can't tell he's fucking lying to them. This might improve short-term metrics - perhaps I'm slightly less likely to cancel the ride on any particular trip - but in the long term it makes me hate this company and avoid using them unless I'm absolutely forced to. There's a million other things in the app and user experience that cause similar mental friction and stress. The result is that these days I'd much rather drive my car to the airport and pay for parking than take an Uber.
- laminarflow 3y agoAlso see: "If you cut through this residential street with 4-way stop signs on every corner and make an impossible left hand turn across four lanes of moving traffic back onto the main road, you can shave 1min off your ETA." - Sincerely, PM of driving directions in SF who takes a company shuttle into the office and doesn't own a car.
- jrockway 3y ago> - Sincerely, PM of driving directions in SF who takes a company shuttle into the office and doesn't own a car. Silicon Valley PMs must drive a lot. My iPhone constantly nags me about "driving" when I'm riding the Subway reading a newspaper. Maybe when BART finally completes the ring around the bay we'll see products designed for people that use public transportation instead of driving alone.
- anotherhue 3y ago> It's so transparent that some asshole PM in San Francisco thinks he's really clever and that lying to users will improve retention or whatever. Couple this with the arse of a VC who's making the meta worse and you all you need is a self-proclaimed capital F Founder type to have the perfect triumvirate of modern digital malaise.
- fnord77 3y ago> Furious New Yorkers have said they’re well and truly fed up with the ride service’s surging prices. Such a terrible shame they're being forced to use uber
- politelemon 3y ago> Uber CEO Dara Khosrowshahi was floored by a journalist’s $51.69 trip, including the driver’s tip, to travel a short distance through downtown Manhattan to Uber’s corporate offices to interview him back in May. To be clear about the headline. The CEO did not experience the event. The journalist told them about it, and they were stunned or expressed being stunned. The CEO is distant from their own product and problems, and completely unaffected by them.
- goalonetwo 3y agoI take Uber a couple times a year (when there are no other alternatives). I always chat with the driver and ask how much he is making out of that ride. I have seen absolutely astonishing price differences. Coming back from SFO to south bay at night a couple weeks ago, we were quoted 120$. The driver take home was...30$. I don't understand how we got in this situation. Is the app really providing that much value? Why can't a scrappy startup with 25 people not create a similar app and take a fixed 1$ a ride? Today there is no other solution than accepting Uber (or similarly Lyft) prices. There should be a world where instead of paying 120$ I pay 60$ and the driver instead of getting 30$ gets 55$?
- swozey 3y agoAustin has had a number of not-Uber/Lyft rideshares. There was a point where U/L were banned by the city council for not doing fingerprint background checks so a bunch popped up. https://www.kut.org/transportation/2021-12-29/here-are-six-ride-hailing-companies-in-austin-that-arent-uber-or-lyft https://www.kut.org/transportation/2021-12-29/here-are-six-r...
- verteu 3y ago> Why can't a scrappy startup with 25 people not create a similar app and take a fixed 1$ a ride? Surely there's a huge network effect? Maybe it could work in one city, though.
- nojvek 3y agoI'm kinda surprised Lyft is cheaper than Uber nowadays, by like a big margin. Almost $20 difference in fare when going to Airport that usually costs $60. I'm sure a ton of drivers have both uber and lyft open, and a lot of users check on both lyft and uber. I don't have any special loyalty, go with whoever is the cheapest and if lyft is just $1-2 more expensive then I chose it over Uber. I think Uber is trying to make a profit but slowly killing the golden goose.
- BaseballPhysics 3y ago> Uber’s CEO blamed inflation for the increased rates, telling Wired during his sit-down that “everything is more expensive.” > But the company’s prices in the US have increased at four times the rate of inflation – for a total of 83% — between 2018 and 2022, according to a recent Forbes analysis. LOL, it's amazing watching CEOs use inflation as cover for their pricing decisions. I'm not one to believe all companies are being this dishonest, but kudos to MSN for disputing their BS.