7 ms·
Teach a man to phish and he’s set for life
- mistrial9 3y agowhen MSFT is called to DC over losing master keys to all emails after proven extended exfiltration of same, make sure to blast-promote a stern warning over imitating the mighty and venerable MSFT by common criminals to the commoners..
- euazOn 3y agoI, too, was unaware of phishing with RLO characters. Video about it here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nIcRK4V_Zvc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nIcRK4V_Zvc
- greatquux 3y agoIt's true: Ever since I became a Phish fan back in '96 I've been set for life! :)
- soupfordummies 3y agojust surrender to the flow ;)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- CraftedByPeter 3y ago[dead]
- NoZebra120vClip 3y agoKrebs appears to misspell the filename here; it is not "pdf.eml Properties" but "fdp.eml" and "Properties" is the title of the Windows dialog.
- thedanbob 3y ago> Like attaching a phishing email to a traditional, clean email message Several people at my org had their email hacked and now I regularly receive my own years-old emails to them sent back to me with phishing links.
- r1ch 3y agoWhat's the point of this attack? If you're using a .EML to display a link to a phishing page, surely a .PDF works just as well?
- ivanbakel 3y agoThe .EML file opens in the Outlook email viewer, presumably? A PDF would open in either the native PDF viewer, or some sort of Outlook PDF previewer - but either way, would be more obviously third-party content than an email in the email client.
- rvnx 3y agoIn theory you could argue that Outlook may be the only vulnerable client, but then you could just say "I forwarded you this e-mail" and have the same result
- wiz21c 3y agoTell a man to phish, and you can sell him phishing poles.
- 13of40 3y agoI find it a little bit dubious that this social engineering evasion is what caused the false negative in phish detection. This guy expects the automated scanner to render the filename graphically, OCR it, then use the backwards result to guess the file type? Because first of all, "foo.eml" and "[RLO]bar.eml" are both EML files to any programmatic scanner, and second they look at the content of the file to figure out what it is, not the extension.
- dave4420 3y agoNo, this guy expects the automated scanner to detect that bidi overrides are being abused, and block it based on that.
- 13of40 3y agoThat's the kind of heuristic rule that's going to come back and bite you when you try to scale up to half a billion attachments a day.
- Dylan16807 3y agoI think it's pretty good. No sane human uses those in casual text. Trying to carve out exceptions could become a complex biting situation, but flat-out blocking/replacing them shouldn't.
- rpigab 3y agoI love Unicode quirks that OSes and big software developers miss, it's so fun to send links with cyrillic 'а' instead of latin 'a', sometimes https:// https:// links are protected from this, but mailto: aren't (so if the mail client doesn't report the wierd character, you can make someone send an email to the wrong hostname), and the RLO chars are so fun, name a file ann<RLO>fdp.exe, and it shows under most software as annexe.pdf, but gets executed as an exe in Windows. Also watch what happens in GNOME desktop environement and its file explorer, like right click on it and view properties, the RLO switch extends to the whole sentence that the filename is written in, it's hilarious. It's supposed to print "<filename> Properties", but instead the window title is "<beginning of filename>seitreporP <end of filename>".
- TacticalCoder 3y ago> I love Unicode quirks that OSes and big software developers miss It's more the development and specs of Unicode that did miss a lot of things. When Unicode came out Bruce Schneier envisioned all the attacks that'd inevitably come and he was, of course, totally right. As he put it a quarter of century ago (2000): "Unicode is just too complex to ever be secure". It's Unicode that did fuck up, not developers who are forced to deal with non-sensical things because somewhere a committee decided that it'd make sense to use a broken system for domain names (for example).
- derefr 3y agoIsn't almost all the complexity of Unicode inherent in the problem of trying to encode documents written in every written language, though? (Esp. when including documents written in multiple languages at once — and often switching languages within a single sentence, such as when a statement in one language quotes text in another language.) Or do you have thoughts on what a "simplified Unicode" — that accomplishes all the same goals — would look like?
- Nextgrid 3y agoProblem is that the executability of files is (at least on Windows) communicated in-band in the filename. In-band signalling was proven to be a bad idea ever since the early days of phone phreaking. Unicode is fine for what it is - conveying text across languages and scripts. The problem is that some environments use the filename as more than what it should be (a memo field for the user and not an instruction for the machine whether to execute the file as code).
- nottorp 3y agoIs Unicode turing complete now? Does anyone think it's a good idea?
- ElectricalUnion 3y agoUnicode still doesn't do loops, so no, but it's sightly less complex that human written language is, so it's very complex for sure. Human language for sure was a awesome idea. We're finding out with Generative Large Language Multi-Modal Models that languages are a interesting building block for what we can call intelligence.
- tadfisher 3y agoDo you want to go back to codepages and needing to know the difference between CP1252 and ISO 8859-1?
- nottorp 3y agoI'm pretty sure there is a more sane solution in between. Too bad the commitees went wild instead. Just like with ipv4 and ipv6.
- mike_hock 3y agoNo, but filenames should never have supported anything other than plain ASCII. Not only filenames but anything that has semantic meaning or is otherwise relevant to the functioning of the system. Unicode should have been confined strictly to document content and UI presentation.
- nradov 3y agoSo Germans shouldn't be allowed to use "ä" in their file names?
- nottorp 3y agoLike the hive mind is trying to make logging in ultracomplicated for security reasons, why not dissalow confusing characters in file names for security reasons? Oh but it would make file names less complex. We can't have that. Edit: btw, how many ways can you express an "ă" in Unicode? How many different file names that look the same visually can you end up with?
- ttul 3y agoThe proper solution to this problem is to render the message as the user will see it and then analyze it using computer vision, running OCR to extract the text and identifying deceptive elements like brands. We built a prototype to detect brand impersonations at scale in this manner and it worked, but the GPU cost was prohibitive (on a billion messages a month) and there were lots of false positives. If anyone is keen to learn more, reach out to me at ksimpson at mailchannels.com. We would like to open source this but don’t have the time to do it properly. If anyone is interested, please reach out to me.
- ShowalkKama 3y agoor you could also render the extension separately allowing only ascii chars... (thus .eml would always show at the end, no matter what)
- rocqua 3y agoMight be cool to do this on domains found on certifacte transparency logs, rather than doing it on domains found on e-mail. Lets encrypt seems to issue about 3M certificates a day, so about 100 million a month. Which seems to be one order of magnitude better.
- masfuerte 3y agoIf I were a phisher I wouldn't put the phishing on the site home page.
- kccqzy 3y agoAh I have a friend at Google doing that. Except they downscale the image to a ridiculously low resolution to save compute costs. At that resolution OCR is no longer feasible but brand detection still works. Naturally being at Google they don't use GPUs but TPUs to do it, but the cost remains so prohibitive that they have to randomly sample messages to go through this process.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jgeada 3y agoOK, in the entirety of my computer usage, I never have had a need to render of unicode in all of its oddities. I would love to have a setting that just turns off all of Unicode permanently. If something arrives with unicode I'd rather it didn't render than to have all this user-hostile behavior appear. I think this one setting would significantly reduce the risk surface area of computers I use.
- brmgb 3y agoIt’s going to be great the first time an European sends you a message and nothing displays because your system can’t render the diacritic in their name.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jgeada 3y agoI am European and my name and surnames would not render. Most English speakers can't even pronounce my name correctly, which bugs me slightly more than the name not rendering correctly in a computer. But I still don't see this as a problem. Allowing arbitrary encodings, arbitrary mix in an single text stream of right-to-left and left-to-right rendering, homonyms and visually identical rendering of different byte sequences are all a problem, and in particular when any of these are being used across a web or OS interface, where recognizing the intent is quite important.
- brmgb 3y agoI agree there is an issue. I don’t agree about what the issue is. The problem is not Unicode rendering. The problem is improperly mingling information of a different nature. File extensions are not a good way to tell you if a file will be executed (Unix got that right from the start). Then executing a file involuntary shouldn’t lead to significant risks for your data and your system. That’s the actual problem which needs to be solved. Mangling text rendering is not the solution.
- miohtama 3y agoMeanwhile the US government is finally starting to realise the weaknesses in cybersecurity that are direct consequences of Microsoft business decisions in their products > Oregon senator Ron Wyden wants the U.S. government to hold Microsoft responsible for what he describes as “negligent cybersecurity practices” that enabled “a successful Chinese espionage campaign against the United States government.” https://www.securityweek.com/us-senator-wyden-accuses-microsoft-of-cybersecurity-negligence/ https://www.securityweek.com/us-senator-wyden-accuses-micros...
- u801e 3y agoGive a man a fish and he'll eat for a day Teach a Nigerian to phish and he'll become a Prince!
- sbuk 3y agoI am always dubious of Krebs since the whole Ubiquiti debacle. I acknowledge that he apologised (in a fashion), but the fact that he doubled down when he must have known that his source was the perpetrator leaves a bad taste. As someone in the security field, I treat everything he reports with a healthy amount of scepticism, double-checking any sources he provides.
- ta1243 3y agoI remember some original reports about ubiquiti but not the specifics, is lodged in the back of my mind as "this company is getting worse" I never saw the apology, but even if I had the damage would still be there, the subconcious part of my mind has downgraded ubiquiti On the flip side maybe ubiquiti deserved to be downgraded - I remember talk about new owners and new directions, and perhaps I never even saw the security claim, and this retraction will unfairly "un-downgrade" them. It's the same problem as the tabloid press. They can spend 3 weeks hounding someone with lies on page 1, then print a retraction on page 14. Even if the retraction was on page 1 it wouldn't undo the damage.
- sbuk 3y agoTrust is an extremely fragile thing (he says in a pseudo-intellectual sat-on-the-sofa on-a-rainy-day kind of philosophical whimsy...)
- e40 3y agoYeah, this bothers me a lot. I've been an Ubiquiti customer for a long time, and when this happened I was extremely nervous for a good while. I even missed the pseudo-apology, but saw the news stories about the perp later.
- user_7832 3y agoTangential: The email mentioned "These messages will be deleted in _24hours_" (emphasis mine, no space) - phishing mails _still_ have typos?! I find it hilarious for right and wrong reasons.
- Modified3019 3y ago>One would think Microsoft would have had plenty of time by now to address this.” Anyone that’s had the pleasure of using office 365 knows microsoft has other priorities. I’m not even sure this was fixed yet: https://forum.level1techs.com/t/am-i-the-crazy-one-here-or-is-this-terrible-design/166835/7 https://forum.level1techs.com/t/am-i-the-crazy-one-here-or-i...