11 ms·
Let Detroit Go Bankrupt
- pchristensen 18y agoDidn't notice that it was written by Mitt Romney. Interesting twist.
- antidaily 18y agoI'd rather bailout GM and Ford, who are not just hurting because of bad business decisions but also because of the credit crunch and high gas prices then, say, Bear Stearns.
- fallentimes 18y agoThis might sound crass, but companies who knowingly and actively pay people to do nothing on a perpetual basis deserve to die: http://www.detnews.com/2005/autosinsider/0510/17/A01-351179.htm http://www.detnews.com/2005/autosinsider/0510/17/A01-351179....
- antidaily 18y agoOk, but how about the hundreds of small businesses and suppliers that depend on the Big 3 for work?
- fallentimes 18y agoIn short; they're in trouble. That's why you should never ever put all your eggs in one basket. As I noted in this post: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=369994 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=369994 my family has already been hurt by this. My Dad was laid off, my Grandpa was forced in to retirement. My other Grandpa lost his job. One of my Uncles who did supplies sales was laid off. Only one of the above actually worked at one of the US car companies - the rest were part of the supplies/small businesses.
- chaostheory 18y agosmart businesses (especially small ones) change and adapt. if not they fail. why subsidize bad practices and decisions?
- lutorm 18y agoThe aim of government is not to support businesses but to support the citizenry. The relevant question is not whether businesses will be better off, it's whether people will be better off.
- ars 18y agoThey'll be better off in the long run. Let GM, etc fail, and get rid of the crippling unions. Then come back with normal hiring practices and they'll buy from suppliers again.
- ckinnan 18y agoWhat about the hundreds of small businesses and startups that are paying the taxes to subsidize the Detroit Three's failure?
- chaostheory 18y ago
- fallentimes 18y agoThe entire time I read this article I found myself nodding in an agreement. I found myself doing the exact opposite during Romney's campaign. As a Detroit native - and this is hard to write - the car bailout should not happen. GM, Chrysler & Ford are currently nothing more than welfare vehicles. Lots of people will go bankrupt and lose their jobs (my Dad already has), firms will die and Detroit will be in absolutely awful shape. But right now they're just prolonging the inevitable and wasting taxpayer money.
- LogicHoleFlaw 18y agoRomney has a proven record of turning around sinking ships. Both the Bain Company and the 2002 Winter Olympics were in bad shape when he took the reins in 1990 and 1999 respectively. He fixed both of them and remade them into viable ventures. I'm quite apt to take his word when he says a managed bankruptcy is the best option for the US auto industry.
- crabapple 18y agoand one wonders why bankruptcy is suitable for any other company in america, including airlines that have gone in and out of bankruptcy numerous times over the years...yet this same option is not permissible for the big3? this is exactly why ch.11 exists - to allow freedom to restructure
- yummyfajitas 18y agoA big 3 bankruptcy will be bad for auto workers, since the bankruptcy judge will rewrite their contracts. Since they currently get way above market rate, the judge will probably give them a pay cut, and authorize the layoff of many (1). Take a look at which politicians support the bailout. Then take a look at which politicians get UAW money: http://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/summary.php?id=D000000070 http://www.opensecrets.org/orgs/summary.php?id=D000000070 Coincidence? (1) Due to union contracts, the big3 are unable to lay off workers as a normal company would do.
- 18y ago
- jimbokun 18y ago"At American Motors, my dad cut his pay and that of his executive team, he bought stock in the company, and he went out to factories to talk to workers directly. Get rid of the planes, the executive dining rooms — all the symbols that breed resentment among the hundreds of thousands who will also be sacrificing to keep the companies afloat." Unions will not take management seriously until this happens. However, I also don't understand how people who constantly argue that U.S. wages must continually fall for the sake of corporate competitiveness think that the U.S. won't collapse without some kind of middle class. And if this seems hyperbolic, please consider the effect of inflation, rotating asset bubbles, decreases in health care affordability, and rising unemployment. Without some kind of wage growth above inflation, I don't see how a real middle class can survive. Perhaps there are specifics in this case that warrant some reductions, but it seems to be the same argument any time an industry gets into some kind of management induced trauma.
- bokonist 18y agoWithout some kind of wage growth above inflation The key is keeping inflation down. Run a sound monetary policy and keep a constant stream of productivity improvements in all sectors, so that the purchasing power of a dollar continually improves.
- chris11 18y agoAnd recently today the heads of GM and Ford both refused to take a one dollar annual salary as Lee Iacocca did when Chrysler was bailed out in the 80's. So I really don't see top management in either Ford or GM to do anything to symbolize sacrifice.
- Tichy 18y agoIt is probably just that, though, a symbolic sacrifice, not a real sacrifice? I suppose they still get their stock options, boni and what not.
- chris11 18y agoI think its more than a symbol. They would probably still get a lot money, but at least it would be mainly based on stock price/performance.
- Locke 18y agoIt baffles me that we'd blow 700 billion bailing out financial institutions that caused our economic problems. Money that's now going towards bonuses and acquisitions instead of buying "toxic assets" as originally intended. Toxic assets that were created by these same wall street companies. As we save the companies that crippled the credit markets, we have no interest in spending a fraction of that same amount of money helping the companies most negatively effected by the condition of those same credit markets. I'm sorry, but I don't see anyone buying a car from a manufacturer in bankruptcy. I think bankruptcy will be the end of the American auto manufacturers. The resulting damage will dwarf the 25 billion a bailout would cost.
- crabapple 18y agoAs we save the companies that crippled the credit markets, we have no interest in spending a fraction of that same amount of money helping the companies most negatively effected by the condition of those same credit markets. are you trying to tell me that gm is simply a victim of the credit crisis??? why would a bank loan them money now?? aren't we all about responsible lending now?? lending money to gm is the corporate equivalent of a subprime loan. we don't want banks making subprime loans anymore.
- Locke 18y agoYes. How do people buy cars? On credit. Harder to get credit means fewer people capable of buying cars. A bad economy means fewer people buying cars. GM et al, did not create the credit crisis. They did not create the bad economic conditions. But we want them, and more importantly, all the people working in that industry to suffer? Honestly, I can't imagine how letting them fail won't cause more than 25 billion in economic damage.
- lacker 18y agoYou think giving them $25 billion is going to be the end of it? They'll just be out of cash again in 6 months, asking for another bailout.
- 18y ago
- crabapple 18y agoone must ask why a waitress at denny's who makes minimum wage and has no healthcare must bail out union workers at gm who make 8x the wages, do less work, have ZERO DEDUCTABLE healthcare (do you? i doubt it), and full pensions. or why should a succesful worker at honda in ohio subsidize not only a failed competitor, but in essence have his own taxation used to undermine his own hard work? as for saving jobs and investment...most of the suppliers are already on death's door if they only rely on orders from detroit. investors have already lost 95% of their money on avg...nothing can reverse these losses in the end the govt cannot give the big three their reputations back. lost reputation is why people do not choose these cars even though they are now comparable in quality. barak obama cannot force me to buy a buick
- blackguardx 18y agoThis post smacks of jealousy. What is wrong with zero deductible healthcare? I don't fault someone for trying to climb society's ladder. I want everyone in America to be able to earn a living wage. Being in a union doesn't make one lazy or overpaid. How do you over pay someone anyway? Who deems what a job is worth to society? It is very unfortunate that the big three made the agreements they did, but they made them. They should be allowed to fail. All this talk of a bailout just furthers the crisis. When things start to look more desperate, the UAW will renegotiate. If they don't, the organization will cease to exist. What I worry about are all those retirees who depend on the pensions they were promised.
- yummyfajitas 18y agoPerson A, a waitress at Dennys, making about $8-10/hour with high deductible health care. Person B, an auto worker at GM, making $30-40/hour with zero deductible health care. [edit: see response to this post, auto worker gets $73/hour.] The bailout: tax person A in order to help person B, with 3 large corporations taking a cut of the proceeds. Does this make any sense? Incidentally, the original poster did not describe union workers as either lazy or overpaid. [edit: forgot to mention, it's actually very likely that the waitress does not pay taxes at all. So more realistically, the waitress should be replaced by someone in the $20/hour neighborhood.]
- deleted 18y ago[deleted]
- davidw 18y agoPolicy? Check. Romney? Check. Politics. http://voxeu.org/index.php?q=node/2574 http://voxeu.org/index.php?q=node/2574 is the best take on it that I've seen so far, though, if we really have to go there (we don't).
- fallentimes 18y agoGreat read - thanks for sharing. It's probably the best take I've read to date. The real question is: who can make it happen?
- mannylee1 18y agoThis coming from the NY Times... They better take a look in the mirror.
- teaquaffer 18y agoI don't follow- what do you mean?
- patio11 18y agoPresumably, he mean that the NYT is a floundering company which has been devastated by a refusal to adapt to new business realities over the last decade. 5 years ago their stock was trading at $47. Now it is at $6. http://finance.google.com/finance?q=NYSE:NYT http://finance.google.com/finance?q=NYSE:NYT (For what it's worth, if they collapse I wouldn't bail them out, either.)
- mannylee1 18y agoExactly, you made that perfectly clear.
- mtw 18y agothe difference is that there are known solutions for automakers (more efficient cars, using japaneese production systems etc.) whereas there isn't one for print media companies
- crabapple 18y agothe nytimes isn't asking the government to deliver their papers.
- run4yourlives 18y agoyet.
- fallentimes 18y agoI think a more likely result is the dissolving of their print publication or converting to a once per week format. Could you imagine telling someone this fifteen years ago? Crazy.
- chris11 18y agoI agree, the big three automakers should fail. They produce cars that people won't buy and are overpriced, and unlike the financial industry, they aren't too big to go bankrupt. I also don't see that they have a viable plan to turn the company around. In the recent congressional hearings, GM blamed their troubles on the financial crisis.
- netcan 18y agoOne thing that isn't mentioned here is the begger-my-neigborness of all this. These same companies lobby multiple governments for grants & incentives to operate locally via their local subsidiaries. Then when they get it they lobby another govenrment citing that they cannot be expected to compete at a disadvantage to their sister/paretn company.
- flavio87 18y agoHe's right.
- mattmaroon 18y agoWhy didn't he talk like this on the campaign trail? If he'd done that instead of trying to fist bump every black guy he saw while yelling "who let the dogs out" he could have been the nominee.
- jmtulloss 18y agoHe gave plenty of economically motivated speeches, both on the campaign trail and while he was governor. The media just covers the fist bumps.
- nazgulnarsil 18y agoAfter getting robbed by a band of thieves you know what's really important to talk about? How you think the thieves should divide up your stuff.
- froo 18y agoThis seems like some common sense... cant they just get some magic beans instead?
- byrneseyeview 18y agoI think we should allow the car companies to form a union. They can collectively agree that unless every single auto worker accepts $10/hour and no benefits, they all fire everybody. It would be very interesting to see how this works out.
- jmtulloss 18y agoWho benefits from this scenario? Between the American people, car company execs, auto workers, and the government, this is a lose-lose-lose-lose plan.
- olefoo 18y agoNot if you are a professional negotiator or a lawyer. This would be full employment for lawyers.
- newsycaccount 18y agoSince workers don't have the right to perform secondary strikes, why should automakers?
- gaius 18y agoIf employee A has a grievance and employees B-Z strike, how's that any different?
- hooande 18y agoThe biggest problem with the detroit automakers is their high pension and medical cost burden. People are living far longer now than they were predicted to when the pension deals were struck in 1951. The Detroit automakers have an unbearable burden when compared to foreign car makers. This drives up their prices and effects all of the business decisions that they make. The management at the big three auto companies hasn't been very brilliant or innovative, but I bet they've done just about as well as the management teams at comparably sized companies. Firing all of them would probably just cause a lot of chaos and waste decades of learning and experience. This financial problems they are facing have more to do with the credit crisis than making the wrong kind of cars. There is this insinuation in that media that if Ford had just made more eco-friendly cars then everything would be ok. There is still plenty of demand for american cars and trucks (especially in the american south). It seems like they just need some time and money to re-negotiate things with the unions and this can be worked out.
- ensignavenger 18y agoRomney's father turned around a failing auto company. Romney has turned around a ton of failing companies. I think I would take his advice on this one!
- sh1mmer 18y agoThe bottom line, if Detroit wants money it needs to justify why it's not just going to sink it into the same failed structure it currently has. Mitt makes some excellent points, it's not that we shouldn't support this industry, we should just do it with consideration and some sensible caveats. Personally this argument goes for Wall Street as well. Not that it's something Mr Paulson seems to understand.
- lallysingh 18y agoCan we just buy Honda out and give them GM?
- fauigerzigerk 18y agoAll that talk about unions misses one much more systemic point. It's that linking social benefits to individual employment relationships is a bad idea. It creates dependencies that make the system inflexible. It reduces worker mobility. It creates long term obligations that individual companies, not matter how large, can never garantee. It's a paternalistic model that puts companies in the position of families or states that care for people based not on merit but on human needs and dignity. Both are important but mixing them creates a conflict of interest. Money is flexible. Use money to pay people for work. Not health plans and pensions, not stock options, just money and people can go and buy all of the former. Keep things simple.
- lutorm 18y agoYeah, this is one of the arguments for universal healthcare and government-managed retirement benefits.
- chris11 18y agoThey just canceled the bailout vote, so it looks like Bush will make the decision now.
- LPTS 18y agoMitt Romney. I'm supposed to take anything this asshole says seriously? Why? Next up, Sarah Palin on Russian Policy, or Bill Kristol's bedwetting?
- mnemonik 18y agoSarah Palin doesn't know anything about foreign policy. Mitt Romney on the other hand is a successful businessman. This means he knows what he is talking about here.
- LPTS 18y agoUhh... No. Mitt Romney is a spineless, shifty fuck who failed at tricking enough republican morons into voting for him against their own economic interests. He has no principles (at all) and would happily say any thing to any audience if his pollsters said it would play. The game he was playing wasn't 'tell people what you think' but 'use 100 years of branding and mass psychology to trick people and you can have the power to do whatever you want regardless of what you said.' I'll say it again. Fuck Mitt Romney. It's important to keep this in it's proper perspective. Mitt Romney is a successful businessman. So we should listen to what he says on the US economy. That's like saying my obsessive compulsive butcher (kill kill kill kill kill cut cut cut cut cut) is good with animals so I should let him watch my pets. Fuck Mitt Romney. I'm disappointed by this thread. I thought the people here were smarter then this. When you listen to Mitt Romney, you are listening to a sociopathic bedwetter in magic underwear who will say anything to get power, and then feel like he can do whatever he wants with his power for winning the game of tricking the most idiots, and that anything he does that hurts people is OK because God wanted him to have power.
- joubert 18y agoThey make shitty cars anyway.
- Tritis 18y agohttp://www.npr.org/news/specials/gmvstoyota/ http://www.npr.org/news/specials/gmvstoyota/ GM's problem is that it costs them money to make a car. Profitability per Vehicle Source: 2005 Harbour Report GM: Loses $2,331 per vehicle Toyota: Makes $1,488 per vehicle If GM continues to lose money on each vehicle sold, how wil a bailout help in any way?
- Dilpil 18y agoThat figure is meaningless, it is amortizing the total operational cost of GM over each vehicle sale, when the total operational cost of GM is not directly proportional to number of cars sold- not by a long shot. The article is falsely portraying that as the average sale price per unit minus marginal cost per car, which it is not.
- bpyne 18y agoOne detail I don't remember seeing in the Op-Ed piece was health care differences between countries. In the countries our auto companies compete against, I believe all of them have health care at the national level. Right there, you have a major cost businesses in the US are absorbing.
- jdminhbg 18y agoIn both Japan and Germany, health care is mandated by the government but paid for by the employer. See e.g. http://www.nchc.org/facts/Japan.pdf http://www.nchc.org/facts/Japan.pdf
- bpyne 18y agoThanks for the link. I read the one on Germany as well. It seems more like a combination of employer and employee payment with the governments being involved as a single payer system - in the case of Germany.
- aswanson 18y agoYeah, let them, if for anything the nonsense they pulled with this: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Who_killed_the_electric_car http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Who_killed_the_electric_car
- nradov 18y agoI see that GM paid out a dividend of $0.25 per common share just a few months ago on 05/14/2008. The problems were well underway by then, yet they chose to piss away about $140MM in cash. That alone should disqualify them for a bailout, at least as long as the current management and board remains in place. http://finance.yahoo.com/q/hp?s=GM&a=04&b=14&c=2008&d=10&e=21&f=2008&g=v http://finance.yahoo.com/q/hp?s=GM&a=04&b=14&c=2... At least Ford had the common sense to cut off dividends in 2006.