9 ms·
It's time to start lobbying hard for an antitrust breakup of Google. This DRM plan, as abuse of a monopoly position, provides more political coverage for a forc
by Animats 3y ago
It's time to start lobbying hard for an antitrust breakup of Google. This DRM plan, as abuse of a monopoly position, provides more political coverage for a forced breakup.
It's pretty clear how to break up Alphabet, because it grew mostly by acquisition.
- Google - search, ads on search pages and nothing more.
- DoubleClick - third party ads on other sites.
- Analytics - services to web sites.
- Cloud - the money-losing data center service. Probably gets sold to AWS or Hurricane Electric.
- Android - phones and similar devices
- Chrome - browsers
- YouTube - streaming content. Probably gets sold to Netflix or AT&T or Comcast.
- Waymo - self-driving cars. Probably gets sold to a car company.
- Alphabet - all the other stuff.
Now, some of these have conflicting interests. That's a good thing. With Chrome separated from Google and Doubleclick, and forced to fight for market share, it's not in Chrome's interest to prevent blocking ads from DoubleClick or Google. Google wants people to see ads on search pages, while Doubleclick wants people to leave the search site and see ads elsewhere. Now there's competition.
Antitrust action against Google is already underway. The State of Texas and several state attorneys general have a case pending.[1] There are other cases.[2] All these cases benefit from Google's move to entrench their monopoly by technical means.
So make lots of noise politically about that. It's quite likely to make Google dump this proposal, on the advice of their antitrust lawyers.
[1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-06-05/google-antitrust-suit-over-ad-tech-sent-back-to-texas-court https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-06-05/google-an...
[2] https://www.lanierlawfirm.com/google-antitrust-lawsuits-explained/ https://www.lanierlawfirm.com/google-antitrust-lawsuits-expl...
- DeathArrow 3y agoThat's wishful thinking. Politicians will never break up Google since they benefit from it.
- caesil 3y agoFundamentally, Big Tech is an outsized part of what sets America's economy apart. Breaking up any of them would potentially be a footgun.
- deafpolygon 3y agoYep - weakening Big Tech in the US will strengthen China's Big Tech, which no one wants.
- choeger 3y agoSo we have to accept control through Google or Apple or otherwise we will be controlled by Alibaba or Huawei? I don't want my devices to be controlled by neither company.
- deafpolygon 3y agoOne wants profits; another wants to influence you. Take your pick.
- UtopiaPunk 3y agoI agree that big tech is huge part of the American economy. In the 1900s, Teddy Roosevelt busted up the biggest monopolies and did it boldy. He was a strong believer in capitalism and market forces, and he believed that government had a responsibility to keep market forces working well. I know we are not in the early 1900s anymore, but I think it is interesting to ponder how the only politicians who dare to say something similar today are the furthest left we can imagine (Bernie Sanders and AOC and the like).
- Animats 3y ago> I know we are not in the early 1900s anymore... We still have the antitrust laws of Teddy Roosevelt's era, the Clayton Act and the 1890 Sherman Act. Sherman Act, Section 2: "Every person who shall monopolize, or attempt to monopolize, or combine or conspire with any other person or persons, to monopolize any part of the trade or commerce among the several States, or with foreign nations, shall be deemed guilty of a felony." The US Justice Department hasn't often applied that standard rigorously, but it can if it wants to.
- qwytw 3y ago
- mrweasel 3y agoIt's like banks, it depends on your logic. We have systemically important banks, banks that will always be bailed out. You have two ways of dealing with that scenario, either prepare to save these companies when they fail or make them non-systemic so we can afford to let them fail. What I fail to understand is why it's better for society to support these "to big to fail" companies. Why not break them up. Why not plan break them up if they become to "important" for a lack of a better term? How can you not see it as a political failing that taxpayers have to be ready to save a company, just because you failed to bring it under control? It's mind boggling.
- vineyardmike 3y agoThere’s reasoning if you can actually see what’s happening. Does it outway the costs? It’s a political question, but there’s some benefits. For example, JPMorganChase is “the” big bank lately. It was able to handle the acute financial crisis this year by providing liquidity and a buyer as needed to keep the system from ever losing a deposit. That was likely bad for them as a business, short term, but it happened because the regulators can call up a single organization and get what they want. Big tech has similar (unrealized) opportunities to keep strategically important things going. One possible example is the ease of releasing the Covid contact tracing system. If there were 20 fragmented parties they may never have aligned.
- mandmandam 3y ago> There’s reasoning if you can actually see what’s happening. You can't see what's happening though, because JP Morgan "mistakenly" deleted 47 million emails. [0] Their fine for that came to about 12 minutes worth of revenue. They "failed" to keep records, firm-wide, right to the top. [1] Again, their punishment was at the "cost of doing business" level. We're talking about the bank that financed and enabled Epstein here [2]. There are other ways to provide liquidity without relying on these ghoulish overlords who manipulate global markets [3] and finance blackmail operations. 0 - https://www.reuters.com/legal/jpmorgan-chase-is-fined-by-sec-over-mistaken-deletion-emails-2023-06-22/ https://www.reuters.com/legal/jpmorgan-chase-is-fined-by-sec... 1 - https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2021-262 https://www.sec.gov/news/press-release/2021-262 2 - https://trendingpoliticsnews.com/breaking-attorney-general-terminated-just-days-after-filing-a-lawsuit-against-jpmorgan-chase-for-aiding-epstein/ https://trendingpoliticsnews.com/breaking-attorney-general-t... 3 - https://www.cftc.gov/PressRoom/PressReleases/8260-20 https://www.cftc.gov/PressRoom/PressReleases/8260-20
- bregma 3y agoPoliticians would never break up Standard Oil or Bell Telephone either.
- qwytw 3y agoWhy? It's pretty straightforward to show how Standard Oil or Bell Telephone were harmful to consumer interests. With Google.. well they are giving away half+ of their products for free which they wouldn't able to if broken up. Antitrust laws from the 1900s were just not designed with that in mind, they were trying to solve quite different issues.
- DoingIsLearning 3y agoI fully agree with a breakup but arguably other than Search, DoubleClick, and Youtube, none of the others are solvent without ad money. On thing I feel we are still missing is for FSF, Wiki, Archive.org, etc. to effectively gather enough cash to start lobbying in politics and in industry much in the same way Meta and Alphabet do. Politicians/legislators are ridiculously cheap to lobby in the grand scheme of things.
- pyrale 3y ago> none of the others are solvent without ad money. This is a consequence of Google's structuring. If the pricing is unrealistic after a split, it's also currently an example of price dumping preventing competitors from emerging.
- kortilla 3y agoThat’s not “price dumping”. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dumping_(pricing_policy) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dumping_(pricing_policy) If you don’t charge a normal price for something anywhere, then it’s just a loss leader (costco hot dogs).
- pyrale 3y agoJust because the marketing dept calls it a "loss leader" doesn't mean it's not predatory pricing. Whether a company crosses the line is defined by the impact it has on the market: if a company with enough market power uses that power to damage competitors, then this is deemed predatory. And, when it comes to Google, their history of leveraging their dominant lines of business to force an advantage in new markets, including via pricing, makes a good case for this. If some spin-offs of a Google antitrust can't swim, let them drown.
- flagrant_taco 3y ago> if a company with enough market power uses that power to damage competitors, then this is deemed predatory I think the trick there is that you legally have to show intent. One could argue that anything a market leader does to grow or even just retain it's market share hurts the smaller competitors.
- hutzlibu 3y ago"Chrome - browsers" And the money is coming from where? Chrome exists mostly, so the ad buisness gets more data and they can influence the direction of the web. Seperate that and there will be no more chrome as there is no other source of income. (Except maybe a little bit from ChromeOS). Otherwise I get it, it is mostly politics to threaten google to reach this.: "It's quite likely to make Google dump this proposal, on the advice of their antitrust lawyers." But a breakup of google(alphabet) is something very unrealistic and actually not something I want to see, unless we also break up Microsoft at the same time. Otherwise we end up with Microsoft dominating the web again. No thank you, I still remember those times.
- Andrew_nenakhov 3y agoWell maybe from search engines, who'd pay to be the default search option? So far, it mostly worked for Mozilla.
- hutzlibu 3y ago"So far, it mostly worked for Mozilla." Yeah, with tracking and ads from the browser enabled by default and by now allmost non existent marketshare. The money from ad companies does not come with no strings attached. (But I still use Firefox btw.)
- Joeri 3y agoMoney for developing chrome is not an issue. Google search could pay chrome to be the primary search engine just like they pay mozilla. Microsoft could fund chromium based on their use in Edge. Etc…
- JellyYelly 3y ago> Google search could pay chrome to be the primary search engine This doesn't sound like a good idea if your goal is to prevent these two companies (or divisions of the company) for co-conspiring.
- hutzlibu 3y ago
- BiteCode_dev 3y agoSure, but then you have to militate also for half of the fortune 500, most of them having bigger impacts.
- bushbaba 3y agoCloud would be a huge profit maker as YouTube, search, ads would all then pay cloud for hosting. And they’d have no where else to go.
- KnobbleMcKnees 3y agoFurther, selling GCP to AWS is not how we "break down monopolies".
- antupis 3y agoas long you can rent rack full of servers and use it easily there is not that kind monopoly.
- tankenmate 3y agoThe logistics at scale can't just be waved away like that; current providers would have at least a 10 year moat at scale to a new competitor even if they did nothing. And you can bet if a new company came along that was a serious threat the current players wouldn't sit idly by.
- KnobbleMcKnees 3y agoYou're comparing huts to skyscrapers
- tankenmate 3y agoThe FTC would never allow that anyway.
- samwillis 3y agoThis may seem like a good idea but so much of Google's power comes from the Search + Search Ads monopoly. That is where they are anticompetitive to the max, that is where a change needs to happen. Splitting everything else off doesn't solve the core problem. Within Search + Search Ads you have a platform where Google are/have: - the sole vendor of a digital asset - ads - the sole marketplace for that asset - a closed algorithmic trading system with no public auditing - no public ledger or auditing showing who bid what - currently one of the main customers for those ads (advertising their own products) Along with that you as an advertiser have to install tracking on your site allowing Google to see every transaction, all revenue, every customer, of your business. The level of spying on the advertisers is insane, when seen in combination with the closed source algorithm and market for the ads the potential for manipulation is enormous. The whole ads platform is built for extracting every last cent of margin from advertisers businesses. It's anticompetitive, monopolistic, and to some extent even a protection racket. The most important "breakup" needs to be the ads business from everything else, including search. That's going to hurt, and I don't have the answers to how to make it work, but changes are needed. I suspect a "breakup" isn't on the cards, maybe some strong regulation of online ad marketplaces, ring fencing them from the rest of the business and auditing of the platform?
- EMIRELADERO 3y ago> The most important "breakup" needs to be the ads business from everything else, including search. That's going to hurt, and I don't have the answers to how to make it work, but changes are needed. You can be happy then. https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/justice-department-sues-google-monopolizing-digital-advertising-technologies https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/justice-department-sues-googl... The press release doesn't mention it, but the actual court document asks the court to: "Order the divestiture of, at minimum, the Google Ad Manager suite, including both Google’s publisher ad server, DFP, and Google’s ad exchange, AdX, along with any additional structural relief as needed to cure any anticompetitive harm"
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoNote, too, that this is the DoJ. They, unlike the FTC, actually know what they are doing.
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoNit: Google Cloud has been profitable this year: https://techcrunch.com/2023/04/25/google-cloud-turns-profit-for-the-first-time/ https://techcrunch.com/2023/04/25/google-cloud-turns-profit-... It's actually perfectly fine to lose money; you have to invest before you can start making a profit, and services like Google Cloud can be money printers once they're established. But all the cloud providers are competing hard, pumping money into 3rd parties / partners that will then sell it and set it up at companies. I was at one company (a famous flower exchange in the Netherlands) that was in the process of moving all their workloads - hundreds of services, from people's office suites to high volume exchanges - to AWS, and I'm confident that the one guy, the new manager of the IT department, has Connections with Amazon to help sell AWS to companies like this. Because once they're in, it'll cost millions and years to move out again; I don't think many companies will do a sideways step often and move from e.g. AWS to GCP.
- adwww 3y agoAlso I don't think selling GCP to AWS really helps competition.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- eddythompson80 3y ago> But all the cloud providers are competing hard They are not competing hard enough. (Or maybe they competing too well? I don’t know) I used to work for AWS then Azure, and now just do consulting for both. The amount of companies I come across with the chief complaint of “We pay too much for AWS/Azure” is staggering. In a healthy market with healthy competition, you’d think that would never be a statement to be made. No one says “I pay too much for Chevron, I’ll only buy gas from Total” AWS, Azure, (and wth) GCP are in the tech support business, not infrastructure resell business. You’d think a cloud only need to sell VMs but there is literally no money in that. That’s the part that “competes hard” also the losing part. As a cloud provider, you want to be out of that shitty business. You want to be SaaS. SaaS is the magic work in Cloud. Selling Software is magic. It made Microsoft in the 80s/90s. It made Oracle in the 90s/2000s. It made Google in the 2000s. Selling software is an incredibly lucrative business. It is where you want to be. 100% of companies I consult for don’t spend money on VMs in the cloud. They always spend it on “log analytics” or “data warehouse” or “serverless” Why hire a Postgres admin when you can pay AWS/Azure 200k a month for postgresql “managed” offering where you can email them whenever things are not working and have _them_ hire the Postgres experts who would look at your usage/queries/tables and suggest an index here, or a stored proc there.
- dragonwriter 3y agoBrowsers aren't a business for Google (or any of the other big browser suppliers), they are an adjunct to other businesses, in Google’s case a way to shape the web—initially through client performance—to support the kind of online app environment that Google’s actual profit making ventures rely on.
- riedel 3y agoI totally agree. IMHO regulators should have been looking at safety net attestation already because it effectively destroys the claim of Google that OEM have a choice and it is not Google's monopoly. The problem is that Google is really good at just keeping below the radar (only the few people will notice that are not using Apple, Google or Microsoft products, which probably does not include any politicians, the broad public or other influential individuals) With this thing it is the same. The problem is: nobody will care. And I think everyone who should care will look away again, because it is just too complicated to explain. The core problem is that a minority raises this concern and this minority is not loud enough. We really need to nag out banks etc if they do not allow to use de-google Android. There should be public visible lists of the few 'good' guys left. Not even tech magazines seem to pick up this topic. I think the only thing to do for now is really actually using free browsers and free operating systems and on the other hand raise the issues (literally on GitHub?) as loud as possible. The world is just lacking enough web activism. The only loud thing about freedom of the web is web3 and crypto, but obviously to me this is just backed by some people who like keep the buzz up to make some more money with speculation.
- charcircuit 3y ago>IMHO regulators should have been looking at safety net attestation already because it effectively destroys the claim of Google that OEM have a choice and it is not Google's monopoly. Apps that require play services are just as much exclusive as apps that require attestation. Phones that don't use play services can create their own attestation API and partener with apps to support it.
- tremon 3y agoCloud - the money-losing data center service. Probably gets sold to AWS Your solution to breaking up a large monopoly is to boost another (quasi-)monopoly? I'd suggest that both Amazon and Microsoft should be prevented from taking over those assets.
- mcny 3y agoYes, we will need to evaluate and approve each acquisition but I am not sure if it is even possible to break up Google. I don't have a solution to the problem but I know this — we can't do the stupidity of breaking alphabet into a bunch of small baby alphabets like what we did with at&t.I think that was complete incompetence, if not corruption. We can't have a bunch of regional companies. However, we can't do what OP said either, even with your safeguards. Amazon and Microsoft don't care if they get Google cloud for themselves to buy. Either they get to buy it or it dies, they still get its customers. I think someone else said elsewhere if Microsoft abuses MsEdge, break up Microsoft as well but that's the kicker. That will take time. Microsoft can and will abuse it's position during this time. I don't think it is possible to do a "safe landing" here. An alphabet Google will either be a nothing burger like the AT&T break-up or will be very painful to ordinary people, at least for some time.
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> we can't do the stupidity of breaking alphabet into a bunch of small baby alphabets like what we did with at&t.I think that was complete incompetence, if not corruption. After the breakup, it became trivial for me to buy my own phone and hook what I wanted up to my phone connection (including dial-up modems later). What do you think would have granted+preserved those options, that wasn't an exercise in incompetence and corruption?
- qwytw 3y agoBut if it's indeed "money-losing" wouldn't it be just worth as much as their equipment is? Also if we are talking about MS/Amazon/Google's cloud businesses we shouldn't ignore that these companies themselves are generally their own biggest clients which is something they could leverage to a significant degree to outcompete their rivals (initially at least)
- greyface- 3y ago> Cloud [...] sold to [...] Hurricane Electric I'm a customer of both GCP and HE and this would be a really, really weird merger. Not saying I don't want to see it. :)
- thwooi4u234 3y ago+1 Google's ad business (and the need to track ad conversions) affects every business sector it's involved in. From Maps (where you loc. is tracked for 'in-store' conversions' to your Google ID which tracks which ads you click, to Chrome pushing for mechanisms to track conversions after cookie-blocking has become standardized. You kind of understand their needs (since ads fund search and everything), but I also don't trust them not to 'over-optimize' (esp. given the unchecked powers, both political and technocratic, they have).
- tyingq 3y ago> - Cloud - the money-losing data center service. Probably gets sold to AWS or Hurricane Electric. I don't think any of this would happen, but I'd rather see it go to Cloudflare so there's still 3 "big player" choices. They seem to be trying to head down the cloud provider path anyway.
- jimbo_joe 3y agoThis will immediately kill some of the parts (Chrome, Analytics, Alphabet) and increase the antitrust issues in others (Cloud, YouTube)
- amelius 3y ago> So make lots of noise politically about that. How? I've seen similar ideas but the best they do is resonate really nicely in this echo chamber.
- civilitty 3y agoSend letters and call your Senators and House representatives. Donate to them the maximum you’re legally allowed to and when you get the staffer call asking for more money, give them an (respectful) earful. All it takes most of the time is a dozen people pushing the issue for a rep to make up their mind on a bill. On contentious issues, a few hundred persistent constituents will convince even Senators in large states. Seriously it’s not that hard when it’s not a culture war issue. The vast majority of the time our politicians get bought out for a pittance like $10k in contributions. It doesn’t take much to bend them the other way when coming from voters. Speaking from experience.
- amelius 3y agoSo what kind of money are we talking about here? Order of magnitude?
- civilitty 3y ago$3,300 is the federal maximum per election per candidate but even a $1-2,000 donation will get a House rep’s attention (better donate the max for a senator though).
- idlewords 3y agoNone of what you suggest has any impact, and your model of how many people it takes to influence a Senator is frankly delusional. A max donation to a campaign will get you a signed thank-you card if you're lucky. Policy on stuff like tech is set by staffers, most of whom work from material helpfully pre-drafted for them by lobbyists. There are some legislators (like Wyden of Oregon) who have very good in-house people on tech policy, while others have no expertise and have to rely on outside parties. But the idea that anyone can be bought for a donation is heartbreakingly naive (and fortunately false). Large donations at best get your calls answered by the junior staffer whose job it is to protect the Senator/Congressman from ever having to talk to people like you directly. Major legislation on tech is rare, and it's generally much easier to kill something you don't like than to get a provision put into it. The latter course requires being deeply plugged in to the people drafting policy (again, mid-level staff on the Hill, who have zero awareness or interest in which private individuals are making campaign contributions) and enough clout and political ability to shepherd your desired policy through the full sausage-making apparatus of Congress. Look at the current dueling bills on crypto for an example of how the process actually works. None of it is driven by strongly-worded letters from constituents.
- TheSpiceIsLife 3y agoYour solution to Alphabet abusing their position in the market is to consolidate some parts of its business in to its present competition. I don’t see how that increases competition.
- Ialdaboth 3y agoWholeheartedly agree. And we shouldn't stop at Google : a large part of western capitalism in 2023 looks pretty much like a dystopian landscape out of a cyberpunk novel. It's a democratic nightmare in the making.
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago> a large part of western capitalism in 2023 looks pretty much like a dystopian landscape out of a cyberpunk novel. It's a democratic nightmare in the making. My take is that this process is inevitable while the following is in play: DoJ rubberstamps monopoly creating mergers, merger desiring companies fund campaigns & otherwise gift politicians, voters keep reelecting those politicians while not overly objecting to their corruption, news orgs fail to cover mergers in a historical context while generally preferring fluff and stenography. Those wishing to expose flaws in my analysis can use the space below.
- charcircuit 3y ago>it's not in Chrome's interest to prevent blocking ads from DoubleClick or Google But it would still be in their interest in preventing ad fraud on the web.
- account42 3y agoWhy? Users don't care about ad fraud and neither should the user agent.
- charcircuit 3y agoBecause sites, advertising networks, and advertisers do care about it and they are part of the web too.
- Aunche 3y agoI don't see why people think that antitrust is a magical silver bullet that will solve everything. Breaking up Google will be great for Google's paying customers, mostly advertisers. That doesn't mean it would it would help the users. If anything, each broken up piece of Google would have less scrutiny that the whole.
- mcv 3y agoIt's ultimately all about ads, though. Ads on the search page, ads in Android aps, ads on web pages, ads in or around YouTube videos, and several big data sets that help them figure out which ads you are most likely to respond to. Although the Chrome team would prefer not to block ads, I'm pretty sure there's some pressure on them to reduce the number of users using ad blockers.
- actuator 3y agoThis is such a naive and for lack of a better word stupid take > YouTube - streaming content. Probably gets sold to Netflix or AT&T or Comcast. Make Netflix more powerful? In what world is that good for competition
- WarOnPrivacy 3y ago>> YouTube - streaming content. Probably gets sold to Netflix or AT&T or Comcast. >This is such a naive and for lack of a better word stupid take What is the not naive, not stupid, clearly-more-beneficial-than-what-we-have action that should be taken with youtube?
- qwytw 3y agoDoing nothing? I mean Youtube is at least competing/trying to compete with Netflix, Spotify and others to some degree at least.
- 4RealFreedom 3y agoI don't understand the downvotes. You asked a legitimate question. How do we fix this anticompetitive monopolistic behavior?
- atomicfiredoll 3y agoI worry the enshitification of a monopoly like Google, who now has it's hands deep in the workings of things like the web and email, means their supposed mission of "organizing the world's information" has devolved into "putting as many paid middlemen in front of the world's information as possible," or walling parts of that information off completely. This goes without saying, but we shouldn't let one company be solely responsible for managing the "world's" information. "Organizing" sounds benign, but they've clearly extended past that. I don't know that you're totally on point about how to break Alphabet up, but you're right that it should be. If information wants to be free, we should also re-examine how to ensure it stays that way in a world where Google isn't it's supposed shepherd.
- dcchambers 3y agoHow exactly does taking one of the 3 major cloud providers and selling it to the largest of them help with monopoly/antitrust? Besides IIRC Google cloud is actually profitable these days. No need to find a buyer.
- delfinom 3y agoThe problem with Chrome is it would have no funding unless we suddenly end up with subscription browsers. It also means the fall of Firefox because they are still dependent on the Google moneytit. The future I see in this direction is Chrome ends up getting a free easy takeover/hijack by Microsoft since they are have no problem throwing money at Edge.
- geysersam 3y agoHow would Chrome make money? Right now they get a blank check from Google because dominance on the web is their business model. But if they're not supposed to sell out users interests to the ad-company, how are they supposed to earn any revenue? Sell Chrome licenses?
- acd10j 3y agoJust like how Firefox earns money, sell default search engine rights to highest bidder (google, bing) etc , Chrome itself can become billions of dollar business.
- geysersam 3y agoSo in other words, sell user interests to the highest bidder. Firefox is not comparable because it's not a stock company. They don't have the obligation to maximize profit for shareholders.
- sdfghswe 3y ago> - Google - search, ads on search pages and nothing more. > - DoubleClick - third party ads on other sites. No, hard disagree. One of the things that gives google its position of power is that its both an ad exchange and a publisher (as participant in said exchange). The correct way of breaking is NOT search+ads vs third party ads. It's search vs ads. Make google a publisher that DOESN'T own an ad exchange and make it compete for search ad revenue on equal footing with everyone else. Lets see how well it does (I'm guessing not well). Same goes for facebook.
- zaphar 3y agoIt is highly unlikely that Android, Chrome, and Analytics can be viable businesses on their own. I can perhaps see a viable path for analytics if a lot of things go their way but those three are almost entirely successful because they are subsidized by the other businesses. Youtube, and the other ads business can probably survive okay on their own but Chrome and Android I suspect can't.
- throwaway201606 3y agoAll can be fully viable, very profitable, very large independent businesses. Android Based on information obtained by Oracle in a lawsuit, Android had, as of 2010-ish, generated $31bn for google https://www.androidauthority.com/android-generated-google-31-billion-668853/ https://www.androidauthority.com/android-generated-google-31... Chrome: Browsers make money by - sharing revenue from ( product and service ) ad searches - prioritization in search engine results in the browser ( eg being set up as the default search engine) https://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/041315/how-mozilla-firefox-and-google-chrome-make-money.asp https://www.investopedia.com/articles/investing/041315/how-m... It is estimated, for instance, that as of 2021, Google was paying Apple $15bn for default browser placement https://www.theregister.com/2023/02/17/google_apple_chrome_ios_revenue/ https://www.theregister.com/2023/02/17/google_apple_chrome_i... Google Analytics: This is much harder to research - since looking for 'revenue' with 'Google Analytics' simply shows how to use the tool to track revenue for 'your' site if you are a Google Analytics user and my Google-fu fails at a quick remedy for that. Best quick result would be a proxy i.e. competitor revenue. MixPanel is a standalone Google Analytics competitor and it makes $96MM from that business https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/mixpanel https://www.crunchbase.com/organization/mixpanel
- pc86 3y agoI know it's just a hypothetical but YouTube being sold to Netflix or god forbid a century-old telecom company sounds awful to me, unless they let it continue to run as basically a completely separate entity - possible under something like Netflix or another tech-forward streaming company, nigh impossible under something like Comcast. I would hope YouTube could just operate as its own company. Certainly there's enough traffic, and it makes Google billions so presumably there's enough for it to survive on its own.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- florakel 3y agoGovernment should force google to give competitors access to its search index so that they have a real opportunity to build a competing service on top of it, AI or search. The same way monopoly telcos were forced to open infrastructure to competing service provides. Google products are getting increasingly crappy. Would be great to see what others could build with their information monopoly.
- local_issues 3y agoGoogle and it's employees are, combined, one of the largest DNC donors. This will never, ever happen.
- vondur 3y agoNo one pays for web browsers, I doubt Chrome would be a viable separate company.
- hakfoo 3y agoRather than sharding the company, and getting stuck in endless discussions of where exactly to draw lines and what business units are unsustainable, why not nationalize it? The "projecty" things like Chrome and Android and Waymo are arguably money sinks that will produce things of significant public value over time-- what if we funded them like other research probjects, with the understanding that the commercial applications will either generate public revenue or directly enhance domestic competitiveness. Imagine if in 5 years, the American carmakers had highly discounted access to Waymo's self-driving technology, but Mercedes and BMW still have to roll their own or license it at an intentionally hostile price? The revenue-generating stuff could be "commoditized" -- turn it into white-label products they'll resell to all comers. You no longer go to Google, you go to a Google Reseller who provides their own ad or subscription monetization model to pay for the underlying infrastructure cost. Since they all have the same core index, they start from strong competitive parity, and then they can focus on their differentating features-- extended custom indexes, more tools, etc.