16 ms·
American hard hat jobs have the highest level of open positions ever recorded
- shrimp_emoji 3y agoBoston Dynamics construction workers when
- 1letterunixname 3y ago4 words: Viable. Guest. Worker. Program. Bracero Program and before were workable. Not that they are directly applicable to today, but the paperwork to work temporarily in the US should be made many times simpler and easier than the convoluted, kafkaesque, corrupt abomination that it is now that benefits primarily medium and large agribusinesses by exploiting undocumented persons. The meat agriculture industry openly advertises salaries in newspapers in central and south America to encourage undocumented migration. It's a dirty secret that undocumented peoples who work for large industrial concerns are generally safe from ICE raids except for occasional token enforcement to maintain the pretense, while other undocumented people are subject to raids at any time. This isn't by accident but through the power of lobbyists and money.
- Tangurena2 3y agoThe last large raids were in 2006 at Swift Meat packing. What set them off was an internal investigation of a Hispanic worker in ICE who the IRS was complaining had not been paying income tax. Due to identity theft, her name & SSN were being used at more than 50 simultaneous jobs. Apparently the financial motive for a lot of identity theft is to find Hispanic name & SSN combos, which were, at least back in 2006, worth over $50 each to companies looking to dodge eVerify checks. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swift_raids https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swift_raids
- ftyers 3y agoUsually it's not the company that pays. The company just says "turn up with an SSN" and then other people who already work there put the new employee in touch with someone who deals in them. I've heard it cost 200-250$ for one. But that way the company has plausible deniability, and its the worker who is the "identity thief". A lot of the stuff is done on word of mouth, by compatriots just looking to help each other out.
- the_only_law 3y agoI’ve been looking at all the jobs in my local area for a little while now. Despite a lot of construction, I have seen very few “hiring” signifiers anywhere. A few management and PM roles get posted, usually wanting people with long established experience, but not many labor jobs. There’s a big construction project that’s been going on right next to me for a while. When I go past it, there’s a lot of yellow tape, and signs warning that it’s a felony to steal from the site, but no “we’re hiring” signs. Most of the jobs I see are bottom tier retail or restaurants positions, call center positions, some logistics jobs, various sales, medical jobs, and management. I do see some electrician work, but usually not in construction. So uh, where are these jobs?
- MaxHoppersGhost 3y agoWhere do you live? These jobs are probably in places that are seeing big growth like Florida, Texas, etc.
- blamazon 3y agoEvery major urban city has these jobs - population is not the only type of growth. Industrial, commercial, infrastructure projects demand just as much if not more of these jobs than residential.
- the_only_law 3y agoI’m in Florida
- blamazon 3y agoThese jobs are not generally posted online because it is a fractious world of zillions of tiny business entities that aren't exactly computer or even record keeping centric. Those PM/management type jobs are posted by general contractors which are much more conglomerated and white-collar (not entirely) than the subcontractors they manage. At those levels, trade unions and trade schools facilitate a lot of the hiring, and the rest is often word of mouth and person to person relationships involved, independent contractors and small businesses and whatnot, often operated completely from one person's cell phone. You might go to a local general contractor and say, do you know anyone looking for help for role X or Y? Almost guaranteed they do. You also won't find hiring signs at large construction sites because it's a significant nuisance to have a stream of random people (usually unqualified) walking into a managed construction area looking for work. I know this from experience.
- ecf 3y agoA lot of these construction jobs are fake advertisements to try to make it seem like the company employed more people than it actually did. Ton of PPP fraud going on in this industry.
- throwaway2903 3y agoYeah. Work for a summer as a manual laborer some time. Grueling, backbreaking work, unless you have the "in" (and five years journeyman experience at no to little pay) to be a plumber/electrician/heavy vehicle operator. Every time I've tried working in laboring I haven't lasted a month, usually less than two weeks (till paycheck). Carrying sheet rock, digging trenches, general haul this go over there. People come out of manual laboring either built like a professional wrestler, with severe muscle-skeletal problems, or both. No one wants to work those jobs because they're so terrible.
- forgetfreeman 3y agoThey don't want to work those jobs because they have no concept of mental and physical toughness. It's a shame too, spend 4-5 years bouncing around through the trades and you'll pick up enough skills to get a lifetime 70% off coupon for all home repair and renovation projects.
- droopyEyelids 3y agoI wanted to argue with you about this, as I have experience working as a construction site laborer, and then I thought back to the time I had to spend a night on-site because a huge beam fell off a wood pile and pinned my leg in the dirt and other fallen lumber, and everyone else had gone home and no one could hear me yelling. I wasn't seriously injured, but ninety nine out of 100 times someone in that position would be.
- Kenji 3y agoThat sounds like a terrifying position to be in.
- throwaway290 3y agoAlmost all of your recent comments are hidden (dead), I don't know why they are flagged because they mostly look OK and constructive to me.
- whiddershins 3y ago
- LargeDiggerNick 3y agoHas anyone tried paying more? These jobs are usually extremely low tier pay. Seems like a no brainer.
- nvr219 3y agoI'm guessing they did not try doing this.
- missedthecue 3y agoHow much would it take before you go work pouring concrete? As in, the minimum you'd take to start.
- tayo42 3y ago100/hr part time work, health care covered, unlimited pto and 401k match while living where i live now. id heavily consider it
- missedthecue 3y agoSo $200k a year before overtime, plus $50k in benefits. The construction industry cannot afford that even with 0% profit margins, and society cannot afford the construction industry to raise quotes high enough to fund that. New homes and city infrastructure projects are already at nosebleed prices.
- Ancalagon 3y agoYou asked and op answered honestly. Most people on HN recognize the value of their labor and won't take a lower paying _desk job_ than what they know they're worth, much less a backbreaking labor job that will likely ruin their health long term.
- applied_heat 3y agoUnlimited paid time off? Why show up at all? This does not exist in the world I live in (utilities)
- joeman1000 3y agoWorking as a labourer wrecked my back. I live with the pain every second of my life now. If they want more people to do this, they should pay them more. There is no such thing as a labour shortage - EVER. This is a stupid term. There is a pay shortage instead.
- throwaway5959 3y agoIs there a way someone could avoid wrecking their back in the kind of work you did or is it inevitable? Like it just takes one accident? I'm really sorry that you're in pain constantly. My wife has a bad back from a motorcycle accident and it's always an off-and-on thing for her. :(
- SantalBlush 3y agoSometimes it's an accident, sometimes it's repetitive motion. I worked in a shop where people had carpal tunnel from handling parts the same way for years, or bad eyes from welders. It really depends. Of course, some people take more precautions than others, and that helps, but it's no guarantee of safety.
- joeman1000 3y agoI think it's the nature of being a labourer, really. Your body is the machine, energy has to move through it by way of forces. Our spines are just not that great at holding up under the forces. Sorry to hear about your wife's situation, too. If she has an office job a nice chair goes such a long way. I got a HM Embody and can say that it improved my ability to work, since there's a lot less pain now.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoDepends on the job and the ergonomics involved but in general: posture. Most people just have really bad posture in general. Even while standing or sitting. There are proper postures to do a lot of activities and they are frequently not observed. Maintaining proper posture is a skill that must be trained until you don't have to think about it. Even something "mindlessly simple" like lifting a heavy object off the ground and carrying it somewhere requires proper posture and technique to reduce chance of injuries. Reduce, not eliminate. You can do everything right and still get injured. When lifting things off the ground, most people will flex and extend the torso instead of using their much stronger leg muscles. The better form is to squat down by flexing the thighs, pick up the object then lift it up by extending the thighs, all while maintaining the spine aligned. Physical education and conditioning is important in these jobs. In our every day lives.
- victorbstan 3y agoWorkers go where the money is.
- fouc 3y agoI think it could be fun to work these types of jobs if part-time was acceptable. Part-time would be ideal to give some time to recuperate and avoid accumulating injuries. I once built a house with two friends over a summer, gruelling work (70-80 hours per week) but lots of fun & great learning experience. A month in I had a major flare up of RSI in both wrists and had to take two weeks off to get it back under control (with the help of ibuprofen to reduce inflammation & on advice of my doctor), and then I wore wrist braces on the construction site after that. If it had been an actual job then I imagine there would've been more pressure to not take that time off to recuperate, leading to longer term damage.
- olliej 3y agoI assume the businesses are raising compensation and benefits accordingly?
- pessimizer 3y ago> According to an outlook from Associated Builders and Contractors, a trade group for the non-union construction industry > Plenty of money to build, not enough to recruit and train edit: > President Biden’s recent infrastructure bill magnifies the issue – money has been allocated for updating America’s infrastructure, but no money has been allocated for enticing new workers into the construction industry, or training new workers. This, according to Davidson, has worsened the labor shortage that already existed prior to the bill’s passage. America only thinks in terms of subsidizing the wealthy. The industry should be paying to train people to get into the industry, and government should be assisting and coordinating private businesses, not providing for them.
- yesiamyourdad 3y agoA lot of people talk about the money, but here's some other factors: Schedule - shifts start at 6AM or earlier. I knew a guy who worked concrete, he'd have to show up at 4AM to load the mixer. I knew another guy who majored in construction management, he said they had a 6AM class every day. The theory was if you couldn't make it to class, you wouldn't make it to work either. Consistency - I knew an electrician who was constantly in and out of work. He was either working 70+ hours a week or out of work for 2-3 months. The construction industry is very boom or bust. Drug Testing - the same friend who majored in construction management told me that something like 60% of their applicants failed a drug screen (almost always marijuana). The crazy thing is that he claimed they didn't actually care - their insurance company insisted on it. THC stays in your urine for quite a while so a positive test doesn't necessarily mean you're high right now, but people just wouldn't stay clean long enough to clear it. Safety - Others have mentioned it but between the day-to-day wear and tear and the risk of accident, it's tough on your body. Not many people over age 50 still work in construction trades, unless they're at Master level or have moved to management.
- tuatoru 3y agoYeah - employers in these industries seem to be acting like there's a plentiful supply of young adult males from which to pick and choose. They need to look at a few demographic tables and charts. 1. https://population.un.org/wpp/Graphs/Probabilistic/POP/15-24/840 https://population.un.org/wpp/Graphs/Probabilistic/POP/15-24...
- Arrath 3y ago> Schedule - shifts start at 6AM or earlier. I knew a guy who worked concrete, he'd have to show up at 4AM to load the mixer. I knew another guy who majored in construction management, he said they had a 6AM class every day. The theory was if you couldn't make it to class, you wouldn't make it to work either. This cuts for the nice highly paid salaried construction engineers too, as you allude to with the classes at 6am anecdote. IME, project management expects the engineers to be on-site at least a half hour or more before the field shift begins, and at least an hour past the field shift to ensure that the 'actual' work, the field stuff, is organized, ready, and gets carried out productively. Regardless if the field is working 8s, 10s, 12s, or more. No first thing in the morning panics or scrambles when a foreman realizes he doesn't have a work plan in hand and his crew of a dozen who started at 6am sits around waiting for the engineer to traipse in around 9am with an iced coffee just to print a pdf that should've been ready the night before. These kind of hours pretty rapidly cut into that equivalent hourly rate your salary equals!
- local_issues 3y ago[flagged]
- vpastore 3y ago[dead]
- Ostrogoth 3y agoI worked unskilled manual labor jobs (ranching/landscaping/construction/roughnecking/etc.) in the southern US starting age 14 during high school, then through university to pay for tuition (sometimes working two jobs), and after university in the oilfields until I finally found a white collar job utilizing my degree. It is back breaking work, sometimes in 100°+ heat/12 hr days, typically with zero health benefits. Many times employers are happy to use people up. The chance of injury is high, and even in skilled trades the longterm career sustainability is tough and hard on the body. It is also sometimes a culturally abrasive/toxic work environment, with hazing and poor leadership. I quickly decided that was not the life I wanted, and leveraged my degree into something else. I think that in the US some of the primary reasons people leave or avoid blue collar/hard hat industries is due to the risk of injury and poor quality/nonexistent or unaffordable healthcare.
- cbxyp 3y agoPretty simple explanation right here: https://i.redd.it/7h1mwj3gcjd61.png https://i.redd.it/7h1mwj3gcjd61.png I do my software engineering work in the middle of the night, while I'd happily work during the day for labor. Why not? Hard work keeps the body young. 2000 hours and licensing barriers is why not. There's no entry level apprenticeships available. There is no on the job training available. Even if someone is an autodidact the shortage is a given when the hiring requires unnecessary experience.
- shagymoe 3y agoYou clearly haven't worked a labor job. "Keeps the body young"? No, it generally destroys the body. Also, there's a reason the phrase "regulations are written in blood" gets repeated. Spoiler: It's because people have been injured and died doing things they didn't know were bad. In this guy's case, does he know under which conditions the giant hole he just dug with his shovel will cave in and bury him alive? Likely not. The same applies to "licensing barriers". This plague of people who think they're smarter than everyone else, especially those who came before them, and know about everything is insufferable.
- letrowekwel 3y agoAt least in my country, there are three types of "labor shortages". 1. Pay and/or working conditions suck so much people aren't interested. Think of nurses, various staff (restaurant, cleaning etc) that are often employed through third-party companies that offer you limited hours on weekly basis. 2. Labor limited through artificial constraints on supply. Doctors are a good example of this here - doctors associations successfully lobby to keep medical school student intake low, which means lower supply and better pay for those who make it. 3. Positions that require just too much experience, knowledge or talent to be obtained simply through right education. Think of top senior software engineers for example.
- bratgpttamer 3y ago> “It’s cultural,” Turmail said. “Mom doesn’t want her babies to grow up to be construction workers. For the last 40 years, we’ve been preaching a message nationally that the only path to success in life lies through a four-year college degree in some kind of an office." ... Vankudre said that construction as a career path is not particularly appealing to young people, and until the U.S. government and construction companies find a way to change that belief among the labor force’s newest generations, the shortage will linger. I used to work medical/safety on major construction sites, and I'm not sure it's purely pay, because lots of guys love the overtime (caused in part by fewer men per man-hour of work). The beginning of the proverbial pipeline is drying/has dried up. Good for workers, bad for companies. A google search for "meme about college vs trades" captures the sentiment: "College Kid is $100k in debt for his PhD in Philosophical Basketweaving, is unemployed, and looks down at tradesmen"; "Tradesman got paid for his apprenticeship, owns a house and a brand-new pickup truck, and just disconnected College Kid's utilities for non-payment"
- lotsofpulp 3y agoAre there job listings showing payrates and work schedules to substantiate this?
- bratgpttamer 3y agoA search for "traveling construction jobs" will get you at least part of the story, but advertised salaries usually don't include the unplanned-but-essentially-guaranteed overtime. There's also Per Diem rates that aren't technically part of salary/base pay - e.g., $250 per day to cover your travel/hotel/meals. The demurrage clauses in contracts are generally more expensive than paying overtime, even 2x rates, so it happens as the project falls behind, which it almost inevitably does, due to weather, failed drug tests, people walking/getting kicked off the job, etc. Things like large concrete pours or topping off a wind turbine need to be done in one go, which can quickly result in 16, 18, or 20-hour days and/or 7-day work weeks. So, the job might advertise $20-40/hr, but many of these guys are making well over $100k annually.
- 3y ago
- nokya 3y agoWith increasing rampant xenophobia and anti-foreigner sentiment, this can only mean good news.
- onewheeltom 3y agoHow about developing modern building methods that are not particularly dangerous to ones personal health?
- CharlieDigital 3y agoRecent Freakonomics episode might have some insights: https://freakonomics.com/podcast/will-the-democrats-make-america-great-again/ https://freakonomics.com/podcast/will-the-democrats-make-ame... Namely many of the major spending bills passed by the Biden admin focuses on actually building things in the US.
- vGPU 3y agoIt turns out going to war against china isn’t the best idea when all of your manufacturing is in china.
- bluGill 3y agoDespite popular belief, there is still a lot of manufacturing in the us. Cheap plastic 'junk' is made in china, but there is plenty of manufacturing in the us and thus know how to do it.
- missedthecue 3y agoIt's not 1998 anymore, China has a huge industry in precision and high tech manufacturing. They build the iphone after all, not to mention most of the components inside, 95% of the drone industry, more automobiles than anyone else, high speed trains, hell, they even make their own 5th gen stealth fighter jets.
- Vt71fcAqt7 3y ago>not to mention most of the components inside Which ones? The display, SoC, and RAM are not manufactured in China. IIRC the battery and one of the cameras are made there and the main camera is not.
- cyanydeez 3y agoAlso, china managed the 2008 recession by make work projects and had those projects really had a use case, it's been successful. Biden clearly understands the real economic value of keeping an economy functional.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- desert_rue 3y agoI majored in construction management in school. I was the only one in my major who didn’t grow up with a father, uncle, or grandfather in the trades. It is often hard, grueling work. I was a project manager so I didn’t ‘perform’ any of the work, but I was still up scaffolding and down in muddy pits. The laborers are out in the worst weather day and night and make decent money- but totally wreck their bodies. So it is a combination of people being steered away from labor jobs into college, not knowing an entry point without family ties, and grueling hard work. I’m surprised anything gets built.
- clove 3y agoHow are they wrecking their bodies? If they don't get injured, isn't the work pretty healthy, like exercise?
- solumunus 3y agoExercising 8 hours a day for 40 years, where much of the “exercise” involves inefficient postures which put load on joints and tendons. This isn’t a session at the local gym with nice machines using movements specifically designed for safety.
- brailsafe 3y agoEven if it were at the gym, it would be a miracle to do that amount of it without simply over-using your bits.
- morkalork 3y agoShit, we get RSI and carpal tunnel syndrome from typing. What is the weight carried by, or repetition of, that by that vs any trade?
- SantalBlush 3y agoExactly. Even in a gym, proper exercise form is essential for preventing injury. At work, proper form often isn't a realistic option.