4 ms·
There is a link on the main page titled "Decolonizing Functions", which leads to... https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Special:MyLanguage/Abstract_Wikipedia/Updat
by userbinator 3y ago
There is a link on the main page titled "Decolonizing Functions", which leads to...
https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Special:MyLanguage/Abstract_Wikipedia/Updates/2023-03-02 https://meta.wikimedia.org/wiki/Special:MyLanguage/Abstract_...
I'm not sure if that is satire, or for that matter this whole site.
- starkparker 3y ago[flagged]
- abathologist 3y agoThat page seems totally reasonable and admirable to me. It’s literally just advocating for including the wide and varied history of algorithm development, in order to encourage readers from many different backgrounds to find ways to connect with the important topic.
- LudwigNagasena 3y ago[flagged]
- cypherpunks01 3y ago> I don’t think an encyclopaedia should cater to racist views of its readers over factual information Uh, nobody thinks this. I'm sensing an straw man argument fast incoming.. > So it seems unreasonable to stretch the truth to diversify or narrow down the number of people you mention It's entirely unclear where you see the truth being stretched? Factually recognizing important contributions by people from under-represented backgrounds is doing the exact opposite of narrowing the "number of people you mention". It's literally mentioning more people who contributed to a certain effort or field of study.
- LudwigNagasena 3y ago> Uh, nobody thinks this. I'm sensing an straw man argument fast incoming.. Of course they do. That's what they say: > The way I understand the program of decolonizing mathematics is to follow two principles: > first, to recognize the contributions of people with diverse backgrounds, in order to offer more protagonists who can inspire and with whom more people can identify > second, to provide examples and motivations that are relatable to under-represented backgrounds and identities, in order to reach and be more immediately helpful to more people They imply that people will more readily identify and congregate with people of their own racial and ethnic background. That may be true, that doesn't make it any less racist. > It's entirely unclear where you see the truth being stretched? Factually recognizing important contributions by people from under-represented backgrounds is doing the exact opposite of narrowing the "number of people you mention". If you factually recognize important contributions, you don't have to make any efforts or care about the raised issue. > It's literally mentioning more people who contributed to a certain effort or field of study. Mentioning more than what?
- atoav 3y agoIf you want to write who invented the algorithm and there is one asian invention in 1303 and one by some eueopean in 1803 then leaving out the asian inventor is actively harmful to the encyclopedia as it distorts truth. This article to me just tries to raise awareness for the fact that our western history of who invented what is often incomplete and sometimes simply wrong. Historians right now have the unenviable task of considering how the history they work with has been distorted by racism (e.g. by playing down the role of certain people with the "wrong" race and instead attributing things to people with the "right" race). I'd like an encyclopedia to list all inventors of something even if they are not known in my culture — preferably in my own language as well, but that is a different topic.
- userbinator 3y agoWhat exactly do you mean by "to find ways to connect with the important topic"? That sort of obfuscated language doesn't help explain anything.
- nonethewiser 3y agoHes saying non-whites feel like functions are foreign to them
- Levitz 3y ago>It’s literally just advocating for including the wide and varied history of algorithm development, in order to encourage readers from many different backgrounds to find ways to connect with the important topic. I'm at a loss of words for what I feel towards respecting (even promoting!) the idea that a piece of knowledge ought to become interesting or valuable if there is ethnic relationship to it. It reeks of supremacist talk to me. If someone came up to me saying that he got into mathematics because Charles Babbage was a white guy, just like him, I'd think that person doesn't belong in current society. This doesn't change if the person belongs to any minority.
- beepbooptheory 3y ago[flagged]
- Levitz 3y agoFeigning ignorance? I am explicit in pointing how minorities tend to get a special deal when it comes to supremacist talk. I just don't condone it. I don't believe that glorification based on race is something you can keep to certain races. I am simply not racist about racism.
- beepbooptheory 3y agoGotcha, well good luck with that I guess.
- ckoerner 3y agoRepresentation matters. Many people are not represented in the worlds knowledge, much less the creation of it.
- js8 3y agoYour outrage at this seems to be analogous to outrage of people who think that it is horrible that Unix has a "kill" operation. Basically, you don't understand that "decolonization" is a metaphor for a broader historical perspective, and instead you're trying to interpret it literally and in a bad faith.
- userbinator 3y agoThe only ones talking about "decolonization" are on one very extreme side of the political spectrum and trying to inject identity politics into everything. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33607032 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33607032
- js8 3y agoI don't understand your argument. Where is, aside from the word "decolonization", the author of that document trying to "inject identity politics"? And to what end? (And you certainly seem to be concerned by identity of the people making those claims..) Take a step back and think about how your statement really sounds. It's like saying that "a group of extremist geeks who wrote Unix is trying to inject violence into everything". It's faux outrage that misses the point.
- nonethewiser 3y agoTo what end? You’d have to ask the author and hope for a grounded answer. Probably internal satisfaction, virtue signaling, or advancing ideology. > Take a step back and think about how your statement really sounds. Why dont you tell him how you think it sounds instead of misrepresenting a consensus?
- raincole 3y agoPeople also got mad at Git for having default branch named master.
- js8 3y ago
- nonethewiser 3y ago[flagged]
- soared 3y ago> first, to recognize the contributions of people with diverse backgrounds, in order to offer more protagonists who can inspire and with whom more people can identify second, to provide examples and motivations that are relatable to under-represented backgrounds and identities, in order to reach and be more immediately helpful to more people Seems pretty reasonable IMO. Feels like pretty mellow and easy actions to take. But the linked post I agree is a bit … condescending? Self congratulating?