9 ms·
> Our schools like to talk about perseverance/grit/etc. a lot, but when it comes down to it they don’t care enough to give students work that requires it. Well
by ryandrake 3y ago
> Our schools like to talk about perseverance/grit/etc. a lot, but when it comes down to it they don’t care enough to give students work that requires it.
Well, they care, but just not about the students who are already excelling (and already bringing up test score averages). I've got a kid in elementary school, and it's pretty evident most of the school's resources are spent on the worst-performing kids, leaving the smarter ones bored and unchallenged. Yea, it was like this too when I was in grade school in the '80s, but it seems much worse today.
If your kid is reading or math-ing beyond grade level, they're just going to get ignored and handed straight-A's while the teachers desperately spend all their time getting Donny Dumbass to at least stop screaming all day and eating crayons. There's no gifted program or tracking/segregating by ability anymore. I guess those are bad for "equity".
- ForOldHack 3y agoPretty much it was that way in the late 1960s... until... we got a computer programming class, but this is about math: In Berkeley, they had a program called 'Seed' that had a great idea, give middle school students access to PhD math students. It was going fairly well, until Dr Steven Giavant stepped into a classroom and wanted to teach the students the frontiers and history of math. ( look this guy up! Genius at Math, Super genius at education. ) I know that besides me, 6 other students got degrees in math, and we suspect 2 more. Absurd. The norm was 1.2, even for Berkeley. He shared his enthusiasm for math, and the children got it. We only found out about it by accident, when my Abstract Algebra professor said that they were in Berkeley Math at that time. ( 15+ years later ). And the second influence was Michael Griffin, who taught computer programming, when I asked him "How do I get to actually learn Calculus?" he basically laid out the curriculum that led to my degree. With two more break throughs, I now can use this to inspire sucess in math. Thanks Steven, and thanks Mike. https://www.facebook.com/MillsMCS/posts/1920193231575804 https://www.facebook.com/MillsMCS/posts/1920193231575804
- javajosh 3y ago>It was going fairly well, until Dr Steven Giavant stepped into a classroom and wanted to teach the students the frontiers and history of math. The way you wrote this it feels like you're about to say that Giavant tanked the program, and your parenthetical is sarcasm. I don't think that was your intent, but you may want to be aware in the future (and it could be an issue with the reader, of course.)
- Harvesterify 3y agoRead it the same way.
- fsckboy 3y agothat's because Dr Steven Giavant was great at math, but nobody was teaching the kids english comp.
- civilitty 3y agoI was about to google "Steven Giavant" to see what flavor of serial killer he was. Totally expected that comment to take a much darker turn.
- jimhefferon 3y agoI'd be very interested to hear more about Dr Giavant. I teach and I'm always looking to hear what works for folks.
- brailsafe 3y agoGrade school is less a place for learning as it is a socialization experiment. Did you actually advance your level in any subject during grade school? Did your kid advance above their grade because of the grades that came before it? What's the utility in the school servicing your special child's aptitude when the school had nothing to do with either their current level or the lack of others'? But there are advanced level classes in some cases
- twump 3y agoIf grade school is for socialization than it should be focused on socialization. Group activities, athletic competitions, creative projects, theater performances, etc.
- bradley13 3y agoYou're right: low performing kids get the attention and resources. The kids doing well "don't need help." Which is just wrong. The gifted kids are far more likely to contribute significantly to our future. Boring them, stunting their potential, ruining their education is the worst thing schools can do. Kids need to be in different tracks. You need at least three tracks. Obviously, it should be possible to move between them as appropriate.
- lexandstuff 3y ago"gifted kids are far more likely to contribute significantly to our future" Citation needed.
- LargeTomato 3y agoI disagree. Citation not needed. Common sense and critical reasoning will suffice here.
- spicebox 3y agoCommon sense is frequently wrong and is usually invoked by people who want their beliefs to be taken as fact without needing to provide support
- bluepod4 3y agoCorrect.
- georgeashworth 3y agoCitation needed
- spicebox 3y agoTouché - “Science has widely come to be understood as a systematic assault on common sense. Common sense said the world was flat; science showed this to be false. Common sense said the sun and the moon were the same size; science showed this to be wrong. Common sense said the Earth was the center of the universe; science showed this to be false. Common sense said matter was solid; science has shown this to be false” https://publishing.cdlib.org/ucpressebooks/view?docId=ft8c6009k3&chunk.id=d0e1167&toc.id=&brand=ucpress https://publishing.cdlib.org/ucpressebooks/view?docId=ft8c60...
- gnicholas 3y ago> There's no gifted program or tracking/segregating by ability anymore. I guess those are bad for "equity". The CA Dept of Education used to require GATE programs. In 2014, they made them optional, so schools stopped offering them. What's shocking to me is that this happened even in districts where there are lots of high-performing kids, with families that care about advanced learning. When we moved to Menlo Park, we were surprised that our highly-rated school doesn't have any programs for kids who are advanced in learning. They just talk about how all their lessons have a "low floor and high ceiling" which sounds nice in theory but doesn't work very well in practice (at least when you have a mix of kids who range from 1-2 grades below grade level to 2-3 grades above grade level).
- alibova 3y agoWe've heard good things about MP public schools so that's disappointing! Did you guys end up going to private?
- gnicholas 3y agoWe’re still in the district, and have finally pushed hard enough that they let our kid take a diagnostic test and move ahead independently. But that literally took 3 years to accomplish, during which time zero math learning happened at school. To clarify, this is the Las Lomitas district, which is west Menlo Park, not MPCSD, which covers downtown and the rest of MP. If you want a magnet program, go to Redwood City — it has one. Even the privates are generally not great on math acceleration. I hear Menlo School doesn’t allow early acceleration either, and they’re one of the more academic private schools. Feel free to email me (contact in profile) if you want more details.
- treeman79 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harrison_Bergeron https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harrison_Bergeron Excellent story about the government not allowing anyone to be too smart or beautiful. Example. If you’re smart, you wear head phones that emit random loud noises so you can’t form thoughts for long.
- spamizbad 3y ago> Well, they care, but just not about the students who are already excelling (and already bringing up test score averages). I've got a kid in elementary school, and it's pretty evident most of the school's resources are spent on the worst-performing kids, leaving the smarter ones bored and unchallenged. Yea, it was like this too when I was in grade school in the '80s, but it seems much worse today. This is basically the education reform movement of the 90s and aughts getting their wish via the monkey-paw. Schools and teachers are measured and judged on how kids perform on standardized tests. Your kid is likely in the 95%+ percentile so there’s not much room for “growth” as far as the metrics are concerned. So their efforts are on pulling up kids from the 5th percentile up closer to the median. Also, it’s not uncommon for low performing students parents to sometimes freak out at the school if their kid starts falling behind, so everyone scrambles to get these kids back on track so the parents don’t pull their kids from school (which will only make things worse for the kids academics)
- twump 3y agoBut won't it make it better for everyone else? Not even sure that bottom 5% should be in school. Just train them for a role that they can be competent in or decide that they will be a future ward of the state.
- turzmo 3y agoThe bottom 5% is hopeless. Yeah it would be better if we did that, but people think about education as a means to provide the individual the chance for success in life rather than thinking about the broader impact of individuals on society and the disproportionate effect that the top has. As far as most people are concerned, a kid that is acing everything is going to be fine in life and they don't worry about anything that could be going wrong there.
- ryandrake 3y agoMy parents were both [retired] teachers, and sadly this is the truth. Some bottom N%, I don’t know if it’s 1 or 5 or 10 or whatever, but they are absolutely beyond anyone’s ability to rehab, let alone educate. Often no fault of their own. Broken families, parents don’t care, gangs, lots of reasons. Any effort spent on them is wasted. They are inevitably fucked, and will end up in some kind of institution (prison, mental health) or unemployable, by age 25. It’s a sad reality and not something politicians like to talk about. We pretend that if we just whip the teachers so they teach harder, these people will miraculously grow up to be functional adults. It’s not going to happen. I remember a guy in my high school whose claim to fame was he dragged some other poor kid into the wood shop and filed his teeth down to nothing with a band saw. Spending 50% of the school budget on these blockheads is not going to rehab them.
- twump 3y ago[flagged]
- bluepod4 3y ago> There's no gifted program or tracking/segregating by ability anymore. I guess those are bad for "equity". I’m assuming you just mean in your school system. Or do you mean more school districts are moving toward this?
- ChainOfFools 3y ago"You remember how one of the Greek Dictators (they called them “tyrants” then) sent an envoy to another Dictator to ask his advice about the principles of government. The second Dictator led the envoy into a field of grain, and there he snicked off with his cane the top of every stalk that rose an inch or so above the general level. The moral was plain. Allow no preeminence among your subjects. Let no man live who is wiser or better or more famous or even handsomer than the mass. Cut them all down to a level: all slaves, all ciphers, all nobodies. All equals. Thus Tyrants could practise, in a sense, “democracy.” But now “democracy” can do the same work without any tyranny other than her own. No one need now go through the field with a cane. The little stalks will now of themselves bite the tops off the big ones. The big ones are beginning to bite off their own in their desire to Be Like Stalks." - C.S. Lewis (in the voice of screwtape), almost 80 years ago.
- chaostheory 3y ago> to at least stop screaming all day and eating crayons Less developed children are challenging to the system, but it gets worse: there are children who are so violent that they essentially attend prison schools. Since this is CA, they are obviously not called that. Pretty sure that this is a massive drain on the educational budget.
- Aeolun 3y agoThose kids are few and far between. Can’t imagine it’s a massive drain on the budget even if they cost 10 or 100x more to educate to the same level.
- chaostheory 3y agoThese children live in the prison. They also require extra staff who are paid more and their very own buildings.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Yea, it was like this too when I was in grade school in the '80s, but it seems much worse today. This is largely a legacy of state testing and “accountability” regimes which were accelerated by national policy like NCLB and focus intense pressure on minimizing the number of students testing below grade level.
- Gustomaximus 3y ago> leaving the smarter ones bored and unchallenged. At my childrens school, as work is often online they allow them to go ahead in modules. The teacher mist open it for them though to have some control. Some people in year 7 are doing year 9 work. Great for challenging them but it will be curious where this goes as you might get some people finishing all of highschool classes for a particular subject quite early and need to keep educating and challenging them. For english they have a program where you can finish your end of school exams for this subject the year early, freeing time for other subjects. This is in Australia.
- sgu999 3y ago> If your kid is reading or math-ing beyond grade level, they're just going to get ignored and handed straight-A's while the teachers desperately spend all their time getting Donny Dumbass to at least stop screaming all day and eating crayons. There's no gifted program or tracking/segregating by ability anymore. I guess those are bad for "equity". Maybe, but at the same time it's OK if your gifted kid only has a PhD and a high paying job but not a Nobel prize. Whereas it's a bit problematic for society if Donny Dumbass spends his life being a burden to everyone because he remains problematic...
- lelanthran 3y agoWe're living on a rock with limited lifespan. Humanity itself is at risk from various extinction level events. If you insist that it's okay for all gifted students to never exceed to the point of making ground breaking discoveries, we're likely extinct sooner rather than later. The nongifted people, even if all completely stop contributing to society, would not result in an extinction. IOW, we are all relying on the gifted people to save us. Hobbling gifted people even slightly has a far worse impact than not helping non gifted people. And yes, I am part of the non gifted.
- paulryanrogers 3y agoHow do you imagine gifted people have or will save humanity from extinction-level events?
- sgu999 3y agoI believe we are facing a strong case of naive techno-optimism. I'll give it a go: a 19 yo genius may find a way to capture kilograms of carbons in each leaf of peppermint through a new kind of photosynthesis, and by showing it to the world, we'll all be able to reproduce it and meet our carbon neutrality by 2050. And my uncle Joe, enlightened, will start spending his days drinking peppermint tea instead of making millions trading disposable plastic products from East Asia.
- 3y ago