9 ms·
The world’s largest wind turbine has been switched on
- TOGoS 3y ago> According to the corporation, just one of these turbines should be able to produce enough electricity to power 36,000 households of three people each for one year What happens after one year? Do they collapse into the ocean and then they have to build a new one?
- retrocryptid 3y ago[flagged]
- timpeq 3y ago"just one of these turbines should be able to produce enough electricity to power 36,000 households of three people each for one year" Does this imply that a turbine only lasts 1 year?
- tekla 3y agoHow does it imply that?
- function_seven 3y agoI think parent is pointing out the unnecessary “for one year” part. What is the purpose of that? I assume that this turbine should be able to supply those 36,000 households for an arbitrary amount of time, not just one year.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- inconceivable 3y agolmao yeah dude they replace it every year.
- sparker72678 3y agoFor whatever reason, wind power tends to be back-of-mind for me. Clearly, I'm missing out! What amazing machines!
- ninkendo 3y ago123 meter blades, that’s insane. This means the tip of the blade travels 772 meters in a single rotation. The speed of sound is 340 meters per second, meaning if it travels more than 0.44 rotations in a second, the tips of the blades are breaking the sound barrier.
- rcme 3y agoThat is crazy, but, on the other hand, seeing this rotate faster than once every two seconds would be insanely fast.
- civilitty 3y agoWe just need to hook it up to a flux capacitor and the next typhoon will give us time travel.
- dylan604 3y agoI did the math, but we didn't hit 1.21 jigawatts
- djbusby 3y agoBack in the day, it was still spelled Giga but pronounced Jiga. I heard from some old-heads at power company.
- rainbowzootsuit 3y agoJigga What, Jigga Who Hard Watt Life
- esafak 3y agoGettin' jiggy wit it
- gnatman 3y ago
- Qem 3y agoCurious about what is the upper limit. How much can we go beyond 16 MW before physics laws put a cap on size?
- samstave 3y agoWe need to figure out how to get things to spin in space really fast - like some piezioelectrical fan blade turbine that takes advantage of the extremes in differential temps? @Twosdai - I was talking about space generators, there is no air. So how get spin, from temperature diffs that can turn a turbine/generator?
- twosdai 3y agoI don't think that it's necessarily speed which is the thing that we should look for. It's how best to convert large amounts of moving air into rational motion. So a large slow moving windmill may generate more power than a smaller faster moving one.
- tda 3y agoLast I heard I think 25MW turbines were in some early stage of development. At least that is the biggest my former employer I recall was considering for their latest installation vessel. But I have been out of the loop for a while, so would love to hear an update. The first 14MW was installed quite a few years ago (and it might have been upgraded to 15MW), so this is just a small-ish increase in max size. The big news, foe at least, is that it is Chinese. Siemens, Vestas and GE have some serious competition now it seems
- windows2020 3y agoI wonder what paint job would best prevent birds from being destroyed by this. It looks like sometimes one blade is painted black for this purpose. How do bird deaths from wind turbines compare to other manmade objects?
- throwbadubadu 3y agoInsignificant on many levels. If we should care for that we should stop all fossil fuel consumption right now, stop eating meat, and most importantly, stop putting glass windows into our cute buildings. Why are these questions always in wind turbine posts before anything els?
- mirko22 3y agoCos some people care about birds? How does eating meat factor into this?
- erulabs 3y agoBecause ostensibly global warming and climate change is of far more existential threat than localized turbines. Wind power could possibly save all birds, at the cost of some birds. It’s similar to when a self driving car gets into an accident - all hand wringing and no looking at broader statistics.
- thinkcontext 3y agoMost people who bring up birds wrt wind turbines don't care about birds, eg Donald Trump.
- adrianmonk 3y agoWell, if the meat is chicken or turkey...
- canadianfella 3y ago[dead]
- 3y ago
- rajandatta 3y agoFascinating article. Looks encouraging. The size of the turbine and the capacity claimed is staggering. Is anyone aware of any materials that explainn how one distributes turbines over a farm to maximize yield? Can a tribune of this scale alter localized flow to require specific distribution patterns?
- jeffbee 3y agoIn the port of Halifax right now there are two heavy-lift semi-submersible transports carrying 12 13MW wind turbines destined for the Vineyard Wind project off Cape Cod. A photo of what the tower segments look like: https://twitter.com/BenMacLeod/status/1680629818931511296/photo/1 https://twitter.com/BenMacLeod/status/1680629818931511296/ph...
- tommiegannert 3y agoGot curious what the power rating of the blade pitch control system is. Couldn't find a size reference, but KEBA [1] sells motors and drivers at the 9 kW and 22 kW levels. Nidec [2] at 26 kW. So just controlling the pitch (presumably of a more average turbine) uses the (peak) power of heating a house in Sweden. Noted that the duty cycle is low, but still. [1] https://www.keba.com/download/x/18628e52a3/pitchone-datasheet_10_2022_en_web.pdf https://www.keba.com/download/x/18628e52a3/pitchone-datashee... [2] https://www.nidec-industrial.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/SSB_Wind_Brochure_Perfect_Pitch_EN.pdf https://www.nidec-industrial.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/...
- nerdponx 3y agoIt'd be interesting to see how much energy a modern natural gas power plant uses for its operations by comparison.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- walnutclosefarm 3y agoMy little "farm" covers 21 acres. The blades on this single turbine sweep an area equal to more than half of that. Amazing.
- jameskerr 3y agoGiant turbines out in the ocean with regular gales and storms. That must be a massive challenge to construct.
- Animats 3y agoThese are advertised as "typhoon resistant". Like all big wind turbines, the props are variable pitch, feather under excessive wind, and rotation stops. The big trouble spot is the gearbox and its bearings.[1] These big turbines are advertised as "semi direct drive" turbines, which means they only have one stage of geared speed step-up. Large wind turbines are very slow compared to desirable generator RPMs, and the bigger the turbine, the lower the RPMs. Bearing trouble is currently the big limitation on turbine life. Not many large wind turbine drivetrains are reaching the 25 year design life. Huge bearings and gears with off-axis loads have problems not seen in other applications. As the wind changes, stresses appear from odd angles. This causes minor bearing damage, which increases wear, which eventually causes major damage. A new research result: [2][3] Argonne National Lab has been able to reproduce this problem in a benchtop setup. The metallurgy/lubrication problem is still not fully understood, and it's getting considerable attention. Stuff like this is the difference between a prototype and a long-lived production product. [1] https://www.stle.org/files/TLTArchives/2020/08_August/Feature.aspx https://www.stle.org/files/TLTArchives/2020/08_August/Featur... [2] https://www.energy.gov/eere/wind/articles/zeroing-no-1-cause-wind-turbine-gearbox-failures https://www.energy.gov/eere/wind/articles/zeroing-no-1-cause... [3] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0921509319302576 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S09215...
- tuatoru 3y agoTruncated-pyramid floating wind turbines shouldn't have as much of a problem with this, as the loads are closer to traditional transverse and axial. (Picture two flat-topped letter 'A's, one behind the other, with a crossbar going from the top of the front one to the top of the back one. The blades spin around this crossbar, an axle. The generator can be at one end of this axle, or in the blade hub. The whole structure is floating, moored at one corner, and can rotate to keep the blades facing into the wind as required.)
- Animats 3y agoThe picture looks strange. You can see a ship through the turbine blade. That seems to be because ifisicence took a promotional picture with lettering and leaf decoration from here [1] and "cleaned it up" with some photo tool. General Electric and Vestas both have 14 megawatt wind turbine prototypes in operation. This seems to be a prototype deployed in a large installation. It's not in the catalog yet.[2] Mingyang has been delivering some 12 megawatt units. Two years ago they announced a similar model with slightly shorter blades.[3] [1] http://www.myse.com.cn/en/ http://www.myse.com.cn/en/ [2] http://www.myse.com.cn/en/cplb/info.aspx?itemid=578 http://www.myse.com.cn/en/cplb/info.aspx?itemid=578 [3] http://www.myse.com.cn/en/jtxw/info.aspx?itemid=825 http://www.myse.com.cn/en/jtxw/info.aspx?itemid=825
- nerdponx 3y agoThe caption says "similar to this one" so I didn't expect much. But it's interesting to see a publication engage in what looks initially like overt copyright infringement.
- constantly 3y agoGood spotting, IFLScience hasn’t been “real” science for a while since they got some traction and vitality. Their role has shifted more towards what makes headlines, which is what sells ads, which is what pays them.
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- Kosirich 3y agoSiemens Games RE has one as well. https://www.rechargenews.com/wind/one-day-one-turbine-359mwh-siemens-gamesa-claims-new-wind-power-world-record/2-1-1331442 https://www.rechargenews.com/wind/one-day-one-turbine-359mwh...
- petee 3y agoIt is an unedited photo, available in their press packet -- http://www.myse.com.cn/en/zlxz/index.aspx http://www.myse.com.cn/en/zlxz/index.aspx
- AYBABTME 3y agoSimilar wind speeds happen every afternoon in "the Slot" in the SF Bay. Maybe we should decorate the area with a similar giant windmill. It also happens to be when peak pricing is in effect.
- danans 3y agoI've been thinking along the same lines recently. The shallows just next to Emeryville seem ideal for this, and would aesthically match the new eastern span of the Bay Bridge. I'm not sure if or why this hasn't been proposed yet.
- post_break 3y agoI can think of a five letter word why. NIMBY
- ljf 3y agoI live on the coast in the East of England and can see three banks of wind turbines on a clear day. The nearest are 4 miles out to sea. When they were first installed there was local opposition, but now no one cares about them at all. They don't ruin the horizon, they aren't an eyesore, and compared to office blocks they don't seem to be killing a large number of birds or causing any other issues with wildlife. They want to build more, but the blockage seems to be the large increases in costs of materials and labour since the project was costed pre-COVID (likely just a play for some govt subsidies?) and also concerns about pylons to carry the power generated. I'm personally not so worried about the pylons esp given the cost of buried cabling.
- dontlaugh 3y agoI think they look nice. Only putting them in the sea is a big limitation in England, though. It’s not easy to defeat the remaining feudal lords who oppose land ones.
- jl6 3y agoThe world used about 180,000TWh of energy in 2022[0]. That requires about 21TW of generation capacity. If we assume wind turbines have a capacity factor of about 30% due to the intermittency of wind, we would need about 69TW of nameplate capacity. If each of these turbines is rated at 16MW, we would need about 4.3 million of them. Is there enough space? Let's assume turbines should be spaced 10 rotor diameters apart[2]. A turbine of this size (246m diameter) would need to have about 2.5 * 2.5=6.25km^2 of dedicated space. So we will need about 27 million square kilometers of open sea space. Coincidentally, that's the same as the total area of continental shelf in the whole world.[3] Continental shelf depth is up to 200m.[4] The deepest wind turbines today are in depths of 59m.[5] What should we conclude? As long as we figure out a way of building turbines in deeper water, or perhaps floating turbines, and a way of manufacturing the required materials (hopefully without recourse to fossil fuels), the project seems just about plausible. But it would be a truly planet-scale endeavour. [0] https://ourworldindata.org/energy-production-consumption https://ourworldindata.org/energy-production-consumption [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capacity_factor#Wind_farm https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capacity_factor#Wind_farm [2] https://ideasmedioambientales.com/wind-turbine-spacing/ https://ideasmedioambientales.com/wind-turbine-spacing/ [3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Continental_shelf https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Continental_shelf [4] https://www.britannica.com/science/continental-shelf https://www.britannica.com/science/continental-shelf [5] https://www.sse.com/news-and-views/2023/04/world-s-deepest-offshore-wind-turbine-foundation-is-installed-in-scottish-waters/\\ https://www.sse.com/news-and-views/2023/04/world-s-deepest-o...*
- robin_reala 3y agoIs anyone seriously proposing a wind turbine monoculture for energy generation?
- jl6 3y agoPick your desired percentage of wind in the future energy mix. Even if we say 25%, it's still going to need millions of turbines. And our energy demands are not shrinking.
- 3y ago
- dtgriscom 3y agoAnybody else notice the small arrow on the base of each blade showing which way it should rotate? (Is it likely that someone would install these blades backwards?)
- doodlebugging 3y agoThey have installed these in the Taiwan Strait where, in the event of war between China and Taiwan, one well-aimed missile knocks out power to 36000 homes or businesses. Obviously the first target and the juiciest targets are those that disrupt and disable the adversary's ability to produce the means and materials of conducting warfare. Therefore power generation, factories that produce munitions or that can be quickly flipped to dual purpose factories are obvious targets to neutralize. Accomplishing the destruction of your adversary's domestic ability to produce the weapons of war, food stocks for the nation, munitions, etc compromises the adversary's ability to conduct a war without needing to depend on outside assistance. In Texas we have numerous wind farms. One of my relatives came home to find a crew at work on the neighboring property building a pad for a turbine. They had received no notice that a wind farm was to be constructed in the area and none about opportunities to object to turbine placement and as a result, while they were trying to determine who to contact about this, brand new turbines were installed on the neighboring property with the nearest one being less than 1500 feet from their home. It appears that they are now stuck with the constant whoosh-whoosh-whoosh of the blades as they rotate and an electric hum, 24 hours a day and their peaceful home now has an inescapable background noise pattern. I love wind power, I have some solar power installed on my own property and will be upgrading that. I think though that the ability to enjoy peace and quiet in your own home should not be compromised by a private utility even if they are providing clean power for public consumption. It would be better if we could replace some older turbines with newer units like this high-capacity turbine in the article. Perhaps with larger, more pwoerful turbines we would need fewer to be installed to be able to meet our state's power consumption needs. New wind power installations should be mandated to use best-available technology so that we end up with durable, reliable, quiet power generation with a minimal footprint.
- matthewdgreen 3y agoTFA is about offshore wind turbines, which would seem to address your concerns about having one built near your house.
- doodlebugging 3y agoBelieve it or don't, I read TFA and added a little color to the situation since most of us understand that great technology like high-capacity turbines has the potential to be useful in more locations than just offshore installations. As time passes and we are able to make the switch from fossil fuel sources to renewable sources we will find ourselves with a requirement that we produce as much power as possible in the smallest footprint. There will always be people who don't want a turbine near their house. That's a simple fact. One of the original arguments against wind installations in California was the argument that it spoiled the view since no one wanted to see a bunch of turbines along a scenic ridge, they preferred the unmolested vistas of their childhood. Later, they focused on noise issues, which are valid concerns, and many states worked with operators and other stakeholders to design a set of guidelines or restrictions on minimal offsets from habitations. Texas is not one of those states and so wind turbines of any size can be installed within the wind farms without taking into consideration existing habitations. Most operators solicit public input though in the case I mentioned, there is no record of any notice to affected people that the wind farm might have an impact on their use of their property or quality of life. It is a lot like the problems we had here during the Barnett Shale boom about 15 years ago where operators bought mineral rights all over North Texas and began drilling for natural gas and then fracking those wells so they would be economical to produce. There were no restrictions in most cities and communities on offsets to housing, schools, businesses, etc and so, as the industry has done so many times in the past, they took advantage of that situation and began drilling knowing that they could deal with those problems later. Over a course of years some communities passed regulations limiting drilling locations and other parts of the operation in a bid to prevent drilling wells just over a fence and the building of compressor stations in neighborhoods. I think if you had a compressor station, even one with all the noise attenuating walls around it, near your own house you would also keep a wary eye on any attempts to bring other noise sources into your area that will interfere with your quiet enjoyment of your private property. The low frequency rumble from the compressor engines is not attenuated by the puffy walls and travels for large distances like ground roll on a seismic record. I am a geophysicist and for me, when the compressor starts up it is like feeling the initial part of an upsweep from a vibrator except that the upsweep never makes it to the higher frequencies. It's just a low frequency rumble that doesn't stop until the compressor engines stop. My mind doesn't get stuck on actualities, I look at possibilities, probabilities, and consequences and for that reason I can see that something like a huge turbine installed today in an offshore generation configuration could easily be employed later as a component of an onshore generation farm. I know that puff piece article didn't cover any of that ground since it was not designed to tell any part of that story.
- weinzierl 3y agoIn the 80s we had GROWIAN [1], which I found utterly fascinating as a kid. I have always been under the impression it proved that ultra-large turbines were a dead end. Maybe they will be rehabilitated? [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Growian https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Growian EDIT: I always remembered GROWIAN as a single blade system, but apparently that was its successor Monopteros, which only ever reached the prototype stage.
- KennyBlanken 3y agoFrom your own link: > Some lessons were however learned from conceptional mistakes made in its construction, e.g., the futility of trying to reach profitable installation sizes without taking intermediate steps > The point of view that multi-MW-yield wind turbines were technically and commercially infeasible gained some currency after the failure of the project, but was eventually superseded by technical progress. Beginning with the late 2000s, twenty-five years after Growian was decommissioned, installations with identical dimensions and yield (100 m rotor diameter, 3 MW net yield) were being produced in large numbers, a class of turbines that has continued to dominate the market and to push forward the mean net yield of newly installed turbines.
- ZeroGravitas 3y agoAnother interesting paragraph suggests this was designed to fail: > The partners as well as the BMFT also had political motives connected with the project. Günther Klätte, management board member of RWE, stated during a general business meeting: "We require Growian [in the general sense of large wind turbines] as a proof of failure of concept", and he noted that "the Growian is a kind of pedagogical tool to convert the anti-nuclear energy crowd to the true faith".[6] A similar statement regarding the incurred financial burdens was reported of Minister of Finance and former Minister of Research Hans Matthöfer: "We know it won't do anything for us. But we do it to demonstrate to the wind energy advocates that it doesn't work."[6] After the Green Party had derided the installation as the electricity provider's "fig leaf" on the occasion of groundbreaking in May 1981, the RWE took internal measures to make sure that publicly a position of open-mindedness towards alternative energy production was emphasized while public interest in wind energy was allayed.
- tln 3y agoHoly crap, they can withstand 79.3 m/s winds... that's 178 mph!
- tuatoru 3y agoNeed to. There are typhoons in the area, and they're getting stronger. 200 mph would be better.
- mx_02 3y agoIs bigger better when it comes to wind power?
- adrianN 3y agoWindmill efficiency scales faster than (blade length)^2, so yes.
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 3y agoYes, for two reasons: windspeed is greater at higher altitudes, and energy capture increases with the square of the blade length: https://www.gwec.net/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/Netherlands_.jpg https://www.gwec.net/wp-content/uploads/2017/01/Netherlands_... This means that a windmill constructed with 3x the building material (3x blade diameter and 3x taller) will generate over 9x the power.
- pkulak 3y ago> just one of these turbines should be able to produce enough electricity to power 36,000 households of three people each for one year What is the point of adding a time component in there? They always say weird things like this that make me double take. "Wait... does one revolution power 36,000 homes for a YEAR???" What's really annoying is that they aren't even wrong, just annoying.
- hamilyon2 3y agoConfusing power and energy units seems to be a constant theme not only in reputable press, but in a lot of publications that consider energy, infographics and so on. There are also instances of correct, but confusing units, like KW/h per year when talking about power. I don't understand it and probably never will. I think at this time readers in much of english-speaking world expect this type of errors and will mind the "correct" language, e.g. simply watts when talking about power. I think there is a joke somewhere here about all power stations stop working exactly after one year of coming online because of people unable to imagine amount of fuel per unit of time.