4 ms·
Germany's auto industry: suppliers' confidence waning
- wolframhempel 3y agoGermany is in an overall tricky spot right now – and likely at the beginning of a long term, downwards trend. It’s the only major EU country whose economy shrank last quarter, it’s mired in endless bureaucracy and red tape and its governing coalition is adding to the problem by discontinuing existing (nuclear) energy supplies, introducing cumbersome legislation and having an overall agenda that purely focuses on redistribution with no concern for value generation. Germany had its Heyday when the technologies it specialised in – namely cars, industrial equipment, and components where at the peak of the technological demand curve. But this peak has long ago moved to software and Germany has nothing to offer in this regard (yes, I am aware of SAP.) Having said that – and despite what this article says – I’m confident that Germany’s car manufacturers will be able to leverage their (in many regards world leading) abilities to succeed in the electric car sector. But Germany’s economy as a whole needs a fundamental change of direction if it is to succeed in the next decades.
- drooopy 3y agoSAP is one of the worst pieces of software I've had the misfortune of using in multiple companies that I've worked for in the past 10 years. I'm not sure it should be used as a positive example.
- wolframhempel 3y agoFair - but they've created a piece of software that has become the backbone of many of the world's largest company's processes. And, as far as vendor lock-in goes, they are unbeatable. Adopting SAP alone is a multi million project with 20+ SAP consultants and once you've introduced it, there is nearly no way to rip it out. The software itself may be bad - but their ability to capture value is incredible.
- fock 3y agoI guess "capturing value" is equivalent to a "rentier oligarchy". Aka the thing you have in the US. Looking at the timescales of climate chaos I'd say European social democracies will not be the worst place to be for the next 30years (and no amount of software will help you unless you are part of the oligarchy...). And if you think we'll all freeze and starve: if we do as the US currently tells us (this is indeed a problem) we can still burn a lot of lignite (which is likely not much worse than leaky fracking fields....).
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago>I guess "capturing value" is equivalent to a "rentier oligarchy". Aka the thing you have in the US. It really isn't equivalent, this opinion just reads like copium. If I jump ship to a better paying job to capture more value, am I now the "rentier oligarchy"? No, I just move to where the money is as it benefits me and also benefits the state who's taxing me to fund social welfare. Similarly it's the job of any country to do the same and orient its economy to where it can capture more value (hopefully in an ethical and environmentally friendly way), as staying behind and falling to do so means less wealth, less tax revenues, and less welfare for its citizens. >we can still burn a lot of lignite It will also heavily reduce your lifespan, which is good for the state I guess, as that means less pensions will have to be paid out.
- fock 3y ago> It really isn't equivalent, this opinion just reads like copium. So what is "capturing value" other than rent? And yes, I would hope that water wars were copium, but they might be a bitter reality soon... > If I jump ship to a better paying job to capture more value, am I now the "rentier oligarchy"? Yes that's fine, I guess you are anyways not very interested in community (which seems to be the thing with many people around...) - btw: what exactly will happen in that place if you have a car accident and can't work for 1-2 years? > No, I just move to where the money is as it benefits me and also benefits the state who's taxing me to fund social welfare. Good. But don't complain once you wake up in a dystopian, oligarchic nightmare. > as staying behind and falling to do so means less wealth, less tax revenues, and less welfare for its citizens. The US is clearly leading in the money metric and yet most metrics much more associated with human welfare (such as lifespan) are trending down... In that metric even Cuba is now better than the US ... There might be more to that than you assume... > It will also heavily reduce your lifespan, I guess either it's ChatGPT here or you are very deep in copium-territory...
- Chiron1991 3y agoTheir software may be bad, but they make huge amounts of money with it. That's all that matters from an economical standpoint.
- kitkat_new 3y ago> I’m confident that Germany’s car manufacturers will be able to leverage their (in many regards world leading) abilities to succeed in the electric car sector sadly politicians give in to their lobbying so it seems they are betting on fossil fuel cars until it's to late, because it makes more profit
- gizmo 3y agoManufacturing cars by assembling parts from 1000+ suppliers is inherently inefficient. This is fine as long as every car company uses the same model. BYD doesn’t; they make 70% of the components used in their cars themselves. This gives them a fundamental cost advantage and European car shoppers are extremely price sensitive.
- vel0city 3y agoPersonally I don't like this shift to more parts being produced exclusively by the car manufacturer. It means the only real place to buy the part is the OEM who has an interest in selling me a whole new car. Meanwhile Denso and Bosch and whoever wouldn't mind just selling me a part through the many retail car parts stores.
- jeffrallen 3y agoGood luck getting the right cryptographic signatures for your part to be allowed by the CAN firewall to write on the CAN bus.
- MrBuddyCasino 3y ago> It’s the only major EU country whose economy shrank last quarter, it’s mired in endless bureaucracy and red tape and its governing coalition is adding to the problem by discontinuing existing (nuclear) energy supplies, introducing cumbersome legislation and having an overall agenda that purely focuses on redistribution with no concern for value generation. This is pretty spot on. People voted socialism, people got socialism, shrouded in green utopianism. There is no positive vision of the future, only guilt and shame about the things we consume and hare-brained schemes about where energy is supposed to come from. Redistribution without concern for value generation sums it up pretty well.
- imtringued 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- MrBuddyCasino 3y agoIf you look beyond the product labels and study the ingredient list instead, you'll find them to be either fraudulent or meaningless.
- arnvald 3y agoAt this points it looks like Germany is almost allergic to innovation. Their government introduces more bureaucracy for companies, discouraging investments there. Berlin had a chance to take #1 spot as the tech capital of Europe post-Brexit, instead we rarely see any new unicorns coming from there. Auto industry is another example - Volkswagen and Volvo groups are #4 and #5 when it comes to battery-only electric cars, and they're behind Tesla, BYD and SAIC (both Chinese). They're not innovators, they're still behind and I don't know if they'll catch up. As an EU citizen I feel more and more negative about the economic future here, with UK having left and the biggest countries (Germany, France, Italy, Spain) struggling to stay relevant, especially in tech industry where AI can soon turn cause a major power shift.
- gizmo 3y agoVolvo/Polestar is also under Chinese management/ownership.
- logicchains 3y agoFor Europe's sake I hope the same thing doesn't happen to Germany that happened to Detroit, as the world moved on and it wasn't able to innovate fast enough to keep pace.
- waihtis 3y agoYou haven't realized yet the EU is basically a temporal version of the USSR? Watch closely how every power mechanism slowly gets roped into the hands of Brussels.
- imtringued 3y agoThat explains why the UK is such a success story. They managed to avoid the tight grip of Brussels. The inflation rate in the UK is significantly lower than in the EU due to the foresight of competent politicians like Nigel Farage and Boris Johnson.
- dazc 3y agoThe UK Govt managed to squander every opportunity that was given to them, and I say this as a tory/leave voter.
- gizmo 3y agoGerman car manufacturers need to start taking Chinese competitors and BYD in particular way more seriously. For the past two decades they have been able to coast and keep their sales numbers up by minimally tweaking their old designs. German car companies are not vertically integrated and are bad at software. They will get beaten badly on price and software quality, and consumer loyalty won’t last. They will have to reinvent themselves if they want to survive.
- wolframhempel 3y agoI generally agree with that. Though I'm not sure it's the right focus when it comes to what makes a car desirable. Looking at BMW's I series cars or Mercedes EQ(X) cars, they are absolutely solid and attractive offerings with the "traditional German" qualities of built quality and refinement. Yes, their software may be lacking, but I'm not quite sure that's the differentiator when it comes to cars.
- gizmo 3y agoSoftware isn't just a pretty UI. It also covers (partial) autonomy, emergency breaking, traffic sign recognition, drowsiness monitoring, automatic parking, air bags, voice control and much more. It's not a differentiator today because all premium car brands are very bad at software. Cars are not computers on wheels yet, but that's the direction. Sensors are dirt cheap now so cars get loaded with them and software becomes a big differentiator. BMW makes pretty good cars, but most Europeans can't afford them. In Germany (which has favorable taxes on cars) the average new car costs €36,000. BMW has nothing at that price. Chinese cars will probably first compete in the budget segment. Only after having established a reputation for making good cars will Chinese brands try to compete directly in the 50k-100k segment, which has consumers who have car ownership as a big part of their identity.
- TacticalCoder 3y ago> emergency breaking If you look at the best braking cars (fastest 60 to 0 and smallest distance), excluding the supercars and hypercars, it's all Audi, Mercedes, BMW and especially Porsche. A lot can be criticized about german cars but not braking well isn't part of it. > In Germany (which has favorable taxes on cars) the average new car costs €36,000. BMW has nothing at that price. A BMW 1-series start at 30 K EUR. Sure it's a "little" car but so are many of the cars people shall buy at 36 K EUR. Unsurprisingly the BMW 1-series is nearly the best selling BMW series in the EU: neck to neck with the 3-series. There are sure a lot of BMW 1-series where I live now (a country neighboring Germany). I don't think BMW, VW and even Mercedes are going to give up that easily. They are trying to shift to EVs and I wouldn't rule out a country who's been producing the finest cars for decades yet (especially jot VW, who's not exactly been the first to adapt new technologies).
- roenxi 3y agoEurope has been seeing a collapse in per-capita energy availability [0] since 2007. The invisible hand of the market is probably working out out what hard cuts are needed to make the best use of what is still available. It wouldn't be remotely strange if Germany was deindustrialising. [0] https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/per-capita-energy-use?tab=chart&country=DEU~CHN~OWID_EU27~OWID_EUR https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/per-capita-energy-use?tab...
- cpursley 3y agoWithout affordable energy prices, Germany just can’t compete with Korea (LG, Hyundai, etc), China or even the US. They’re in big trouble - especially when the tax revenue needed for their generous social benefits collapse. They need to sort this out asap because once you deindustrialize, you not only lose your facilities (deterioration), but the know-how (US as case in point).
- ZeroGravitas 3y agoThat's primary energy inputs. Efficiency and electrification will also reduce it. As we try to get to net zero we're expected to double or triple the supply of electricity, while still reducing primary energy as we reduce the colossal amount of fossil fuels wasted as heat during burning them.
- Ericson2314 3y agoEU being started in the 1990s was a huge mistake. They need Big Fiscal like the US so they can. get rich again, but their constitution largely prohibits it. If they did an infrastructure build-out it would be amazing cause they are currently way more efficient at building things than we are.
- Ericson2314 3y agoAnti nuclear is also stupid, but with a big infra push France would simply build so much nuclear Germany would begrudgingly import everything they need. Good enough for now and also hilarious.
- reisse 3y agoThere is a thing I rarely see on HN in discussions about nuclear power in France. French nuclear "success story" is based on colonialistic exploitation of African uranium mining. With the increase of US, Chinese and Russian influence in Africa, France may one day find themselves in a position where they won't have cheap fuel for the power plants.
- ArmandGrillet 3y agoThis is not a thing on HN because this is not a thing in real life. Over the sixteen-year period between 2005 and 2020, nearly three-quarters of the 138,230 tonnes of natural uranium imported into France came from four countries: Kazakhstan: 27,748 tonnes (i.e. 20.1%); Australia: 25,804 (18.7%); Niger: 24,787 (17.9%); Uzbekistan: 22,197 (16.1%). Only Niger is in Africa, and France has 10 years stored in case of geopolitical conflicts.
- seydor 3y agoSo i should hesitate to buy a german EV?
- rstuart4133 3y agoI was in Germany for a few months. Every Germany manufacturer has EV models, and there are a quite a manufacturers so that means a there lot of German EV's to choose from. That's because their government has put in strong tax incentives towards EV's. And most Germans seem to prefer to buy German cars and that goes for EV's, so you see of lot of German EV's in Germany. But ... all the German EV's I saw were their existing ICE car bodies retrofitted with batteries and an electric motor. Right down to still having the exhaust hump going down the centre of the car. Even to a pleb like me it was obvious this layout sucked compared to say a something that was built from the ground up to be an EV, like a Tesla. Move outside of Germany, and German EV's are rare - true EV's like Tesla's dominate. I guess the cost of re-doing the car body design must be huge. But until they do it I'd avoid them. And I'd say if they don't make the investment, they are doomed to suffer the fate of the dinosaurs.
- seydor 3y agoI dont see a problem even if they are retrofitting cars. German cars are still higher build quality than Tesla. But if german auto industry is going to have trouble upgrading batteries in 10 years, that is a concern. German EVs are not rare in the rest of europe either
- mathverse 3y agoEurope is culturally wired to play it safe and stable and that encourages focusing on B2B businesses with predictable revenues.
- mustafa_pasi 3y agoI would not generalize to the whole of Europe. This is true of Germany, which dictates what happens in Europe. But even France is more dynamic. And if you look further North or East or South you also see more willingness to take on risk.
- seydor 3y agoI wonder why this topic has been disappeared from the list