7 ms·
Singapore to execute woman on drugs charge for the first time in 20 years
- hohohmm 3y ago[flagged]
- GordonS 3y agoFor 30g of heroin? On what planet is 30g considered "trafficking"?
- nickthegreek 3y agoI dont agree with the death penalty. But on this planet, many countries/states would consider this amount trafficking. Its >4g in the state of Georgia, Florida, NC, etc.
- kasey_junk 3y agoSingapore
- ajot 3y agoOn Disney World* with the Death Penalty, of course * Gibson's article was "Disneyland with the Death Penalty", but Disney World fitted better with the "planet" theme. https://www.wired.com/1993/04/gibson-2/ https://www.wired.com/1993/04/gibson-2/
- keepamovin 3y agoCool, thanks for posting this article! Any freewall link?
- selectodude 3y agoThat’s 24 bundles of heroin. 1250 doses.
- Ekaros 3y agoHow many doses does average user take a day? It seems that for single user for personal use that many doses should last quite a while.
- GordonS 3y agoOnly if it's 100% pure heroin. If it's typical street-level purity, it's more like 300 doses. Either way, these seem categorically like personal use quantities to me.
- HideousKojima 3y agoEven though Singapore's war on drugs is ruthless, it seems to actually work. Supposedly Singapore only has 30 opiate abusers per 100k citizens, compared to 600 per 100k in the US.
- seunosewa 3y agoChopping off arms is arguably very effective against burglary and armed robbery, but that doesn't excuse Saudi Arabia's barbaric ways.
- digdugdirk 3y agoHaving met a number of people who made quite a nice living smuggling drugs into Singapore, I'd caution against taking those numbers at face value.
- chongli 3y agoSingapore is a tiny island. The U.S. has a gigantic border with Mexico, a place with drug cartels as powerful as many small countries’ armies. The difference in sheer difficulty of controlling their respective borders is enormous.
- Eumenes 3y agoThe US could put a major dent in the drug trade if it wanted to. US sends billions to Ukraine, NATO, Israel, etc, for their defense and security. There is no will. Inbound drugs and illegal labor is good for business.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoNot to mention the outbound guns. It’s two way trade at this point, and one reason our official gun ownership statistics are so skewed (no, 25% of Americans don’t own 10 guns each, those guns are just in Mexico and Central America).
- chongli 3y agoYou could also say the same thing about health care or any of the myriad other problems the US faces. Supporting Ukraine and outrage at Russia's invasion are among the most bipartisan issues the US has had in years. But honestly, the US's problems are shared by many other Western democracies, albeit on a smaller scale. Polarization is happening in many different countries, even ones that lack the two-party system of the US.
- 0xhenri 3y agoDeath penalty for 500g of cannabis, rather violent. In France it would cause thousands of executions
- bohadi 3y agoThen it is good that Singapore makes laws in Singapore, and France in France, and not the other way around, isn't it.
- mytailorisrich 3y agoDrug traffickers in France have AKs and police tends to stay away...
- TinyRick 3y agoI could literally walk into a store today and buy that much legally where I am. Crazy that some cultures would murder a human over such a thing.
- sourcecodeplz 3y agoNot crazy at all. Not every country needs millions of mentally ill people due to drug abuse.
- baggy_trough 3y agoMany people enjoy being able to walk around a downtown in total safety at any hour of the day or night. Or being able to leave a laptop on a coffee bar table to reserve a place while you go to the bathroom. Are these things related to harsh punishments? Probably to some degree.
- TinyRick 3y agoSo your solution is to murder drug addicts and mentally unstable unhoused people? Years ago we took a different approach to solving these problems, and put them in state subsidized mental institutions. While not perfect, that seems like a more humane way of treating the situation than jumping straight to the death penalty.
- 55555 3y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-PXAOZwvv04 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-PXAOZwvv04
- belorn 3y agoNote sure if other people got confused by the title. This is not the first time in 20 years that a person got executed for drugs charge. There has been 14 of those in the last 6 months. She is the first woman to be executed in the last 20 years for this specific crime.
- BowBun 3y agoHaving lived in Singapore, I'm ok with this. I can't judge foreign countries by my Western values when all the countries that agree with those values face crippling drug problems. If this is the extent of it and it isn't abused, I think it's fair for a country to take this stance.
- nickthegreek 3y agoThe abuse is happening by the State.
- ipaddr 3y agoWhere do you draw the line? Murdering a women is okay because she had a chemical she was going to use personally. Would removing body parts like cutting off an arm for stealing be acceptable? Or rape for adultery? Judging life by western standards seems like a sensible thing to do if you come from the west.
- waihtis 3y agothe woman was trafficking. It's not only for personal consumption but for others too. If a trafficker sold heroin to your child, would you be as lenient about it?
- deadbeeves 3y agoWell, did the woman sell heroin to children?
- ipaddr 3y agoYes because I wouldn't blame her for my childs addiction. Arresting her means your child gets it from another source potential more dangerous. You need to treat the addiction not kill the messenger. My child is probably more like her than I would want to believe. Both struggling mentally and needing help. Killing her means I'm okay with killing my own child because they shared with a friend.
- 3y ago
- ekianjo 3y ago> "There is no evidence that the death penalty has a unique deterrent effect or that it has any impact on the use and availability of drugs," said Amnesty International's Chiara Sangiorgio in a statement. Oh really? Then please explain why there are few death by drugs in such countries while there are hundreds of thousands of deaths due to overdose with opoids in the US as we speak where their use is completely decriminalized? You don't get to say "X does not work to fix Y problem" without doing any kind of homework. Or then, make a statement that "death penalty is bad no matter what", but saying that it's not a deterrent is a very debatable question for drugs.
- TinyRick 3y agoSince when are opiods are decriminalized in the US?
- supazek 3y agoIn Minnesota I would say it’s de facto decriminalized. I bought a house from a guy who had more than 3 grams of fentanyl and half an ounce of meth when he got busted. His fourth strike with this level felony and overall at least his 10th time in jail. He got a sentence of 14 months in prison. Not exactly hard time for someone who is literally out there killing people. And yes I’m still looking for money buried in the yard
- weird-eye-issue 3y agoCorrelation isn't causation or something like that?
- whymauri 3y ago>completely decriminalized? Does decriminalized mean something I'm not aware of? Do you mean that prescriptions are not criminalized? Use? Possession?
- wang_li 3y agoAlso the number of people who have been executed who are recidivists is zero. Compared to ~20% in Singapore. So it assuredly reduces some crime.
- csomar 3y agoAnother source mentions that it's 1Kg? This is a recurrent recent problem with Western media that's cherry-picking details to advance an agenda. At this point they lost all credibility. > Saridewi Djamani, who was charged with trafficking a total of 1kg of drugs containing 30.72g of pure heroin, also claimed she was suffering from persistent depressive disorder and severe substance use disorder. It appears she might have had 1Kg of drugs but only 30g of heroin. It would be more interesting if the BBC does some real investigative work on whether different races in Singapore are treated differently by their justice system. The defendant here being racially Indian.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deadbeeves 3y ago"1 kg of drugs containing 30 g of heroin"? So is that 30 grams of heroin plus filler, or is it 1 kg of something else that's been adulterated with heroin? What does "drugs" mean?
- Dudester230602 3y agoTreating genders equally might be a sign of progress in an otherwise conservative society.
- pb060 3y ago> "There is no evidence that the death penalty has a unique deterrent effect or that it has any impact on the use and availability of drugs," said Amnesty International's Chiara Sangiorgio in a statement. Arguing about whether the death penalty acts or not as a deterrent can distract from the primary point. If one believes the death penalty is wrong in principle, then that should be the central argument. Debating its effectiveness opens the door to counterarguments and can weaken the stance. I believe that the focus should be on the moral and ethical reasons against it.
- jonhohle 3y agoI posted stats elsewhere, but those saying the death penalty is not a deterrent would have to show the true cause of such a significantly lower per capita deaths by overdose in Singapore vs western countries. My current feeling is that there is a limit we should be willing to spend, as a society, on someone who chooses to actively inflict harm on or enable harm to come to others. I struggle to see the humanity or benefit to society in sending someone to prison for the remainder of their natural life that satisfies either the condemned or the victim. Capital punishment has become significantly more expensive than life imprisonment, which may be one of the strongest arguments against it, imho.
- ghostDancer 3y agoYou have to compare similar situations a small island with a heavily controlled and under surveillance society is not comparable to western countries with much less controls and bigger borders easily crossed.
- vixen99 3y agoTangential: The BBC writes on alleged public support in Singapore for the death penalty - 'But anti-death penalty advocates refute this'. There are strongly held views on either side of this contentious debate but a refutation, if that's what it is, would settle the issue for most rational people. Since to refute is to disprove by argument, the existence of such a refutation would imply the Singaporean Authorities have circulated false data. I don't think the BBC believes that or is even implying it. They mean there is a vigorous debate. https://www.mha.gov.sg/mediaroom/press-releases/findings-from-recent-studies-on-the-death-penalty-in-singapore/ https://www.mha.gov.sg/mediaroom/press-releases/findings-fro...
- iroddis 3y agoI travelled to Singapore on business once, and the immigration form had a warning about the death penalty for drug-related offences printed in red, all caps lettering. It was definitely jarring.
- Brian_K_White 3y agoThere has been more than zero times in my life when I discovered I was in posession of something I was unaware of. Not often drugs specifically, but I can't say for sure never that either. In my 20's I had friends that spanned a full spectrum, and not all activities were organized and orderly. You go on a camping trip, or even just a night in someone's back yard, you come back with mystery items in your blanket/towel/bag/cooler/coat. I don't smoke and yet I somehow have been in posession of many lighters at different times. If someone doesn't understand how that happens, I can only feel sorry that they have lived so little that they never lent a girl their coat at a party or provided the blanket that everyone else sat on etc. But then they end up in a position to decide what constitutes fair and reasonable expectations for everyone else.
- foogazi 3y agoCrossing it off the list right now
- Roark66 3y agoAnd that is why I'll personally never go to any country that has a death penalty for something so stupid as "being in possession of X". We're not even talking kilos of the stuff with a potential to impact hundreds of people's lives. No, it is an amount consistent with her explanation she was "stocking up for a month". Yes, she admitted selling some of it. But, a death penalty for something like this is not just inhumane. It is uncivilised and extremely backwards. It reflects badly not just on Singapore as a country, but on all the countries that allow this to happen. Unfortunately there are a lot of state-sanctioned atrocities in the world. If we compare sentencing a small time drug trafficker to death in Singapore with mass organ harvesting from political prisoners in China the former seems less important. However the fact is, the western world has far less influence over China than a country like Singapore. Where are the threats of sanctions? Where is the mass condemnation in media? Kudos for BBC to write about it t, but their article should call a spade a spade, not dance around it.
- jonhohle 3y agoDevil’s advocate: There are around 20 death sentences for drug dealing per year in Singapore and an annual overdose death rate of 1.18 per 100k and approximately 0 death penalties for dealing. In the US, the overdose death rate is >20 per 100k. The penalties are severe, but if they contribute to the reduction of general population deaths, may be less worse than western approaches in terms of lives saved. (Obviously there are lots of factors that go into those stats, geography, access, culture, etc. and punishment cannot be the only variable evaluated) Edit for more scale: there are around 100,000 overdose deaths per year in the US vs 60(!) in Singapore. A metro area of 5M in the US (the approx population of Singapore) would have >1,000.
- Brian_K_White 3y agoSo the ends justify the means?
- jonhohle 3y agoIf there is a causal relationship between those who sell drugs on the black market and deaths from those drugs, I don’t know if the means aren’t justified. Could I give my life to save 20, I’d consider that an honor.
- iamnotsure 3y agoDon't drink and kill.
- iamnotsure 3y agoBadly written comment, please ignore.
- dirtyid 3y agoExecute none brown traffickers when?
- foogazi 3y ago"Give me liberty, or give me death!" - Patrick Henry
- xk_id 3y agoTangential, but why is richard branson featured so much in this? (The one sentence OpenGraph link description also mentions him). Why promote some random billionaire opinion? It’s like they’re trying to inculcate the idea that somehow wealth confers authority on societal issues.
- rajnathani 3y ago[Sir] Richard Branson has been a pretty vocal opponent of the death penalty for many years now. To exemplify: it’s literally a part of his Wikipedia page too. Besides, the article is from the BBC, so there’s always going to be a slight British touch in the reporting.
- xk_id 3y agoA lot of people are vocal opponents of various things. I just don't get what about this richard dude and his wealth makes british people care so much.