9 ms·
Japanese population falls in all 47 prefectures for the first time
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bruce511 3y ago>> It’s a natural process for people from areas experiencing population growth to move to other places experiencing decline This strategy works as long as there are more places (by volume) experiencing growth than decline. Since the trend is slower growth overall, there will be a point where global growth stops, and clearly then the strategy will start to fail. Frankly, from a planet point of view I'd hope that point comes sooner than later. This will play out in obvious ways (lifting retirement age etc) but ultimately the quality of life will increase overall until some sort of stable population number emerges.
- Thorrez 3y agoLifting retirement age will happen at the same time as increasing the quality of life? Wouldn't the retirement age only need to be increased if there's a problem? And wouldn't there being a problem mean quality of life has a problem? Also, look at cities that have had a decreasing population, such as Detroit. They don't look so good.
- andyferris 3y agoIn Detroit I think unemployment rose (and quality of life declined) before the population started to shrink - the order of the cause and effect are important! OTOH in countries with decreasing overall populations due to birth rate and not lack of economic opportunity (emmigration), it might be possible to sustain high employment rates, low crime, and good quality of life. (There might be more need to fund social services, however, if the population is also aging).
- ramraj07 3y agoThere will be a period of massive upheaval when the fundamental tenet of all economic models and assumptions (perpetual growth) is completely chronically invalidated and we run out of resources as the models reset to something that’s absolutely zero sum (as it should be). Great suffering and fighting can be expected during this period.
- Barrin92 3y agowhile the question is open if economic growth will continue forever neither resources or population are an issue. The German economy say, has grown by 400% since the 1970s in real terms while the population has stayed stable. Energy use has slightly fallen over the last few decades. Economic growth is technologically driven and developed economies are at or already past peak resources consumption.
- bitschubser_ 3y agoi'm no economist... but didn't externalizing a lot of production offset the missing population growth? So germany just externalized raw material extraction and production but still kept the profits?
- dredmorbius 3y agoGermany has also "climbed the value ladder" focusing on production of high-value goods whilst counting on imports to provide for low-value ones. Some of that is of course classic Ricardian "comparative advantage" of trade. Much is, though, outsourcing high-impact / high-resource / high-effluent production to elsewhere.
- ramraj07 3y agoMore fundamentally I’m not convinced that we are not in a zero sum game as seems to be assumed under all economic theory.
- imtringued 3y ago
- jgilias 3y agoI come from a place that has experienced a population drop of ~30% over the last ~30 years. During the same time period inflation adjusted GDP has ~doubled, quality of life has increased immensely. Granted, all of this is due to historically extraordinary events playing out. But still, less population doesn’t necessarily imply no or negative growth. There’s an interplay of factors affecting if growth is possible, and population is just one parameter of those.
- ChatGTP 3y agoThis is because your still able to access all the benefits of globalization. You probably have things like cheaper property prices and access to all the latest tech. You're basically leaching off goods and services provided by those in high growth areas. I think the idea is we might reach a point where globalization itself is hard to maintain and then things start to unwind, dramatically fast.
- perryizgr8 3y ago> You're basically leaching off goods and services provided by those in high growth areas. Exactly. Extolling the virtues of low population growth because it enables a higher quality of life is misguided. Your life is higher quality because billions in China are toiling away in inhuman conditions, making goods for you, and unable to move to your location.
- postmodfemenist 3y agoIsn't it great? Nixon was a goddamn genius. Too bad that free ride is winding down, I hope some other mass of people assume that role so I can continue to enjoy myself. Before you yell at me consider that China lifted an unprecedented amount of people out of even more inhumane conditions as a result of this process.
- thriftwy 3y agoPeople in China are also experiencing immense economical growth. Eventually they will indeed run out of people willing to do lower level jobs in the factories, then economic growth can move somewhere else. Bangladesh, Africa, Philippines perhaps? Then we observe these countries whose population subset is actually able to move to a different, richer location (such as Maghreb countries) and we see apparent lack of serious economic growth, industry development and general instability. Makes one question all of your assumptions.
- postmodfemenist 3y agoFrom a planet point of view let me assure you that fewer young Japanese people running around helps absolutely nobody and nothing.
- cmews 3y agoExcept fish populations in the oceans. Japanese are well known for their very high fish consumption
- postmodfemenist 3y ago[flagged]
- flangola7 3y ago[flagged]
- dredmorbius 3y ago<https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36796212 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36796212>
- flangola7 3y agoWhat does that have to do with religion?
- dredmorbius 3y agoDang, if you're not aware, is HN's moderator: <https://www.newyorker.com/news/letter-from-silicon-valley/the-lonely-work-of-moderating-hacker-news https://www.newyorker.com/news/letter-from-silicon-valley/th...>
- flangola7 3y ago
- NoMoreNicksLeft 3y agoIt's not clear to me that fertility will ever rebound. Is there a scenario, where some little Japanese girl who has been the only child from only children for 4 or 5 or 10 generations wakes up one morning and says to herself "I want to grow up to be a mommy and have 2.1 children"? And, if she doesn't do that, then some other little girl in Japan has to say that same thing but with a number higher than 2.1. Why would they buck the trends of their own ancestors, their own family? Surely, it looks similar to the ancient past where some lineage looks as if the same happened. But that was because only one offspring survived to adulthood, and then of his or her children only one survived. But they were having many more with tragic results. Those children, for as long as they lived, existed in a world where people were trying to have many. This is the part where people reply to me as if I were crazy. But children who grow up seeing those adults around them having few children internalize that as normal, and don't seek to have more than that number.
- Ygg2 3y ago> It's not clear to me that fertility will ever rebound. It might. But it won't be pretty. Either the land will be taken over by new arrivals that will assimilate and their increased fertility will lift fertility. Another scenario is that things go pear shaped and fertility rises because of uncertainty.
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- kalleboo 3y ago> "I want to grow up to be a mommy and have 2.1 children" I live in Japan and have Japanese friends. Lots of Japanese I know want to have kids, and wouldn't mind having 3 or more kids. They love kids! And it's still the dream of many women here to get married, have kids, and be a housewife since they know how terrible the careers are in this country. But 1 or 2 is the limit due to work/time, finances, practicality (housing, vehicles/public transit). The families I know with more kids are the ones who can afford having a housewife or who have multi-generational homes (live-in grandparents). What I'm trying to say is that I think one major reason people aren't having more kids isn't because they don't want them, but because society isn't built to enable them to.
- coding123 3y agoEveryone thinking damn Americans moving, it's actually the Chinese.
- 1-6 3y agoFuture Japanese kid names: Fumiko Wang, Aoi Kim, Akira Nguyen
- guerrilla 3y agoLevels of xenophobia might need to drop drastically before that's popular.
- Teeorb 3y agoIt is not that deep, just a forecast on the future diversity of the Japanese demographics. One step toward the future!
- fuzzbazz 3y agoThe fertility rates of: Wang (1.2), Kim (0.8), and Nguyen (1.9) are all under replacement rate (2.1) and two of them are worse than Japan's (1.4). According to the UN Population Fund 2023.
- optimalsolver 3y agoDeshaun Kanawa
- jesterson 3y agoYou clearly unaware that Wang-s are experiencing the same trend and hopelessly trying to fix it (spoiler alert: they will fail)
- masteruvpuppetz 3y agoDon't forget Tomayashi Patel :D
- neilwilson 3y agoLow interest rates and lack of manpower was one of the catalysts of the Industrial Revolution. Perhaps Japan is going to be the place to be if you're in the "do more with machines" business. They can only solve this with significant capital investment and major productivity improvements.
- themitigating 3y agoIsn't that something they've already been doing?
- bamboozled 3y agoI'm not really sure about this, Japan loves meaningless highly manual process intensive jobs and high employment rates, so I understand what you mean, but replacing people with machines isn't really in their DNA even though Japan seems to like robot movies. Maybe in the face of some type of economical crisis they will change their tune but I wouldn't bank on it. In my opinion, they've been burned once, they were the top dogs for a while, economically poised to even surpass America, and now, a lot of people are without money. So I think it will take a bit of convincing to want to go back to those days. Japan has an interesting sort of apathy (??), kind of like, they're happy to not be the center of attention and just go on minding their business. We had some business development people visit Japan recently and they were stunned at the lack of competitiveness and interest in growing their businesses. I guess this is a culture which was happy isolate itself from the world for centuries and I guess if it could, there's nothing saying it wouldn't do it again...I have to say, I can't always blame them :)
- ehnto 3y agoThere is likely a "correct" size for any given business in regards to it's function in society. If you chase eternal growth you are somewhat at odds with the society you're part of. Eventually you either need to exploit it to grow past the size it needs you to be, or move out into other markets. I think the difference is that for the most part, small and medium businesses in Japan are just trying to fit the size of their role in their communities, growth for the sake of growth isn't the goal. Just observations and idle thoughts from me though, both views on growth clearly have merit and I can't actually speak for Japanese business owners.
- kristopolous 3y agoI wonder if offering a more generous Nordic-socialism style maternity policy would help. There's a bunch of cultural reasons for the low birthrate but a bunch of encouraging benefits might help address that.
- Teeorb 3y agoJapan is way too densely populated in comparison to Nordic countries. It is difficult to alter a country's socioeconomic status by mimicking some foreign policies originated from a country of desired template.
- Hamuko 3y agoHow is population density related to social benefits?
- bluepod4 3y agohttps://sustainablereview.com/high-population-density-pros-and-cons/ https://sustainablereview.com/high-population-density-pros-a... There’s a Pros/Cons table where the first row almost seems like a paradox. A “pro” of a high population density is that you have access to resources. A “con” is that the resources are still limited.
- greiskul 3y agoThis page is completely wrong in so many levels. It says it's talking about population density, but many of the cons are about population numbers. If you have the same number of people of a city, but spread out more, it is harder to provide services for them. Pollution? Yeah, a city looks bad, until you realize how suburban sprawl absolutely decimates entire ecosystems in huge areas. It is way better for the planet if human beings concentrate in a few places, and try to leave the biggest amount of area possible to nature. Also, the pollution per capita of less dense areas is way bigger, since the lack of public transit means everybody needs to drive everywhere.
- olliej 3y agoIs it falling just because of birthrate, or because they're getting on top of people not reporting people who die of old age?
- Ygg2 3y agoMainly birthrate, but also lack of immigration. Not that immigration is a cure. It's more of a way to delay population decline.
- mixmastamyk 3y agoThat’s great, congratulations Japan. (Yes, I really mean it. Hard to believe when so many are growth at all costs partisans.)
- ehnto 3y agoI think it will still be challenging to make the economics work, policies that assumed growth will need to change (such as assumptions around affording welfate programs). Otherwise I agree, there probably should be an equilibrium point to float around that they can aim for.
- mixmastamyk 3y agoRight, it's the first point brought up every time in rebuttal. But, when have we not had to make adjustments to policy when circumstances change? The argument against a sustainable population basically boils down to, "but, then we'd have to make adjustments to policy!" Which is not the slam-dunk some seem to think it is.
- methou 3y agoI was always hoping that given the fact that japanese population is dropping, they will want more foreigners in this Country. Yesterday marks my first anniversary in Japan. I love this Country and very keen to stay for naturalization based on my past experience with another non-free Country. People who has longer experience please correct me if I'm saying something stupid, what Japan stands out to me are: * Overall it's a very affordable place and people are friendly by default. * It is a free world Country if you care about freedom * People take privacy seriously as parts of their daily matters, minimal data share. (unsure about the lucrative advertising business, please enligh) * Comfortable level of tech, you can say it's low tech, but they got all the details right, and experience is great. (No aggresive behavior analysis, rare ily seen QR code for menu/ordering) And some realities to offset the love: (Ordered low to high on impact, by personal feelings) * Unfair compensations, a large majority of companies pays their employees in a Nenko System, basically your salary increments by the x years of service inside the company * HIGH welfare tax, Nenkin will take away around 10% of your PRETAX income. * Language, I love this Country and I would like to learn their culture and their language * Etiquette, the Japanese way of daily routinal interactions are very much formulated, you can take vantage of that when you are fresh off boat and trying to do basic things like shopping and lodging. But say if your goal is to integrate into their society, it's going to be a long painful journey for the talented. I got a few friends spent better half of their lives in Japan who just gave up on becoming Japanese. One of which quitted so well that he occasionally violates social norms. Bottom line: you will need a strong incentive to stay in Japan and start/move your family here, and your first experiences won't be good. So why would foreigners stay if it's next to impossible to become local. If you are doing well enough in the Country you are already within, then you definitely would miss it and go back.
- theonlybutlet 3y agoIf that Nenkin pension contribution is 10%, it's actually very low relatively speaking.
- deaddodo 3y agoThis is a difficult question to answer, really. Very few pension systems are orthogonal to others and so it's hard to equate. The US Social Security system (what I assume they are comparing to) is 6.2% (or 12.4% for self-employed, as they are their own employer and contribute both shares) for 420mos; at max contribution, this comes out to 2572usd/mo at age 62 up to 4555usd/mo if you wait til age 70. Meanwhile, to max out an Irish state pension, you would need to contribute 13keur/yr for atleast 240mos (longer at a lower contribution), which comes out to ~1076eur/mo starting at age 67. I don't know what the Japanese system is like, but the point is that there are multiple variables to take into account. Length of contribution, type (tax rate and pre or post, or flat) + amount of contribution, when you qualify to receive it, recipient stipulations (can you work or not, does the rate change, does the age change, etc). Based on some back of envelop comparisons from my little research of the Japanese system (what wikipedia provides, since I can't read Japanese); it would seem that the US system is a little fairer (or, at least, generally equivalent) for W2 employees: a lower rate and contribution requirement [6.2% vs 10%], with a shorter term requirement [35 vs 40 years] but a slightly lower payout at a later age [4.5kusd@70 vs 5.5kusd@65] with a lower overall tax burden [nominal 17% vs flat 25%]. But both are a fair bit better than the Irish system. Please feel free to correct me if those are off, however. Even those are just assumptions based on you making no private retirement contributions and you working a white collar job and then going full state pensioner at the full retirement age. If any variables change, it can drastically effect the payout/taxrate. So it's almost impossible to fully compare.
- throwaw1yyy 3y agoI’d love to go over and have a few kids but I hear it’s in poor taste. Learning Japanese and emigrating is particularly tough because of their culture and on top of that it seems most Japanese women would be uninterested in having a family with an American she couldn’t speak too
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jkhdigital 3y agoYou’d be surprised
- _xnmw 3y agoAnd is that bad? So many people suggesting immigration as a “fix” but a fix for what? What’s wrong with a declining population?
- cute_boi 3y agocapitalism and declining population don't go hand in hand with each other.
- irrational 3y agoSince declining populations are here to stay and are increasingly more widespread, sounds like capitalism will need to learn to adjust or risk being replaced.
- ragebol 3y agoIs there any system that does? Especially if a large portion of the population is too old to work and provide for themselves.
- imtringued 3y agoI don't know if would happen in practice but the one Silvio Gesell proposed would probably handle as much growth, stagnation or even degrowth as the people collectively decide to want. The reason for that is that the concept of 'Freigeld' forces people to think about production and consumption schedules. With regular money you can pretend that labor can be stored like any commodity, which is actually not possible.
- thriftwy 3y agoIf you know you are in the Ponzi scheme, the first thing you do is stop throwing any more money at it, because it does become more risky as time goes on. "Capitalism and not participating in Ponzi schemes don't go hand in hand with each other" becomes nonsense. The last one to jump off that track before it collapses becomes capitalistic winner. But the ones who jumped before that moment are still better on than ones who ended up paying to them.
- dredmorbius 3y agoFWIW, discussed a day earlier: <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36873646 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36873646>
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoWow I read this posted headline as general population falling, (and kind of assumed that was what many have predicted for the very elderly Japanese population etc, which partly it is) -- but the headline includes "as foreign population surges". Should have figured out how to incorporate that into the post as it's an important additional angle in the story
- anigbrowl 3y agoHN only allocates 80 characters for the headline. I thought the decline across all prefectures of greater weight than the increase in immigration (which is mentioned at the outset of the story anyway).