18 ms·
Boeing has now lost $1.1B on Starliner, with no crew flight in sight
- LorenDB 3y agoOr, as The Register likes to call it, the Calamity Capsule.
- arcticbull 3y agoLost, or invested? One imagines if they outright lost it and saw no opportunity to recoup (i.e. no longer an investment) they'd just end the program.
- ceejayoz 3y agoThe contract doesn't permit Boeing to cancel. NASA can.
- mulmen 3y agoHow does that work? Does Boeing pay a penalty if they don’t make progress?
- randunel 3y agoUS law allows companies to split off a subsidiary with all the liabilities and the main company to continue to function with all the assets just like before https://www.ltltalccommittee.org/ https://www.ltltalccommittee.org/ Boeing wouldn't need to pay anything.
- radicaldreamer 3y agoThey would never get another space contract again if they did that, but they can see this will be a larger market in 30 years, so they'll lick their wounds and continue on commercial space projects.
- nordsieck 3y ago> They would never get another space contract again if they did that People say that, but I don't think it's true. Boeing pulled out of the Phantom Express project seemingly unscathed. https://www.space.com/boeing-withdraws-darpa-military-space-plane.html https://www.space.com/boeing-withdraws-darpa-military-space-...
- humanistbot 3y agoYou cite LTL / J&J like they got away with it. It's currently being litigated in multiple courts, it could go either way: https://money.usnews.com/investing/news/articles/2023-06-27/j-js-8-9-billion-talc-settlement-faces-us-bankruptcy-test https://money.usnews.com/investing/news/articles/2023-06-27/...
- HDThoreaun 3y agoNo, that is not how bankruptcy court works. The subsidiary needs to have enough assets to pay the creditors, up to the entire value of the company.
- voxic11 3y agoThey could end the program but violating their contract probably costs them more than just finishing the work at a loss.
- mezeek 3y agothey would have cancelled a long time ago if they could
- ragebol 3y agoFor that investment to work, they need to bring in some revenue as well. The ISS is scheduled to retire by 2030. Let's assume this capsule goes operational in 2025 and flies twice a year, that's 10 flights to recoup well, well over a billion by then. Let's say a 100 million per flight. Not sure what the contract is exactly, but it's not looking great. Pretty sure SpaceX is cheaper, so NASA will be the only customer.
- throwawaymobule 3y agoNASA plans to have other places to send astronauts by then. The ISS will almost certainly have its life extended again before that though.
- pavon 3y agoNASA has already awarded all the ISS crew flights up through it's scheduled retirement in 2030. Boeing is contracted for 6 flights, and SpaceX for 14 (including the 6 it has already flown). NASA hasn't published the milestone payment schedules, but the total contract was for $4.2 billion, so Boeing would have needed to budget a 26% profit margin on the whole endeavor to break even at this point. That wouldn't surprise me, but they are probably quickly reaching the point where they will actually be losing money.
- SOLAR_FIELDS 3y ago> Because Starliner was funded by NASA through a fixed-price contract, as part of the Commercial Crew program, Boeing is responsible for any cost overruns and financial losses due to delays. Given Boeing’s history here this feels like the right kind of contract for this sort of work. Ensures all incentives are aligned
- kotaKat 3y agoHey, we're finally getting some of those lucrative tax breaks back in the form of watching Boeing suffer!
- kawehjr 3y agoThe current NASA administrator, a bureaucrat who grew up during the Bush Cost+ era, is actually opposed to fixed-price contracts because they only save a lot of taxpayer money and might not actually help us get deliverables faster.
- OrvalWintermute 3y agoThere is a different perspective on that from large acquisitions around firm fixed price contracts. If you're doing some low risk building, say a 10 mile road on flat ground with known soil, replacing a previous road, that is well-known to current specs with set-in-stone requirements (no pun intended) it is easy to pitch that firm fixed price because the contractor will know exactly what to do, and there are 20 road building companies that could do the work. Now, building an advanced spacecraft with a host of uncertainties in a vastly more complex environment that may require novel technologies development and a great deal of engineering is very different if you want to pitch that firm fixed price because the contractor perspective is that is very risky, and there are likely going to be changing requirements. The contractors will want to make the Govt pay for that risk, since they are on the hook for it. All risk is on the contractor. The contractor will also fight for $ for every changing requirement. By comparison, in a time & materials contract, the risk is on the government, and changing requirements don't matter much, if you change them, risk is still on the government. This explains why firm-fixed price is not always the best approach, and sometimes time & materials contracts may make for a more economical acquisition approach - because risk and changing reqs can translate into dollars.
- areoform 3y agoThis comment is your regularly scheduled reminder that they were supposed to be the safe option. The people who'd come in clutch when SpaceX failed (and it was assumed in certain quarters that SpaceX would fail to deliver on time). They were paid 2x more than what NASA paid SpaceX. https://arstechnica.com/science/2022/09/nasa-will-pay-boeing-more-than-twice-as-much-as-spacex-for-crew-seats/ https://arstechnica.com/science/2022/09/nasa-will-pay-boeing... RIP Boeing.
- mezeek 3y agoTo be clear to readers, the were only paid for their achieved milestones, which is nowhere near the full contracted amount since they haven't flown anyone. As for the 2x part... it's cause their bid was 2x what SpaceX bid itself. And both got their bids accepted.
- nordsieck 3y ago> As for the 2x part... it's cause their bid was 2x what SpaceX bid itself. And both got their bids accepted. Mostly. NASA did just give Boeing extra money for some pretty dubious reasons. > NASA instead requested Boeing “propose prices for additional flexibilities to fill an anticipated crew access gap, including shortening its lead times for rocket and spacecraft production,” the report states. After what OIG described as “prolonged negotiations,” NASA agreed to pay Boeing an additional $287.2 million for those mission flexibilities. > The OIG report concluded that much of those payments were not necessary, since there were other methods to provide schedule flexibility to mitigate gaps in crew access to the station. The report specifically notes that, five days after NASA agreed to the additional payment to Boeing, the company submitted a proposal to NASA offering to sell five Soyuz seats it has acquired from Russian company RSC Energia for $373.5 million. > The report concluded NASA’s payment of $144 million to accelerate the timetable for two of the four Starliner missions was unreasonable, and that it overspent by $43 million when it granted Boeing authorization to proceed on one Starliner mission a year earlier than necessary. > OIG also criticized NASA for not giving SpaceX, the other company with a commercial crew contract, an opportunity for offering its own proposal to address any gap in crew access to the ISS. “In our judgment, contacting both providers would have been a prudent approach to maximize the Agency’s options while also ensuring fairness,” the report concluded. https://spacenews.com/nasa-inspector-general-criticizes-additional-boeing-commercial-crew-payments/ https://spacenews.com/nasa-inspector-general-criticizes-addi...
- MrOwnPut 3y agoDid anyone expect otherwise?
- balozi 3y agoSometimes the profits are found in product development, instead of product delivery.
- FireBeyond 3y agoWhile there are concerns with the bidding process, I think this is a pretty big "nothing", in the grand scheme. There is some pretty horrific anti-Boeing spin. > Throughout this spring, NASA and Boeing had been working toward a July launch date of the spacecraft, which will carry two astronauts for the first time. > Asked whether Starliner might be able to launch this year, Stich did not offer a concrete timetable. "We're not really ready to talk about a launch opportunity yet," he said. "We're going to work the technical issues first, and then we'll sit down with the Boeing team when the time is right and pick a launch target." Reasonable and responsible as a response. However, Ars spins that response into: > Such an answer suggests that Starliner's launch on an Atlas V rocket ... may very well slip into 2024. I mean, a few month delay on a brand new space vehicle isn't "OMG, Boeing failed!" But even that is not enough: Ars doubles down, and now NASA's refusal to provide a concrete updated launch date means not only is it "[slipping] into 2024", but apparently almost to 2025: > Given the ongoing delays, it is now possible that Crew-9 flies next fall, before Boeing's first operational mission, Starliner-1. Which is hilarious (ambiguity about launches) as NASA doesn't even know when in 2024 (except that it will be at least Spring) Crew-EIGHT will launch... (and neither NASA nor SpaceX itself has made any communication on Crew-9 launch timeframes.) All 100% speculation. The "ongoing delays" in this context are "in June, Boeing announced that it would push back the July launch". I also question Ars' framing of this as "losing money"... it's R&D expenditures. Ars (and its Space editor, Eric Berger, who has written books about SpaceX) are pretty heavy proponents of SpaceX (which I generally am too, despite being less enthusiastic about its leader), and this article just reeks of subjective opinion, more so than objective neutrality.
- adolph 3y ago> > Such an answer suggests that Starliner's launch on an Atlas V rocket ... may very well slip into 2024. > I mean, a few month delay on a brand new space vehicle isn't "OMG, Boeing failed!" Atlas V . . . is America's longest-serving active rocket. In August 2021, ULA announced that Atlas V would be retired, and all 29 remaining launches had been sold.[ As of 10 November 2022, 19 launches remain. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atlas_V https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Atlas_V
- 3y ago
- TheCaptain4815 3y agoI truly hope this is the beginning of the end for these bloated "boomer defense companies". Palmer Lucky actually started a defense company after seeing just how inefficient and bloated those big companies were, and is already worth 10 billion! Highly recommend watching this interview he had about the future of all this. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S-sD2FTjSaw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S-sD2FTjSaw
- Animats 3y agoThere's no market. Private manned launches have been on Space-X's price list for years. Anybody buy one yet?
- bradyd 3y agoYes, they've had 3 so far and have at least 4 more planned. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SpaceX_Dragon_2#Crew_Dragon_flights https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SpaceX_Dragon_2#Crew_Dragon_fl...
- Animats 3y agoRight, billionaire space tourism is a thing.
- signatoremo 3y agoSo there is indeed a market for private flights? Saudi Arabia and Turkey also purchased seats on Dragon for their space programs. The market exists alright
- shirro 3y agoYes it is. It is hoped that finding commercial applications for space technology will benefit NASA by giving providers more opportunity to amortise development costs and lower prices. It isn't all billionaires but they are part of the picture as it is probably around $55 million per seat for orbital flights though the exact numbers are not disclosed. Axiom's last mission had two Saudi astronauts (Saudi airforce captain and a biomedical scientist) funded by their government. The next Axiom mission will be flying astronauts for the Turkish space agency(air force colonel), Italian defence force (test pilot) and Swedish space agency/ESA (test pilot, esa astronaut) as well as their Axiom commander who is a legendary ex-NASA astronaut. Even the upcoming Polaris Dawn which is funded by billionaire Isaacman will have two SpaceX lead operations engineers and an ex-USAF fighter pilot onboard and Isaacman is a respectable pilot himself. They are going to be pushing private spaceflight to new limits.
- uristohkrat 3y ago
- dfgssdfgsdfg 3y agoIronically it looks like Boeing's stock soared today on some positive news about aircraft sales
- freeopinion 3y agoIt is exciting to me to see a company that is willing to spend $billions$ on research and allow it to continue when it is doesn't lead to immediate profits and any visible gains. It is depressing to work for a company that seems immune to wasting $billions$ and countless human resources wandering around lost. When there are no consequences for failure there can be an amazing culture of innovation. There can also be a dumbfounding culture of negligence and mismanagement. Sometimes we only distinguish between the two based on survivorship bias.
- panick21_ 3y agoThis is the opposite. Because Boeing has no culture of innovation, their capsule was conservative in every choice. Slow development, bad software practices, lots of established slow contractors. That why it is expensive and behind schedule. And the are continuing to build it not because of innovation but rather because it would be an utter and complete embarassment for them to give up. They would lose all credibility as a space contractor and would have little chance to ever bid for another big NASA project again.
- MagicMoonlight 3y ago>Because Starliner was funded by NASA through a fixed-price contract, as part of the Commercial Crew program, Boeing is responsible for any cost overruns and financial losses due to delays. Whoever it was in NASA that got that into the contract deserves a promotion
- bigbillheck 3y ago[flagged]
- evilos 3y agoFull Self Driving is imminent and X.com is the future of finance!
- srameshc 3y agoSocial finance, we will all be networked and worked and paying each other via X ! :)
- MrOwnPut 3y ago[flagged]
- dang 3y agoSince we just asked you to stop posting like this and you've continued to do it, I've banned the account. If you don't want to be banned, you're welcome to email hn@ycombinator.com and give us reason to believe that you'll follow the rules in the future. They're here: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.
- grecy 3y agoElon also said the Falcon 9 would work, said it would be re-usable, said the Falcon 9 heavy would work, said the Model S would be good, said the Model 3 would be great, said the Model Y would be the most popular car in the world, etc. etc. Obviously he's not hitting 100%, but you can't deny his companies are achieving immensely more than anyone ever thought possible. If I could take Elon's ratio of "I said it would work vs. it's real and it does", I would, and so would any sane person.
- jackmott42 3y agosane person here, I would only take Elon's claim that something would work seriously if it relied mostly on newtonian mechanics to verify. which model S being good, falcon 9 working etc, that is all it takes. basic physics napkin math. anything with nuance (self driving) or human emotions in play (twitter), and he is the same as any boomer uncle complaining about kids these days
- ThinkBeat 3y agoThis is I am sure a stupid question but is that a lot? In the context of building a new rocket system? Allegedly the development of the F35 cost about $35 billion according to one 2020 study. (Which I think was estimated at the start to about $400 million in non-inflation adjusted dollars) If I look at it through that frame, spending $1.1B on developing a rocket seems ok (I Know they are not done so the cost will keep rising)
- roelschroeven 3y agoTo be precise, this is not about the development of a rocket: Starliner will launch on an existing rocket, the Atlas V. This is about developing and building Starliner spacecraft, putting them on Atlas V rockets, and after successful acceptance tests putting people in them to fly them to and from the ISS.
- 51Cards 3y ago"...and the second problem came with hundreds of feet of P-213 glass cloth tape inside the spacecraft found to be flammable." How does the craft get built and you just discover this now?
- shmoe 3y agoIf it's Boeing, it ain't going.
- Georgelemental 3y agoGood read on the decline and fall of Boeing: https://www.thepsmiths.com/p/review-flying-blind-by-peter-robison https://www.thepsmiths.com/p/review-flying-blind-by-peter-ro...
- travisporter 3y agoHow was crew dragon so successful? From my reading, NASA worked closely with SpaceX, why did this not help Boeing?
- thegrim22 3y agoKind of interesting to think about relating this to the ongoing UAP hearings, where it's alleged that private government contractors overbill for projects and funnel the extra money to the UAP programs. Boeing has been mentioned by name a few times.