4 ms·
With the rate at which ICE cars randomly ignite, you'd think they would've banned electric cars already (self ignition for ICE engines is way higher than that o
by jeroenhd 3y ago
With the rate at which ICE cars randomly ignite, you'd think they would've banned electric cars already (self ignition for ICE engines is way higher than that of electric cars for some reason). Cars on boats, regardless of fuel type, is just incredibly risky.
That said, it's impossible to extinguish a lithium battery so I can't blame them. When a fire does eventually start, it'll burn for the entire duration of the trip and probably a while after as well.
Their take on hybrids (with much smaller batteries) and hydrogen cars (those are just weird, more complex ICE cars) is bad, though.
My guess is that there's more going on. Perhaps the extra weight of modern cars is causing them problems? They would have to ban ridiculous vehicles like SUVs as well if that were a concern, but it could explain why a shipping company is putting out such strict limitations.
- gtirloni 3y ago> it's impossible to extinguish a lithium battery Really?
- marcosdumay 3y agoThe thing about batteries is that they include both components necessary for maintaining a fire. (Just like explosives, by the way, but less mixed.)
- KRAKRISMOTT 3y agoDo lead acids contain oxidizer and fuel too?
- marcosdumay 3y agoYes, all batteries do. But both are much less reactive than on lithium batteries.
- KRAKRISMOTT 3y agoWhy though? Are all batteries inherently two way redox reactions?
- marcosdumay 3y agoYes, rechargeable batteries work by two way redox reactions.
- jeroenhd 3y agoFirefighters let electric cars burn out far away from other things that can be set on fire or they're temporarily cooled off long enough to be dunked into a shipping container full of water so they can be moved safely. Lithium batteries contain extremely strong oxidizers, which means starving the fire is near impossible. Cooling the reaction down is a way to make the flames go out, but damaged lithium batteries tend to let out hydrogen gas (very flammable, obviously) and the heat of one burning battery cell can damage the one(s) next to it. You can't just extinguish them because they'll relight themselves later. In fact, several Teslas have lit on fire hours after a somewhat minor incident that the car could just drive away from. Aside from dropping the burning wreck into the ocean, I don't know how you could possibly hope to really extinguish a burning electric car on a boat. When those things go, they go! Electric cars are great, but electric car fires are terrible. That's not necessarily a problem; ICE cars go up in flames all the time too, but they're easier to put out. I'll gladly take the lower risk of self combustion for an EV parked in a garage over the risk of an ICE car parked in the same spot; how hard it is to put out a car fire isn't really relevant when you're lucky to get out of the house safely anyway.
- reisse 3y ago> With the rate at which ICE cars randomly ignite, you'd think they would've banned electric cars already (self ignition for ICE engines is way higher than that of electric cars for some reason). Cars on boats, regardless of fuel type, is just incredibly risky. ICE cars ignite randomly mostly when the engine is running, which is not the case on ferries. I'd bet self-ignition of ICE cars with stopped engine is more rare than self-ignition of stopped electric cars. And in most cases of ICE fires handheld fire extinguisher is enough to stop the flames...
- Ekaros 3y agoAnd once you are done with ICE it almost always stays done. EVs more likely just keep burning for long time.
- whelp_24 3y agoHydrogen cars in the most common version (correct me if i am wrong), are closer to hybrids right? Like the motor is electric and is powered by the hydrogen generator.
- jeroenhd 3y agoIt depends on the exact engine, but as far as I understand them the hydrogen is turned into electricity and water and then exhausted out back. They're not exactly ICE cars or hybrids because they don't ignite the hydrogen (they use fuel cells instead) but they are pumping fuel around and filled with combustible material. I suppose in terms of fires, they're closer to hybrids because they'll charge an electric battery that can also be used with tech like regen braking for better fuel efficiency. Then again, if a hydrogen tank lights on fire, that'll probably cause a strong burst of flames (assuming explosion prevention mechanisms work) similar to bursts that escape from burning lithium cells. They're really their own category, but there are so few hydrogen cars that I don't think it really matters to be honest.
- nradov 3y agoWeight is not an issue. Vehicle weights are known and factored into vessel stability calculations. The maritime authorities in each country will typically set cargo weight limits for each deck. It's common to carry heavy trucks weighing tens of tons on ro-ro ferries. So, spare us your uninformed nonsense about "ridiculous vehicles like SUVs".
- jeroenhd 3y agoAccording to this news article (GTranslate): https://www-nrk-no.translate.goog/nordland/slar-tilbake-mot-spekulasjonene-_-lover-a-ta-med-biler-1.14479034?_x_tr_sl=auto&_x_tr_tl=en&_x_tr_hl=nl&_x_tr_pto=wapp https://www-nrk-no.translate.goog/nordland/slar-tilbake-mot-... the "ferry", which is more like a cruise ship with a cargo hold, can hold up to nine cars in total. When the new ships were announced, rumor had it that it couldn't even take cars at all. If you manage to stuff ten tons trucks into that thing, I'm not so sure you'll be able to leave port at all.
- marcosdumay 3y ago> self ignition for ICE engines is way higher than that of electric cars for some reason They have flammable lubricants spread everywhere on the same environment as high-current electric circuits, high-powered attrition-based devices and a bare hot fuel burning engine. It's a wonder that fires are as rare as they are. (I mean, I must have seen some 5 ICE cars catching fire. Compared to how many I've seen in total, that's an incredibly low ratio; it's a scheduled aviation level of safety.) I do expect electric cars to catch fire much less often, but that's because they are naturally not prone to it. But yes, if the decision was up to me, I would want to have some real numbers, and I don't think anybody has them yet, so expect things to be random.