20 ms·
U.S. Senate bill crafted with DEA targets end-to-end encryption
- jtode 3y agoWell, tech workers of the free world?
- seeknotfind 3y agoIf you can get a bit, you can get a file. Limiting communication of criminal organizations, you are raising the barrier to entry. However, drugs are big money at scale, so big organizations can solve it. Most people with a technical background could figure out how to solve comms too. I don't think it'll move the buck. We need better methods for tracking physical shipments, decriminalization of use, and investment in schools, science and other programs which build viable alternatives to trafficking.
- bhhaskin 3y agoAh yes. The criminal organizations wouldn't want to break the law now would they?
- jtode 3y agoAt some point we have to say no to government overreach. This looks like that to me. The question is, do we collectively have any gonads, or are we just a bunch of well-fed kept poodles of the aristocracy?
- lockhouse 3y agoI think they should craft a bill that targets the DEA instead.
- brucethemoose2 3y agoFirst off, going after e2e encryption is wrong. ...But I am starting to get sick of unencrypted Big Tech's liability shield. It was enacted to let the nascent social media platforms survive. But they aren't startups running out of garages anymore. They are some of the richest entities on the planet, they can patrol their own platforms, but they will not patrol their own platforms out of the goodness of their hearts unless it affects their bottom line, or a law makes them fear prosecution.
- gruez 3y ago>they can patrol their own platforms, but they will not patrol their own platforms out of the goodness of their hearts unless it affects their bottom line, or a law makes them fear prosecution. We already see what happens when government delegates law enforcement to corporations: AML/ATF regulations that financial institutions have to follow. The idea is basically the same: "banks can patrol their own customers, but they will not patrol their own customers out of the goodness of their hearts unless it affects their bottom line, or a law makes them fear prosecution". The result? People getting randomly banned because some aspect of them or their transaction info contained something tangentially related to something that's sanctioned[1]. The calculus clearly favors companies being trigger-happy than not. If some Al-Qaeda transaction goes through and the media gets wind of it, they'll get fined and/or raked over the coals by regulators and legislators. The reverse happens and the most is some grumbles but you still stay in business. I fully expect the same dynamic to happen for social media companies. Anything that can vaguely be considered offensive will be taken down. Imagine the youtube demonetization debacle, but worse. [1] eg. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35337210 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35337210, or https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24450828 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24450828
- junofan 3y agoI mean should a private company like Snapchat be making money off of fentanyl dealers? There are plenty of alternatives. I guarantee Snapchat already reports child pornographers.
- immibis 3y agoThe right middle ground may be some susceptibility to court orders. E.g. Google shouldn't have to patrol files stored in Google Drive, but a court should be able to get a search warrant for a Drive or order files to be removed. YouTube shouldn't have to proactively search for ElsaGate content, but should have to comply with law enforcement orders to help law enforcement find out why it is happening.
- nullc 3y agoPrior to S230 providers could be shielded from liability through common carrier status. But they couldn't enjoy that protection and remove crap. For point to point services, a very hands off approach makes sense. You generally don't need to remove crap: Garbage in, Garbage out, people can ignore or locally filter what they don't want. But for public online forums a degree of moderation is required (otherwise someone can just flood it with garbage and make it useless to everyone) and generally desirable. S230 is as much about letting people moderate with immunity (both for the things their well intended efforts missed, and for harms created when their moderation goes over broad) as it is anything else. By count most of the deplorable material that shows up on platforms is not illegal or tortious. Material which is offensive, abusive, demeaning, misleading is often lawful and it often doesn't create doesn't create substantial real liability-- except in the form that without broad brush protections like S230 people can sue over whatever frivolous thing they want anf unless you're a multi-billion dollar entity you may well be bankrupt before your inevitable win. A world without powerful liability shields is one where you can't safely irritate or offend parties with significantly more money or power than you. And we can see that already platforms facebook, google, twitter, etc. are effectively immune already to civil suit by virtue of their size and wealth-- just look at the lack of effect litigation over their privacy breaches or shutting users out of their own data with no notice causing them grave harm. ... Or incidents like Apple & Google's wage fixing conspiracy, which while they were eventually convicted cost them less than they saved in wages. Their bad policies are in part because their size, wealth, and power make them significantly immune to public opinion. To the extent that the bad governance of social media sites is harmful to the public we've be better served by having more alternatives. Facebook, Twitter, etc. could survive in a world with S230, but the smaller and better curated alternatives you'd presumably like to see move over very likely couldn't. When we look at laws like the proposed what we can see is the government trying to deputize corporations to investigate and enforce the law on their behalf. One of the drivers of this is that it throughly undermines due process: The constitution established safeguards against government search but we've figured out that we lack the same safeguards against corporations (since we've "voluntarily" handed our data over to them) and so if governments coerce corporations to search they can substantially bypass our fourth amendment rights.
- candiddevmike 3y agoWhy doesn't the DEA chase the Senate on sanctioning China for Fentanyl precursors? https://www.brookings.edu/articles/chinas-role-in-the-fentanyl-crisis/ https://www.brookings.edu/articles/chinas-role-in-the-fentan...
- brookst 3y agoBecause they know trying to reduce supply side is hopeless as long as there’s demand.
- slavboj 3y agoWeirdly enough approximately 100% of the DEA's budget goes towards restricting the supply side, so this would be quite the realization for them to undertake.
- quickthrower2 3y ago100% goes on running Chaos Monkey against the supply side.
- wkat4242 3y agoI don't think the DEA really wants to end the war on drugs. Because without that there is no DEA. At least not as we know it. They just want to show a big win in the news every once in a while to show they are still 'protecting' the world and justify their budget. And those big wins are found in the supply side. All the while not doing anything to solve the real problem to society. Which is the pain and suffering caused to drug addicts and their unproductivity and care costs. But actually helping them is not glamorous. This is particularly pronounced in the US where spending billions on heavily armed agencies kicking down doors is guaranteed re-election but spending a few dimes to help someone in need is 'evil communism'. So all the budget goes to the boys with the toys for the big busts pretending to make a difference. All the other issues like the surrounding crime and cartel megaprofits and corruption are a result of the system of enforcement (strict laws make crime more profitable and hard punishment makes the criminals having nothing to lose and thus more ruthless). It's not the root problem of drugs in general.
- kevin_thibedeau 3y agoClearly we'll have to eliminate the dangerously transgressive TLS protocol from all .gov sites and let the mayhem ensue.
- gruez 3y agoThe had a solution for that since the 90s: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clipper_chip https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clipper_chip
- onesphere 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crypto_Wars https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crypto_Wars
- mindslight 3y agoThat is the banner from the last battle. TLS is exactly the type of centralizing protocol that these people now want - "security" that is fully contingent upon (ie vulnerable to) corporate middlemen and other centralized entities.
- aaomidi 3y agoCT literally exists.
- mindslight 3y agoComputed tomography? Certificate transparency? The Nutmeg State? None of these have anything to do with the main problem with TLS as commonly used, which is that servers are fully trusted.
- aaomidi 3y agoBut, that’s the objective of TLS? TLS isn’t a barrier to e2ee.
- vgivanovic 3y agoThis bill is a gift to the Russians and the Chinese! Now they will be able to read anyone's communications, and do you think they are going to stop encrypting their communications?
- immibis 3y agoOoh, that is a GREAT way to explain to dense politicians why encryption should not be banned.
- wildrhythms 3y agoI fear that explanation could still be used to justify a backdoor to read the communications of our 'enemies'.
- boredpeter 3y agoOr we could pass universal healthcare and get drug addicts the healthcare they need to fix their addiction problems and thus lower demand for the products. Nah, let’s create a massive surveillance state and keep drug addicts homeless and living in poverty. It’s what the private health insurance companies want.
- lockhouse 3y agoThe private health insurance companies are not the ones pushing for this, it’s the intelligence community.
- wildrhythms 3y agoIt's all interlinked man. >A handful of members of Congress, allied with the nation’s major drug distributors, prevailed upon the DEA and the Justice Department to agree to a more industry-friendly law, undermining efforts to stanch the flow of pain pills, according to an investigation by The Washington Post and “60 Minutes.” The DEA had opposed the effort for years. The law was the crowning achievement of a multifaceted campaign by the drug industry to weaken aggressive DEA enforcement efforts against drug distribution companies that were supplying corrupt doctors and pharmacists who peddled narcotics to the black market. The industry worked behind the scenes with lobbyists and key members of Congress, pouring more than a million dollars into their election campaigns. https://archive.is/TMfA4 https://archive.is/TMfA4 https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/2017/investigations/dea-drug-industry-congress/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/2017/investigations/...
- nonethewiser 3y ago> Or we could pass universal healthcare and get drug addicts ... This is rather off topic. You could say this in response to literally any effort that is not healthcare for drug addicts.
- coderintherye 3y ago[flagged]
- nimbius 3y ago"...when the companies have “actual knowledge” that illicit drugs are being distributed on their platforms" chat providers could also pivot to a pfs model with deniability that effectively removes them from ever knowing about chat at all. Frankly I think providers are in a bind. Federal agencies using this regulation could tank the product through repeated action against the public interest (like disclosing an abortion for example.). The compliance overhead is also nontrivial. Then again it could force the hand of companies like signal into a supreme court showdown.
- mindslight 3y agoFTA: > it includes particularly controversial language holding companies accountable for conduct they don’t report if they “deliberately blind” themselves to the violations. So it sounds like the "actual knowledge" is false advertising that doesn't reflect the actual dynamic of the bill.
- immibis 3y agoAFAIK in law "deliberately blind" would mean if they see some drug sales and then pretend they didn't. It doesn't mean if they deliberately hide message content, or at least, it doesn't mean that by itself. Signal, which is deliberately E2EE, would not be considered deliberately blind to drug sales, as that isn't its main use. Tor might be in hot water and might be required to block specific .onion addresses. Of course new ones will pop up, but the Tor project will be accidentally blind to those, not deliberately.
- pashadee 3y ago"Deliberately blind" implies the use of encryption (by a platform or provider). One solution I think is to provide a user side toggle or option to enable encryption. Then it is not deliberate from the provider's perspective, but a user choice/preference. And it is not unreasonable for the user to expect privacy (encryption), ergo this choice defaults to encrypted. At worst the provider is intentionally blinded by the user, and not deliberately blind. But do we move the argument back to whether including (the choice of) encryption to mean deliberately blind?
- Kon-Peki 3y agoLink to the actual bill [1]. The worry is that it has some vague language that would make social media companies drop E2E encryption. I’m definitely not a legal expert, but the proposed law specifically says: g) Protection Of Privacy.—Nothing in this section shall be construed to require a provider to— “(1) monitor any user, subscriber, or customer of that provider; “(2) monitor the content of any communication of any person described in paragraph (1); or “(3) affirmatively search, screen, or scan for facts or circumstances described in subsections (b) and (c). It seems like the goal is to make it so that when people complain to websites about specific instances of illegal conduct, the website is not allowed to ignore the complaint. [1] https://www.congress.gov/bill/118th-congress/senate-bill/1080/text https://www.congress.gov/bill/118th-congress/senate-bill/108...
- slavboj 3y agoOf course you're not "required to monitor", you're just also required not to be "deliberately blind". The combination of these is that you are required to maintain the capability to surveil users upon request (ie, no scary encryption) - and once that capability is in place, the next step is pseudo KYC and SAR functionality.
- Kon-Peki 3y agoThe words “deliberately blind” aren’t in the text I linked to. I see a paragraph that says you can’t knowingly and willingly fail to make a report or you get fined. But the very next paragraph says this doesn’t mean you have to monitor anyone or screen or scan anything people write. I’m just not seeing it. What I do see is that a bunch of internet companies really don’t like the idea of being fined a lot of money every time their customer service AI makes a mistake when categorizing a complaint about drugs, because they know their customer service AI is garbage.
- slavboj 3y agoIt's possible it's a versioning discrepancy - the language being referred to is here. Your version is "as introduced". During the committee process I believe it is possible for language to be altered before an actual vote without a formal "amendment". https://twitter.com/JakeLaperruque/status/1678887225516277761 https://twitter.com/JakeLaperruque/status/167888722551627776...
- cryptonector 3y agoThe DEA -of all agencies- will cause all this trouble?? They're out of control.
- SoftTalker 3y agoHow hard would it be to develop an add-on app of some sort that GPG-encrypts messages before you send them. Something like a textbox that encrypts its content, copies it to the clipboard, and then pastes it into the message app. Vice-versa on the receiving side. It's becoming clear that if you want to keep the government and tech companies from snooping on your messages you need to take matters into your own hands.
- xen2xen1 3y agoClients like Pidgin have an OTR (off the record) plugin that will do end to end encryption over random channel IIRC. It's possible.
- ale42 3y agoDefinitely. I was doing EE2E with friends using Pidgin and OTR plugin (just because it was possible, not that we were discussing anything sensitive) over ICQ and MSN... so ages before TextSecure (now Signal) was even a thing.
- jojobas 3y agoDitch commercial "free" messaging, deploy your own Matrix instance and make accounts for your friends and family who can't.
- SoftTalker 3y agoYeah that's probably the way.
- wkat4242 3y agoGPG is probably not the best choice for IM because it lacks Perfect Forward Secrecy. Meaning if someone obtains the key they can read all consent ever encrypted with it both past and present. PFS requires that both endpoints communicate together so for email's "fire and forget" structure it didn't make sense. But for IM it sure does.
- sneak 3y agoThis is a 1A violation - this restricts the ability of people to publish e2ee software. It's prior restraint.
- ETH_start 3y agoThis is the AML approach's "platform providers must presume their clients guilty until they prove them innocent"/"criminalize privacy" philosophy being applied to communication.
- FrustratedMonky 3y agoSup ETH_start. You need to go get in on this . https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36864547 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36864547
- ETH_start 3y agoThanks, I rebutted it here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36872645 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36872645
- dhx 3y agoWould YouTube need to report [1] (a news report about a police officer accidentally overdosing on fentanyl due to exposure on the job) because it is a fact or circumstance regarding the unlawful distribution of a fentanyl? How many rap songs and lyrics would need to be reported just because they appear to contain lyrics about potential actual drug use? Would every "{celebrity_name} dies from drug overdose" news article and discussion on social media need to be reported? Should USPTO patent US3141823A[1] (a method for synthesising fentanyl) be reported? Perhaps that social media user who linked to this patent is involved in the unlawful manufacture of fentanyl? Should the National Institutes of Health published article "An Efficient, Optimized Synthesis of Fentanyl and Related Analogs"[3] be reported? Perhaps that social media user who linked to this article is involved in the unlawful manufacture of fentanyl? Given the proposed bill prevents notification of the preservation request for at least 5 days, is the platform meant to delete the offending content for terms of service violation, or leave the content in place so as to not alert the user(s)? If the platform can't delete the offending content, what happens if the content was uploaded alongside copyright infringing material, pornographic material, or other content that the platform would typically immediately remove? [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jd76HxqCPf0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jd76HxqCPf0 [2] https://patents.google.com/patent/US3141823A/en https://patents.google.com/patent/US3141823A/en [3] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4169472/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4169472/
- KennyBlanken 3y agoThe "cops ODing on fentanyl they touch in crime scenes" thing is not medically possible. It's always the cops having a panic attack from thinking they're about to OD because they touched some fentanyl. They get taken to the hospital, tested, and no trace of fentanyl is found in their bloodstream...but the media (and police) make a huge deal of it all and leave out the "and no fentanyl was found in their blood" because it's embarrassing. The only way an officer could be exposed to fentanyl is by ingesting it, not touching it.
- Obscurity4340 3y agoDo you really think that's why they make such a big deal about it? It seems like a heavily exaggerated type of virtue signalling to scare people into voting heavier restrictions. I am extremely cynical towards the notion that they are actually "afraid" of it in any sense at both the individual and bureaucratic levels.
- tareqak 3y agoI think that that needs to be what I call “the dog shall not bark up the wrong tree” laws where an organization cannot spend its resources on influencing the laws that manage its conduct. You can argue that it makes sense that these people understand the problem best so they should have some input into the decision-making process. However, I think that the most they should do is present the raw data of their operations sanitized of only the sensitive information that they are required to sanitize by law and no more. Otherwise, they are just government lobbyists lobbying for their advantage.
- mycall 3y agoWho would lobby your points? ACLU? Word out to ACLU with their Mobile Justice app. Should be on everyone's phone just in case.
- loudambiance 3y agoI just and looked for the app, and it isn't available on my device because it was made for an older version of Android :(
- chongli 3y agoEverything went wrong when lawmakers criminalized possession of drugs. All of this nonsense follows from a system where ordinary people are treated with suspicion and criminals are given exclusive access to a highly profitable market. Al Capone and his ilk taught us the disastrous consequences of prohibition a century. Yet we continue making the same mistake with different substances.
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoStrongly agree. How would you word an anti-Prohibition Constitutional amendment?
- jurynulifcation 3y agoThis is an interesting challenge. I guess the best way I can put it would be: "That no law shall be made preventing an informed and consenting adult from consuming whatever substance they so please." As a side tangent: Tennessee prevents the sale of raw milk. I can not go to a dairy farmer in TN, watch him produce a pail of milk, and pay him for the pleasure of considering that pail of milk to be mine. Why? This is probably the stupidest prohibition I have yet to see. If you want to prevent the general public from unwittingly consuming raw dairy, that makes sense. But why can I not purchase raw dairy that I know to be raw and produced in good condition? There is a work-around to this, where you are legally entitled to consume the dairy of any cow you own... and so some dairy farmers sell "shares" of their cow, which entitles you to its milk. I'm not wholly against such an arrangement but it does seem rather farcical in its mandatory character.
- wmidwestranger 3y agoSo, uh, what right to be secure in person and property without a warrant approved by a judge? The US Bill of Rights was so contentious at the time and the supporters so adamant that they ended up being the first 10 amendments to our constitution. The supporters could have very well held out and either forced them to be included in the constitution or left us with the original Articles of Confederation (not the Southern State's one) but compromised. Even if the Bill of Rights were in the constitution, and not amendments, I expect they would be just as disposable. And for what? So the DEA and CIA can continue to operate with the same privilege as the East India Company? How does this, or the drug war, serve the average American? I do not for a second believe this provides any benefit to the average American. I do believe it will allow executive agencies privileged access to markets and information of felonious goods, likely to their benefit and not the citizens.
- KennyBlanken 3y agoDon't forget that CBP has essentially unlimited vehicle search authority within 100 miles of federal borders. Two thirds of the US population live within that zone. https://www.aclu.org/know-your-rights/border-zone https://www.aclu.org/know-your-rights/border-zone Imagine living in NYC, hopping on a subway car to go to work from your apartment in the Bronx, and getting stopped/searched by CBP, agents seizing your cell phone and laptop, and demanding your social media account passwords and threatening to detain you if you don't comply: https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2017/02/give-us-your-passwords/516315/ https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2017/02/give-... https://www.wired.com/2017/02/guide-getting-past-customs-digital-privacy-intact/ https://www.wired.com/2017/02/guide-getting-past-customs-dig... It's fucking insane that US citizens are now advised to make sure a family member, friend, or attorney is aware of you traveling across a US border in case you're detained. This country just keeps slipping further and further towards fascism.
- immibis 3y agoThe country is already fascist. Don't downplay it.
- unethical_ban 3y ago>A Thursday press release from sponsor Sen. Jeanne Shaheen (D-NH) highlighted statistics from the DEA supporting the need for the legislation. >Within a five-month period, Shaheen said, DEA investigated 390 drug-poisoning investigations and found that 129 had direct ties to social media. >“Unfortunately, federal agencies have not had access to the necessary data to intervene, which has allowed the crisis to worsen,” the press release said. Sincerely The cost of a free society. To prohibit private communication between people is a key step for any future totalitarian regime.
- dclowd9901 3y agoHow would this stop a sufficiently large criminal organization from creating their own encrypted messaging app and distributing it internally?
- friend_and_foe 3y agoSufficiently large? The software is there, I could deploy something like that in an afternoon. I'm not a criminal organization. Anyone can deploy their own e2ee infrastructure.
- immibis 3y agoBut where will you put the server? Not in the USA, that's for sure. Not in the UK. Not in Europe. Maybe you can broadcast your encrypted messages illegally on shortwave radio, until the FCC catches you broadcasting illegally on shortwave radio. Maybe you can bounce them off the moon (that's a real transmission technique) or hijack someone else's satellites (more trivial than it sounds because a lot of them are quite dumb). Or you can put a server in somewhere like Myanmar where they won't care about servers hosting E2EE apps, but they also won't care about strange men in black suits turning up and stealing servers hosting E2EE apps. Either way you'll have some difficulty.
- sweetbitter 3y agoYou could just use onion services to to hide the server, and store some backup onion services (whose private keys are kept offline) within the application or its files. When the server goes down due to seizure, you spin up a new one under the backup service's pubkey, and sign a list of new backup keys which will also be kept offline until the next seizure. You could also combine encryption with steganography, if you strip non-random 'protocol information' from your encrypted bits. Doing that, it would not be easy to prove that you are sending encrypted messages at all without having obtained your keys.
- immibis 3y agoWe're talking about a scenario where Tor is illegal.
- lillecarl 3y agoThere seems like there's new bills from Australia, UK and the US every day. They'll just keep going until the shit gets passed?
- timeimp 3y agoYes - because the public has a very, very short-term working memory. The public pressure and ad campaigns _against_ these things have to be constant. All it takes is 1 domino to fall then it becomes "well, if it is good enough for <other country>, its good enough for us!"
- sgath92 3y agoI am not sure that the American public cares much about what has become the norm in other countries so that line doesn't really carry any weight here. I'd argue that instead, its more that the public is so apathetic about bad-turns of law that they'll just shrug with a sigh and begrudgingly tolerate the new paradigm.
- lillecarl 3y agoI don't get how the political system can work like this, we keep denying laws that are absolute dogshit. The politicians give them a makeover and try again. They only need a yes once and we need a no every time. Makes me question democracy really, it seems fundamentally broken when the peoples voice is supressed over and over. Same stuff happens in Sweden, but with other kinds of laws.
- bombcar 3y agoDemocracy makes a lot more sense if you see it as an emergency escape valve to prevent violent revolution (because you assume anyone willing to violently revolt would be willing to vote).
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- 3y ago
- jimt1234 3y agoThe DEA?! Well, I guess that makes sense considering how well things have gone with the so-called War On Drugs. /s
- eternityforest 3y agoIt's amazing that we have GDPR and attempts at encryption bans, at the same time, on the same planet.
- friend_and_foe 3y agoIn many cases, in the same countries.
- eternityforest 3y agoAnd with seemingly far more public interest in GDPR-like stuff than protecting encryption rights. It almost seems like they're both driven by the same anti-tech sentiment, and encryption isn't as important when you really want no tech at all. Scary!
- photochemsyn 3y agoThe DEA should be abolished, it's a ridiculously corrupt organization. Incorportate it into ATF (Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms) and be done with it alreadty.
- P_I_Staker 3y agoShould be replaced with an organization that does comprehensive drug interventions like rehab, harm reductions, and maybe some enforcement. At least this would be an answer for what to do with all the people and bureaucracy, which is apparently an issue.
- Animats 3y agoHere's a law review argument that encryption is constitutionally protected by the 4th amendment.[1] That might succeed today. Court decisions have been moving in the direction of stronger protection of 4th Amendment rights against law enforcement. [1] https://digitalcommons.lmu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3014&context=llr https://digitalcommons.lmu.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3...
- b3nji 3y agoCoincidentally, there is a similar law being out forward in the U.K. Is this a contrived effort, or a happy accident for the government is pulled off?
- immibis 3y agoIt's a case of "multiple discovery". All countries are seeing the same conditions, which cause them to want to ban encryption, at the same time.
- jauntywundrkind 3y agoThe encryption issue is nuclear bad, an imminent threat to speech & freedom & liberty. It's not as immediately catastrophic, but telling everyone running a site network or service they now have to actively police that shit &tell the DEA everything is also a pretty awful walk back of safe harbor. Discord is going to have to go through hell to survive & comply with such a measure. Where does it even stop? Do the feds now get paged every time someone says they got high? And it's the feds... are the feds here trying to route around an ever increasing number of state's decriminalizations/legalizations? It may be legal but the feds are listening in all online places? Government's ability to concern-troll the world into illiberal shitty authoritarianism is so manifestly endless & diverse. They are just horrible pathetic chumps, in nation after nation after nation. This is why the Declaration of Independence of Cyberspace was written: because there is a moral obligation to obstruct deny & prevent exactly this sort of illegitimizing intolerable nonsense that these power grabbing maniacs would gladly foist upon us.
- robbywashere_ 3y agoI want to see an amendment to the United States constitution for the right to encryption.
- andrewstuart 3y agoSurely it’s needed for the “protection of the children”?
- fredgrott 3y agoWhat is the context of the last paragraph by Carl Szabo from NetChoice He said that if the bill is enacted all reporting by social media sites “would be subjected to Fourth Amendment processes, and it will actually become harder for law enforcement to identify these threats." We had the same debate when they were thinking about pulling down backpages in that if it is out in the open it is easy for LEOs to find and bring justice to bear unlike something not happening out in the open. Would that mean there would have to be a process of SM account take downs that goes through the courts via 4th Amendment?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- larata_media 3y agoIt’s anti first amendment. This bill won’t stand up to judicial scrutiny if ever challenged.
- yurishimo 3y agoSponsor: Sen. Marshall, Roger [R-KS] Cosponsors: - Sen. Shaheen, Jeanne [D-NH] - Sen. Durbin, Richard J. [D-IL] - Sen. Grassley, Chuck [R-IA] - Sen. Klobuchar, Amy [D-MN] - Sen. Young, Todd [R-IN] Call your senators and let them know you DO NOT SUPPORT THIS! It seems hokey and feels like it doesn't matter, but Senate staff really does keep track of this kind of stuff.
- LorenPechtel 3y agoI'm quite surprised--I expected pure Rs on this.
- phatskat 3y agoIt’s rarely pure Rs, even if it’s just Manchin and Sinema. Remember that most Ds are barely right of center.
- sieabahlpark 3y ago[dead]
- greatfilter251 3y ago[flagged]
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- advael 3y agoThe DEA was invented as part of the most successful effort in human history to create a totalitarian police state, and it is no surprise that they want to further clamp down on civil liberties at a national level Drug enforcement was always a massive totalitarian project, has destroyed millions of lives, and continues to make the world a more dangerous and less free place for nearly everyone. It is both incredibly unethical and, from the perspective of its purported aims of actually reducing the harms of drug use, a massive policy failure at every level (though if you agree with me that its true purpose is a police state, it is an incredible success). It's not just users of so-called "street drugs" that suffer, it is everyone who has to interact with the massive police state we have built, or receive any medical treatment. Even very privileged people who have never used an illegal drug can run afoul of the kafkaesque rules about identifying "drug-seeking" behavior, even if they are spared the worst of the violent enforcement apparatus that has ravaged countless neighborhoods and communities throughout the world as police departments have become more and more powerful paramilitary organizations with more carte blanche mandate to search for an ever-widening array of substances in people's private property, up to and including their bodies. As with most things, the outcomes this puts on the majority of the people affected are much, much worse. Drug enforcement has destroyed countless lives for the mere act of possessing substances - or sometimes even equipment associated with their use or manufacture - that any enemy, especially anyone with official authority, can easily plant on someone. It is the primary driving factor for the unprecedented incarceration rates of the US in particular and has also through second-order effects ravaged the economies, infrastructure, and communities of numerous other countries in the massive US sphere of influence If we purport to care about things like civil liberties or human rights, the continued existence of drug enforcement is an emergency situation that has been actively on fire for a very long time. We need to repeal the Controlled Substances Act and every piece of legislation that has ever resulted from it. Deciding what drugs consenting adults can use on themselves should never have been the purview of the government, and the harms of this have grown worse every year for nearly half a century. The DEA is a key and irredeemable part of that. You can't expect a monster you created to eat people's faces to suddenly voluntarily stop