4 ms·
It's not amazing, it's obviously delusional. Think about it - if it really worked you have invented a perpetual motion machine, since you could just feed the f
by IshKebab 3y ago
It's not amazing, it's obviously delusional.
Think about it - if it really worked you have invented a perpetual motion machine, since you could just feed the fresh water through a little water wheel back into the ocean.
You don't need to do any maths at all to know that his maths has gone drastically wrong somewhere.
- MostlyStable 3y agoIn the absence of the sun (which is what ultimately drives ocean mixing), eventually this would lead to a layer of pure fresh water on top of a layer of salt. The energy is being driven by osmotic pressure of salt water. Once you have extracted the water out of the salt, that pressure is exhausted. Thus it is not perpetual.
- roflc0ptic 3y agoTake a long tube with an osmotic filter on it. Put it in the sea with one end out. Pressure is going to fill the tube up, no, just like a snorkel? Probably back up to sea level, possibly minus whatever force reduction caused by the filter? Boom, water filtration with no expenditure of energy. It may be wrong but it really isn't "obviously delusional."
- postalrat 3y agoYou forgot the part where the water in the pipe is less dense and would be pushed up.
- MarkMarine 3y agoThis isn’t a closed system. It’s not perpetual motion, there is an EXTRAORDINARY amount of energy added to the system by the sun. Saying “maths” instead of just math sounds quite odd, why are you making it plural? Is solving one equation “a math” and solving multiple equations “maths”?
- xdex 3y ago“Math” is used in USA and Canada. “Maths” is used by the rest of the English speaking world.
- MarkMarine 3y agoSounds ridiculous
- _wayl 3y ago"Math" sounds funny as a brit - it's just what you're used to, although I will admit "math" is probably more technically correct.
- vorticalbox 3y agoReminds me of "school of rock" > So, get off your ath, let's do some math.
- jaapbadlands 3y agoYou do
- devindotcom 3y agoNo one has mentioned it but maths is short for mathematics. Also, your judgment of a very common figure of speech comes off as provincial.
- MarkMarine 3y agoFair, I was being trite. The idea that the ocean is a closed system that doesn’t include all the solar energy, currents, mixing and everything else added to it plus an osmotic membrane would represent a perpetual motion machine just sounded so laughably stupid I was just trying to be equally annoying and dumb.
- rhtd 3y agoI disagree to disagree, I henceforth declare this a mathses space for all mathstronauts