6 ms·
As someone with direct experience with someone that has a mental illness, there needs to be something better than the present system. I think something went ri
by m463 3y ago
As someone with direct experience with someone that has a mental illness, there needs to be something better than the present system.
I think something went right, then wrong with the treatment of mental illness in california.
Years ago, when the laws were changed to allow mentally-ill but benign or even non-ill people to escape the "snake pits", lots of people could recover.
But later state mental illness funding was cut.
Now clearly mentally ill people - who needed help - were turned away unless they were clearly "a danger to themselves and others".
Many homeless people are these mentally ill people, and can't get help (and they can't be forced in unless they are dangerous, which is usually how recovery begins).
Additionally, some clearly mentally ill people suffer from anosognosia, which seems to fix their self-image in their mind to eliminate any self doubts or insight into their mental image.
At a minimum, there needs to be a way - with checks and balances - to support recovery for people who don't have insight into their disease, and the current system doesn't provide it.
I also think it would pay for itself, as lots of mentally ill people don't get proper treatment, yet are still a huge burden on the health care system.
- htss2013 3y ago>Now clearly mentally ill people - who needed help - were turned away unless they were clearly "a danger to themselves and others". People talk as if this standard is the source of problems, but it's a fine standard. We just don't enforce it. Eg, if a homeless drug addict overdoses and is brought back by the fire dept with narcan, this is clearly someone who is a danger to themselves. They should be treated no differently than someone rescued from a suicide attempt. Fentanyl itself changes the imminent danger of being an opiate addict because there's no remotely safe way to use it. Any chronic user of Fentanyl is a danger to themselves. Someone who is unable to maintain basic level of health on the street is the same. Do you have infected wounds festering? Teeth rotting out of your mouth? The government would take away a pet dog from someone in that state, but for a human doing it to themselves, no problem.
- TurkishPoptart 3y agoA devil's advocate view is, if someone has no regard for their own wellbeing, why should taxpayers be forced to foot the bill for their care? There are resources for those who want rehab, food, and a safe place to sleep in my city, but if those people want to keep using dangerous drugs, it complicates everything else.
- htss2013 3y ago>Someone has no regard for their own wellbeing, why should taxpayers be forced to foot the bill for their care? Ethically, due to having their minds hijacked by addiction and/or mental illness, it is as if they're reduced to being children again. We don't put children on the street and respect their decisions to ruin their lives, because we understand they don't have the mental capacity to decide such things. Practically, it's probably net cheaper for tax payers to force them to get clean or go to a mental hospital. But you have to account for all externalities and opportunity costs, which no one does.
- Incipient 3y agoUltimately good mental health care is at odds with how your society is set up in the US. You're very much a capitalist/user-pay type approach. Anything that remotely seems to help the common good gets shot down as "socialism". Mental health, and a lot of other societal issues (homelessness etc) all need a socialist/common good type solution. Unfortunately, I just don't see the US being able to get it together, especially combined with the general decline of your country as a whole/on average.
- creata 3y ago> lots of mentally ill people don't get proper treatment, yet are still a huge burden on the health care system. I'm not saying you're right or wrong, but why do you believe that?
- nightfly 3y agoInstead of getting the treatment they need, they end up tying up ER resources? Either because of continual crisis with no proper diagnosis, or just lack of health insurance to find/afford any other options
- mlyle 3y agoER visits are inordinately costly, but are generally the only way for homeless people to receive care (behavioral, chronic health conditions, etc). I'm having difficulty finding the source, but I've read that individual "frequent fliers" have consumed hundreds of thousands of dollars of emergency services without receiving substantive care that would improve their situation.
- ec109685 3y agoWhy is an ER fundamentally so much more expensive than another office visit? Just an anecdote, I don’t see any late night “urgent care” places anymore. If they were sufficiently less expensive than ERs, it seems like insurance companies would incentivize them to have longer hours. Otherwise, after 9pm, you have to go to ER.
- mlyle 3y ago> Why is an ER fundamentally so much more expensive than another office visit? Two main reasons: you need to use personnel, equipment, and rooms that can offer the highest levels of care. And you need to pay for having a facility staffed to handle worst case loading (with triage) 24/7. You also tend to have pretty exhaustive testing on the "emergent" side to make sure everything is immediately OK prior to discharge.
- 3y ago
- bko 3y agoDo you have a source about California mental health spending being cut? Anytime i read a comment about spending being cut or austerity it never materializes when I look it up. I blame the media that reports "cuts in the future anticipated spending growth" as "cuts". So basically someone said spending on X will grow Y percent a year and someone else comes in and changes Y to slightly lower. Sure enough: > The chart below shows that over the last 10 years, state budget expenditures on health have increased nearly 8% per year, while spending on education, transportation, and natural resources has increased at less than half that rate. https://www.chcf.org/blog/californias-unfinished-business-addressing-health-care-costs/ https://www.chcf.org/blog/californias-unfinished-business-ad...
- swivelmaster 3y agoYou’re not going back far enough. https://calmatters.org/justice/2019/03/hard-truths-about-deinstitutionalization-then-and-now/ https://calmatters.org/justice/2019/03/hard-truths-about-dei...
- coryrc 3y agoThere are no dollar amounts in that article.
- swivelmaster 3y agoOh okay so I guess it must not be true then...? https://www.kqed.org/news/11209729/did-the-emptying-of-mental-hospitals-contribute-to-homelessness-here https://www.kqed.org/news/11209729/did-the-emptying-of-menta... "1967 Ronald Reagan is elected governor of California. At this point, the number of patients in state hospitals had fallen to 22,000, and the Reagan administration uses the decline as a reason to make cuts to the Department of Mental Hygiene. They cut 2,600 jobs and 10 percent of the budget despite reports showing that hospitals were already below recommended staffing levels." "1967 Reagan signs the Lanterman-Petris-Short Act and ends the practice of institutionalizing patients against their will, or for indefinite amounts of time. This law is regarded by some as a “patient’s bill of rights”. Sadly, the care outside state hospitals was inadequate. The year after the law goes into effect, a study shows the number of mentally ill people entering San Mateo's criminal justice system doubles." "1973 The number of patients in California State mental hospitals falls to 7,000." So in six years the number of patients in state [mental] hospitals falls from 22,000 to 7,000, and in the FIRST YEAR ALONE after the initial cuts the number of mentally ill patients entering the criminal justice system in just one county doubles. This was on the first page of the google results.
- thwy435384 3y agoThe reason it was likely done away with is because it was abused. There will always be cases like that, most you'll never hear about. The mentally ill are also an easy target for haters with government power.
- rhaway84773 3y agoTo be fair mental illness was far less understood and far more maligned than it is today making the likelihood of mistreatment of the mentally I’ll far more likely.
- fires10 3y agoI whole heartily agree. Even when they are a clear danger to themselves, getting help can be non existent. I tried to save the mother of my children. Went to court numerous times and couldn't even get to a hearing, even when the doctors support it, there are barriers with HIPPA. Individual is now deceased.
- indymike 3y ago> As someone with direct experience with someone that has a mental illness, there needs to be something better than the present system. This is the truth. But the answer is not to go back to the system that the current one replaced (every US state has horror stories, in my state's case it was so bad someone opened a haunted house in the former state mental hospital), which was by all means, a lot worse. Right now the current system is so poorly funded that it has huge quality problems, care is largely inaccessible to people who need it, and workers burnout on high hours/low pay. > I also think it would pay for itself, as lots of mentally ill people don't get proper treatment, yet are still a huge burden on the health care system. Not to mention our social welfare system, judicial system and so on.