10 ms·
> Rather than introduce just the number of particles released by one container, the researchers instead exposed the cells to particle concentrations that infant
by Aurornis 3y ago
> Rather than introduce just the number of particles released by one container, the researchers instead exposed the cells to particle concentrations that infants and toddlers might accumulate over days or from multiple sources.
> After two days, just 23% of kidney cells exposed to the highest concentrations had managed to survive
So they used concentrations that they believe toddlers might accumulate over two days and it killed 3/4 of the kidney cells?
Given that we’re not seeing toddlers around the world have kidney problems after consuming two days worth of micro plastics, let alone multiple years worth, this model doesn’t seem at all representative of real-world outcomes.
Still concerning, but when the results are so far removed from real world observations I don’t know what to make of the whole situation.
- balaji1 3y ago> we’re not seeing toddlers around the world have kidney problems is it possible that then we don't fully understand the resilience of the human body? It is certainly possible, when the article can state that: > the health effects of consuming micro- and nanoplastics remain unclear
- teekert 3y agoWe are seeing a steady increase in childhood cancer [0] and our male population now has half the sperm count the same population had in 70s [1]. [0]: https://www.mja.com.au/journal/2020/212/3/incidence-childhood-cancer-australia-1983-2015-and-projections-2035 https://www.mja.com.au/journal/2020/212/3/incidence-childhoo... [1]: https://backreaction.blogspot.com/2022/11/why-are-male-testosterone-levels-falling.html https://backreaction.blogspot.com/2022/11/why-are-male-testo...
- tremon 3y agoThe OP was walking about kidney damage specifically. Have these cancers and sperm quality issues been linked to kidney function?
- XorNot 3y agoOverweight and obese men are more likely to have lowered sperm counts[1] and obesity has tripled since 1970[2]. [1] https://www.healthymale.org.au/news/obesity-overweight-can-impact-male-fertility https://www.healthymale.org.au/news/obesity-overweight-can-i... [2] https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/obesity-and-overweight https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/obesity-and...
- veave 3y agoSurely it cannot be that hard to control for weight when doing a study on testosterone amounts in the body? i.e. we have half the sperm, but that's overall - do people who have a healthy weight also have half the sperm?
- sfn42 3y agoThese are the problems that arise when everyone and their moms start talking about scientific studies this way. We don't have enough information. We don't know how they collected their data, we don't know how they analyzed it, even if we did most of us don't know enough to judge those methods etc. Most "science" is honestly worthless crap done by some random person mainly because they want a PhD or are trying to pad their publication count. They look for some arbitrary thing to test, half-assedly design a study, collect as little data as they can get away with, do a little p-hacking and such to make sure the results are significant (otherwise the time was wasted) then they publish.
- foobiekr 3y agoHave you considered that you are simply listing two symptoms together instead of identifying cause and effect?
- XorNot 3y agoThe average American consumes 23% more calories per day in 2010 then in 1970[1] and does 100 calories less physical activity per day in their occupation since 1960[2]. [1] https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2016/12/13/whats-on-your-table-how-americas-diet-has-changed-over-the-decades/ https://www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2016/12/13/whats-on-... [2] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3102055/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3102055/
- y7 3y agoThose things could be related to any change in society. There's nothing to suggest it's plastics in particular, right?
- iforgotpassword 3y agoRight, but is your suggestion to say "business as usual" until we have definite irrefutable proof for each and everything? I have no idea how likely or unlikely it is that having plastic in our bodies has any negative impact whatsoever, but that doesn't mean I can't still try to reduce the risk of accumulating more of it in my body. As with most things in life it's a tradeoff, with convenience mostly. I don't have pans with teflon anymore. I avoid plastic bottles for beverages, which means I almost never drink any soda. I got rid of almost all my Tupperware and use paper bags or boxes made of steel when possible. And even though I grew up using the microwave a lot as a teen, I somehow ended up never owning one myself after moving out. Yet for some reason I still managed to survive.
- flangola7 3y agoIf it isn't plastic then what is it? We have been steadily identifying and reducing the number of toxic agents the public is exposed to. Fifty years ago in the 70s the average person would have regular exposure to lead gas, lead paint, tobacco smoke (even if they didn't smoke themselves - indoor smoking was still legal), potent pesticides, and maybe even asbestos. But there were far fewer everyday plastics at the time.
- mrob 3y agoI suspect improvements in communications media. Every day, the average man sees many other men who out-compete him, with no hope of that ever changing. He sees men who are richer, taller, stronger, smarter, etc., in ever increasing realism and "engagement". Beating them is impossible, so the correct strategy in the environment of evolutionary adaptedness would be social submission and hoping they are generous. It seems plausible that there's some biological mechanism that lowers testosterone to aid this process.
- 3y ago
- parentheses 3y agoThe article is only presenting that: 1. nano/microplastics kill kidney cells in a lab environment 2. nano/microplastics come from microwaving containers Regardless of whether you agree with the conclusion _you_ are drawing from reading the article, the article is saying those things. In order to make a real-world-ish experiment, we'd have to start experimenting on children. I feel that while you're expressing outrage at a potentially real thing, you're also being unreasonable in that. Sorry in advance if this comes off as harsh.
- toweriewrwer 3y ago[flagged]
- jahsome 3y agoI have a feeling there is a good number of parents willing to volunteer a child. They start getting mouthy around 3. /s kinda
- earthbee 3y agoI don't think anything Auronis was expressing outrage, nothing they wrote even hints at it to me. They just seem to be expressing a line of reasoning.
- cowl 3y agoIn fact no. The parent comment is right in emphasizing the "exposure to concentrations equivalent to accumulations over several days and sources". So while your point 1. is technically true, it comes with the caveat of heavy concentrations. We know of thousands of "factors" that become dangerous or toxic in big concentrations but are innocuous or even beneficial in small doses. I'm not saying that plastic is either of these but to leave out the dose concentration is clearly misrepresenting from your part. So I don't know if you haven't read the article till the end (because this caveat of the concentration comes later after the sensational part you emphasized) or you are purposely trying to mislead others. The discrepancy of their result ("three-quarters of cultured embryonic kidney cells had died") with reality also clearly points to something very wrong with this study. That high level of cell mortality is not observed anywhere in reality.
- drones 3y agoGenerally speaking I don't take lab results seriously until I see tests in real world environments. Deployment always presents new challenges after development. Not trying to be dismissive, but statements like that reminds me of "Miracle Drug Ivermectin[0]/Industrial Bleach[1] Cures Covid After XX Hours" [0] https://www.monash.edu/discovery-institute/news-and-events/news/2020-articles/Lab-experiments-show-anti-parasitic-drug,-Ivermectin,-eliminates-SARS-CoV-2-in-cells-in-48-hours https://www.monash.edu/discovery-institute/news-and-events/n... [1] https://www.fda.gov/news-events/press-announcements/coronavirus-covid-19-update-fda-warns-seller-marketing-dangerous-chlorine-dioxide-products-claim https://www.fda.gov/news-events/press-announcements/coronavi...
- coldtea 3y ago>Given that we’re not seeing toddlers around the world have kidney problems We're not seeing them having severe kidney problems - easily detectable ones. They could still have damage or accululated crap on their kidneys. In any case, the article doesn't say kids kidneys die in 2 days. It says lab kindey cells die when exposed to such microplastics, and microwave setups produce those microplastics. Meaning: kids are exposed to kindney damaging microplastics through this mechanism. The extend of the damage, as the article also states, remains to be evaluated.
- robertlagrant 3y ago> Meaning: kids are exposed to kidney damaging microplastics through this mechanism This is still the problem, then. The damage is based on the amount. You could demonstrate that kidney cells die when exposed to cyanide, and apple pips have cyanide in them, and you might say "kids are exposed to kidney damaging cyanide through this mechanism. The extent of the damage remains to be seen". If someone challenged that by saying that kids who eat apples aren't all dying of cyanide-induced kidney failure, you could also say we're just not seeing easily detectable ones. But you'd be absorbing (and re-emitting) entirely the wrong impression without the supporting contextual info that genuinely links the two together. We don't create more and more unusual hypotheticals to explain a belief in things or effects that we don't know exist. We demonstrate why we think they should exist and go from there.
- DangerousPie 3y agoI don't have access to the paper, but just reading the abstract it gives these numbers: > Exposure modeling results suggested that the highest estimated daily intake was 20.3 ng/kg·day for infants drinking microwaved water and 22.1 ng/kg·day for toddlers consuming microwaved dairy products from polypropylene containers. > Furthermore, an in vitro study conducted to assess the cell viability showed that the extracted microplastics and nanoplastics released from the plastic container can cause the death of 76.70 and 77.18% of human embryonic kidney cells (HEK293T) at 1000 μg/mL concentration after exposure of 48 and 72 h, respectively. If I'm reading this right, they exposed these HEK293T kidney cells to far higher concentrations (1000 μg is 1000000 ng, and that's per mL) than toddlers would be exposed to from these containers. So the fact that the cells die doesn't really mean much, since exposure to too much of anything will cause cells to die. The real question is whether the exposure you'd receive from occasional microwaving would be enough to ever cause any meaningful health problems. Unfortunately papers like these always like to talk about dramatic metrics like 'billions of nanoplastics' without putting that into any meaningful context.
- WithinReason 3y agoSo it seems that a concentration of microplastics that's 50 million times higher than a toddler would get still leaves 20% of cells alive? To me this implies that normal exposure levels to microplastics are likely completely harmless.
- Dalewyn 3y agoI wouldn't frame it as "harmless", but it is probably accurate to say any harm is insignificant at worst.
- nucleardog 3y agoIf it's a single, acute exposure sure. I'm no doctor or microbiologist or anything, but there definitely seems to be a strong connection between "things that cause cellular damage" and "increased risk of cancer with long term exposure".
- mrob 3y agoIt's bad reporting. The actual numbers from the abstract are "22.1 ng/kg·day" for the worst case ingested dose, and "1000 μg/mL" for the tested toxic concentration. If you assume the solvent is water (solvent isn't specified in the abstract but water is the obvious choice) and convert the units to make it easier to compare, that toxic dose is "1,000,000,000ng/kg". There's no plausible way a toddler is going to accumulate that much within "days".
- Omin 3y ago1,000,000,000ng is 1kg, so that'd would be as much plastic as solvent by mass.
- mda 3y ago1,000,000,000ng = 1g
- gattr 3y ago@Omin, @mda, just a side note: I recommend using the (centuries old, I guess) established typography rule and putting a space between the number and the unit symbol. See [1] for additional info. [1] SI Unit rules and style conventions, https://physics.nist.gov/cuu/Units/checklist.html https://physics.nist.gov/cuu/Units/checklist.html
- baxtr 3y agoIt is specifically: #15 Unit spacing There is a space between the numerical value and unit symbol, even when the value is used in an adjectival sense, except in the case of superscript units for plane angle.
- nprateem 3y agoI never understand this pedantry. The GP is commenting on a forum, not writing a research paper. Who cares how they write, as long as they're understood?
- refurb 3y agothis model doesn’t seem at all representative of real-world outcomes. That made laugh. Like you said, it doesn't pass the sniff test. That should be the first thing any scientist does with their results - Does this match up with what we current know about X? If it doesn't, you need to go back and find out what's wrong with your model.
- rmbyrro 3y agoThe first thing they said is that real world impact to health remains unclear. Then they added the in-vitro test results. One can imagine it's not trivial to run a trial on toddlers to discover how bad nanoplastics are to their kidneys...
- surge 3y agoMy wife pointed out and I feel dumb for not realizing it because I know this myself, you never heat baby food much past 30 seconds, certainly not for 3 minutes at highest setting. Babies generally eat baby food at room temperature to body temperature, and anything outside that is considered extreme to a baby's sensitive nervous system, not to mention you wouldn't want to risk lava spots that might burn their mouths. That adds a rather unrealistic element to the study. It's far more likely to effect people eating microwave dinners, reheating food/meals in plastic containers, and even then those are different tougher plastics, that said it might be reason enough to just invest in glass containers for food storage.
- unsupp0rted 3y agoI wonder how it went when our ancestors heated food for babies to eat on a burning camp fire? Was that a factor in high child mortality?
- doubleg72 3y agoI wonder how our ancestors used a material not even developed yet without getting to to melt on an open fire.
- unsupp0rted 3y agoI mean it's difficult to precisely gauge when cooking food on a camp fire how hot it'll be for a baby to eat. I guess they would do it by finger touch then.
- kube-system 3y agoThe practice of using utensils exclusively and not touching food with hands is a relatively recent thing.
- barbazoo 3y agoI wonder how our ancestors used a material not even developed yet without getting to melt on an open fire they haven't discovered yet.