5 ms·
New laws trying to criminalize filming cops
- Clubber 3y agoFilming police performing their duties is a constitutionally protected activity affirmed by many circuit courts and strongly alluded to by the SCOTUS. >On July 1, an Indiana law went into effect making it a crime to come within 25 feet of an on-duty police officer if ordered to stay back. Legislators in Florida, Louisiana, and New York have produced similar laws. 25 feet isn't very far. In the other states mentioned I believe it's 10 feet, which is reasonable. It's been this way for a long time. Sounds like the articles objective is to peddle anger. >What stops an officer from walking up to someone filming them and then arresting them for being "too close" since they're now <10 feet from officer in question? It's the incident, not the officer. I'm sure one will try, but it the charges would hopefully be dropped. The government machine does protect itself though. >Does the 10 foot rule apply if you are the one being spoken to by the police? E.g. if you are recording a traffic stop. It would not, but one will probably try to say it does. The law is for people who have nothing directly to do with the stop.
- giraffe_lady 3y agoHave the legal position of any other scotus-affirmed rights changed recently that would have people on their toes, do you think, maybe? I've seen first hand police use the justification of stopping filming them to use violence on and arrest people filming them. For however long it takes to get this in front of the supreme court, assuming they choose to hear it, assuming they choose to endorse our rights, it will be used that way. They don't let you out of prison when the law used to justify your arrest is affirmed unconstitutional. It doesn't put your teeth back in your head or undo the TBI you got during the arrest. The article's objective seems to be to prevent the spread of these laws. The spread of these laws is something you should be angry about, and understanding and applying that to the goal is not malicious.
- Clubber 3y ago>Have the legal position of any other scotus-affirmed rights changed recently that would have people on their toes, do you think, maybe? Having read the reasoning of overturning Roe (I assume that's what you are alluding to), no, I'm not concerned. First amendment is on a much stronger legal standing than Roe was based on and has much fewer contradicting laws. >They don't let you out of prison when the law used to justify your arrest is affirmed unconstitutional. Obstructing is usually the charge used. It's not a prison-length offense (> 1 year). But yes, it depends. If your lawyer brought up the constitutionality of the law (as they should have), you can get released, but it does take time unfortunately. >It doesn't put your teeth back in your head or undo the TBI you got during the arrest. It does not. Fortunately here have been more and more police convicted of criminal activity doing things like this, so I'm hopeful for the future. I'd like to also add that the proliferation of camera phones is probably the single most helpful thing it reigning in bad behavior. Police body cams as well. It makes misbehavior much more difficult to cover up and justify. Either way, you're arguing about police brutality, not the fact that journalists need to be 10-25 feet away from an incident to film. I think 10-25 feet is reasonable. I think 10 feet is more reasonable than 25.
- AlexandrB 3y ago> First amendment is on a much stronger legal standing than Roe was based on and has much fewer contradicting laws. I wonder what precedent links filming something to the 1st amendment. If I wanted to undermine the ability to film police, this is where I would look - because recording something, it could be argued, is not an expressive act. Consider states with "2 party consent" laws for recording phone conversations. These have not been ruled unconstitutional even though it's a similar activity to filming the police.
- Clubber 3y ago>If I wanted to undermine the ability to film police, this is where I would look - because recording something, it could be argued, is not an expressive act. I linked this on an earlier reply, but I believe it answers your question. https://canons.sog.unc.edu/2022/11/responding-to-first-amendment-audits-is-filming-protected-by-the-first-amendment/ https://canons.sog.unc.edu/2022/11/responding-to-first-amend... >Consider states with "2 party consent" laws for recording phone conversations. These have not been ruled unconstitutional even though it's a similar activity to filming the police. Police have tried using this as an exception but I believe it was shot down because it's in public. The fact that some of them disliked being filmed so much just bolsters the case that they need to be filed, IMO. >Most of us would be furious about being filmed on the job. We just don’t render deadly force. If you're in public, you're always being filmed. Look up at most light poles, there's cameras everywhere.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoClearly there's some distance where proximity becomes interfering with an arrest. However, I don't see why that should ever change based on if you are holding a camera or not. I wonder what pre-existing law or case law says about police telling people too back away.
- Clubber 3y ago>I don't see why that should ever change based on if you are holding a camera or not. It should not, but I believe that holding a camera is a strong signal that a person is operating as a journalist. It could be argued that a person watching an incident can easily be operating in the same capacity. I was wrong, the SCOTUS hasn't directly addressed filming of police, but that seems like it never got a chance to make it there because it's been affirmed in many circuit courts. They have alluded several times on how they feel about filming government officials (strongly support), but no case has directly made it in regards to explicitly filming police. https://canons.sog.unc.edu/2022/11/responding-to-first-amendment-audits-is-filming-protected-by-the-first-amendment/ https://canons.sog.unc.edu/2022/11/responding-to-first-amend... To date, there is no U.S. Supreme Court case establishing a right to film public officials engaged in carrying out their official duties or a right to film inside of public buildings generally. However, the Supreme Court has recognized a “paramount public interest in a free flow of information to the people concerning public officials.” Moreover, the Supreme Court has acknowledged that “the First Amendment goes beyond protection of the press and self-expression of individuals to prohibit government from limiting the stock of information from which members of the public may draw.” Filming public officials engaged in public duties may fall within this broadly defined “newsgathering” or “information gathering” right that courts have recognized in prior First Amendment cases. >Except, you know, in the Supreme Court. Yes, that is a strange exception.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- s1artibartfast 3y agoWhy does it matter if they are a journalist or not in this context?
- bigbillheck 3y ago> Filming police performing their duties is a constitutionally protected activity affirmed by the SCOTUS For now.
- harimau777 3y agoDoes the 10 foot rule apply if you are the one being spoken to by the police? E.g. if you are recording a traffic stop.
- autoexec 3y agoAccording to the Arizona law even if a police officer is beating you, you'd be committing a crime by recording them so long as the police can claim that you were also "INTERFERING WITH LAWFUL POLICE ACTIONS". As long as they scream "stop resisting" at you, you'll probably be a criminal.
- noptd 3y agoCan you link an instance of this happening or is this entirely speculation on your part?
- autoexec 3y agoThe text of law is pretty short, you can read it yourself https://www.azleg.gov/legtext/55leg/2R/bills/HB2319S.pdf https://www.azleg.gov/legtext/55leg/2R/bills/HB2319S.pdf It was only put in place a year ago, and it was very quickly contested as unconstitutional, which it is, and a judge stopped it from being enforced. The Republican who drafted and sponsored the law has vowed to try again. ”If if the judge says, you know, this is bad because of ‘x’, next year, though, the bill will come in bill minus ‘x’,”
- AlexandrB 3y agoWhat stops an officer from walking up to someone filming them and then arresting them for being "too close" since they're now <10 feet from officer in question?
- calgarymicro 3y ago> New York Really? Who was it introduced by? NY has actually passed a 'right to record' bill that did the exact opposite[0], so I'd be shocked if anything like this had a snowball's chance in hell of passing there. [0]https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/bills/2019/S3253 https://www.nysenate.gov/legislation/bills/2019/S3253
- mitt_romney_12 3y ago>25 feet isn't very far. In the other states mentioned I believe it's 10 feet, which is reasonable The 25 ft buffer means that while people aren't prevented from recording an arrest, they are prevented from making a recording that would actually show anything. Like the article says "They create a visual and auditory buffer likely to produce reasonable doubt in the courtroom. Is the officer’s knee on the suspect’s shoulder, or on his windpipe? Is the suspect fighting, or flailing? From 25 feet, with officers blocking visibility, phone cameras can’t capture crucial details. From 25 feet, they can’t capture choking sounds or someone crying “I can’t breathe.”"
- minitoar 3y agoBut like all laws applying a heuristic to technology it will rapidly become outdated.
- rootusrootus 3y ago> From 25 feet, they can’t capture choking sounds or someone crying “I can’t breathe.”" If you really believe that, I recommend going outside and stepping off 25 feet and then trying some smartphone recordings. 25 feet is actually very close. I wouldn't be surprised if cops find it very uncomfortable to have bystanders that close when any kind of violent encounter is in progress. Most people can run that distance in under 2 seconds.
- mitt_romney_12 3y ago> If you really believe that, I recommend going outside and stepping off 25 feet and then trying some smartphone recordings. I recommend you trying that in a high stress situation involving an number of people in close proximity and lots of environmental noise. And then trying to see how that footage would be interpreted by a hostile lawyer in court > I wouldn't be surprised if cops find it very uncomfortable to have bystanders that close when any kind of violent encounter is in progress These are not violent encounters, the only violence that is going on is from the police. While I do care about the comfort of the police while arresting people, I am more concerned about not being assaulted or killed.
- kerblang 3y ago> Sounds like the articles objective is to peddle anger. Just my opinion, but Slate is heavily left-slanted, moreso than Vox. That's not a crime, of course, but I really don't think this kind of echo-chambering is a good fit for HN, even when recognizing HN is quite off-topic-tolerant. Of course people are gonna do what people do anyhow.
- Clubber 3y ago>I really don't think this kind of echo-chambering is a good fit for HN The nice thing about HN is there is a lot of discussion poking holes in any particular narrative. At least we get to hear and consider both sides of an issue rather than the single side most media portrays. I think that's healthy as long as it remains civil, and it mostly is.
- whoknew1122 3y ago> "Many states have passed hate-speech laws that protect the police from verbal or symbolic abuse, such as stomping on a “Back the Blue” sign while “smirking in an intimidating manner” (the crime for which a woman in Utah was prosecuted)." Wow... this is just... The police have a monopoly on the legalized use of violence. Police carry at minimum one deadly weapon (a handgun), but usually have multiple so-called less-than-lethal weapons such as tasters and batons. And often more lethal weapons such as a shotgun or assault rifle in their car. But they are so fragile that a smirk can intimidate them? I'm not sure how someone wearing body armor and carrying multiple weapons that can incapacitate or kill someone can be intimidated by a smile.
- bamfly 3y ago> I'm not sure how someone wearing body armor and carrying multiple weapons that can incapacitate or kill someone can be intimidated by a smile. They're wannabe military tough-guys with laughably worse training and culture, much of which tells them they should be pee-pants scared all the time (seriously—folks very-successfully sell some wacko training courses to cops; or, just look at the disconnected-from-reality-and-common-sense mythology they've built up, within their ranks, around fentanyl). That's the best-case explanation for that behavior. Sometimes they're literal machismo-fueled gangsters (yes, literally, as in, "involved in organized crime") and will punch down all day long to make sure they're feared. [EDIT] Actually, school districts suffer from some similar problems, as far as being sold all kinds of ineffective and wrong-headed wacko programs and training, and too-frequently ending up corrupt little petty empires (OMG, the amount of money superintendents siphon off to pals...)—I think in both cases we may have opted for a level of devolution that's tipped at least a bit too far toward local autonomy, and could perhaps benefit from something like a professional management/officer corp that gets re-assigned every few years, like officers in the military, to prevent empire-building and make corruption and deviation into wacko-land much less likely. Though, I think that kind of thing's on exactly nobody's radar, so don't expect it to ever happen. [EDIT EDIT] I mean obviously the problem's more severe and grave with cops, it just occurred to me that a lot of the problems in both spheres might be for organizationally-similar reasons.
- 3y ago
- hprotagonist 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glik_v._Cunniffe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glik_v._Cunniffe
- ralusek 3y agoBeing a police officer is a privilege. The population grants you the authority to detain us, accuse us, and even kill us. Few professions should be subject to higher scrutiny.
- screwturner68 3y agoThey hold a public trust like judges (and in theory politicians) and because of this they need to be held to the highest standards and not the lowest standards (which is what we do now). In my opinion a cop breaking the law is much more egregious than a civilian breaking the same law because the cop betrayed the public trust.
- ceejayoz 3y ago> In my opinion a cop breaking the law is much more egregious than a civilian breaking the same law because the cop betrayed the public trust. Yes. It should be an aggravating circumstance in charging/sentencing akin to hate crime enhancements.
- next_xibalba 3y agoI find this type of overly simplistic claim pretty naive and unhelpful. If you knew any police, you would know it sure doesn't look like a privilege. It is often an unpleasant job. Policing is much more dangerous than the average job, often involves dealing with the mentally ill, intoxicated, people in some form of crisis, people who are just antisocial criminal jerks, etc. It is not very well compensated profession. Society cannot function without laws and enforcement of laws. Police deserve the basic respect we accord to teachers, firefighters, and other vital civil servants. If you want to solve a problem, it is first useful to gain an accurate understanding of the current state.
- HDThoreaun 3y agoI don’t see how these statements contradict each other. We can both hold police accountable for their actions and also show them respect. Letting them get away with abusing the population isn’t showing them respect.
- annoyingnoob 3y agoPolice officers are citizens just like everyone else. No one has any expectation of privacy while operating in public. The police are just asking for more people to dislike them. How do you treat everyone like shit, try to take away our rights, and then expect everyone to respect you? Respect is a two-way street.
- mrangle 3y agoEveryone doesn't get treated like shit. Most people respect and want cops. People whining about cops being mean to them, and their general dispositions, tends to think that their police interaction is a super special customer service experience and that the system is faulty when it falls short of their expectations. The reality is that cops deal with the worst of society multiple times per day, even if you don't represent it. The robot doesn't yet exist that can remain psychologically fresh given that. The summary take is to move to a very rural area if you need to feel relatively better respected by cops.
- harimau777 3y agoOf course the majority respect cops. It's generally the minority that they abuse.
- rootusrootus 3y agoAnd very frequently, the cops in question are minorities themselves.
- harimau777 3y agoPersonally, I don't see how that changes things. Even minority cops work in a systemically flawed system.
- toolz 3y agoI'd say most people want cops, because they hate criminals even more, but even in my conservative groups, no one respects someone for being a cop. It's a shitty job that attracts rough characters. I want tons of cops, but I don't want to interact with them ever. They are very often just thugs operating within a structured organization to stop thugs operating with no guiding principals.
- chmod600 3y agoA law about staying back when a police officer asks doesn’t seem like the most terrible rights violation. It’s like virtual yellow police tape. One way to look at this is that it clarifies how far you need to stand back. 25 feet is slightly far, maybe it should be 15 feet instead?
- harimau777 3y agoIt could be pretty easily abused. For example, a situation where there is less than 25 feet (or even 10 feet) of clearance like a sidewalk. During the height of the BLM protests, local police told protesters to get off of the sidewalks and then arrested/assaulted them for being in the street.
- distortionfield 3y agoThis is exactly how laws like this are intended to be used. They’re entirely about protecting status quo police power and control.
- toolz 3y agoI agree it doesn't sound so bad, but from another perspective: why should a cop be given the authority to demand a law abiding citizen move 25ft for any reason? That's just unchecked power waiting to be abused and there's simply no reason cops have given the public to believe they won't abuse power frequently, if given the opportunity.
- kodah 3y ago10-25 feet seems reasonable with 25 being the upper bound of reasonability. The average person can move 9-12ft/s in a single direction; starting speed would be slower so generous is 5-6ft/s. 2 seconds worth of distance sounds reasonable to keep everyone safe. As others have pointed out the issue likely isn't the distance. It's that police can enforce their own measures here without accountability.
- mitt_romney_12 3y agoThe issue is also the distance, because it makes it harder to get accurate footage of what's going on
- costanzaDynasty 3y agoI've always thought hate crime laws are so misguided. It's just another law to use against people you don't like. Piling on charges for no other reason other than making you feel good. Do you like the perp? No: Hate crime Yes: The brain isn't fully formed yet I worked on the low end of a giant corporation and they would always add new rules, seemingly targeting people they we trying to fire. Stupid rules like you can't wear white shoes or you have to shave everyday. Each rule targeting a certain employee they didn't like.
- rootusrootus 3y agoWhat's the difference between first degree murder and second degree murder? Is that any different than a hate crime designation?
- s1artibartfast 3y agoPremeditation and planning is the difference between federal first and second degree murder.
- rootusrootus 3y agoIntent, essentially. This sounds the same as a hate crime designation, which is also a matter of intent.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoHate crimes are actually not really based on intent. They are based on motivation. You commit a crime because of a protected characteristic if you act “wholly or partially” because of that characteristic. This may be demonstrated by showing that you were biased against the victim. Think of it this way: 1) what did you do 2) what were you trying to do 3) why did you want to do that 4) what led you to want that. Bias plays into the last two while intent is more about the second. There are some overlaps, but I would consider what intent to be different. Intent is what outcome you are trying to achieve. Motivation is Why you want to achieve that outcome.
- trinsic2 3y agoTo get back on topic, I can see both sides of the spectrum on this. On the one hand, they will be dirty cops that use this to their advantage, but on the other hand, I see the possible scenarios of people getting too close and interfering with that particular job, maybe I'm not seeing this for what it is but I don't think it's a bad thing for having to be some distance away from a police situation. Being too close you run the risk of other people getting harmed and I feel like this article is a little bit biased.
- thefurdrake 3y ago25' is too far. It's far enough that phone cameras may miss finer details of an altercation, which is the intent. 10' would be more reasonable. You should really be considering what "being close to police officers means you risk getting harmed" being statistically-common enough that you bring it up actually says about what's going on.
- euniceee3 3y ago25' is fine if ALL officers involved have body cameras. Getting that footage should be as simple FOIL request. There needs to be a streamlined process for citizens to obtain footage as easy as it is to browse on Nextdoor. The problem is when you have a police line established that is 25' from the action and then have to move back another 25'.
- iudqnolq 3y agoI thought this until I tried to actually watch and understand body cam footage. it's quite a lot harder to parse and misses quite a bit that cell phone cameras capture. there's also an interesting argument that by always showing the officers' perspective it will make people more likely to empathize with them. I'm not sure exactly why bodycam footage is so much worse. I think part of it might have to do with the odd height it's placed at.
- sidewndr46 3y ago
- cratermoon 3y agoMaybe time to revive this site https://pinacnews.com/ https://pinacnews.com/
- moretrashplz 3y ago[flagged]
- moretrashplz 3y ago[flagged]
- RickJWagner 3y agoFilming of cops should be legal, from a safe distance. But-- the entirety of the filming should be public property. Failure to turn over the entire video should carry criminal penalties.