7 ms·
Tesla directors agree to return $735M following claims they were overpaid
- hiddencost 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Fezzik 3y agoIt’s noted a few sentences in that there is a separate lawsuit regarding the $56B…
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jonas21 3y agoMusk's pay package was tied to TSLA stock hitting certain price targets -- if it failed to do so, he wouldn't be paid at all. Here's what the NY Times wrote back in 2018 [1]: > Tesla is worth only about $59 billion today. If Mr. Musk were somehow to increase the value of Tesla to $650 billion — a figure many experts would contend is laughably impossible and would make Tesla one of the five largest companies in the United States, based on current valuations — his stock award could be worth as much as $55 billion. Well, he managed to do the "laughably impossible" -- Tesla is worth over $900 billion today. Shareholders should be thrilled. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/23/business/dealbook/tesla-elon-musk-pay.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/01/23/business/dealbook/tesla-e...
- asdfgiasnio 3y ago[flagged]
- slashdev 3y agoWhat’s the crime? This is a really low brow drive by comment from an anonymous user.
- panick21_ 3y agoIt was based on stock value, deliveries AND profit. So it was like can you make it into a large company by valuation that is profitable?
- ajaimk 3y agoThese are 2 different lawsuits.
- vanjajaja1 3y ago> It was brought by shareholder Richard Tornette, who claimed that "the largest compensation grant in human history" was given to Musk, even though he didn't focus entirely on Tesla Not understanding how this something related to law? Either he was given the grant legally, or he wasn't. What does it matter how it compares to other people or what percentage of his focus was on Tesla?
- wyre 3y agoIt’s related to law because shareholders are sueing Musk and it’s up to the courts to decide if it was granted legally or not.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- respondo2134 3y agothe question is not if the grant was legal, but if the board issuing options to themselves in this quantity is in the fiducary interest of the shareholders.
- dghlsakjg 3y agoThe board of directors has a legal responsibility to govern in the interest of the shareholders. The argument is that the board giving $750mm of shareholder money to themselves is not in the interest of the shareholders for somewhat obvious reasons.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoBut didn't they agree to do it if Tesla's stock got to some amount? Shouldn't they have written a limit in if they didn't want to exceed a certain amount of compensation?
- dghlsakjg 3y agoNo. That's Musk's personal pay package as CEO. This was just stock options that the board gave themselves for their services
- moralestapia 3y ago>The $735 million settlement will be paid back to Tesla in what's called a "derivative lawsuit" — the largest ever awarded by Delaware's Court of Chancerty, according to Reuters. Musk is really making a good impression there, lol.
- agentgumshoe 3y agoWell I suppose he can pay out the arbitration a bit easier now...
- freeone3000 3y agoAs an investor, I am happy about this outcome. It’s more money in the company and less money for its employees — always a good thing.
- tibbydudeza 3y agoLove that name - Court of Chancerty - second time they did this - did they not enforce the Twitter buy offer against Elon ???.
- peterfirefly 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Court_of_Chancery https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Court_of_Chancery Derived from the word Chancellor.
- moralestapia 3y ago>did they not enforce the Twitter buy offer against Elon They did, I wouldn't be surprised if it was the same judge, lol. The lesson here is that DE's Court of Chancery doesn't fool around.
- taeric 3y agoSeems at least in spirit related to https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ko8C3surjhM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ko8C3surjhM. Also note for those skimming this is the board of directors. Not "directors" in the company. If that makes any sense.
- CSMastermind 3y ago> Also note for those skimming this is the board of directors. Not "directors" in the company. If that makes any sense. Board of directors not people in middle management at the company with the title of director.
- jmccaf 3y agoYes, 'director' is job title in engineering management. Generally Ranks above 'manager' and below vice-president
- respondo2134 3y ago"Director", the job title is used in EM, but there are directors in all areas of the company. It's the position between Senior Manager and a VP role
- kaeresten_dit 3y agoWhat I don't understand is what the wahalla is really about, seems to be one of two: :the board granted themselves an unusually high amount of stock when it was granted :the company did performed too well in the interim bringing the value of their comp too high seems odd to me as options are granted to 'upper management' as a performance incentive, so the lawsuit brought forth seems to base level br about the company doing too well , that is to say if it is not about the first reason all along
- woobar 3y agoTechnically the board is not the management. They have a very indirect effect on stock performance. More importantly, TSLA remained flat (moving around $17) between 2017 and 2020 when this huge payouts were granted: The Defendants saved their most audacious behavior for 2018. That year, excepting two directors who joined the Board in December 2018, the nonemployee directors received compensation worth an average grant date value of $8,706,126. Average board member comp is in $100K range. [1] https://cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/tesla-detroit-shareholder-complaint.pdf https://cdn.arstechnica.net/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/tesla...
- rgbrenner 3y agoFor comparison, bob igor gets paid 125k in cash and 250k in equity to serve on apples board. Or Joseph Jimenez, the former ceo of Novartis, gets paid 300k to serve on GMs board. It’s unusual for board members to get paid over 1m. The average is less than 100k.
- kneel 3y agoSeems silly, if their equity goes up in value should they have to return everything over 1m? It's not their fault that people bought the stock and made them rich.
- pjanoman 3y agoThey're returning the equivalent of 3 million stock options. They gave themselves 11 million stock options between 2017-2020, which means they're still getting around $2 billion for being on the board. They're not returning everything over $1 million at all. https://www.reuters.com/legal/tesla-directors-settle-lawsuit-over-compensation-735-mln-2023-07-17/ https://www.reuters.com/legal/tesla-directors-settle-lawsuit... Do you have an opinion on whether the work they've done is worth $2 billion?
- kneel 3y ago>Do you have an opinion on whether the work they've done is worth $2 billion? Their market cap went up by 1 trillion. Again, they were just compensated in equity. It's easy to look back and criticize them as overcompensated but at the time they were just receiving equity worth a fraction of what it is today.
- woobar 3y agoAt the time they were getting close to 10-20x more than an typical board member of an S&P 500 company. The lawsuit was brought up before the stock took off.
- 3y ago
- michaelteter 3y ago"Tesla argued that stock options were used to ensure Director's incentives were aligned with investor goals." I would think board members' actions should be aligned with investor goals as a requirement of holding the board positions. Outsized compensation shouldn't be necessary to make someone do their job reasonably well.
- beebmam 3y agoOutsized compensation is to acquire and retain talent, not to ensure jobs are done well.
- triceratops 3y agoAs large shareholders they 1. Have an incentive to see their company be managed well and 2. Are probably passionate about the company, its industry, and its mission Isn't that sufficient motivation and incentive for retaining talent on the board?
- lo_zamoyski 3y agoI really did wish we'd stop using the word "passionate". The passions are a matter of affect and therefore variable and changing. No mature, responsible adult grounds his life or his actions in his passions. You don't run a multibillion dollar company on passion. This is exactly the opposite of what you should be doing. Follow your reason, not your passions. The worst thing a person can do is to be led by his passions, to have them direct his life. It is better to say "dedicated to the company and its mission". Dedication is a matter of reasoned decision and consistent activity for the good of something. How you feel is irrelevant. If you wake up cranky one day, you still go do what you need to do. You don't wait until you "feel" like it.
- triceratops 3y agoOk pretend I used the word "dedicated". Does it make what I said less valid?
- firebirdn99 3y agoHow is Tesla stock worth nearly $1B back again, after dropping under 300B recently? The market is bonkers. And any sense of how valuations work are just made up at this point.
- LanceJones 3y agoThe market is reality. Everything else is just opinion.
- Zambyte 3y agoThe market is a reflection of opinion. Everything else is what you are told is someones opinion.
- rapsey 3y agoStock price is a function of investor optimism. Tesla is crushing it and there is nothing stopping them from growing. Thus the stock price is high.
- lawn 3y agoRampant speculation. Bitcoin is doing really well too.
- 3y ago
- Jamesbeyond 3y ago[dead]
- londons_explore 3y agoIf the board misbehaves and awards itself an unfairly large pay packet, then the shareholders can react by firing the board via a shareholder vote. Why didn't that happen here? I don't really see what role a court has in deciding if the board is 'fair' in its pay decisions, as long as all legal processes were followed and the board didn't do anything in secret.
- alex_young 3y agoMaybe because the shares are controlled by the majority shareholder and the other shareholders want some protection against that shareholder? This is why we have an SEC.
- londons_explore 3y agoThe majority shareholder has a larger chunk of the shares than he has control of the board. A big board pay packet he has every reason to reject if it was unreasonable.
- TheCoelacanth 3y agoNot if he's colluding with the board to get a gigantic pay package for himself (a separate lawsuit is fighting his $56 billion pay package, calling it "the largest compensation grant in human history").
- nubinetwork 3y ago[flagged]