7 ms·
The World Bakes Under Extreme Heat
- mikestew 3y agohttps://archive.ph/LZrOx https://archive.ph/LZrOx
- veave 3y agorevs up engine while keeping clutch down
- thehappypm 3y agoOne thing this latest heat wave is worrying me about is that climate disasters seem like they will happen no matter what happens with CO2. Like, the hottest temperatures from Death Valley are from a century ago. Tornadoes, droughts, heat waves, monsoons, floods, hurricanes -- not to mention earthquakes and volcanic eruptions -- will all continue even if CO2 goes back to pre industrial levels. Then what?
- nvm0n1 3y ago[flagged]
- Thoeu388 3y ago[flagged]
- joenathanone 3y agoCO2 isn't the only thing that can and does contribute to climate, just one of the possible gasses that can, and currently is contributing.
- thehappypm 3y agoSure. But, if the point of de-carbonizing is to stop extreme weather altogether, we're not going to achieve that, ever.
- joenathanone 3y agoNot stop in this instance but rather not contribute to.
- sethrin 3y agoIt's also not going to stop meteor strikes, but fortunately no one has ever suggested that was the purpose of decarbonization.
- thehappypm 3y agoI mean, if stopping extreme weather isn’t the point of decarbonization, what is the point?
- sethrin 3y agoReducing it, ideally to pre-industrial norms. Stopping extreme weather is obviously impossible, and so obviously so that it's bizarre you're even trying to prop it up as a strawman.
- api_or_ipa 3y agoThe specific hottest temperature reading from Death Valley in 1913 is far from certain. The reality is we aren't sure how accurate that reading really was (turns out, measuring accurately temperature is harder than one might think). We're a lot more certain about recent temperature readings and aside from Death Valley there are far more records broken nowadays than in the past. For example just 2 years ago, Canada's hottest temperature reading was (121.3f) in Lytton BC. Before that, the record was set thousands of miles away. Lytton usually gets hot in the summer, but never that hot.
- thehappypm 3y agoInterestingly, the list of weather records data shows that the extreme highs are really scattered throughout the last century. It seems probable, though, that these will all fall in the next couple decades. Africa: 1931 Antarctica: 1982 Asia: Tie, 2023 and 2017 Europe: 2021 North America: 1913 Oceania (incl. Australia): Tie, 1960 and 2022 Oceania (excl. Australia): 1973 South America: 1905 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_weather_records https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_weather_records
- ramesh31 3y agoI'm just gonna start investing in water stocks at this point.
- thehappypm 3y agoI doubt it. They still are plagued by horrible winter conditions. Chicago gets below 0F every year, Buffalo gets bombed with snow.
- swamp40 3y ago> The winters get shorter every year. Chicago was 6 months of winter this last year. Hate to see how it used to be.
- dvh 3y agoWait till your great lakes turn into toxic green sludge
- organsnyder 3y agoBeen there, done that.
- candiddevmike 3y agoOn the one hand, it's nice and quiet here without all the west coast folks, on the other, maybe more liberal folks moving to Wisconsin would turn it blue again.
- germinalphrase 3y agoWisconsin is already blue. Redistricting was removed from a panel of (nominally) nonpartisan former judges and given to the legislature. The subsequent maps drawn by the legislature were the most effectively gerrymandered maps in the country (at the time) and set a strategic precedent for partisan gerrymandering across the country. Edit: for context, this redistricting happened in 2011 Edit 2: I will happily walk back my first sentence to “purple”; however, the impact of partisan redistricting has been made repeatedly clear as Republicans in the state legislature significantly over perform in capturing seats vs statewide voter count. I will also add that I believe the problem here is partisan gerrymandering, not specifically that Republicans over-perform. Partisan gerrymandering is explicitly anti-democratic whether it is taking place in Wisconsin or New York.
- octokatt 3y agoThe Wall Street Journal is reporting climate change now. The debate is over. Can anyone tell me why debate at any level is still happening, and why drastic measures are not being taken? I get this is a relatively slow-moving problem, unlike war or abrupt famine, but crivens.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoAlmost nobody debates that human accelerated climate change is real, the debate is mostly around what to do about it. Plan of action and implementation details.
- test098 3y agoyou can see examples of climate denial right here on HN. here's some from the past month (https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=pastMonth&page=0&prefix=true&query=climate&sort=byPopularity&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=pastMonth&page=0&prefix=tr...): "Climate change is overhyped in my view" "While local climate change is always with us, the reality of global change is lacking, and the projections have been pushed out year for year over the last forty years now." "Does it really seem reasonable that our little human technology, an infinitesimal fraction of the energy at work in the Solar System is making a huge difference?" "I immediately know the article is trash the moment they start blaming global warming for how hot or cold it is today rather than broader weather patterns. The upper and lower bounds for temperature at a given time of year are far more dependent on geography. It's trivially easy to see that all this "record breaking" is just recency bias, not global warming." "Climate has been changing since earth got a climate." "I think it's unwise to constantly associate normal temperature fluctuations with any threat to civilization"
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- postalrat 3y agoBecause there isn't a single debate settled by your comment.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 3y agoThe way to deal with this both short term and long term is plentiful, zero carbon energy like solar, wind, nuclear. Even without global warming, earth always had times and places which have been very inhospitable to humanity. Energy helps make earth habitable. Starting with fire, and continuing on with air conditioning, energy makes the world habitable for humanity.
- IntrepidWorm 3y agoIt is much more effective to do more with less. There will always be a need for air conditioning in some cases, but having 10 million single window units blasting walls of heat into a crowded city very quickly becomes an arms race where nobody wins (except perhaps the AC manufacturers). Finding efficient ways to use our energy matters just as much as finding efficient ways to produce our energy. Keep in mind as well that many of the current methods of manufacturing green technologies only end up exporting their carbon to the global south.
- AbrahamParangi 3y agoThe bitter lesson is that, actually, quantity usually beats efficiency. Increasing efficiency has a brutal difficulty that is constrained by thermodynamics whereas the universe is almost limitlessly full of energy, space, and mass.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3y agoI spent a few days recently in Vermont where it was hot but the wind was able to blow straight through the cabin and no A/C was necessary. No matter how many window fans I use in my apartment it doesn't come close. Buildings are not designed to do this, they're designed to pack humans together. I'd say that we need more efficient buildings but then we would also need to tear down what we have. That's more carbon!
- nerdponx 3y agoPart of the concern with climate change is that you could start seeing literally uninhabitable hot temperatures in more and more parts of the world, which passive cooling are unable to save you from. You can get pretty far with warm gloves and weak fire in Vermont winter, but if the summer heat conditions are right, you just die no matter how tough you are and no matter how much air flow you have. That's not exactly a problem in Vermont yet, but people already die of heat stroke in the summer in the Northeast, and that's going to get worse as the climate gets warmer, with the disparity of course being along socioeconomic lines.
- CrzyLngPwd 3y agoToo late to change now.
- mkoubaa 3y agoPSA: try to enjoy it. It's likely the coolest summer of the rest of your life
- stolenmerch 3y agoClimate change means the earth is heating up in the aggregate, not that it's a constant, linear increase everywhere. I live in the midwest US, which is normally baking in mid-July. They cancelled swimming for my child today because it was too cold. However, we'll also see an abnormal scorching heat soon enough - not to mention more examples of extreme weather events over the years.
- mkoubaa 3y agoTechnically I agree but I think my point still roughly stands
- karol 3y agoYeah, for sure.
- AbrahamParangi 3y agoI would like to register a contrary prediction: I think things will be basically okay even under fairly extreme climate change. I understand that many people may disagree with this prediction and some of those people will disagree with even communicating this prediction, as they will see it as boosterism for our decadent industrial society. However, I think if we are interested in what is true, we need to allow ourselves to conceive of such things as human civilization continuing on without much fuss.
- nerdponx 3y agoThis is a bit like driving drunk and believing that things will be OK because until now the road has been mostly clear and you've only swerved a couple of times. It's totally possible that things will turn out not so bad, you'll get home without hurting yourself or anybody else, and you'll sleep it off. Or you will murder somebody in cold blood with your car. Worth the risk?
- wredue 3y agoAs far as well can tell, all of the previous mass extinctions were due primarily to climate change. Your prediction has no evidence behind it. On the contrary, the evidence suggests that we are currently at the beginning of a mass extinction event. It’s not that there will be a mass extinction if we don’t stop. It’s already started my dude.
- AbrahamParangi 3y agoYou could just as easily argue that "things will be more or less fine" is highly evidence based (things have been fine in the past) and in contrast millenarianism has an awfully bad evidentiary track record. A mass extinction event is underway, but it's not just starting. We are not at the beginning. There is this idea that the premodern world was "basically natural", but the reality is that 70% of animals larger than 45kg that were present in North America when humans arrived are already extinct. There is no Eden to go back to or preserve. The world hasn't been in equilibrium since hominid intelligence started taking off and our only constant is change.
- 3y ago
- throwaway33608 3y agoI actually decided to quit my entire dev career some months ago and move to the country side as I didn't see a point in the grind anymore given the situation with the world. (I know this might seem extreme - I was ripe for a downshift anyways, and am financially stable.) So now I'm literally just watching the world burn and trying to figure out long term plans. The more you look at what's going on in planet Earth, the more absurd it seems. I'd be interested to hear how other HNers plan for the future.
- asoneth 3y agoSeveral years ago we left NYC for a small old New England town not far from where I grew up. Our neighbors have victory gardens, chickens, goats, bees, and/or fruit trees. We insulated our home, got solar panels, started a garden and a cellar, and built up a backlog of firewood. We eat more fresh local food and spend more time working outside, building relationships with neighbors, and working on community projects. I still pay attention to global events, vote, minimize my "carbon footprint", march, and all the stuff that feels morally necessary. But when that's all I was doing I felt pessimistic because I felt like none that actually made a dent in the world's problems. Since then I've found it more useful to focus attention on local problems. For example, hosting refugees, helping at the food bank, teaching repair or technology classes, supporting locally-owned farms and businesses, motivating friends and neighbors to get around town by foot or bike, advocating for low-income housing in your neighborhood, that sort of thing. Climate change will not end civilization. But it'll cause a lot of misery. So if you're already fulfilling whatever moral obligation you feel you need to do at the global level then maybe consider finding a resilient community, putting down roots, and figuring out what you can do to help your neighbors.
- throwaway33608 3y agoThank you, that is inspirational.
- taylodl 3y agoIf you don't mind my asking, what community is this? I'd like to use it to find similar communities closer to my family.