4 ms·
This series of blog posts have had some really great insights. However, they’ve also left me feeling uneasy for reasons I couldn’t really put my finger on. It
by Aurornis 3y ago
This series of blog posts have had some really great insights. However, they’ve also left me feeling uneasy for reasons I couldn’t really put my finger on.
It finally clicked when I read the section justifying the company's low compensation:
> Industry data shows that Honeycomb is about average in this as a series D startup, not an outlier. I have friends who are line managers at larger companies who take home more than I do in my current role. To be clear, I’m not complaining — I am paid well for what I do, and I’m always, always grateful to be extremely well compensated relative to most American workers, who are well paid relative to the world median
It’s great that the author is satisfied with their own compensation. What bothers me is the contrast between their company’s “about average” compensation and these blog posts espousing excellence at every level the company, mentioning “inhumane” schedules in the past to deliver SOC2 and HIPAA compliance, talk of using off time to do continued industry learning, and the insinuation that the insinuation that the author and their boss are established industry thought leaders.
All of this talk of excellence and high performance at every level with one big exception: Compensation. Reading the section about how they have data showing their compensation is “about average” gave me flashbacks to early in my career when I was underpaid (relative to doing similar work at other companies) and yet charismatic company leaders insisted our compensation was in line with industry averages according to some data they found somewhere. It took me a while to realize the 50th percentile compensation should go along with 50th percentile expectations and 50th percentile performance. The companies who expect 95th percentile performance but give “about average” compensation and use charismatic leaders to convince everyone that it’s okay are, in my experience, not a good deal for the employee.
- hayd 3y agoThey should definitely renegotiate ("complain") if they're not being paid a fair market rate... Comparing "relative to the world median" is just absurd, the comparison can only be to others in similar roles/locations. Is she $200k, $400k, or more? Potentially line managers in big companies could be earning more than any of those numbers.
- Aurornis 3y agoI was thinking more about all of the employees at the company who aren’t VP level and are paid significantly less than this. When a company espouses “about average” compensation as one of their core principles while simultaneously espousing excellence in everything else, there’s a mismatch.
- lizthegrey 3y agoWe're paid decent enough for SF bay startup salaries. Worldwide, regardless of where we live/work. This works out quite advantageously for having a distributed workforce, and means many folks earn very top of market for where they happen to live (if there is even a tech market where they live!) Also, salary bands are transparent both to employees and applicants.
- elliot_ta 3y ago[dead]
- nickstinemates 3y agoWhat is left unsaid: working at a startup at an executive level typically involves whole percentages of equity in the company. If honeycomb continues to succeed and there's some sort of exit or liquidation (which can happen in series D, E rounds for select individuals like executives) then I am sure the total comp is not "about average" but instead much greater than average.
- Aurornis 3y agoExit liquidity for executives is great for those executives, but it doesn’t help the rest of the employees. If leaders are writing blog posts about how everyone needs to accept “average” compensation while cashing out high equity grants for themselves, that actually makes it worse.
- dalyons 3y agoYeah for executive positions like VP the vast majority of the comp is in stock. At a bigco that will be liquid, at a startup it won’t, hence the difference in “market rate”. But the startup equity is theoretically worth much more, it’s a huge risk but you have to on some level believe the valuation, or you wouldn’t take the job.
- dilyevsky 3y agoMost of those D stage startups are now firmly underwater on their options issues in last couple years. Since this person was employee #12 it’s probably not as bad but still nowhere near what one could be making as sr manager at faang (which is what these startup vps are roughly equivalent to in scope and hence pay)
- Aurornis 3y ago> At a bigco that will be liquid, at a startup it won’t, hence the difference in “market rate”. Keep in mind that the compensation was described as "about average" relative to other series D startups. They readily admitted that it was significantly lower than big companies.
- qqtt 3y ago
- dclowd9901 3y agoMight explain previous allusions to not being able to find a good external VP to fit the role.
- kylequest 3y agoYou are oversimplifying it picking comp as a single/only dimension. There's so much more to being in a startup. That's ok. For some people maximizing current comp is the most important thing. Others have a more long term game where working at a startup with lower comp opens up new opportunities later on (even if the startup equity doesn't work out). For other people it's about feeling alive... What's the point of higher comp at a big company if you hate your life (or, in a less extreme case, where you just don't feel fulfilled or satisfied)...
- jstummbillig 3y agoI don't see a conflict. Obviously, the blog post in question is a biased opinion piece. The author is working there. The company allowed the publication. Take it with a grain of salt, will you. But what you wrote seems like a very intricate way of saying "In the end, no matter how much I want other things in my job, I personally am not cool with giving up on the money". There are people who are willing to work different jobs or for different companies – let's say the Wikimedia foundation – and be okay with the pay not being as high as it could be at Google, doing similar work, because they derive something from it that's not measured in money. And that's also important because most companies will simply never be able to generate Google money and still need excellent people to work on good and valuable projects. Figure out what you value. If, in the end, it's mostly the money and you don't see any value in what the company offers you outside of that, just be honest about it and take the money.
- tjpnz 3y agoThat uneasy feeling is consistent with many of the recent Glassdoor reviews. Sounds like a miserable place to work.