7 ms·
Why was the F-117 retired so quickly?
- ggm 3y agoAnother question might be why no other nation was allowed to acquire them. Lots of advanced fighters get exported. Advanced guided missile radar evading aircraft less so. The comment about having to use low level attack craft to destroy specific radar types so the f117 can evade the other types is telling: "invisible to radar" was a bit hype-y
- LorenPechtel 3y agoIt was effectively invisible to the radars that existed when it was made. High frequency radars are more accurate than low frequency, nobody used low frequency at the time. They're also smaller, I don't think you could use a low frequency radar with a missile's seeker. Low frequency is good enough to throw up flak, though--and that's how the one that was lost got hit. It was also vulnerable to bistatic radar--but I don't believe a bistatic radar could even have been built back then. It was basically a one-trick wonder that got counterdesigned.
- laverya 3y ago> nobody used low frequency at the time I don't think this is true. Low frequency was and continues to be the best option for early warning and over-the-horizon use cases. > good enough to throw up flak, though - and that's how the one that was lost got hit It was hit with a 1960s era SAM after running the same route again and again. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1999_F-117A_shootdown https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1999_F-117A_shootdown
- ahazred8ta 3y agoIt's hard to absorb the long-wavelength radar used by large, stationary units, but they can be taken out with cruise missiles early in the conflict. Stealth works very well against short-wavelength radar used by hard to target SAM missile launchers that are still around after the big radars are dead. So they don't really mind as much that they can be seen by the type of radar that doesn't shoot at them.
- tonyarkles 3y ago> Another question might be why no other nation was allowed to acquire them. Lots of advanced fighters get exported. My understanding of this is that there's a threshold of "really good but not too good" that is a bit arbitrary. The F-117 and the follow-on F-22 Raptor both crossed over the line into "way too good" territory and couldn't be exported. While it's pretty cool having aircraft that are so advanced that no other country on earth can own them but your own, the net result ends up being... you don't have anyone to share the NRE costs with, which drives the unit cost and spare parts costs up like crazy.
- icegreentea2 3y agoThere are basically 3 different eras of the F-117. First, during the Cold War... the F-117 was one of America's silver bullets. Don't wanna risk anything getting leaked out. In the 90s to early 2000's... who on earth would buy an F-117? Especially amongst nations friendly to the USA. With the exception of maybe Israel, no US aligned nation had a reason to have a low observable strike aircraft. In the twilight of its career - well the JSF/F-35 existed. Why buy the old, single purpose, first generation stealth aircraft when F-35s should be just around the corner...
- mshockwave 3y agoHighly recommend reading "Skunk Works: A Personal Memoir of My Years at Lockheed", written by the father of F117, Ben Rich. It detailed the history of creating NightHawk as well as other famous aircrafts like U-2 and BlackBird(A-12 / SR-71). Too bad the book couldn't cover F-22 Raptor as it hasn't been declassified at the time of writing (1996)
- dekhn 3y agoTo me, the real recognition of their proficiency was learning that SR-71s leak fuel like crazy when they are on the ground... because their body expands from heat during flight. At first I thought that was incredibly wasteful, then I realized it was actually brilliant, given the circumstances in which the plane was used.
- bostonsre 3y agoYea, that and the external engine used to start the engines were pretty great ideas to simplify the project and still meet their requirements.
- bombcar 3y agoIf it’s crazy and it works, it’s not crazy.
- adolph 3y agoEach of the two Buick V-8s had eight straight exhaust pipes that exited out of the bottom of the AG330. Each engine had a Hydromatic transmission with electric shift, and the two transmissions were coupled together by a 12 inch wide, toothed Gilmer belt. The pilot told the Crew Chief via intercom "Engage Buicks". The Buick operator pressed "Jet Start", and movement of the Buick throttle (one throttle lever controls both engines) downward engaged the transmissions. . . . The pilot would watch his onboard gauges to confirm minimum oil pressure, fuel pressure, and rising RPM, and then set the jet throttle to idle. At that point 30cc of TEB was injected into the burner cans, a characteristic green flame was emitted, the J58 lit off, accelerated and started to run on its own. The accelerating jet started to unload the Buicks, and when 3,200 rpm was reached, the pilot called "Buicks out", the Crew Chief signaled "cut", the Buick operator hit "Cart Shutdown", the probe fell free passively, and the cart throttle automatically returned to idle. https://www.thesr71blackbird.com/Aircraft/Engines/starting-the-sr-71-blackbirds-j58-engines-ag330-start-cart https://www.thesr71blackbird.com/Aircraft/Engines/starting-t...
- dcposch 3y agoOne simple reason - separate from the less fun possibilities involving defense procurement politics - is that the F117 was a transition technology. It proved that super low radar signatures were possible. The design used those big low poly triangles not because it’s optimal (aerodynamically, very much not!) but because of the limits of computer simulation at the time. There’s a whole fascinating story about how the theory behind low observable was developed by a Soviet scientist, published, ignored there, then implemented here. But computer technology quickly advanced to where low-poly aircraft made airworthy by brute force were no longer necessary. See the B2 Spirit, also a very special simulation derived shape but streamlined.
- teruakohatu 3y agoI had never considered that the Northrop YB-49 [1] might have ultimately worked if computer simulation had been available at the time. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northrop_YB-49 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northrop_YB-49
- amethyst 3y agoAnother key requirement would have been computer-aided flight control systems. The only reason the B-2 can remain stable during maneuvers is thanks to its fly-by-wire system that translates the pilot's directions into control surface adjustments that achieve the desired results, and continually adjust those controls faster than the human pilot can react.
- blamazon 3y agoThe curious may find this wikipedia article a good jumping point down this rabbit hole: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relaxed_stability https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Relaxed_stability
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mc32 3y agoMy favorite is the Grumman X-29: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grumman_X-29 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grumman_X-29 (It worked and they built two, I think) but ultimately a dead-end.
- qbasic_forever 3y agoIt's funny to go back to early 90s conspiracy/UFO culture and its talk of seeing "black triangles" flying around area 51 or other secret military sites. Turns out it was just people seeing testing of the F117 or B2 and not alien technology.
- jprd 3y agoI dunno, most of the Black Triangle sightings were in the US Northeast, were MUCH larger and super slow. This is my anecdotal memory from Art Bell, local news and the such.
- Sai_ 3y agoI saw one in the Pittsburgh area ca 2014-15. Slow, quiet, but too big to be a glider or Hindenburg style gas balloon. It was freaky.
- NikkiA 3y agoNot really, the F117 became public knowledge during desert storm in '91. Most of what the public calls triangle UFOs is air-air-refueling practice
- jillesvangurp 3y agoExactly, the shock and awe strategy used during the first gulf war involved a lot of video footage of high precision weaponry being used to hit all sorts of targets and long briefings by generals talking about how awesome they were. The F117 deployment to Iraq was big news and widely reported and the US Airforce basically couldn't shut up talking about just how awesome these things were.
- metaphor 3y ago> The F117 deployment to Iraq was big news and widely reported and the US Airforce basically couldn't shut up talking about just how awesome these things were. Desert Storm, sure. 12 years later for Iraqi Freedom? Nope. We were in the sandbox low key to kickstart Saddam's farewell/get-rekt party and back at Holloman much quicker than most other air expeditionary squadrons.
- jbuzbee 3y agoIf you search on youtube, you can see that some F-117s are still flying. For example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9UUOJBBNfZY&ab_channel=YoutubeNews https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9UUOJBBNfZY&ab_channel=Youtu...
- icegreentea2 3y agoYes. It currently looks like USAF is using F-117s in testing/training roles. Some warzone articles: https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/f-117-nighthawks-caught-roaring-through-a-canyon-in-awesome-images https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/f-117-nighthawks-caugh... https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/retired-f-117-nighthawks-may-fly-for-another-decade https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/retired-f-117-nighthaw...
- coffee-- 3y ago"This airplane was a secret project of the U.S. Army" it says. Really.
- tylerflick 3y agoI chuckled when I read that part.
- projektfu 3y agoSo secret, they convinced the air force to believe it was their project.
- Meph504 3y agoI mean, in the grand scheme of things, the air force was born from the army air corp. So abstracted enough I guess there is some truth to that.
- jjkeddo199 3y agoUSA should send some mothballed F117 to Ukraine after their pilots get experience with F16, it costs us nothing and would help them where they are struggling the most (missing airpower).
- WaxProlix 3y agoTrue, we should arm them with nukes too, they're missing that capability as well.
- peepeepoopoo17 3y agoYou forgot the carrier battle group.
- qbasic_forever 3y agoI don't think _anything_ about flying the F117 would transfer over from the F16 other than "the stick at your legs moves the ailerons". They are completely different aircraft and the F117 as I understand is notorious for being difficult to fly and control. Not to mention the stealth advantage has been defeated by modern AA systems like Russia's S400 SAM, so you're really just getting a heavy and difficult to fly aircraft that only carries two 500 lb bombs. There's much better stuff that should be sent before you start scrounging up mothballed F117s.
- jjkeddo199 3y agoF117 supposedly shares many components with F16, more than you'd think. F16 is extremely vulnerable to GBAD and won't be able to safely fly close to the front lines. Ukraine is struggling because it cannot strike Russian supply lines safely like USA did to Iraq in 1991. It is unproven that an S400 could defeat a well-operated F117 -- We cannot say the same for something like F16. I think it is questionable ethically to "lead Ukraine on" in terms offering military support, if that support is intended to only be just enough to manage a bloody and protracted stalemate. We should either pressure them to settle, or genuinely offer enough weapons to help them succeed (pushing Russia to accept some kind of "'conditional' defeat 'with honor'"). Letting both countries bleed themselves out like its WW1 should not be an option.
- medo-bear 3y agobecause it got slapped out of the air by a far less potent force??
- tgsovlerkhgsel 3y agoThe actual content, after removing the ChatGPT-style filler: > Some contemporary stealthy strategic bombers like the famous B-2 are able to remain unnoticed even in the presence of low-frequency radars. But new radar technologies threaten even these powerful stealth bombers. Therefore, the F-117, optimized to defeat high-frequency radars, is no longer relevant in current fights. > Moreover, it cannot map out threat emitters in real time like its successors F-22 and F-35. It is also not able to survive when it is detected and confronted.
- flangola7 3y agoWhat are the new radar technologies? Isn't radar ultimately a very simple process?
- c_o_n_v_e_x 3y agoNot an expert but I think over the horizon radar is a relatively new-ish tech. Legacy radar is relies on line of sight to to your target.
- kube-system 3y agoBouncing a signal is simple. Making sense of the signal you get back is extremely complicated.
- causality0 3y agoThat's like saying "aren't cameras a very simple process" when comparing Explorer 6 and the JWST.
- icegreentea2 3y agoImproved networking and sensor processing is one big avenue of improvement. Low observable designs typically do the majority of their heavy lifting by 'deflecting' radar beams away from the source. This means distributed systems of transmitters and receivers, networked together with enough compute oompf could potentially do a much better job at detecting and tracking. At the absolute bleeding edge of radar technology (like... probably decades and decades out) is developing and deploying quantum radar systems (these use entanglement to try to increase signal to noise).
- NikkiA 3y agoBecause it was security by obscurity, and the moment it was shot down over Serbia, it became useless.
- 13of40 3y agoWhen I was in air defense school in the mid-90s, we would regularly lock onto these during training. It might be invisible on radar, but it was just like any other plane to short range infrared and ultraviolet shadow seeking weapons like the Stinger and Avenger.
- lowbloodsugar 3y agoTechnology moved on and the F-117 can't keep its pilots alive once its stealth is defeated.
- aidenn0 3y agoWhich is pretty much what TFA says.
- Meph504 3y agoThat entire article could be summed up in a simple sentence. They advancement of low frequency radar made it obsolete. I suppose it is just me, but really can't stand when a simple answer is drug out to a massive, article like this.
- xboxnolifes 3y agoI don't agree that the article is drawn out or massive at all. It has 5 short sections, each only a few sentences, and each section answers a question relevant to the topic: what is the F-117, why was it made, how did it work, when did we stop using it, and why did we stop using it. The questions are up front, and the answers are fairly concise.
- Justin_K 3y agoThis article is from a content mill and is the product of chat GPT.
- LeoPanthera 3y agoWas this written by ChatGPT? It's incredibly puffy, keeps repeating itself, and ultimately says very little.
- afastow 3y ago99% yes. The other 1% is that maybe they used a different chatbot.
- ssijak 3y agoIt was retired over Yugoslavia https://theaviationgeekclub.com/an-in-depth-analysis-of-how-serbs-were-able-to-shoot-down-an-f-117-stealth-fighter-during-operation-allied-force/ https://theaviationgeekclub.com/an-in-depth-analysis-of-how-...
- srb24 3y agodespite the "F" designation it wasn't ever a multi-role fighter (ignoring it's er... trasnsport role in Executive Decision) and nowadays most combat aitcraft can't afford to be so specialised
- cameldrv 3y agoBecause the F-117 is not all that stealthy, and a good strategy for defeating it became known. In 1999 over Serbia, one F-117 was shot down and supposedly another one was damaged. It was shot down by a Russian S-125, which is a missile system from the early sixties. The Serb air defense officer that shot it down says that the F-117 was detected by his radar at 23km. He developed the tactic of moving his radar and missile launcher regularly, and then only turning on the radar for a short time and moving again. He says that the F-117s going into Serbia were following the same flight path over and over and he figured out a good time and place to turn on the radar. In the book Skunk Works, there's some detail about the mission planning that goes on for F-117 missions. They have software that, given the positions and types of radars, will find the lowest risk path in to the target. This is also referenced here: [1] Knowing all of this, you can surmise that the F-117 is detectible out to 20-30km (depending on angle), but they simply route the planes to go around the radars. Presumably if a new radar pops up, the F-117 can detect this (or be cued by an AWACS or EW plane) and fly another way, or turn around. However, if the radar pops up suddenly, it may be too late. Once the effectiveness of this tactic was proven, the value of the F-117 went down a lot. Then you start looking at the other deficiencies of the plane. It has a small bomb load, not very long range, no supersonic capability, limited sensors, no air to air capability. If the plane is invincible, these are forgivable, but if not, then maybe not. Anyhow despite all of that, they still fly the F-117 in retirement for training and testing purposes, and they still get sighted in the air and on ramps periodically.
- Glawen 3y agoGreat post, I knew about the story, but thanks for the detailed explanation.
- voxadam 3y agoI've always loved the "Sorry we didn't know it wasn't invisible" propaganda poster[0] created by the Serbians after they shot down that F-117. [0] https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/c0/Serbian_poster_%22Sorry_we_didn%27t_know_it_was_invisible%22.jpg https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/c/c0/Serbian_...
- 3y ago
- sombragris 3y agoThe pictured cockpit, from the Air Force museum, looks like a prototype or a very early model. The real cockpit had at least two multifunction displays. Modern digital avionics is the heart of this precision bombing platform, increasing mission effectiveness and decreasing pilot workload. The F-117 cockpit is equipped with Heads up display (HUD), twin color multifunction display indicators, and a digital moving map system. https://www.f117sfa.org/about-the-f117 https://www.f117sfa.org/about-the-f117 A cockpit picture: https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/5a36dd6f8a02c74fc8515e9b/1529964442663-0HPSO0UYSPEDASN3B0QC/f117_cockpit.jpg?format=2500w https://images.squarespace-cdn.com/content/v1/5a36dd6f8a02c7...
- metaphor 3y agoCorrect. The larger display unit in the center was the primary human interface for IRADS video fed from FLIR/DLIR turrets.
- freediver 3y agoOnly one F-117 was shot down and it is an interesting story made into a documentary movie. https://www.military.com/military-life/how-air-force-pilot-became-friends-man-who-shot-down-his-f-117.html https://www.military.com/military-life/how-air-force-pilot-b...
- nickdothutton 3y agoI think it’s worth remembering that achieving stealth isn’t about the aircraft exclusively. It’s about the entire mission profile. Route, time of day, defeat of certain radars by means other than stealth, terrain considerations, altitude and approach.