7 ms·
> For example, I could start coning cruise cars, and cause these numbers to skyrocket And why would that not be a valid data point? Cars driving on public road
by paxys 3y ago
> For example, I could start coning cruise cars, and cause these numbers to skyrocket
And why would that not be a valid data point? Cars driving on public roads need to successfully handle all regular day-to-day situations, not just the happy path. It seems like almost every day I run into some Cruise or Waymo (mostly Cruise) vehicle stuck in the middle of the street blocking traffic, and that should not be excused as "oh it's just learning".
Self driving car companies love to release reports comparing themselves against regular drivers when it comes to collisions and deaths, but conveniently skip over every other aspect of driving. The way things are today, if we continue to release more and more of them into San Francisco it will basically lead up to a total traffic deadlock, and yet people will still keep repeating "oh but they kill 0.1 fewer people per million miles so it's an improvement".
- veec_cas_tant 3y ago> And why would that not be a valid data point? Cars driving on public roads need to successfully handle all regular day-to-day situations, not just the happy path Are you considering someone putting a traffic cone on a vehicle a day-to-day situation?
- paxys 3y agoWhat would you do if you were stopped at an intersection and someone put a traffic cone in front of you? Sit there for the rest of your life blocking everyone behind you, or move it/drive around it? Same for literally every example that deviates from the happy path, no matter how minor. Construction work, something fallen on the road, a delivery van stopped on the side, temporary street closures. These cars are nowhere close to being intelligent enough to handle city driving, and won't be for a very long time.
- aaomidi 3y agoI like that you’re getting downvoted but actually being able to react to these situations is a good skill to have.
- brigade 3y agoThey put the cone on the hood, it's not an obstacle on the road. The car could try to shake it off, maybe, but is shaking it into the middle of the street and creating an obstacle really the right move? Should self-driving cars be required to have a robotic arm capable of moving a traffic cone from a car surface to the sidewalk to handle this specific situation? Also the anti-car activists can easily move on to a wide variety of other methods to obstruct sensors.
- civilitty 3y agoI think the answer is quite obvious: require self driving cars to have a six degree-of-freedom robotic arm that folds into the front of the car. It can be used to remove traffic cones and clothesline cyclists!
- silisili 3y agoIf we can have it give a little shake or window knock to the car in front of me, stopped at the light that's turned green, checking texts - consider me on board!
- kelnos 3y ago> Should self-driving cars be required to have a robotic arm That does raise the question of what kinds of adverse situations an AV should have specialized hardware or software to handle. Maybe they should have a robotic arm! I dunno, probably not, but maybe! A less silly example might be if the car breaks down. When a human driver is in the car, they can put the car in neutral, get out, and push it to the side of the road, out of the way of traffic. An AV will just sit there, blocking traffic, until a tow truck can arrive (which in most places can take 45 minutes or more). Granted, in this case, I don't think there is anything an AV can do. But I think these sorts of things are worth thinking about.
- scarmig 3y agoI'd be interested to know how Waymo/Cruise currently sense and respond to catastrophic failure. A blown tire? Brake failure? Broken timing belt? Which isn't to say that humans respond especially well to these things, but at scale, AV should be able to handle them not just as well as humans do but much better.
- tlb 3y agoThey handle some crazy situations. https://twitter.com/kvogt/status/1641123102858919953 https://twitter.com/kvogt/status/1641123102858919953
- loandbehold 3y agoPutting cone on self driving car is vandalism and should be punished accordingly. Self driving companies have footage of people doing it. Is SFPD looking for these people? Self driving companies shouldn't need to be able to deal with criminals trying to actively disable it. These cars weren't designed to drive in a warzone. Most businesses are not able to operate when criminals try to actively interfere with its operations. Some basic level of law and order is required for modern society to exist.
- dghlsakjg 3y agoVandalism in California requires "maliciously damaging, destroying or defacing someone else's property". A cone on a hood does none of those things. It might be some other crime, but we can't slap people with charges that won't stick in a court of law. The counterpoint to the argument is that you shouldn't be deploying deadly machinery on public roads with no ability to handle common issues and expecting it to be a problem for the SFPD/CHP.
- lsaferite 3y ago> you shouldn't be deploying deadly machinery on public roads with no ability to handle common issues Is someone putting an obstruction on your hood a common situation where you live?
- gerash 3y agoExactly. once there is a reasonable negative consequence to these actions people will adjust. Why hasn't SFPD arrested anyone yet?
- scarmig 3y agoIt would be amusing to see how humans react if you run up to their cars while stopped, put a traffic cone on the hood, and run away. Would most people try to shake it off while driving away, or stop in the middle of traffic? What's actually the right thing to do, both as a person and as an AV? More pertinently, should it be legal for people to go up and put traffic cones on top of actively driven vehicles, intentionally to confuse or disrupt the driver? Or should they be punished?
- kelnos 3y ago> It would be amusing to see how humans react if you run up to their cars while stopped, put a traffic cone on the hood, and run away. Hah, good call. I'm thinking that if I was at a traffic light or stop sign, and it wasn't a major road with other lanes of cars and lots of traffic whizzing by, I'd hop out, move the cone, and go about my day. If I didn't feel safe, I'd accelerate slowly enough so as not to shake off the cone, and move to the side of the road and deal with it there. > More pertinently, should it be legal for people to go up and put traffic cones on top of actively driven vehicles No, it absolutely shouldn't. In the case at hand, what if one of these AVs with a cone on it ended up blocking traffic and delaying an ambulance or fire truck, causing someone to die? I get that this is a protest movement, but I wouldn't want that on my conscience. And people protest in all kinds of ways that aren't legal (often called "civil disobedience"). People who do that should expect to suffer consequences, and accept that outcome as a part of the protest.
- K0balt 3y agoI mean, free cone?
- jmoss20 3y ago> It seems like almost every day I run into some Cruise or Waymo (mostly Cruise) vehicle stuck in the middle of the street blocking traffic ...really? I've seen this maybe once or twice, total. Is there really some part of town where this is a daily occurrence?
- dekhn 3y agoDuring the height of Critical Mass, bicyclists would surround minivans and keep them from leaving. Drivers don't know what to do because if they push too hard they'll knock over and injure a cyclist. I don't expect self-driving cars to deal any better with cones, or any hostile action towards a car.
- Vecr 3y agoThat's an ambush, are the self defense laws there that bad?
- dekhn 3y agoUhhh... if you're surrounding by multiple layers of cyclists and try to drive your way out hitting a few cyclists, the cyclists are going to swarm your car and kill you. To be fair, I think this only happened a few times and it was caused by a small number of bad players, while the majority of Critical Mass participants were ethically (if somewhat inconveniently) demonstrating their collective power.
- sroussey 3y agoWhat happens when you cross an autonomous car and stand-your-ground gun laws? Through in some citizens united where a corporation is a person, and you might have cars that fight back... 8)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- __loam 3y agoIt's a lot higher than 0.1 people. 40 people died in SF last year due to traffic accidents. I've yet to hear about a self driving car killing someone despite how many there are in the city. I also disagree that coning a self-driving car's sensor is a "regular day to day situation". Throwing paint on someone's windshield or slashing their tires is a crime. E: making stat accurate
- dekhn 3y agoYour numbers are wrong: https://sfgov.org/scorecards/transportation/traffic-fatalities https://sfgov.org/scorecards/transportation/traffic-fataliti... In 2022 (the year with the most), there were 40, not hundreds. Please try to keep your stats as honest as possible.
- Spooky23 3y agoPeople on HN said the same thing about Tesla before they started ramming bridge abutments, etc.
- medellin 3y agoDepending where someone put a cone on my car i would possibly just run them over or drive off unsafely if i felt that it was an attempt to rob me or steal my car. Having things like that categorized differently makes sense because it’s caused by humans being dicks. But maybe you are right and that is the new reality we live in where none of us get to advance because of a small group of angry and stupid people.
- m00x 3y agoWhile it is an incredibly shitty thing to do, that does not give you the right to murder someone.
- naniwaduni 3y agoPutting large vision-blocking objects on people's cars while they're using it is absolutely in the class of things that will get people killed entirely gratuitously, and while I wouldn't go as far as to say that it's right to kill the perpetrator, they certainly have no right to complain if happen not to survive the encounter.
- jrmg 3y agoMan, and further up this post there was someone talking about running over groups of cyclists if they maliciously surrounded their car. Try to remain calm. You’re generally not allowed to just _murder_ people who attempt to inconvenience, detain, or rob you, even though they are ‘being dicks’. That’s not how crime is dealt with in a stable society. It’s not a ‘new reality’. I really hope we’re not devolving into a place where more people think this way…
- CatWChainsaw 3y agoWe are that far gone. https://philosophybear.substack.com/p/a-short-comment-on-self-defense-and https://philosophybear.substack.com/p/a-short-comment-on-sel...
- 3y ago
- parl_match 3y ago> And why would that not be a valid data point? It is, I didn't say it wasn't. It's also not really in the same class as an accident with injury.
- mustacheemperor 3y agoIf you start putting cones on the hoods of human driven taxis at red lights, that will also cause traffic diversions. The tendency of humans to pester the driverless taxis more than the drivered ones doesn’t seem like any metric related to the technology’s performance. Someone putting a traffic cone on the hood of your car is more than a typical deviation from the happy path. As to your personal anecdote, all I can say is it’s different from my own experience driving in SF or riding in my partner’s car. We see plenty of driverless vehicles, and generally they’re behaving smarter than the average SF Saturday morning driver, not worse. I don’t live in a cruise-populated neighborhood so I’m sure your experience may vary elsewhere. On that note, my neighborhood doesn’t have much transit at all. It’s a 30m walk to a grocery store or 25 to the 3rd st muni. We only get limited bus service. So I would be very happy to see additional transit options in SF.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- nova22033 3y agoIt seems like almost every day I run into How are they expected to respond to this data point?