22 ms·
It's official: Smartphones will need to have replaceable batteries by 2027
- t0bia_s 3y agoGreat, finaly ungluing phones become history.
- anonu 3y agoThis will likely make phones bigger and/or available power (mAh) worse as the battery will need more material surrounding it to make it replaceable. Good intentions but makes the customer worse off IMO
- ponorin 3y agoa lot of people seem to get this wrong so let me reiterate: whether a phone has removable battery or headphone jack, etc. or not has almost zero relations to its thickness, waterproofing, etc. it's simply a choice that manufacturers made. they know how to make it fit into their devices, they just don't wanna try. of course there will be non-zero costs involved but so is shoving in multiple cameras, motorized parts or even a fragile folding display with a water-resistant hinge. again, it's not even something they haven't tried before, and they know it. every manufacturers mocked apple for removing the headphone jack before doing it themselves because selling wireless earbuds was more profitable than saving their face.
- ponorin 3y agoI will throw another hot take: Most people don't want or need "waterproof" (read: IP-rated) phones. I haven't seen people washing phones in the sink, or using it out on the beach, (of course there will be some outliers, but they aren't designed for seawater anyway) nor is it that useful to have in our day-to-day lives. In my experience, most smartphones, even without water-resistant ratings, do survive accidental spills or even drops. And for cases where it won't, splash resistance would suffice. Claim of water resistance is already kind of misleading, because it's only temporary and only applies to fresh water (river is not "fresh water" in this case). So it's more limited than what companies want you to believe, and people's habits haven't changed anyway. Unless you live in Japan, or you frequently expose your phone in non-fresh water (for which you would need a different kind of accessory anyway), there's practically no reason you should have a IP rated phone.
- operatingthetan 3y agoI take it you never use your phone in the bathtub. Trust me, lots of people do it.
- ponorin 3y agosorry, i tend to leave my phone out of my bathroom. not that IP rating is applicable for hot water (or extra chemicals like soap for that matter) anyway.
- operatingthetan 3y agoThe focus was "most people," not you. And the iphone's water resistance works just fine in a warm tub. If you're generalizing for what most people need, you should at least understand how people use the devices. Made up constraints like the soap and temperature are irrelevant to common usage and their needs in a device.
- rightbyte 3y agoSeems good. Is there any rule against "DRM" like vendor lockin for replacement batteries?
- M2Ys4U 3y agoYes: "Software shall not be used to impede the replacement of a portable battery or LMT battery, or of their key components, with another compatible battery or key components."
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dangus 3y ago> Companies like Samsung, Google, Apple, etc., don’t design devices specific to Europe. I think they actually will do just that. Look at the Wikipedia page for any iPhone and you’ll see that each model has multiple regional SKUs. China has a SIM card tray while the US doesn’t. I think smartphone makers will make the battery rectangular and put it in a convenient spot and then make a different rear case part just for Europe. The rest of the world phones will have perhaps the exact same “removable” battery but it will be behind a case that has no door.
- crooked-v 3y agoThe waterproofing in particular makes me think this is likely. Many average consumers care way more about having a device that will survive being dropped in the sink now than they do about replacing an 80% capacity battery in two years.
- pjmlp 3y agoNokia already had waterproof phones during the Symbian OS and Series 30/40 heyday. They did just fine with replaceable batteries.
- The_Colonel 3y agoSamsung S5 was waterproof while having replaceable battery. Technology is certainly there. But I also question your premise, I don't think it's as clear. I've never dropped my phone in a sink, but had battery issues with basically every phone. Often the battery starts failing much earlier than 80% in two years.
- traverseda 3y agoWhat I've never understood is why all this waterproofing effort is going into making perfectly sealed little boxes when I imagine that a factory applied conformal coating would do a similar job. It seems like they're focused on making the box the electronics are in water proof instead of making the electronics themselves waterproof. Sure, the screen might be a bit harder and you'd need to pay special attention to any connector, maybe re-applying the coating if you remove a connector, but I just don't get it. Does conformal coating not work as well as I imagine it does? Is it too expensive to apply? Does it have some kind of heat dissipation drawback I'm not aware of? To me it looks like water proofing is being used as an excuse to add built-in obsolescence to products, since I imagine that conformal coating would do the job better. What am I missing?
- crooked-v 3y agoHow is this going to affect devices like Airpods, where having replaceable anything would mean increasing the size of the device itself to allow for the physical moving parts for that? Or will companies just stop selling those in Europe?
- TaylorAlexander 3y agoSounds like this is specific to smartphones. Though I would love to see user replaceable batteries in smart watches.
- crooked-v 3y agoNope, it's everything. From the EU document: > Any natural or legal person that places on the market products incorporating portable batteries shall ensure that those batteries are readily removable and replaceable by the end-user at any time during the lifetime of the product. That obligation shall only apply to entire batteries and not to individual cells or other parts included in such batteries. > A portable battery shall be considered readily removable by the end-user where it can be removed from a product with the use of commercially available tools, without requiring the use of specialised tools, unless provided free of charge with the product, proprietary tools, thermal energy, or solvents to disassemble the product. > The obligations laid down in paragraph 1 shall not apply where continuity of power supply is necessary and a permanent connection between the product and the respective portable battery is required to ensure the safety of the user and the appliance or, for products that collect and supply data as their main function, for data integrity reasons.
- Dig1t 3y ago>That obligation shall only apply to entire batteries and not to individual cells or other parts included in such batteries. 2024 will be the year that Apple stops selling the iPhone and releases the all new iBattery. It's a special battery that's also a revolutionary communications device!
- 3y ago
- pjmlp 3y agoGreat news!
- mholm 3y ago> By 2027, all phones released in the EU must have a battery the user can easily replace with no tools or expertise Hmm. I wish this were worded a bit differently, in that I wouldn't mind having a screwed in compartment if the phone came with a tool that could be used to open the battery compartment. Being able to replace by hand excludes even operations like the sim tray's mechanism. EDIT: This is actually the case. I was quibbling over nothing I think the rest of the regulation to require recycling seems a good move on the surface.
- The_Colonel 3y agoI don't think this will be a problem in practice. Old smartphones' batteries could be typically replaced without any tools.
- ISL 3y agoOld smartphones rarely had IPX ratings.
- mrguyorama 3y agoAnd yet waterproof watches have had replaceable batteries forever, at least a decade ago they still did.
- crooked-v 3y agoIt actually requires no specialty tools not included with the product, so tiny screws are still fine as long as there's a tiny screwdriver in the box.
- dang 3y agoRelated. Others? The EU’s fight for user-replaceable smartphone batteries - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36466153 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36466153 - June 2023 (328 comments) EU: Smartphones Must Have User-Replaceable Batteries by 2027 - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36394922 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36394922 - June 2023 (13 comments) European Union votes to bring back replaceable phone batteries - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36361510 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36361510 - June 2023 (606 comments) EU parliament passes law on user replaceable batteries - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36336190 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36336190 - June 2023 (18 comments) Non-replaceable battery? Not if this proposed EU law passes - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34129250 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34129250 - Dec 2022 (234 comments) EU legislation could bring back user replaceable batteries - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34085963 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=34085963 - Dec 2022 (23 comments) Replaceable batteries are coming back to phones if the EU gets its way - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30867892 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30867892 - March 2022 (14 comments) EU to make it mandatory to use customer-replaceable batteries in household items - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30660953 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30660953 - March 2022 (637 comments)
- Kon-Peki 3y agoThere is a link to this document [1], which has article 11: > Any natural or legal person that places on the market products incorporating portable batteries shall ensure that those batteries are readily removable and replaceable by the end-user at any time during the lifetime of the product. That obligation shall only apply to entire batteries and not to individual cells or other parts included in such batteries. > A portable battery shall be considered readily removable by the end-user where it can be removed from a product with the use of commercially available tools, without requiring the use of specialised tools, unless provided free of charge with the product, proprietary tools, thermal energy, or solvents to disassemble the product. There are exceptions: > By way of derogation from paragraph 1, the following products incorporating portable batteries may be designed in such a way as to make the battery removable and replaceable only by independent professionals: (a) appliances specifically designed to operate primarily in an environment that is regularly subject to splashing water, water streams or water immersion, and that are intended to be washable or rinseable; (b) professional medical imaging and radiotherapy devices, as defined in Article 2, point (1), of Regulation (EU) 2017/745, and in vitro diagnostic medical devices, as defined in Article 2, point (2), of Regulation (EU) 2017/746. Does a smartphone qualify under the section (a) exemption? What if Apple starts to say that we can rinse off our iPhones any time they get dirty? They already show advertisements in which iPhones get dunked in water. > The obligations laid down in paragraph 1 shall not apply where continuity of power supply is necessary and a permanent connection between the product and the respective portable battery is required to ensure the safety of the user and the appliance or, for products that collect and supply data as their main function, for data integrity reasons. Another potential loophole? [1] https://data.consilium.europa.eu/doc/document/PE-2-2023-INIT/en/pdf https://data.consilium.europa.eu/doc/document/PE-2-2023-INIT... EDIT - It appears that page 11 & 12 make it clear that any battery in a smartphone is a "portable battery"
- lb4r 3y ago> Any natural or legal person that places on the market products incorporating portable batteries shall ensure that those batteries are readily removable and replaceable by the end-user at any time during the lifetime of the product. That obligation shall only apply to entire batteries and not to individual cells or other parts included in such batteries. So would this apply to something like the Nintendo Switch, and/or Steam Deck?
- dkjaudyeqooe 3y ago> By 2027, all phones released in the EU must have a battery the user can easily replace with no tools or expertise. The article is wrong. The rule is that obscure tools must not be required: > A portable battery shall be considered readily removable by the end-user where it can be removed from a product with the use of commercially available tools, without requiring the use of specialised tools [...]
- wilg 3y agoHow is specialized defined?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- packetlost 3y agoIf glue is considered unspecialized this does basically nothing for repairability.
- mdorazio 3y agoThe comma placement makes the glue answer a bit strange, but I'm interpreting it to mean glues are no-go unless the manufacturer provides a solvent and re-gluing kit as well. Full text from [1] (emphasis mine): > A portable battery should be considered to be removable by the end-user when it can be removed with the use of commercially available tools and without requiring the use of specialised tools, unless they are provided free of charge, or proprietary tools, thermal energy or solvents to disassemble it. Commercially available tools are considered to be tools available on the market to all end-users without the need for them to provide evidence of any proprietary rights and that can be used with no restriction, except health and safety-related restrictions. Also answers the above question regarding "specialised" - that would be anything not fitting the "commercially available" definition. [1] https://data.consilium.europa.eu/doc/document/PE-2-2023-INIT/en/pdf https://data.consilium.europa.eu/doc/document/PE-2-2023-INIT...
- yayitswei 3y agoSeems like a good change. Will probably cost a lot to redesign everything, but smartphones are due for a shakeup.
- yjftsjthsd-h 3y ago> Will probably cost a lot to redesign everything I wouldn't think too much cost, since targeting 2027 means it should only affect phones that aren't even designed yet? (At least, I don't think anyone is taking 3-4 years to get a phone to market)
- yayitswei 3y agoI'm thinking of all the things that are reused between product generations, from form factors to manufacturing processes.
- vladvasiliu 3y agoI don't know about Apple, but Samsung seems to have figured that going the other way, from replaceable battery to non-replaceable, made sense. I doubt it would cost them that much in engineering to go back to that.
- johncessna 3y agoWhy do they need 4 years for this? This was how most phones used to work.
- zihotki 3y agoBecause "time to market" is not zero. Manufacturers need time to develop and produce new devices. Plus sell the ones already in the release chain. That's a quite reasonable time frame.
- everdrive 3y agoNice! My iPhone is from 2018, I'll try to hold out until then.
- ern 3y agoMy iPhone was also bought in 2018 (iPhone X) but it will be obsolete with the new iOS release. The iPhone X seems to have aged a lot better than the iPhone 8, which it was released alongside, but it looks like Apple's decided to kill both off at the same time.
- neets 3y agoI wonder what kind of RFID chips will be inside them by them so people can still be tracked?
- zargon 3y agoDoes this require OEMs to sell the batteries? Because third party batteries tend to be time bombs, in my experience.
- jsmith45 3y ago> Any natural or legal person that places on the market products incorporating portable batteries or LMT batteries shall ensure that those batteries are available as spare parts of the equipment that they power for a minimum of five years after placing the last unit of the equipment model on the market, with a reasonable and non-discriminatory price for independent professionals and end-users.
- tomjen3 3y agoThat seems like a big loop hole: have all repairs done by TimWillFix, which charges the same cost to everybody, including Apple. Apple owns TimWillFix. Done. Prices are non-discriminary and independents get shafted.
- pessimizer 3y agoIt's not about repairs in general and not about independents, it's about replacement batteries. It requires that replacement batteries be easy to replace by the user, and replacement batteries be sold for a reasonable price for at least 5 years. If Apple creates a subsidiary that keeps their batteries in production, more power to them.
- jsmith45 3y agoThe law does not allow that. They must be available at a reasonable price for "for independent professionals and end-users". Several of relatively small number of exceptions to user replaceable batteries still require that independent professionals be able to replace the battery.
- roxgib 3y agoFive years is much too short, although it's nice to see that it's measured from the date of sale stop rather than start.
- elwebmaster 3y agoIt’s unbelievable how people on here are defending manufacturers and designers when we have GoPro which is much more water resistant than most phones out there and has a replaceable battery.
- Kon-Peki 3y agoI'm not sure that people are defending the manufacturers so much as taking a cynical view in which they believe that the manufacturers will find a way to not have user-replaceable batteries.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- can16358p 3y agoThe Smartphone war is MUCH more aggressive than action camera war, and every cubic millimeter counts. Of course an iPhone with a replaceable battery can be made while still being waterproof, but that would lose a lot of real estate.
- irrational 3y agoWill iPhones no longer be waterproof? I've actually dropped my iPhone in the ocean a number of times (just in tidal zones, never in deep water) and have washed it off with tap water. It stills works perfectly fine a few years later.
- Volundr 3y agoOnly is Apple chooses to quit making them waterproof. Plenty of existing devices have user replaceable batteries and are waterproof, for example GoPros.
- flangola7 3y agoThere were waterproof phones with removable batteries in the past.
- asadotzler 3y agoYou do realize we've been making waterproof compact electronic devices for ages, right? I had 50 meter digital watch in 1986 with an easily replaced battery. Why is it so hard for you youngins to imagine modern companies making this work? There are zero tech or material hurdles here. None. Haven't been for 40 or 50 years at least. Jesus.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- AniseAbyss 3y agoMy 200 euro electric toothbrush already has a dying battery and its only been a year. Sometimes I wonder if they do it on purpose.
- Ballas 3y agoThe key is to not store it on the charger. Only charge it when it is low - that dramatically increases the battery life. I have had sonicare brushes that failed due to metal fatigue with a battery that could still do ~2 weeks between charges.
- projektfu 3y agoMy first one had a soldered-in NiCd battery. I'm not sure if they're using a less toxic chemistry now. My current one is at least 6 years old now.
- antonpirker 3y agoMy Smartphone still has a replaceable battery :-)
- ecf 3y agoUser-replaceable batteries always have a negative effect on the design of a product. I’d rather see free battery replacements every X years be offered from authorized techs.
- kedikedi 3y agoI am very much wondering how Oura (the smart ring company) will handle this as the thing is very small. Their current design is fully casted, and practically impossible to do any kind of repairs.
- BiteCode_dev 3y agoAnd the hearing aids, the pacemakers, etc
- Volundr 3y agoPacemakers at least should be a non-issue since the law specifically exempts devices where continuous power is required for the safety of the user. I think an unpowered pacemaker would definitely jeopardize ones safety. But yeah my mind also immediately went to very small devices like hearing aids.
- adrenvi 3y agoMaybe this is why Apple is focusing so much on health sensors. It's a bit of a stretch but it could be argued that Apple's fall detection and heart rate monitoring is required for the safety of the user.
- PawgerZ 3y agoHearing aids already have replaceable batteries, don't they? I guess I don't know the whole market, but you can buy batteries for my brother's heading aids at Walmart. They take a minute or less to replace. Same with my friend's hearing aids.
- opyate 3y agoHallelujah. I take very good care of my phones, and 4 years in, I have to put a very pristine phone in the drawer, because it can't hold a charge any more.
- xnx 3y agoLaw of unintended consequences makes me think this will result in more e-waste as devices with readily removable batteries are more likely to be damaged by drops and liquids. They will also use more materials than devices with permanent batteries. Everything is tradeoffs, and I don't think this law is making the right ones.
- asadotzler 3y agoyou're just making excuses for corporations. casio gave me a water proof digital watch with replaceable batteries almost four decades ago and it had no issues with shock or water damage, ever. this is the silliest argument I've ever heard in defense of megacorps. what a joke.
- xnx 3y agoI've had phones with replaceable batteries and those without. If my current phone were available with and without a replaceable battery (and the related reliability/cost tradeoffs), I'd probably pick the permanent battery.
- notTooFarGone 3y agowhat tradeoff - like you dont get to choose that replacable battery are just worse because it fits your world view. You can design replaceable solutions to be as reliable as "permanent" ones. Have it cost 10$ more for the same reliability, you would pick the replacable battery one in a heartbeat.
- obliteratus 3y agoI have a hard time trusting that this is for environmental or user friendly reasons. Those may certainly be outcomes, barring better battery tech that obviates needing to care about a removable battery once batteries last decades, but I don't think they're the intended reason for this. I think it's just what they're saying to make it sound more appealing to the end user who may not realize what's actually happening. The reason I'm skeptical is because this is not happening in isolation from other related things happening in Europe. Consider how France is pushing for authorities to have unprecedented direct access to people's devices in this dystopian push: https://www.lemonde.fr/en/france/article/2023/07/06/france-set-to-allow-police-to-spy-through-phones_6044269_7.html https://www.lemonde.fr/en/france/article/2023/07/06/france-s... This reminds me of when I visited France not long ago. At the airport they started opening my laptop to check it out. I never had that happen at any other airport before. They took it out in front of me and opened it up to look inside it. It was a bizarre experience because that held up the entire flight's departure for no reason. It was an unpleasant and uncomfortable experience. Their general tendency towards authoritarian dystopian types of ideas since then is palpable. So all of this suggests to me they want to have easy access to consumer hardware for interdiction reasons. It'll be way easier for them to get into devices that are otherwise behind proprietary or less common enclosure mechanisms. It's strange how with the EU it's one step forward for protecting users (I like the spirit of GDPR for example) and then just a giant step backwards with these types of moves. Unless the EU adopts strict user privacy laws at the constitutional level, I don't see why this confluence of variables isn't suggesting an anti user mindset. If someone with an expertise in these things can offer guidance on why interdiction doesn't work this way and what I'm missing about the risks here, I'd greatly appreciate it!
- Tainnor 3y agoThis is just baseless speculation mixed with personal anecdotes (as if there weren't countless anecdotes about the United States TSA requesting access to personal computing devices). Europe is a big place and it should be no surprise that there are multiple things happening at once. The push for user replaceable batteries has been ongoing for years now and is not related to whatever Macron's trying to do unilaterally in his own country, which is only one member state of the EU.
- 3y ago
- hasseo 3y agoGood. This will make life a lot easier.
- TT-392 3y agonow my waterdamaged fairphone 3plus just needs to hold out until then
- mojuba 3y agoWouldn't "user replaceable" make it more expensive? Besides I can't even imagine an iPhone that can be easily opened by anyone, stay water resistant and "Apple-y" at the same time...
- asciimov 3y agoIt'll pop out just like a sim card. Push a little tool into a button, out she goes.
- marinhero 3y agoI hear you but it think they’ll comply and provide a way to have all those things. There was no incentive to have it up until now. With fines on the line they better get creative.
- firefoxd 3y agoThere are so many things we couldn't imagine with iPhone. But the clever engineer, when motivated, will figure out how to do it. Let's leave it to them.
- xbmcuser 3y agoAh no they have the design chops to build something where the batteries can be easily replaced but that would make phone replacement slower so was not prioritised this will force the hands of manufacturers. I hope it results in something like the nokia 3310 battery where we get a battery that is designed to be used in multiple devices. And because the phone was so popular the battery was easily available many manufacturers of product like eink readers etc starting using them in own devices.
- Angostura 3y agoGood
- jhoechtl 3y agoI predict that Asian Android-targeting manufactures will respond quickly, Apple with some tricky lawyers-speak never.
- kramerger 3y agoCopying my comment from the other post from AppleInsider: "No it doesn't. This is appleinsider, and obviously they think everything is about Apple. But if you read the proposal, it never mentions smartphones. It is fairly clear that this aims to target other types of electronics such as hand tools. I'm pretty sure EU is satisfied with at cost smartphone battery replacement policy they introduced while back. The whole point is to not scrap electronics just because the battery is old, not that average Joe should be able to do it himself for the cost of making phones more expensive to produce or lose IP ratings."
- happymellon 3y agoThis completely makes sense. The battery replacement program is straightforward enough, and Samsung have a similar battery replacement program here in the UK. This is an ewaste prevention policy not a "right to repair". Right to repair comes next, we just want any sort of repair to be considered for these electronics.
- red_trumpet 3y agoFrom [1] > The regulation provides that by 2027 portable batteries incorporated into appliances should be removable and replaceable by the end-user And from the proposal[2] > This Regulation should apply to all categories of batteries placed on the market or put into service within the Union, regardless of whether they were produced in the Union or imported. It should apply regardless of whether a battery is incorporated into appliances, light means of transport or other vehicles or otherwise added to products or whether a battery is placed on the market or put into service within the Union on its own. What makes you think smartphone batteries are excluded? [1] https://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/press/press-releases/2023/07/10/council-adopts-new-regulation-on-batteries-and-waste-batteries/ https://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/press/press-releases/2023... [2] https://data.consilium.europa.eu/doc/document/PE-2-2023-INIT/en/pdf https://data.consilium.europa.eu/doc/document/PE-2-2023-INIT...
- kramerger 3y agoBecause this legislation did not come out of nowhere. There were investigations about batteries at home before they fianlized this, and none of it involved smartphones. For example, there was a lot of talk about Dewalt, B&D, Ryobi and others each having a different batteries and a different type of chargers. Smartphone battery issue was addressed separately and the whole spin on user replacable smartphone battery seems to come from forums like this and not EU. In fact, this proposal specifically allows water proof devices to be handled by a professional (an "independent" professional to be exact, which is very much inline with the previous proposal on smartphone battery replacement).
- Animats 3y agoI'd rather have a 10-year lithium iron phosphate battery, no connectors, no memory cards, no sim cards, inductive charging, unbreakable glass, and a hermetically sealed case that doesn't require another case around it. Just build it for a reliable 10 year life with a 10 year warranty. No user serviceable parts inside.
- kosma 3y agoYou won't have it, as it doesn't align with the manufacturers' incentive to sell you a new one every two years.
- wiredfool 3y agoI’d be happy if they flatly banned single use vaping devices.
- robwilliams 3y agoThe ban on replaceable flavored pod vapes caused that. Such a bizarre rule and so wasteful. You couldn’t replace the battery on the pod vapes but at least you could reuse the recharge and reuse the battery.
- yonatan8070 3y agoI'd be happy if they banned all vaping devices
- np1810 3y ago> I'd be happy if they banned all vaping devices (circa 2019) Why has India banned e-cigarettes? https://www.thehindu.com/news/why-has-india-banned-e-cigarettes/article61982896.ece https://www.thehindu.com/news/why-has-india-banned-e-cigaret... Worth sharing and the reasons are justified atleast for me...
- noctuid 3y agoI'd be happy if they banned all devices
- benblack86 3y agoI'd be happy if they banned everything
- can16358p 3y agoSeriously? Having it optional for people who want it, trading off design and durability? Sure. I'm perfectly happy with the iPhone's battery life, never intend to (nor wanted to) change the battery, and use it around or even under sea/pool. This "improvement" would either change the IP rating or lose a lot of inner space to keep the waterproof rating while still supporting battery changing. Why would I, as a user, want a totally backwards rule for something I'm never planning to do in my entire life? If someone wants that functionality, they can get a cheap Android phone with swappable battery and 100 spare batteries. Making such a thing mandatory is beyond ridiculous.
- nikau 3y agoWelcome to society where sometimes the better good overrides your desire for a 0.5mm thinner phone.
- mpol 3y ago[...]Having it optional for people who want it[...] But then it doesn't exist, right? Like today, which phones do have replaceable batteries? So the free market doesn't work and the government needs to step in. Blame the manufacturers (or the customers if you want).
- ndlan 3y agoOr maybe people don't really care about replaceable batteries?
- danielbln 3y agoIn addition, the notion of "just switch from your lived-in ecosystem and flagship phone to some new ecosystem and cheap-o Android phone" just so the battery can be replaced without jumping through hoops seems like a bad take.
- mypastself 3y agoIf there was truly a critical mass of users clamoring for this particular feature, surely a phone manufacturer would have already jumped at the opportunity to grab that market share?
- roxgib 3y agoWhat about AirPods and the like? I'm all for it with phones and everything else, but some devices are small enough that non-replaceable batteries might well be justified.
- iefbr14 3y agoNo doubt those batteries will be proprietary, with a chip in it so you can only use new batteries supplied by your phone producer. Better start working on a law against that too.
- hardware2win 3y agoIt should have been implemented years ago against printer industry
- DaanDL 3y agoMaybe some smartphones will now say you're "in need of a new battery" quicker now :-)
- alex_duf 3y agoIt had not occurred to me and this is terrifying
- scotty79 3y agoAlso replacement batteries for old phones will probably cost nearly as much as new phones and will have a huge profit margin for phone manufacturers.
- catchnear4321 3y agowhy? it will be fine. mildly overpriced batteries of varying reliability will be ubiquitous. you will be able to get rid of that warning message with a stop at a gas station, or perhaps… a low monthly fee. perhaps rather like toothbrush head, you could get a new one periodically. on subscription. just throw the old one in the trash, and it will magically disappear to somewhere else.
- fragmede 3y agoif you've been paying attention, batteries already report percentage and serial number over too few connectors. There wasn't, or weren't successful lawsuits stopping innovation when printers died, what's to stop innovation again LLMs?
- pb060 3y agoI'm not sure this is a good idea. I had to replace my iPhone batteries only twice since iPhone 3. Price was reasonable considering the price of the iPhone itself. Waste was managed and hopefully recycled by Apple. How many people would buy more cheaper batteries and not properly dispose the old ones? I know the article mentions recovery of waste etc. but it's up to the governments to be compliant and, as bad as it sounds, I tend to trust private companies more than governments.
- tinus_hn 3y agoI see two options: * this turns out a lot less exiting than people want it to be * a lot of companies are just going to leave the EU market I don’t think Apple is going to produce a Fairphone, and combined with the charger meddling and the App Store meddling I expect them to draw a line in the sand sooner or later. And then we will just all import them from the UK, just like before the iPhone was even sold in mainland Europe.
- evilos 3y agoAFAIK the new iphone 14 already meets these standards. It's really not the insane burden everyone is making it out to be.
- danielbln 3y agoThe EU market is one of the biggest in the world, and the second largest 1st world market after the US. Not even Apple can afford to drop that market, they are beholden to shareholders after all. Also, comparing this to 2007, when basically no-one had a smartphone, to now where every one and their dog have a smartphone in their pocket doesn't make a lot of sense.
- tinus_hn 3y agoIf you consider Europe (not the EU by the way) a market, and China, Japan and the rest of Asia separate markets, yes. But Apple can definitely afford to drop that market, they make their own rules and everyone that invests in them knows it and has been reaping the rewards for decades. And if everyone imports the phones through the UK it’s not like they are completely dropping it anyway. They’ve threatened to leave a market before, if conditions are such they can’t work: https://www.macrumors.com/2021/07/12/apple-threatens-to-leave-uk-market/ https://www.macrumors.com/2021/07/12/apple-threatens-to-leav...
- thesnide 3y agoI'd argue that UK and EU aren't of the same size. And threatening is one thing. Actually doing it is another.
- Neil44 3y agoI liked my old Samsung Galaxy 2 where you could flip the back off and swap the battery. I had 2 batteries and a stand alone charger which was AMAZING for trips away.
- fourseventy 3y agoThis feels like over-regulation to me. I would rather see the free market work this out on its own. If customers want a phone with a replaceable battery and Samsung refuses to make one, customers will switch away from Samsung and to a new manufacturer. Capitalism at work.
- kfk 3y agoThe issue is externalities. It's not a 100% free market because actors are not paying for Co2 emissions and pollution. If we had a carbon tax and that cost was part of the price of smartphones, I would be close to agreeing with you.
- rajeshmr 3y agoFinally, a step in the right direction. So much struggle to get back what we once took for granted (user replaceable batteries).
- gottfired 3y agoAs long as this process counts as user replacable, nothing will change. https://www.theverge.com/2022/5/21/23079058/apple-self-service-iphone-repair-kit-hands-on https://www.theverge.com/2022/5/21/23079058/apple-self-servi...
- Thorentis 3y agoCan't wait for Apple to start requiring you buy a new iBattery for the low low cost of $599.99 once a year when the old one is rejected by the phone for being unable to hold sufficient charge.
- ljf 3y agoThis cannot come soon enough - I have a 4 year old Huawei P20 Pro - the phone still more than meets my needs in terms of gaming, photos/videos and day to day use - I've not had a single issue with the phone - other than that finally the battery has started to go, and if I use it heavily (watch video or game for the 2 hours of my return commute) there is no way the battery will last the day. The cost to replace it is not worth it to me, and DIY seems needlessly complex. For now I'll just carry a charger/powerbank - but I'd far rather swap out the battery. Years ago I had a Dell Streak which I loved - that battery was swappable for that, I'd carry a couple of spare batteries in my bag for it - so I could do 2 or 3 days heavy use, without the need to recharge (the batteries were smaller and lighter than carrying a charger and the weird proprietary cable).
- nani8ot 3y agoAgreed. My Pixel 4a works great except that the battery is below 80% health (and except that GrapheneOS ends support in ~ a year). Replacing the battery risks breaking the display, since it requires removing the latter which is really thin on this phone.
- scarface_74 3y agoYour phone works great except for losing operating system support? Isn’t that the ultimate “other than that, how was the play Mrs. Lincoln?”
- nani8ot 3y agoLineageOS might support my phone longer, even if drivers don't get updated. And I'd have my battery replaced for a while now, if it wasn't a bit difficult.
- ftrobro 3y ago> the phone still more than meets my needs Does it still get upgrades to newer Android versions? Personally the reason I need to get a new phone is usually that the OS no longer receives upgrades (which means that apps drop support for it) or even security patches.
- nordsieck 3y ago> The European Council only has jurisdiction over Europe, obviously. So this law will not, technically, have an effect in any other area of the world. > However, that doesn’t really mean much in the grand scheme of things. Companies like Samsung, Google, Apple, etc., don’t design devices specific to Europe. Apple, for example, is not going to create a European iPhone with a replaceable battery and one for the United States without. In other words, this law will change all iPhones. It will also change all tablets, laptops, EVs, e-bikes, and anything else with a rechargeable battery. IMO, this is not necessarily true. Apple gave in over USB-C/lightning in large part because it's the right thing to do[1], but IMO, many consumers strongly prefer a thin phone over a replaceable battery. I suspect that Apple will at least strongly consider making a European version of the iPhone and a version that is thinner and/or has better battery capacity. I'd be happy if Apple does move their entire line to replaceable batteries - I'd prefer to be able to do a battery swap myself. But I don't think most consumers share my preferences. --- 1. I don't mean this in any sort of moral sense. Just in a technological one. Lightning is firewire reborn. It may have been compelling at one time, but the world has passed it up. And much like firewire, Apple would have eventually dropped it; which means that being forced to give it up a bit earlier than they'd like it's a particularly big blow.
- kklisura 3y ago> many consumers strongly prefer a thin phone Is this really the case? Is there any kind of research on that? Anecdotally: I have never seen anyone having an iPhone without a cover case. The case makes the phone _bulky_ yet no one complains.
- NoboruWataya 3y agoI'd also like to see research on it, but ultimately, pretty much every large company went in that direction for a reason. The phone market is pretty competitive, if users preferred a replaceable battery to a thinner phone we'd see some company stealing market share by offering exactly that. A thin phone with a phone cover is thinner than a bulky phone with a phone cover. Maybe the fact you're going to be putting a cover on it is why you want it to be thin in the first place.
- drooopy 3y agoThis can't come soon enough. In my house we a drawer full of electronics, from tablets and game consoles to phones and laptops that have been made obsolete by their glued in batteries. It doesn't help that a lot of those devices also came with their own proprietary cable connector for charging so we can't even use most of them even with a dead battery as we don't have the chargers anymore. Also, I really don't care about devices becoming thicker because that's a non-issue these days. They are too slim for their own good. My iPhone SE 2 bends in my pocket.
- neop1x 3y agoThen why don't you sell them on eBay? There are many people buying older, broken stuff but if you put it for 10 years to a drawer, it will become too old to be useful even for them...
- sparrowInHand 3y agoIt could literally have twice the thickness of the phone as batterypack in the back.. wish you could order that..
- flagged24 3y agoThis was not uncommon in the early smartphone days. I rember buying a battery with twice the capacity for my HTC Touch HD, it came with a larger back cover.
- evilkorn 3y agoI had one for my g1. The chineseium plastic was pretty bad though and I had to buy replacement back covers for the extended battery.
- quijoteuniv 3y agoAgree, they have been getting away with this for way too long. I would love to see another law saying that if they do not support the hardware anymore they need to release, open source the drivers so that it can still be used.
- ulrischa 3y agoWe had this 10 years before
- cypress66 3y agoI wished they allowed non user replaceable batteries if they use chemistries that support a high number of cycles (such as LFP batteries). I'd rather have a battery that lasts the full lifespan of the device, than a easy to replace battery.
- deanc 3y agoOn the surface this is probably a good thing but I wonder how we are going to keep features like waterproofing when it’s easy for consumers to pry open the device. I kinda like that I can lark around with my phone near a pool on holiday without the fear of bricking my device. This leaves me with similar feelings to the incoming usb-c requirement for iPhone too. I love lightning. Its only weakness is where the head meets the cable but there’s plenty of aftermarket cables with strength in this area. USB-C heads are prone to damage and breaking.
- thathndude 3y agoI love the idea of USB-C everything, but the USB-C port seems much more prone to breakage. I have a graveyard of Nintendo Switch devices with bad USB-C ports. First they start as fickle about charging, then progress, and then eventually stop charging. If I’m lucky, I’ll have the foresight to wipe them before they completely die.
- Etrnl_President 3y agoGreat, except it's likely only because your ID will be hardcoded to that device, making this a necessity for their grid. People can barely ever be pessimistic enough to overcome their delusions, but one needs only to be stepped on once or twice to start noticing the trend…
- ensocode 3y agoThis is so overdue. Hopefully this will not affect water resistance and shock resistance too much, but I am sure there will be innovations until 2027 in this field.
- GuB-42 3y agoThe Galaxy S5 was water resistant and one of the toughest of the "mainstream" phones of its generation. All that with a removable battery. When you get into the rugged territory, there is diving equipment with removable batteries, so it is absolutely not a limitation.
- lacrimacida 3y agoI bet the smart phone manufacturers will botch this in other ways, batteries will be replaceable yet they’ll find ways to make phones obsolete just like before. We’ll go back to having drawers of old phones and batteries.
- benzin 3y agoI have a ten year old laptop - bought a replacement battery, good as new - for 15 minutes. Now it dies in 2 minutes when unplugged. Maybe a trustworthy brand will emerge to handle the different battery sizes available.
- mattfrommars 3y agoThis has to be one of the stronger act to be environmentally friendly Apple can do apart from using recycled aluminum.
- daemontus 3y agoI am really fed up with all the "nobody keeps a phone long enough to make battery replacements useful" arguments around here. Out of the 10+ phones in our family over the last 5-10 years, one was water damage and one was failure of the internal flash memory. Every other phone was replaced because the battery died. Every single one. Official replacement was no longer available and DIY was either impossible (lack of parts) or eventually ended up damaging the device beyond economical repairability. Regular people that don't have thousands of dollars in disposable income (and nothing useful to spend it on) haven't cared about phone specs for years. Hell, I love tech and could buy a new phone every year and even I haven't cared about phone specs since the original Google Pixel. If you brick your phone every year because that's just who you are, no judging. If you want a new phone every year and can afford one, its your money. Just remember that you are fortunate enough to be able to do so. And someone will surely buy your used phone and likely (try to) replace the battery in it. Overall, it's like claiming that nobody drives cars that are 10+ years old because they needed a new clutch. Or that a 50 year old house needs to be torn down because fixing the roof economically is clearly beyond our engineering prowess. Are there people that swap cars every 5 years? Absolutely. But that does not mean those cars go to a scrapyard. I will not comment on the technical aspects of this proposal, since the actual outcome might very well need to be settled in the court still. But dismissing the general point of legislature which demands better longevity for devices that basically everybody needs to partake in modern society is rather shortsighted.
- FooBarBizBazz 3y agoMy phones have been destroyed not by ageing batteries but by bloating software. You need to update software for security reasons, but those updates also take up more space and run slower (because developers work only as hard as is necessary to make apps run acceptably on their phones, which are typically new models). Space bloat, more than time bloat, has been the biggest issue. Open bootloaders and drivers (after a certain number of years at least?) would help with that. Make available enough to let open source developers help themselves. Even if Google stops supporting Android on my hardware, or Apple stops supporting iOS, there should at least be a stripped down Linux? I'm not sure how useful even that would be though, because that surely won't be able to run the latest apps used by society. Sigh. Maybe everything is just an arms race. Phones won't stop going obsolete until it is physically impossible to make faster phones. Since space bloat has been a bigger problem than time bloat, I could maybe have gotten more life out of my phones if the OS had supported the installation of apps to the SD card. Maybe that could be a cheap partial fix.
- Euphorbium 3y agoI was going to upgrade when usb-c comes out, but now I am absolutely waiting untill the replacable battery model comes out.
- cmurf 3y agoNow they need replaceable operating systems. Once the manufacturer ends support, they need to be required to release the information necessary for others to support it.
- scarface_74 3y ago> An IP68 rating would be very difficult to obtain while still offering a premium-feeling device with an easily replaceable battery, for example. These are hurdles OEMs will need to get over to be in compliance. It doesn’t concern anyone that regulators in the EU who know nothing about tech are forcing companies to have worse designs?
- welcome_dragon 3y agoSo what? Honestly the only thing this will change is that after X months/years your phone will no longer receive security updates, and the carriers will require a phone that receives security updates to join their network. Thus, the same cycle. It's actually going to make things much worse in my opinion.