8 ms·
Fairphone 3 gets seven years of updates, besting every other Android OEM
- exabrial 3y agoIs there any android phone any the size of an iphone mini? I don’t need a giant 9” screen. I’m ready to switch back to android.
- bcraven 3y agoiPhone (13) mini: 131.5 x 64.2 x 7.7 mm 14 results: https://www.gsmarena.com/results.php3?nHeightMax=132&nWidthMax=65&nThicknessMax=8&nOrder=18&sOSes=2 https://www.gsmarena.com/results.php3?nHeightMax=132&nWidthM... Answer, yes (but they're shit).
- tmikaeld 3y agoand made before 2019
- sudosysgen 3y agoThe basic S23 is half a centimeter larger in every dimension (except thickness) and is a very, very good phone. If that's too large, there's also the Xperia 5 IV and the Asus Zenfone.
- haunter 3y agoAsus Zenfone 10 is 5.9", released last week (the mini is 5.42”)
- ksala_ 3y agoThe Zenfone is the same size as a regular iPhone. I know reviewers hype it up as a small phone and in the android context, it is - but it's not comparable to the iPhone mini.
- onli 3y agoModern? According to gsmarena, literally the only Android phone with at least Android 12 with a height less than 135mm (the iPhone 13 mini is 131.5mm high, according to the same site) is the Cubot J20. Which looks adorable, but is a 60€ Aliexpress device and probably not what you seek. If you are okay with older phones, there is the Sony Xperia XZ2 compact, which is even supported by several custom roms and would then run Android 13. Or there are foldables of course, like the Samsung Flip. That's at least small some of the time, and there are some alternatives where the small screen on the outside is big enough to be usable, like the new razr+.
- Jiejeing 3y agoThe S10e is still supported by LineageOS and is 5.6", which is fairly close to the iphone mini (but still bigger).
- quitit 3y agoI'd happily buy a phone the original iPhone (iPod) size. I'm yet to find a productivity app where that extra screen space solves the problem. Same thing with laptops, whatever I can't do on a 14", I also can't do on a 16".
- aldarisbm 3y agofor me in software engineering, it really does make a difference to have that extra space when having two things open side by side. Also I DJ for fun sometimes, and having the extra real state helps a LOT.
- wussboy 3y agoI don't think OP is saying screen size isn't important. It is (as I type this from the rightmost of 3 24" 4K monitors...). They're saying that what they can't do on a 14" they also can't do on a 16". Those two inches don't help.
- quitit 3y agoThanks that is exactly my point, because I'm not losing any functionality with a slightly smaller phone, but I am gaining something that is more mobile, fits into pockets and usable with one hand. I understand the large screen appeal, there's a lot of folks out there now where they use their phone to watch shows and in some cases is their only computing device.
- the_gipsy 3y agoA lot of UIs are built for big screens and scale down for smaller iPhones. It's harder to read and interact with a smaller phone.
- robin_reala 3y agoSmaller phones are easier to interact with if we’re taking single hand interactions.
- the_gipsy 3y agoYea it's a tradeoff, sadly.
- exabrial 3y agoNot everyone uses their phone for UIs. A lot of us Gen-X / Elderillenials have a more disconnected lifestyle, whereas a lot of younger-llenial and Gen-Z their life is centered on communication first. As such, a Large screen is not a priority, but portability is, because I'd assume just leave my house without my phone if it's too big to tuck in a pocket on a bike ride.
- shucks 3y agoYES. I've just got a unihertz atom xl, I love it. All of their phones are pretty unique - they make one with a blackberry keyboard, mine can operate on DMR radio frequencies. They are not enormous phablets. They do only support Android 11, but I'm not really so interested in bleeding edge Android these days.
- DiggyJohnson 3y agoOh man, I used the Unihertz Jelly 2 w/ a 3in screen for a few years in college. Was awesome to combat my smartphone addiction.
- YellOh 3y agoI was interested and looked it up. For anyone else that cares, Unihertz is a Chinese company. I'll probably add it to Huawei in my mental "avoid" bucket for the foreseeable future.
- ChuckNorris89 3y agoSamsung S23
- exabrial 3y agoI just want to say thank you everyone for the responses
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- aidenn0 3y agoUnihertz makes a few niche phones, check out their sizes. They are updating the Jelly line (3" screen, might be too small for you, but is what I own) right now for a fall release. The Atom XL is a ruggedized phone with a slightly larger (4") screen. FWIW, those both are thicker than an iphone mini (gotta fit the battery somewhere I guess). [edit] There is also the Titan Slim. It's a 4.2 inch screen, but has a keyboard, making it narrow, but very tall (5.75"). And if you do go for the super tiny Jelly series, don't get the 2E; it's designed as a second phone and so is less well spec'd than the older Jelly 2 (or the upcoming Jelly Star).
- Moldoteck 3y agoNot iphone mini size, but asus zenfone 10 is acceptable
- yankput 3y ago_please_ make a Fairphone with a good camera :( and I will switch from iPhone in a heartbeat. Making pictures of my kids is what I do with my phone the most.
- Zambyte 3y agoCould you replace your phone with a camera then?
- yankput 3y agoI don’t want to carry two devices, same reason why I don’t have a separate GPS, separate watch, separate music player, separate gaming handheld.
- Zambyte 3y agoHence why I said "replace"
- supertrope 3y agoThey do bring up a good point. An actual camera is almost always better than a camera module. But most people value cost and convenience over having the superior tool. I've witnessed people who are unable to navigate when their phone shows SOS only. They were unaware that GPS does not depend on cellular Internet. People scoff at dedicated GPS navigation devices or paper maps as antiquated.
- woobar 3y agoYou phone will navigate without cell service. All you need is offline maps. No need for a dedicated GPS
- nsajko 3y agoWhat do you mean, the photos seem fine to me?
- 3y ago
- wkat4242 3y ago7 years yes but updates are few and far between. That matters a lot too. With Fairphone you don't get monthly security updates and timely major upgrades. It's admirable that they go for longevity but irregular security updates doesn't really cut the biscuit for the more security-conscious customer. It's really just a matter of when they happen to get around to it. Samsung is better at this IMO, while they don't do it quite as long they do maintain a decent cadence that they specify for each model. Still it hurts me they supported my S8 for such a short time because it was my best phone ever. Since then they've really improved their game on the software side but not the hardware.
- CrampusDestrus 3y agoYou people are never happy. Maybe if phones costed $10k a company could afford such a team of engineers to keep Android as updated as upstream AOSP
- pizza234 3y agoSecurity is topic that is definitely worth taking very seriously, and worse, it's in contrast with an industry fundamentally designed around planned obsolescence. I don't have estimates, but I think it's safe to estimate that there are millions of otherwise perfectly valid phones that either are in use, with serious vulnerabilities (in particular, bluetooth ones) and are not going to be patched, or have been thrown away because of that.
- CrampusDestrus 3y agoAs long as smartphone device drivers are proprietary there will be an upper limit of how much a phone can be updated. Not to mention that Android and iOS get more computationally intensive each version way quicker than Desktop OSs do. Windows 10 from 2012 and Windows 10 today basically run the same. Sure, if most drivers were open source like on desktop linux we could tweak them to work with newer and newer Android versions, but what happens when AOSP gets a computationally expensive update (i.e. embedded ML voice recognition or realistic TTS)? then you would have to create custom versions of AOSP that only have the stuff a particular phone model can handle and this would create and unbareable ecosystem of poorly maintained distributions
- ahtaarra 3y agoI think the biggest deal-breaker for me is that they chose to go with /e/OS which is not something I enjoyed after trying it briefly since the skin over AOSP to me seemed ugly and bloated and change for the sake of it. I would like to try out the recent Zefones and the nothing phone also seems good. But at the moment I have my Pixel 6a which is serving me well enough.
- COGlory 3y agoThere's no skin on /e/OS, it is just a fork of LineageOS with a few Google/telemetry things removed, MicroG integrated, and a handful of apps/services preinstalled. Are you talking about the default launcher? You can download dozens of different launchers on their app store, and install them with one click. Including Trebuchet, which is the default launcher on LineageOS, which is, at this point, de facto AOSP.
- TT-392 3y agoThey support /e/OS, but it comes with normal android out of the box.
- 1ko 3y agoMeanwhile I have a 12 years old desktop PC still going strong. The mobile OS world looks pretty sad in comparison.
- CptanPanic 3y agoWhat do they mean by "we aim to support..." doesn't sound very sure of 7 years of updates.
- RankingMember 3y agoRealistically, what are the chances this phone's manufacturer even survives 7 more years? They're in a very competitive space.
- YtvwlD 3y agoThey exist for ten years now.
- gpvos 3y agoThey depend on others for many things regarding that support.
- D13Fd 3y agoThis is great! But I worry that it assumes that the company behind it will stick to the promise, and will still be around in 7 years.
- YtvwlD 3y agoThe FP2 got 7 years of updates.
- grishka 3y agoWhat about Project Treble? That was supposed to define a clear boundary between the hardware-dependent and hardware-independent parts of Android so that one could be updated without touching the other. The goal was exactly that, to remove the dependency on SoC manufacturers for system updates. Yet somehow this dependency still exists? Meanwhile GSIs (generic system images) also exist and run on everything where you could unlock the bootloader.
- zozbot234 3y agoProject Treble doesn't go that far. It allows you to boot a mostly hardware-independent ("generic") AOSP, but it's still dependent on AOSP version, hardware architecture (32- vs. 64-bit) and other details such as the partition arrangement, which varies by device. Project Droidian is trying to make it feasible to run something close to a mainstream Linux userland (hence, not just AOSP) on top of Treble drivers, and it's not very easy.
- pjmlp 3y agoYes, however the update still needed to be pushed by the OEMs themselves, as Google didn't want to force their hand. Naturally they rather sell new devices. GSI came later as Google decided to make way for most components to updatable via Play Store. ART was the last one to make it on Android 12, specially since they couldn't ignore Java evolution any longer, as Java libraries started to become unavailable on Android.
- Bud 3y ago2026 Android doesn't even exist yet. To me this is a ludicrous and premature claim. They can claim this AFTER 2026 gets here and their device still runs whatever Android looks like in 2026. And runs it well, with acceptable performance and battery life. Not before.
- gpvos 3y agoBoth my FP1 and FP2 broke down physically way before OS support ran out. I hope my current refurbished FP3 will last a little longer. Monthly security updates? Ha! I had no idea those were a thing until I switched to DivestOS for a while. FP just doesn't do that.
- notRobot 3y agoLineageOS and custom roms have been doing this for close to two decades. And those are entirely based on volunteer efforts. It actually doesn't take that much work. The reason Google etc don't do it is because then they'd get to sell fewer phones since they wouldn't be getting obsolete so quickly. Apple supports devices for a lot longer because they get a lot of recurring and ongoing revenue from Apple services on Apple devices, so it's in their favour if devices stay usable for longer. You can understand almost all decisions made by tech companies if you think along the lines of "how are they profiting by doing _______?"
- boring_twenties 3y agoLineageOS and other custom roms do not and cannot do this -- they are dependent on the OEM for firmware and kernel updates. Once those dry up, you get Android updates but ultimately the device remains vulnerable to lower level attacks.
- kernal 3y agoPeople keep spreading this fallacy. LineageOS cannot update the OEM device drivers because the OEM"s will never release the source for them.
- penguin_booze 3y agoI remember lol-ing when Firefox came out with FirefoxOS ages ago. I thought, "why on earth do we want yet another phone when we've open source Android?". I'm slowly realizing that we've run out of choices now. Between the gluttonous Android, and kidney-demanding and walled garden of iOS, we don't have an alternative. And if the articles I'm reading are right, Apple is slowly eating all of Android's meals. Apps that you can't live without--be that because of $WORK requirements or other quality of life improving ones--they're available only for Android and iOS. Using such services via web is a no-go: "it's either our app or nothing". I can't park my car without installing their app. (The other alternative is to phone them up! What year is it now - 2020?!). I wish we built foundational mobile application ecosystem around web technologies [0]. That would have stripped down the phones' front-end and user-facing requiremnt to 'just be able to run web browser'. No bulky updates; no deprecations. In the normal course, the only thing that needs update/upgrade is the battery, every n years or so, n > 5. [0] with the provision to extend functionality via native plugins, of course -- like the Capacitor framework [1] does. [1] https://capacitorjs.com/ https://capacitorjs.com/
- eipi10_hn 3y ago> Apple is slowly eating all of Android's meals Eating in terms of what?
- edgineer 3y agoThis is a forum of hackers, so this ought to be easy to answer: Alice is using a Pixel XL in 2023. Its last Android patch was in 2019, on Android 10, but she keeps up with play store updates. Other than this, she is reasonably security conscientious. She does not sideload strange apps, but could be tricked into visiting a malicious link before exiting out of it. She is not a high value target. By 2024 Eve has hacked Alice's phone as a result of this outdated phone. What is the most likely mechanism? Here are my speculations: Visiting a malicious link at the same time there is a major browser vulnerability. This sandboxes the malware, unless there is a second vulnerability, a sandbox escape. Receiving a malicious text message that exploits a Message app vulnerability. Attack on the baseband processor. Pleas correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't see any of these as being very likely.